The Value of Fundoplication in the Treatment of Type I Achalasia.

BACKGROUND: Type I achalasia comprises 20% of achalasia and has nearly absent esophageal motor activity. Concerns that fundoplication decreases the effectiveness of Heller myotomy in these patients has increased adoption of peroral endoscopic myotomy (POEM). Hence, we compared outcomes after Heller myotomy with Dor fundoplication vs POEM. METHODS: From 2005 to 2020, 150 patients with type I achalasia underwent primary surgical myotomy (117 Heller myotomy, 33 POEM). Patient demographics, prior treatments, timed barium esophagrams, Eckardt scores, and reinterventions were assessed between the 2 groups. Median follow-up was 5 years for Heller myotomy and 2.5 years for POEM. RESULTS: The Heller myotomy group was younger, had fewer comorbidities, and lower body mass index vs POEM. Risk-adjusted models demonstrated clinical success (Eckardt ≤3) in 83% of Heller myotomies and 87% of POEMs at 3 years; longitudinal complete timed barium esophagram emptying and reintervention were also similar. An abnormal pH test result was documented in 10% (6 of 60) after Heller myotomy and in 45% (10 of 22) after POEM (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Despite nearly absent esophageal contractility, Heller myotomy with Dor fundoplication and POEM result in similar long-term symptom relief, esophageal emptying, and occurrence of reintervention in patients with type I achalasia. There is decreased esophageal acid exposure with the addition of a fundoplication, without compromised esophageal drainage, allaying fears of a detrimental effect of a fundoplication. Hence, choice of procedure may be personalized based on patient characteristics and esophageal morphology and not solely on manometric subtype.

A comparative study of robotic and laparoscopic approaches to Heller myotomy.

OBJECTIVE: Minimally invasive Heller myotomy for achalasia is commonly performed laparoscopically, but recently done with robotic assistance. We compare outcomes of the 2 approaches. METHODS: From January 2010 to January 2020, 447 patients underwent Heller myotomy with anterior fundoplication (170 with robotic assistance and 277 laparoscopically). End points included short-term and longitudinal esophageal emptying according to timed barium esophagram, symptom relief according to Eckardt score, and time-related reintervention. Normal esophageal morphology, present in 328 patients, was defined as nonsigmoidal with width <5 cm. We performed a propensity score--matched analysis to evaluate outcomes among robotic and laparoscopic groups. RESULTS: Timed barium esophagrams showed complete emptying at 5 minutes in 58% (77/132) of the robotic group and 48% (115/241) of the laparoscopic group in the short term (within 6 months of surgery). In the propensity-matched patients with normal esophageal morphology, the robotic group had a higher longitudinal prevalence of complete emptying of barium at 5 minutes (54% vs 34% at 4 years; P = .05), better intermediate-term Eckardt scores (1.7% vs 10% > 3 at 4 years; P = .0008), and actuarially fewer reinterventions (1.2% vs 11% at 3 years; P = .04). CONCLUSIONS: Both robotically assisted and laparoscopic Heller myotomy had excellent outcomes in patients treated for achalasia. In a matched subgroup of patients with normal esophageal morphology within this heterogeneous disease, the robotic approach might be associated with greater esophageal emptying, palliation of symptoms, and freedom from reintervention in the intermediate term. Long-term analysis would be important to determine if this trend persists.