Vapor Intrusion Investigations and Decision-Making: A Critical Review.

At sites impacted by volatile organic compounds (VOCs), vapor intrusion (VI) is the pathway with the greatest potential to result in actual human exposure. Since sites with VI were first widely publicized in late 1990s, the scientific understanding of VI has evolved considerably. The VI conceptual model has been extended beyond relatively simple scenarios to include nuances, such as biological and hydrogeological factors that may limit the potential for VI and alternative pathways, such as preferential pathways and direct building contact/infiltration that may enhance VI in some cases. Regulatory guidance documents typically recommend initial concentration- or distance-based screening to evaluate whether VI may be a concern, followed by a multiple-lines-of-evidence (MLE) investigation approach for sites that do not screen out. These recommendations for detailed evaluation of VI currently focus on monitoring of VOC concentrations in groundwater, soil gas, and indoor air and can be supplemented by other lines of evidence. In this Critical Review, we summarize key elements important to VI site characterization, provide the status and current understanding, and highlight data interpretation challenges, as well as innovative tools developed to help overcome the challenges. Although there have been significant advances in the understanding of VI in the past 20 years, limitations and knowledge gaps in screening, investigation methods, and modeling approaches still exist. Potential areas for further research include improved initial screening methods that account for the site-specific role of barriers, improved understanding of preferential pathways, and systematic study of buildings and infrastructure other than single-family residences.

Evaluation of vapor intrusion using controlled building pressure.

The use of measured volatile organic chemical (VOC) concentrations in indoor air to evaluate vapor intrusion is complicated by (i) indoor sources of the same VOCs and (ii) temporal variability in vapor intrusion. This study evaluated the efficacy of utilizing induced negative and positive building pressure conditions during a vapor intrusion investigation program to provide an improved understanding of the potential for vapor intrusion. Pressure control was achieved in five of six buildings where the investigation program was tested. For these five buildings, the induced pressure differences were sufficient to control the flow of soil gas through the building foundation. A comparison of VOC concentrations in indoor air measured during the negative and positive pressure test conditions was sufficient to determine whether vapor intrusion was the primary source of VOCs in indoor air at these buildings. The study results indicate that sampling under controlled building pressure can help minimize ambiguity caused by both indoor sources of VOCs and temporal variability in vapor intrusion.

Temporal variability in volatile organic compound concentrations in sanitary sewers at remediation sites.

In recent years, there has been a growing recognition of the importance of sewers as preferential pathways for vapor intrusion. This pathway involves volatile organic compound (VOC)-impacted vapor migration through the interior of pipes or conduits towards the potential receptor. A number of research initiatives have been undertaken to improve the understanding of this pathway which, in turn, supports development of sampling methods to evaluate whether it is a concern at a given site. One aspect of the conceptual model that is important to understanding the potential risk of sewer vapor intrusion is the degree to which VOC concentrations vary over time. This paper presents results of field sampling conducted in Texas, Utah, and California to explore temporal variability of chlorinated VOC concentrations in sewer vapor over different timescales. These results, along with results from other studies, suggest that wide ranges of VOC concentrations can occur at given sampling locations. However, long-term temporal variability (months to years) is much higher than short-term variability (days). The timescale over which the variations occur has implications on sampling methods and frequency. The results suggest that multiple grab samples collected over a longer time period, such as on a quarterly basis, are more appropriate for characterizing the long-term average sewer vapor concentrations than single time-integrated samples collected over a period of hours to days. Because time-integrated samples can often be logistically more difficult to collect, an understanding of the timescale of variability may help practitioners balance field logistics considerations with data adequacy when characterizing VOC concentrations in sewers.

A conceptual model for vapor intrusion from groundwater through sewer lines.

The role of sewer lines as preferential pathways for vapor intrusion is poorly understood. As a result, these pathways are often not considered when developing vapor intrusion investigation or mitigation plans. Neglecting this pathway can complicate data interpretation, which can result in repeated, and potentially unnecessary, rounds of sampling. Although a number of recent studies have highlighted the importance of sewers as preferential pathways at individual buildings, there is currently little specific technical or regulatory guidance on how to address it. The purpose of our study, therefore, was to conduct systematic testing to better understand the sewer vapor intrusion conceptual model. Through sampling at >30 different sites, the degree of interaction between impacted groundwater and the sewer lines were identified as the main factor when determining the degree of risk for sewer vapor intrusion at a given site. Higher risk sites are those with direct interaction between the subsurface volatile organic compound (VOC) source, such as groundwater, and the sewer line itself. This information can be used to prioritize sites and buildings to test for this particular exposure pathway.

Evidence of a sewer vapor transport pathway at the USEPA vapor intrusion research duplex.

The role of sewer lines as preferential pathways for vapor intrusion is poorly understood. Although the importance of sewer lines for volatile organic compound (VOC) transport has been documented at a small number of sites with vapor intrusion, sewer lines are not routinely sampled during most vapor intrusion investigations. We have used a tracer study and VOC concentration measurements to evaluate the role of the combined sanitary/storm sewer line in VOC transport at the USEPA vapor intrusion research duplex in Indianapolis, Indiana. The results from the tracer study demonstrated gas migration from the sewer main line into the duplex. The migration pathway appears to be complex and may include leakage from the sewer lateral at a location below the building foundation. Vapor samples collected from the sewer line demonstrated the presence of tetrachloroethene (PCE) and chloroform in the sewer main in front of the duplex and at multiple sample locations within the sewer line upstream of the duplex. These test results combined with results from the prior multi-year study of the duplex indicate that the sewer line plays an important role in transport of VOCs from the subsurface source to the immediate vicinity of the duplex building envelope.