Conceptualising production, productivity and technology in pharmacy practice: a novel framework for policy, education and research.

CONTEXT AND BACKGROUND: People and health systems worldwide face serious challenges due to shifting disease demographics, rising population demands and weaknesses in healthcare provision, including capacity shortages and lack of impact of healthcare services. These multiple challenges, linked with the global push to achieve universal health coverage, have made apparent the importance of investing in workforce development to improve population health and economic well-being. In relation to medicines, health systems face challenges in terms of access to needed medicines, optimising medicines use and reducing risk. In 2017, the International Pharmaceutical Federation (FIP) published global policy on workforce development ('the Nanjing Statements') that describe an envisioned future for professional education and training. The documents make clear that expanding the pharmacy workforce benefits patients, and continually improving education and training produces better clinical outcomes. AIMS AND PURPOSE: The opportunities for harnessing new technologies in pharmacy practice have been relatively ignored. This paper presents a conceptual framework for analysing production methods, productivity and technology in pharmacy practice that differentiates between dispensing and pharmaceutical care services. We outline a framework that may be employed to study the relationship between pharmacy practice and productivity, shaped by educational and technological inputs. METHOD AND RESULTS: The analysis is performed from the point of view of health systems economics. In relation to pharmaceutical care (patient-oriented practice), pharmacists are service providers; however, their primary purpose is not to deliver consultations, but to maximise the quantum of health gain they secure. Our analysis demonstrates that 'technology shock' is clearly beneficial compared with orthodox notions of productivity or incremental gain implementations. Additionally, the whole process of providing professional services using 'pharmaceutical care technologies' is governed by local institutional frames, suggesting that activities may be structured differently in different places and countries. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: Addressing problems with medication use with the development of a pharmaceutical workforce that is sufficient in quantity and competence is a long-term issue. As a result of this analysis, there emerges a challenge about the profession's relationship with existing and emerging technical innovations. Our novel framework is designed to facilitate policy, education and research by providing an analytical approach to service delivery. By using this approach, the profession could develop examples of good practice in both developed and developing countries worldwide.

Detection of adverse events of transfusion in a teaching hospital in Ghana.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Monitoring the whole chain of events from the blood donors to recipients, documenting any undesirable or untoward effects and introducing measures to prevent their recurrence if possible are components of haemovigilance systems. Only few sub-Saharan African countries have haemovigilance systems, and there are very little data on adverse events of transfusion. Adverse events monitoring is an integral part of a haemovigilance system. Our study aimed to establish the incidence and types of adverse events of transfusions in Ghana and to identify interventions to improve effectiveness. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This prospective observational 1-year study enrolled 372 recipients of 432 transfusions in a Ghanaian teaching hospital. Vital signs were monitored at 15, 30 and 60 min intervals during the transfusion, then 8 h until 24 h post-transfusion. Three investigators independently classified any new signs and symptoms according to Serious Hazards of Transfusion definitions. RESULTS: The adverse events incidence was 21·3% (92/432), predominantly mild acute transfusion reactions (84%). A total of 20 transfusions (4·6%) were stopped before completion, 60% of them for mild febrile reactions, which could have been managed with transfusion in situ. CONCLUSION: This prospective study indicates a high incidence of adverse events of transfusion in Kumasi, Ghana. The significant numbers of discontinued transfusions suggest that guidelines on how to manage transfusion reactions would help preserve scarce blood stocks. Gradual implementation of a haemovigilance system, starting with monitoring adverse transfusion events, is a pragmatic approach in resource-limited settings.

Improving the screening of blood donors with syphilis rapid diagnostic test (RDT) and rapid plasma reagin (RPR) in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC).

BACKGROUND: Syphilis testing conventionally relies on a combination of non-treponemal and treponemal tests. The primary objective of this study was to describe the positive predictive value (PPV) of a screening algorithm in a combination of a treponemal rapid diagnostic test (RDT) and rapid plasma reagin (RPR) test at Komfo Anokye Teaching Hospital (KATH), Ghana. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From February 2014 to January 2015, 5 mL of venous blood samples were taken from 16 016 blood donors and tested with a treponemal RDT; 5 mL of venous blood was taken from 526 consenting initial syphilis sero-reactive blood donors. These RDT reactive samples were confirmed with an algorithm, applying the Vitros® /Abbott-Architect® algorithm as gold standard. RESULTS: A total of 478 of 526 RDT reactive donors were confirmed positive for syphilis, making a PPV of 90·9%. Of the 172 (32·7%) donors who were also RPR positive, 167 were confirmed, resulting in a PPV of 97·1%. The PPV of the combined RDT and RPR (suspected active syphilis) testing algorithm was highest among donors at an enhanced risk of syphilis, family/replacement donors (99·9%), and among voluntary donors above 25 years (98·6%). DISCUSSION: Screening of blood donors by combining syphilis RDT and RPR with relatively good PPV may provide a reasonable technology for LMIC that has a limited capacity for testing and can contribute to the improvement of blood safety with a minimal loss of donors.

Cost and effectiveness comparison of two methods for screening potential blood donors for anaemia in Vietnam.

AIM/OBJECTIVE: To compare the cost and effectiveness of Copper Sulphate (CS) and HemoCue (HC) methods for screening blood donors for anaemia. BACKGROUND: Robust information from developing countries about cost and effectiveness of anaemia screening methods for blood donors is scarce. In such countries there are widespread shortages of blood, so the most cost-effective method should maximise blood supply without compromising donor safety. METHODS: Economic data (e.g. staff time, equipment and buildings) were collected from direct observation of procedures and purchase data from Hanoi's Central Blood Bank administrative department. A framework for comparing the cost and effectiveness of anaemia screening methods was developed and a cost per effective (i.e. usable and accurate) test was generated for each method. RESULTS: Samples from 100 potential donors from the Hanoi Central Blood Bank (static) and 198 from two mobile units were tested. The mean probability of an ineffective anaemia test was 0·1 (0·05-0·2). The average cost of an HC test was $0·75 (static $0·61 and mobile $0·89) and a CS test was $0·31 (static $0·17 and mobile $0·45). The difference between static and mobile units was predominantly due to transport costs; the difference between the two methods was predominantly due to the HC microcuvettes. CONCLUSION: In this setting the CS yields greater value for money than the HC method for screening blood donors. The relative cost and effectiveness of CS and HC may be different in places with higher staff turnover, lower test accuracy, higher anaemia prevalence or lower workload than in Vietnam.

Building capacities in research for blood services in Africa.

BACKGROUND: Capacity building of African based blood services researchers has been identified as key in developing a sustainable programme of generation local evidence to support sound decision making. There are a number of research training programmes that have been instituted targeted at blood services in Africa. The article shares programme experiences of building research capacities for blood services in Africa. METHODOLOGY: The Francophone Africa Transfusion Medicine Research Training network, the NIH REDS-III and NIH Fogarty South Africa programmes and T-REC (Building transfusion research capacity in Africa) have been the key research capacity programmes targeting blood services in Africa over the last decade. To understand their experiences on the implementation of the capacity building programmes, data were drawn from research outputs, publications and end of programme reports. The success, challenges and the main research outputs from their initiatives were highlighted. RESULTS: The Francophone research network achievements included more than 135 trainees and in excess of 30 publications. The NIH REDS study the achievements included more than 12 research publications with South Africa junior investigators as lead authors. The NIH Fogarty program currently includes 56 short course trainees, 5 Masters and 6 PhD candidates. The four year (2011-2015, funding period) T-REC programme produced more than 20 publications, 4 PhDs, 42 in-service Diploma in Project Design and Management (DPDM), and supported bursaries for 60 Masters/undergraduate research. The main common challenges in the running of the research programmes include shortages of in-country mentoring and identified needs in high quality research grants writing. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: The key achievements for the blood services research capacity building include a mix of short courses, medium-term (epidemiology & biostats) and MS/PhD degree training. Also, having a "train the trainers' programme to develop in-country mentors has been instrumental. Overall, the key recommendations for blood services research capacity building include the need for research collaborations with high-income countries which can jump-start research,and for more in-country grant-writing capacity building, which would help sustainability.

Simultaneous Eulerian-Lagrangian velocity measurements of particulate pipe flow in transitional regime.

We present a unique pipe flow rig capable of simultaneous particle tracking and flow velocity measurements in a dilute, neutrally buoyant particulate pipe flow in regimes of transition to turbulence. The flow consists of solid glass spheres for the disperse phase and a density-matching fluid for the carrier phase. The measurements are conducted using a bespoke, combined two-dimensional particle image velocimetry and particle tracking velocimetry technique. The technique takes advantage of a phase discrimination approach that involves separating the disperse and carrier phases based on their respective image characteristics. Our results show that the rig and the technique it implements can effectively be employed to study transitional particulate pipe flows at dilute concentrations.

Maternal mortality in sub-Saharan Africa: the contribution of ineffective blood transfusion services.

In sub-Saharan Africa, where blood supply is critically inadequate, severe haemorrhage is a leading cause of maternal deaths. The aim of this review was to estimate the impact of lack of blood on maternal deaths and identify reasons and potential solutions. Databases and websites from 1970 to 2007 were searched for information concerning maternal deaths and near misses due to haemorrhage in sub-Saharan Africa. Original studies that provided qualitative or quantitative information about blood transfusion services in relation to obstetric deaths or near misses were included. Data about maternal haemorrhage deaths associated with lack of blood for transfusion and reasons for blood shortages were extracted from the full text of articles by two independent reviewers using predesigned, piloted forms. Twenty of 37 selected studies described a direct association between maternal deaths and lack of blood transfusions. Five of 37 provided quantitative information which showed that overall 26% (16-72%) of maternal haemorrhage deaths were due to lack of blood. Reasons included nonaffordability of blood, lack of blood donors, unwillingness of relatives to donate and inadequate supplies and transport. Lack of blood for emergency transfusions is a major, but poorly quantified and under-researched cause of maternal deaths in sub-Saharan Africa. Potential solutions include more blood donations, better financing mechanisms and more efficient management systems. Complementary approaches to prevent severe anaemia and treat hypovolaemia are important to reduce use of transfusions.

Evaluation and costs of different haemoglobin methods for use in district hospitals in Malawi.

AIMS: To evaluate the characteristics of manual haemoglobin methods in use in Malawi and provide evidence for the Ministry of Health in Malawi to enable them to choose a suitable method for district hospitals. METHODS: Criteria on accuracy, clinical usefulness, user friendliness, speed, training time, and economic costs were determined by local health professionals and used to compare six different manual haemoglobin methods. These were introduced sequentially into use in a district hospital in Malawi alongside the reference method. RESULTS: HemoCue was the optimal method based on most of the outcome measures but was also the most expensive (0.75 US dollars/test). DHT meter and Jenway colorimeter were the second choice because they were cheaper (0.20-0.35 US dollars/test), but they were not as accurate or user friendly as HemoCue. CONCLUSIONS: The process for choosing appropriate laboratory methods is complex and very little guidance is available for health managers in poorer countries. This paper describes the development and testing of a practical model for gathering evidence about test efficiency that could be adapted for use in other resource poor settings.

Chronic malaria and splenic lymphoma: clues to understanding lymphoma evolution.

In west Africa, splenic lymphoma with villous lymphocytes and hyper-reactive malarial splenomegaly have many clinical and immunological features in common suggesting an aetiopathological link. We hypothesize that in hyper-reactive malarial splenomegaly the dysregulated immune response to repeated malaria infections results in a stimulated, proliferating pool of B cells in which perturbation of cell growth and apoptosis by environmental and other factors promotes the development of SLVL. In Africa these factors are likely to include infectious agents several of which have already been associated with B-cell non-Hodgkin's lymphomas.

Pharmacist's review and outcomes: Treatment-enhancing contributions tallied, evaluated, and documented (PROTECTED-UK).

PURPOSE: The purpose was to describe clinical pharmacist interventions across a range of critical care units (CCUs) throughout the United Kingdom, to identify CCU medication error rate and prescription optimization, and to identify the type and impact of each intervention in the prevention of harm and improvement of patient therapy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A prospective observational study was undertaken in 21 UK CCUs from November 5 to 18, 2012. A data collection web portal was designed where the specialist critical care pharmacist reported all interventions at their site. Each intervention was classified as medication error, optimization, or consult. In addition, a clinical impact scale was used to code the interventions. Interventions were scored as low impact, moderate impact, high impact, and life saving. The final coding was moderated by blinded independent multidisciplinary trialists. RESULTS: A total of 20517 prescriptions were reviewed with 3294 interventions recorded during the weekdays. This resulted in an overall intervention rate of 16.1%: 6.8% were classified as medication errors, 8.3% optimizations, and 1.0% consults. The interventions were classified as low impact (34.0%), moderate impact (46.7%), and high impact (19.3%); and 1 case was life saving. Almost three quarters of interventions were to optimize the effectiveness of and improve safety of pharmacotherapy. CONCLUSIONS: This observational study demonstrated that both medication error resolution and pharmacist-led optimization rates were substantial. Almost 1 in 6 prescriptions required an intervention from the clinical pharmacist. The error rate was slightly lower than an earlier UK prescribing error study (EQUIP). Two thirds of the interventions were of moderate to high impact.

Extracting, storing, and transporting whole blood DNA under tropical conditions.

A simple and robust technique for the extraction of DNA under tropical field conditions is described. It requires minimal equipment and is based on lysing cells in whole blood and precipitating the nuclei containing the DNA by centrifugation. The DNA solution can be stored in guanidinium buffer for many months without being refrigerated. Further purification of the DNA can then be carried out in a laboratory with facilities for ultracentrifugation by banding the DNA through cesium chloride. This method yields DNA of sufficient quality and purity for Southern blotting and probing and alleviates the need to transport whole blood between different countries and laboratories.

Four drug combination cytotoxic chemotherapy following surgery for breast cancer.

A prospective randomized clinical trial of treatment with vincristine, cyclophosphamide, methotrexate and 5-fluorouracil after conventional curative treatment for stage II breast cancer is described. The results at 2 years are recorded together with details of toxicity. Future plans are discussed briefly.

Circulating villous lymphocytes--a link between hyperreactive malarial splenomegaly and splenic lymphoma.

Significant numbers of villous lymphocytes were noted in the blood of patients with a clinical diagnosis of hyperreactive malarial splenomegaly (HMS) in Ghana. Demographic and haematological data were recorded from 22 patients with massive splenomegaly. Additional investigations included lymphocyte immunophenotyping, protein electrophoresis and immunoglobulin gene rearrangements. Although all patients had over 30% villous lymphocytes and no leucocytosis, 7 had no evidence of a monoclonal disorder. Immunophenotyping and the presence of monoclonal lymphocytes identified 3 further patients with B-cell splenic lymphoma with villous lymphocytes (B-SLVL). HMS and SLVL co-existed in the same, predominantly female, patient population and were indistinguishable except by molecular analysis of lymphocytes. The discovery of the uncommon villous lymphocytes in both non-malignant and malignant disorders in the same geographical area suggested that HMS and SLVL are pathophysiologically related. In Caucasians with SLVL the malignant cells arise from B-cells that have undergone antigen selection. We postulate that the excessive proliferation of polyclonal B-lymphocytes, driven by frequent exposure to malaria, predisposes to the emergence of a malignant lymphoma, B-SLVL, in tropical West Africa.

Serological similarities between hyperreactive malarial splenomegaly and splenic lymphoma in west Africa.

In West Africa hyperreactive malarial splenomegaly (HMS) and splenic lymphoma with villous lymphocytes (SLVL) are demographically and clinically indistinguishable. Determination of lymphocyte clonality is needed to differentiate clearly between these 2 disorders. To obtain evidence to support our hypothesis that HMS and SLVL are aetiologically related we studied the serological profile of malaria-related antibodies in HMS and SLVL in West Africa. We found that in SLVL total immunoglobulin M and antimalarial antibody levels were markedly raised, a combination which is characteristic of HMS. These findings strongly support a developmental relationship between HMS and SLVL in tropical Africa and implicate malaria in this process.

Immunoglobulin gene polymerase chain reaction to distinguish hyperreactive malarial splenomegaly from 'African' chronic lymphocytic leukaemia and splenic lymphoma.

Hyperreactive malarial splenomegaly (HMS) is found in geographical association with B cell lymphoproliferative disorders such as 'African' chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) and splenic lymphoma with villous lymphocytes (SLVL). It is sometimes not easy to make a differential clinical diagnosis between these conditions. We have previously used Southern blotting as a definitive method for the diagnosis of monoclonal lymphoproliferation in these disorders, but this is expensive, lengthy and technically difficult. In the present paper we have compared Southern blotting with polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of the immunoglobulin heavy chain gene. We found an excellent correlation between the 2 methods in demonstrating monoclonal populations of lymphocytes in patients with a clinical diagnosis of CLL or SLVL. We have further demonstrated monoclonality in a patient who could not be classified as CLL or SLVL on clinical criteria alone. In contrast, patients with well defined HMS or with non-B cell proliferations all showed polyclonal rearrangements. We propose that the immunoglobulin gene PCR is a useful tool for the investigation of tropical splenomegaly of uncertain origin.

Use of clinical judgement to guide administration of blood transfusions in Malawi.

The aim of this study was to investigate whether clinicians in Malawi could use clinical judgement alone to administer blood transfusions in accordance with guidelines. Clinicians at a district hospital did not use the Lovibond Comparator haemoglobin results provided by their laboratory as they felt them to be unreliable, preferring instead to rely on their clinical judgement alone to guide transfusion practice. Their transfusion practice and the Lovibond haemoglobin results were monitored against the World Health Organization recommended haemiglobincyanide method for haemoglobin measurement without the clinicians having access to this result. The Lovibond Comparator method was shown to have a sensitivity of only 21% to detect trigger haemoglobin values for transfusion published in local guidelines. Without access to a useful haemoglobin result, clinicians gave 67% of transfusions in accordance with the haemoglobin trigger values in the guidelines. This study shows that clinical features alone can provide a reasonable guide about the need for transfusion, and that poor quality laboratory tests limit the effectiveness of transfusion guidelines.

The operation, quality and costs of a district hospital laboratory service in Malawi.

Laboratory services are run down in many low-income countries, severely constraining their input to patient care and disease surveillance. There are few data about the quality and cost of individual components of the laboratory service in poorer countries, yet this information is essential if optimal use is to be made of scarce resources. Staff time, range of tests, workload, and safety procedures were monitored over 12 months (1997-98) in a typical district hospital laboratory in Malawi. Data were collected to calculate the total economic cost of these services. Of the 31203 tests performed, 84% were to support blood transfusion and diagnosis of malaria and tuberculosis (TB). Test quality was reasonable for malaria and TB microscopy and blood transfusion, but poor for haemoglobin estimation. The cost per test ranged from US dollars 0.35 for haemoglobin to US dollars 11.7 per unit of blood issued and the total annual cost of the laboratory service was US dollars 32618. Blood transfusion and microscopy for malaria and TB comprised the majority of tests. Ensuring that these tests are of the highest quality will therefore have the most impact in reducing wastage of laboratory resources. Inadequate quality of haemoglobin estimations is a particular problem. The findings of this study are likely to be relevant to other low-income countries with similar disease burdens.

Prevalence and survival of Toxocara canis eggs in the urban environment of Perth, Australia.

Using a technique of proven efficiency no Toxocara canis eggs were recovered from a total of 266 sand samples collected from "dog beaches" and parks in the Perth urban area. This observation emphasises that the major risk to humans is from an environment in which puppies are found. Other observations, made at a heavily contaminated site, showed that the eggs of T. canis disappeared from sandy soil over about 6 months during a period in which it would have been expected that conditions were favourable for egg survival. Other data are also presented indicating that the prevalence of T. canis in adult dogs in Perth is quite low. However, T. canis eggs were recovered in large numbers from the majority of soil samples collected from Perth dog-breeding establishments.

[the early diagnosis of the vertical transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1. The evaluation of diagnostic tests]. / Diagnóstico precoz de la transmisión vertical del virus de la inmunodeficiencia humana tipo 1. Valoración de las pruebas diagnósticas.

BACKGROUND: The early diagnosis of vertically transmitted human immunodeficiency virus infection cannot be based on the presence of specific serum antibodies since those of the maternal IgG class pass the placenta and may be detected in children for up to 18 months. Based on this fact, the aim of this study was to evaluate other techniques for early diagnosis of the infection applicable from birth in 306 children of infected mothers. METHODS: The production of in vitro antibodies, virus culture and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) were used. The sensitivity of the techniques was estimated in the 40 children diagnosed with human immunodeficiency virus infection and specificity was determined in the 266 uninfected children. RESULTS: The sensitivity for the production of in vitro antibodies was 62.0% at 3 months and 94.7% at 6 months; 90.4% and 88.2%, respectively, for the viral culture and 92.3% and 94.1%, respectively, for the PCR. The specificity of all the cases was higher than 89.4% although varied in relation to age. CONCLUSIONS: The combination of several diagnostic techniques provides better performance for the early diagnosis of vertical transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus. Given that viral culture takes longer to provide results and is more expensive, it is less recommendable for routine use, although the form of viral replication may be useful to establish the prognosis.