Building tolerance by dismantling synapses: inhibitory receptor signaling in natural killer cells.

Cell surface receptors bearing immunotyrosine-based inhibitory motifs (ITIMs) maintain natural killer (NK) cell tolerance to normal host tissues. These receptors are difficult to analyze mechanistically because they block activating responses in a rapid and comprehensive manner. The advent of high-resolution single cell imaging techniques has enabled investigators to explore the cell biological basis of the inhibitory response. Recent studies using these approaches indicate that ITIM-containing receptors function at least in part by structurally undermining the immunological synapse between the NK cell and its target. In this review, we discuss these new advances and how they might relate to what is known about the biochemistry of inhibitory signaling in NK cells and other cell types.

Protein kinase C-θ clustering at immunological synapses amplifies effector responses in NK cells.

In lymphocytes, stimulation of cell surface activating receptors induces the formation of protein microclusters at the plasma membrane that contain the receptor itself, along with other signaling molecules. Although these microclusters are generally thought to be crucial for promoting downstream cellular responses, evidence that specifically links clustering potential to signaling output is lacking. We found that protein kinase C-θ (PKCθ), a key signaling molecule in multiple lymphocyte subsets, formed microclusters in activated NK cells. These microclusters coalesced within the immunological synapse between the NK cell and its target cell. Clustering was mediated by the regulatory region of PKCθ and specifically required a putative phosphotyrosine-binding site within its N-terminal C2 domain. Whereas expression of wild-type PKCθ rescued the cytokine production defect displayed by PKCθ-deficient NK cells, expression of a PKCθ point-mutant incapable of forming microclusters had little to no effect. Hence, PKCθ clustering was necessary for optimal effector function. Notably, only receptors containing ITAMs induced PKCθ microclusters on their own, explaining previous observations that ITAM-coupled receptors promote stronger activating signals and effector responses than do receptors lacking these motifs. Taken together, our results provide a cell biological basis for the role of PKCθ clustering during NK cell activation, and highlight the importance of subcellular compartmentalization for lymphocyte signal transduction.

Analysis of substrates of protein kinase C isoforms in human breast cells by the traceable kinase method.

A previous report [Abeyweera, T. P., and Rotenberg, S. A. (2007) Biochemistry 46, 2364-2370] described the application of the traceable kinase method in identifying substrates of protein kinase Cα (PKC-α) in nontransformed human breast MCF-10A cells. Here, a nonradioactive variation of this method compared the phosphoprotein profiles of three traceable PKC isoforms (α, δ, and ζ) for the purpose of identifying novel, isoform-selective substrates. Each FLAG-tagged traceable kinase was expressed and co-immunoprecipitated along with high-affinity substrates. The isolated kinase and its associated substrates were subjected to an in vitro phosphorylation reaction with traceable kinase-specific N(6)-phenyl-ATP, and the resulting phosphoproteins were analyzed by Western blotting with an antibody that recognizes the phosphorylated PKC consensus site. Phosphoprotein profiles generated by PKC-α and -δ were similar and differed markedly from that of PKC-ζ. Mass spectrometry of selected bands revealed known PKC substrates and several potential substrates that included the small GTPase-associated Cdc42 effector protein-4 (CEP4). Of those potential substrates tested, only CEP4 was phosphorylated by pure PKC-α, -δ, and -ζ isoforms in vitro, and by endogenous PKC isoforms in MCF-10A cells treated with DAG-lactone, a membrane permeable PKC activator. Under these conditions, the stoichiometry of CEP4 phosphorylation was 3.2 ± 0.5 (moles of phospho-CEP4 per mole of CEP4). Following knockdown with isoform-specific shRNA-encoding plasmids, the level of phosphorylation of CEP4 was substantially decreased in response to silencing of each of the three isoforms (PKC-α, -δ, and -ζ), whereas testing of kinase-dead mutants supported a role for only PKC-α and -δ in CEP4 phosphorylation. These findings identify CEP4 as a novel intracellular PKC substrate that is phosphorylated by multiple PKC isoforms.

Nanoelectrochemistry of mammalian cells.

There is a significant current interest in development of new techniques for direct characterization of the intracellular redox state and high-resolution imaging of living cells. We used nanometer-sized amperometric probes in combination with the scanning electrochemical microscope (SECM) to carry out spatially resolved electrochemical experiments in cultured human breast cells. With the tip radius approximately 1,000 times smaller than that of a cell, an electrochemical probe can penetrate a cell and travel inside it without apparent damage to the membrane. The data demonstrate the possibility of measuring the rate of transmembrane charge transport and membrane potential and probing redox properties at the subcellular level. The same experimental setup was used for nanoscale electrochemical imaging of the cell surface.

Inhibitory receptor signaling destabilizes immunological synapse formation in primary NK cells.

Upon engagement of their cognate class I major histocompatibility complex ligands, receptors containing immunotyrosine-based inhibitory motifs (ITIMs) transduce signals that block cytolytic and inflammatory responses. In this manner, ITIM-coupled receptors play a crucial role in maintaining natural killer (NK) cell tolerance toward normal, healthy tissue. A number of studies, mostly using immortalized NK cell lines, have demonstrated that ITIM signaling functions by disrupting the cytolytic immunological synapse formed between an NK cell and its target. However, more recent imaging experiments using primary NK cells have suggested that inhibitory receptor engagement does not antagonize contact formation, casting doubt on the hypothesis that ITIM signals destabilize the synapse. To resolve this issue, we analyzed primary NK cell activation and contact formation on supported lipid bilayers containing controlled combinations of activating and inhibitory ligands. Under these conditions, we observed that ITIM signaling clearly inhibited adhesion, cell arrest, and calcium influx, three hallmarks of synapse formation. These results are consistent with previous reports showing that inhibitory receptors deliver a "reverse stop" signal, and confirm that ITIM signaling functions at least in part by destabilizing cytolytic synapse formation.

Inhibitory signaling blocks activating receptor clustering and induces cytoskeletal retraction in natural killer cells.

Natural killer (NK) lymphocytes use a variety of activating receptors to recognize and kill infected or tumorigenic cells during an innate immune response. To prevent targeting healthy tissue, NK cells also express numerous inhibitory receptors that signal through immunotyrosine-based inhibitory motifs (ITIMs). Precisely how signals from competing activating and inhibitory receptors are integrated and resolved is not understood. To investigate how ITIM receptor signaling impinges on activating pathways, we developed a photochemical approach for stimulating the inhibitory receptor KIR2DL2 during ongoing NK cell-activating responses in high-resolution imaging experiments. Photostimulation of KIR2DL2 induces the rapid formation of inhibitory receptor microclusters in the plasma membrane and the simultaneous suppression of microclusters containing activating receptors. This is followed by the collapse of the peripheral actin cytoskeleton and retraction of the NK cell from the source of inhibitory stimulation. These results suggest a cell biological basis for ITIM receptor signaling and establish an experimental framework for analyzing it.

Phosphorylation of alpha6-tubulin by protein kinase Calpha activates motility of human breast cells.

Engineered overexpression of protein kinase Calpha (PKCalpha) was previously shown to endow nonmotile MCF-10A human breast cells with aggressive motility. A traceable mutant of PKCalpha (Abeyweera, T. P., and Rotenberg, S. A. (2007) Biochemistry 46, 2364-2370) revealed that alpha6-tubulin is phosphorylated in cells expressing traceable PKCalpha and in vitro by wild type PKCalpha. Gain-of-function, single site mutations (Ser-->Asp) were constructed at each PKC consensus site in alpha6-tubulin (Ser158, Ser165, Ser241, and Thr337) to simulate phosphorylation. Following expression of each construct in MCF-10A cells, motility assays identified Ser165 as the only site in alpha6-tubulin whose pseudophosphorylation reproduced the motile behavior engendered by PKCalpha. Expression of a phosphorylation-resistant mutant (S165N-alpha6-tubulin) resulted in suppression of MCF-10A cell motility stimulated either by expression of PKCalpha or by treatment with PKCalpha-selective activator diacylglycerol-lactone. MCF-10A cells treated with diacylglycerol-lactone showed strong phosphorylation of endogenous alpha-tubulin that could be blocked when S165N-alpha6-tubulin was expressed. The S165N mutant also inhibited intrinsically motile human breast tumor cells that express high endogenous PKCalpha levels (MDA-MB-231 cells) or lack PKCalpha and other conventional isoforms (MDA-MB-468 cells). Comparison of Myc-tagged wild type alpha6-tubulin and S165N-alpha6-tubulin expressed in MDA-MB-468 cells demonstrated that Ser165 is also a major site of phosphorylation for endogenously active, nonconventional PKC isoforms. PKC-stimulated motility of MCF-10A cells was nocodazole-sensitive, thereby implicating microtubule elongation in the mechanism. These findings support a model in which PKC phosphorylates alpha-tubulin at Ser165, leading to microtubule elongation and motility.

Conformationally constrained analogues of diacylglycerol. 29. Cells sort diacylglycerol-lactone chemical zip codes to produce diverse and selective biological activities.

Diacylglycerol-lactone (DAG-lactone) libraries generated by a solid-phase approach using IRORI technology produced a variety of unique biological activities. Subtle differences in chemical diversity in two areas of the molecule, the combination of which generates what we have termed "chemical zip codes", are able to transform a relatively small chemical space into a larger universe of biological activities, as membrane-containing organelles within the cell appear to be able to decode these "chemical zip codes". It is postulated that after binding to protein kinase C (PKC) isozymes or other nonkinase target proteins that contain diacylglycerol responsive, membrane interacting domains (C1 domains), the resulting complexes are directed to diverse intracellular sites where different sets of substrates are accessed. Multiple cellular bioassays show that DAG-lactones, which bind in vitro to PKCalpha to varying degrees, expand their biological repertoire into a larger domain, eliciting distinct cellular responses.

Design and characterization of a traceable protein kinase Calpha.

Protein kinase Calpha (PKCalpha) is a critical component of pathways that govern cancer-related phenotypes such as invasion and proliferation. Proteins that serve as immediate substrates for PKCalpha offer potential targets for anticancer drug design. To identify specific substrates, a mutant of PKCalpha (M417A) was constructed at the ATP binding site such that it could bind a sterically large ATP analogue derivatized through the N6 amino group of adenosine ([gamma-32P]-N6-phenyl-ATP). Because this analogue could be utilized by the mutant kinase but not by wild-type PKCalpha (or presumably other protein kinase) to phosphorylate peptide or protein substrates, 32P-labeled products were the direct result of the mutant PKCalpha. Kinetic analysis with [gamma-32P]-N6-phenyl-ATP revealed that the mutant retained undiminished affinity for the peptide substrate (Km = 12.4 microM) and a Vmax value (10.3 pmol/min) that was only 3-fold lower than that exhibited by the wild-type enzyme with natural ATP. However, with [gamma-32P]ATP, the mutant had a somewhat lower affinity (Km = 82.8 microM) than the wild-type enzyme (Km = 9.3 microM) in vitro but was competent in causing aggressive motility in nonmotile MCF-10A human breast cells (with endogenous ATP), as previously described for wild-type PKCalpha. The FLAG-tagged PKCalpha mutant was expressed in MCF-10A cells and used to co-immunoprecipitate high-affinity substrates from lysates. Immunopellets were reacted with [gamma-32P]-N6-phenyl-ATP, and radiolabeled products were analyzed by SDS-PAGE and autoradiography. Mass spectrometry of selected bands identified several known substrates of PKC, thereby validating the methods used in these studies. These findings provide a foundation for future applications of this traceable PKCalpha mutant.