RESUMO
BACKGROUND: The Cholera Hospital-Based Intervention for 7 Days (CHoBI7) mobile health (mHealth) program was a cluster-randomized controlled trial of diarrhea patient households conducted in Dhaka, Bangladesh. METHODS: Patients were block-randomized to 3 arms: standard message on oral rehydration solution use; health facility delivery of CHoBI7 plus mHealth (no home visits); and health facility delivery of CHoBI7 plus 2 home visits and mHealth. The primary outcome was reported diarrhea in the past 2 weeks collected monthly for 12 months. The secondary outcomes were stunting, underweight, and wasting at a 12-month follow-up. Analysis was intention-to-treat. RESULTS: Between 4 December 2016 and 26 April 2018, 2626 participants in 769 households were randomly allocated to 3 arms: 849 participants to the standard message arm, 886 to mHealth with no home visits arm, and 891 to the mHealth with 2 home visits. Children <5 years had significantly lower 12-month diarrhea prevalence in both the mHealth with 2 home visits arm (prevalence ratio [PR]: 0.73 [95% confidence interval {CI}, .61-.87]) and the mHealth with no home visits arm (PR: 0.82 [95% CI, .69-.97]). Children <2 years were significantly less likely to be stunted in both the mHealth with 2 home visits arm (33% vs 45%; odds ratio [OR]: 0.55 [95% CI, .31-.97]) and the mHealth with no home visits arm (32% vs 45%; OR: 0.54 [95% CI, .31-.96]) compared with children in the standard message arm. CONCLUSIONS: The CHoBI7 mHealth program lowered pediatric diarrhea and stunting among diarrhea patient households. CLINICAL TRIALS REGISTRATION: NCT04008134.
Assuntos
Cólera , Telemedicina , Bangladesh/epidemiologia , Criança , Cólera/epidemiologia , Cólera/prevenção & controle , Diarreia/epidemiologia , Hospitais , Humanos , Higiene , Saneamento , ÁguaRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: The Cholera-Hospital-Based Intervention for 7-days (CHoBI7) mobile health (mHealth) program delivers mobile messages to diarrhoea patient households promoting water treatment and handwashing with soap. The randomised controlled trial (RCT) of the CHoBI7 mHealth program demonstrated this intervention was effective in significantly reducing diarrhoea and stunting amoung young children. The objective of this study was to assess the implementation of the CHoBI7 mHealth program in delivering mHealth messages during this RCT. METHODS: 517 diarrhoea patient households with 1777 participants received weekly text, voice and interactive voice response (IVR) messages from the CHoBI7 mHealth program over the 12-month program period. The program process evaluation indicators were the following: the percentage of CHoBI7 mHealth messages received and fully listened to by program households (program fidelity and dose), and household members reporting receiving and sharing an mHealth message from the program in the past two weeks (program reach). RESULTS: Ninety two percent of text messages were received by program households. Eighty three percent of voice and 86% of IVR messages sent were fully listened to by at least one household member. Eighty one percent of IVR quiz responses from households were answered correctly. Program households reported receiving a CHoBI7 mHealth message in the past two weeks at 79% of monthly household visits during the 12-month program. Seventy seven percent of participants reported sharing a program message with a spouse, 55% with a neighbour and 49% with a child during the program period. CONCLUSION: There was high fidelity, dose and reach of mobile messages delivered for the CHoBI7 mHealth program. This study presents an approach for process evaluation that can be implemented to evaluate future mHealth programs.
OBJECTIF: Le programme CHoBI7 (Cholera-Hospital-Based-Intervention-for-7-days) de santé mobile (mHealth) délivre des messages mobiles aux ménages avec patients atteints de diarrhée pour promouvoir le traitement de l'eau et le lavage des mains au savon. L'essai contrôlé randomisé (ECR) du programme mHealth CHoBI7 a démontré que cette intervention était efficace pour réduire de manière significative la diarrhée et le retard de croissance chez les jeunes enfants. L'objectif de cette étude était d'évaluer la mise en Åuvre du programme CHoBI7 mHealth dans la diffusion des messages mHealth au cours de cet ECR. MÉTHODES: 517 ménages avec des patients atteints de diarrhée ont reçu chaque semaine des messages SMS, vocaux et de réponse vocale interactive (RVI) du programme mHealth de CHoBI7 pendant les 12 mois du programme. Les indicateurs d'évaluation du processus du programme étaient les suivants: le pourcentage de messages mHealth du programme CHoBI7 reçus (fidélité au programme et dose) et entièrement écoutés par les ménages participant au programme (fidélité au programme et dose) et les bénéficiaires déclarant avoir reçu et partagé un message mHealth du programme (portée du programme) au cours des deux dernières semaines. RÉSULTATS: 92% des SMS ont été reçus par les ménages participant au programme. 83% des messages vocaux et 86% des messages RVI envoyés ont été entièrement écoutés par au moins un membre du ménage. 81% des réponses aux quiz RVI des ménages ont été correctement répondues. Les ménages du programme ont déclaré avoir reçu un message CHoBI7 mHealth au cours des deux dernières semaines dans 79% des visites mensuelles des ménages pendant les 12 mois du programme. 77% des participants ont déclaré avoir partagé un message du programme avec un conjoint, 55% avec un voisin et 49% avec un enfant pendant la durée du programme. CONCLUSION: La dose et les messages délivrés dans le cadre du programme mHealth de CHoBI7 l'ont été avec une fidélité élevée. Cette étude présente une approche d'évaluation des processus qui peut être mise en Åuvre pour évaluer les futurs programmes mHealth.
Assuntos
Diarreia/prevenção & controle , Promoção da Saúde/métodos , Higiene , Saneamento/métodos , Telemedicina/métodos , Envio de Mensagens de Texto , Purificação da Água/métodos , Adolescente , Adulto , Idoso , Idoso de 80 Anos ou mais , Criança , Pré-Escolar , Cólera/prevenção & controle , Feminino , Transtornos do Crescimento/prevenção & controle , Humanos , Lactente , Masculino , Pessoa de Meia-Idade , Adulto JovemRESUMO
BACKGROUND: Measurement of antenatal care (ANC) service coverage is often limited to the number of contacts or type of providers, reflecting a gap in the assessment of quality as well as cost estimations and health impact. The study aims to determine service subcomponents and provider and patient costs of ANC services and compares them between community (i.e. satellite clinics) and facility care (i.e. primary and secondary health centers) settings in rural Bangladesh. METHODS: Service contents and cost data were collected by one researcher and four interviewers in various community and facility health care settings in Gaibandha district between September and December 2016. We conducted structured interviews with organization managers, observational studies of ANC service provision (n = 70) for service contents and provider costs (service and drug costs) and exit interviews with pregnant women (n = 70) for patient costs (direct and indirect costs) in health clinics at community and facility levels. Fisher's exact tests were used to determine any different patient characteristics between community and facility settings. ANC service contents were assessed by 63 subitems categorized into 11 groups and compared within and across community and facility settings. Provider and patient costs were collected in Bangladesh taka and analyzed as 2016 US Dollars (0.013 exchange rate). RESULTS: We found generally similar provider and patient characteristics between the community and facility settings except in clients' gestational age. High compliance (> 50%) of service subcomponents were observed in blood pressure monitoring, weight measurement, iron and folate supplementation given, and tetanus vaccine, while lower compliance of service subcomponents (< 50%) were observed in some physical examinations such as edema and ultrasonogram and routine tests such as blood test and urine test. Average unit costs of ANC service provision were about double at the facility level ($2.75) compared with community-based care ($1.62). ANC patient costs at facilities ($2.66) were about three times higher than in the community ($0.78). CONCLUSION: The study reveals a delay in pregnant women's initial ANC care seeking, gaps in compliance of ANC subcomponents and difference of provider and patient costs between facility and community settings.
Assuntos
Cuidado Pré-Natal/economia , Serviços de Saúde Rural/economia , Bangladesh , Feminino , Custos de Cuidados de Saúde/estatística & dados numéricos , Pesquisa sobre Serviços de Saúde , Humanos , Gravidez , Cuidado Pré-Natal/organização & administração , Serviços de Saúde Rural/organização & administraçãoRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: We estimated the cost-effectiveness of a digital health intervention package (mCARE) for community health workers, on pregnancy surveillance and care-seeking reminders compared with the existing paper-based status quo, from 2018 to 2027, in Bangladesh. INTERVENTIONS: The mCARE programme involved digitally enhanced pregnancy surveillance, individually targeted text messages and in-person home-visit to pregnant women for care-seeking reminders for antenatal care, child delivery and postnatal care. STUDY DESIGN: We developed a model to project population and service coverage increases with annual geographical expansion (from 1 million to 10 million population over 10 years) of the mCARE programme and the status quo. MAJOR OUTCOMES: For this modelling study, we used Lives Saved Tool to estimate the number of deaths and disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) that would be averted by 2027, if the coverage of health interventions was increased in mCARE programme and the status quo, respectively. Economic costs were captured from a societal perspective using an ingredients approach and expressed in 2018 US dollars. Probabilistic sensitivity analysis was undertaken to account for parameter uncertainties. RESULTS: We estimated the mCARE programme to avert 3076 deaths by 2027 at an incremental cost of $43 million relative to the status quo, which is translated to $462 per DALY averted. The societal costs were estimated to be $115 million for mCARE programme (48% of which are programme costs, 35% user costs and 17% provider costs). With the continued implementation and geographical scaling-up, the mCARE programme improved its cost-effectiveness from $1152 to $462 per DALY averted from 5 to 10 years. CONCLUSION: Mobile phone-based pregnancy surveillance systems with individually scheduled text messages and home-visit reminder strategies can be highly cost-effective in Bangladesh. The cost-effectiveness may improve as it promotes facility-based child delivery and achieves greater programme cost efficiency with programme scale and sustainability.
Assuntos
Atenção à Saúde , Aceitação pelo Paciente de Cuidados de Saúde , Bangladesh/epidemiologia , Criança , Análise Custo-Benefício , Feminino , Serviços de Saúde , Humanos , GravidezRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: We examined the incremental cost-effectiveness between two mHealth programs, implemented from 2011 to 2015 in rural Bangladesh: (1) Comprehensive mCARE package as an intervention group and (2) Basic mCARE package as a control group. METHODS: Both programs included a core package of census enumeration and pregnancy surveillance provided by an established cadre of digitally enabled community health workers (CHWs). In the comprehensive mCARE package, short message service (SMS) and home visit reminders were additionally sent to pregnant women (n = 610) and CHWs (n = 70) to promote the pregnant women's care-seeking of essential maternal and newborn care services. Economic costs were assessed from a program perspective inclusive of development, start-up, and implementation phases. Effects were calculated as disability adjusted life years (DALYs) and the number of newborn deaths averted. For comparative purposes, we normalized our evaluation to estimate total costs and total newborn deaths averted per 1 million people in a community for both groups. Uncertainty was assessed using probabilistic sensitivity analyses with Monte Carlo simulation. RESULTS: The addition of SMS and home visit reminders based on a mobile phone-facilitated pregnancy surveillance system was highly cost effective at a cost per DALY averted of $31 (95% uncertainty range: $19-81). The comprehensive mCARE program had at least 88% probability of being highly cost-effective as compared to the basic mCARE program based on the threshold of Bangladesh's GDP per capita. CONCLUSION: mHealth strategies such as SMS and home visit reminders on a well-established pregnancy surveillance system may improve service utilization and program cost-effectiveness in low-resource settings.