The interplay between agency and therapeutic bond in predicting symptom severity in long-term psychotherapy.

This study investigated the interplay between agency and therapeutic bond in predicting patient symptoms in outpatient psychotherapy. A total of N = 731 patients provided measurements of agency (Therapeutic Agency Inventory; TAI), therapeutic bond (bond subscale of Working Alliance Inventory-Short Form Revised [WAI-SR]), and symptoms (Symptom Checklist Short Form [SCL-K11]) every fifth session of long-term treatment for up to 60 sessions. When investigated in separate models, both more agency and a stronger therapeutic bond predicted symptom improvement. However, within-person changes and between-person differences in agency predicted symptom improvement over and above the effects of therapeutic bond. Multilevel response surface analysis was used to further investigate the interplay between agency and therapeutic bond. When both agency and therapeutic bond levels were high, symptoms improved the most. When agency and therapeutic bond ratings differed, symptom ratings were significantly lower when agency exceeded therapeutic bond levels than when therapeutic bond ratings exceeded agency. Findings suggest that both agency and therapeutic bond are important treatment factors, but outcome could be improved when a strong therapeutic bond is combined with an equally strong sense of agency that empowers patients to pursue changes in their lives. When a strong therapeutic bond is present, but the patient feels less agentic, therapists may want to foster agency to improve outcomes. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).

[Level of personality functioning and attachment style as predictors of the successful referral to outpatient psychotherapy]. / Persönlichkeitsstruktur und Bindungsstil als Prädiktoren für die erfolgreiche Aufnahme einer ambulanten psychotherapeutischen Behandlung.

Level of personality functioning and attachment style as predictors of the successful referral to outpatient psychotherapy Objectives: Outpatient psychotherapy is a key element in the effective treatment of mental health problems. First results suggest that interpersonal problems lead to difficulties in receiving outpatient psychotherapeutic treatment. The relationship between these difficulties, attachment style, and the level of personality functioning is still unclear. Methods: We invited 1011 patients of a psychosomatic-psychotherapeutic university outpatient clinic to participate in the study. The clinical diagnoses according to ICD-10, as well as symptoms of depression (PHQ-D), and quality of life (SF-36) were recorded. Hypothesized predictors for the successful referral to outpatient therapy were patient age, availability of local outpatient treatment, number of ICD-10 diagnoses, the motivation for psychotherapy (FPTM), fear of stigmatization (Stig-9), level of personality functioning (OPD-SQ), and attachment style (ECR-RD). Results: We were able to catamnestically reassess n = 300 patients (67.3 % of patients initially referred to outpatient therapy). A smaller number of clinical diagnoses, greater availability of psychotherapeutic care and higher therapy motivation, as well as a lower level of personality functioning predicted the successful referral to outpatient psychotherapy, while the combination of impaired personality functioning and avoidant attachment style was a negative predictor. Conclusions: Contrary to expectations, patients with a lower level of personality functioning are more successful in receiving outpatient psychotherapy. However, patients with a combination of impaired personality functioning and a high degree of attachment avoidance run the risk of not asserting their need for treatment.

Association Between Insight and Outcome of Psychotherapy: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.

OBJECTIVE: An increased understanding of repetitive dysfunctional patterns and their relationship to an individual's life history is regarded as a key mechanism of change in insight-oriented therapies. At the same time, empirical research on the insight-outcome relationship is rare, and its generalizability is restricted by the use of a wide range of definitions and methods among studies. The authors conducted a meta-analysis to systematically examine the association between patient insight and psychotherapy outcome across a range of treatment modalities. METHOD: Insight was defined as patients' understanding of associations between past and present experiences, typical relationship patterns, and the relation between interpersonal challenges, emotional experience, and psychological symptoms. From 13,849 initially identified abstracts, the authors extracted 23 independent effect sizes. A random-effects meta-analysis was performed to assess the magnitude of the insight-outcome relationship. Risk of publication bias was assessed with funnel plot inspections, Egger's regression test, and Duval and Tweedie's trim-and-fill procedure as sensitivity analyses. RESULTS: A significant, moderate correlation (r=0.31) was observed between insight and treatment outcome. Sensitivity analyses demonstrated the robustness of the results. CONCLUSIONS: The findings support the importance of insight for psychotherapy outcome. Insight may be a relevant mechanism of change across different treatment modalities.