Lumbar Discectomy and Reoperation Among Workers' Compensation Cases in Florida and New York: Are Treatment Trends Similar to Other Payer Types?

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to better understand current treatment trends and revision rates for lumbar disc herniation (LDH) in the workers' compensation (WC) population compared with other payer types. METHODS: This was a retrospective analysis of outpatient claims data from Florida and New York during 2014 to 2016. RESULTS: WC patients were less likely to undergo discectomy in Florida (15% vs 19%; P < 0.001) and New York (10% vs 15%; P < 0.001). The odds of WC patients undergoing revision discectomy were 1.5 times greater than patients covered by private payers or all other non-WC payers (P = 0.002). CONCLUSIONS: WC patients undergo discectomy significantly less often than non-WC counterparts, which may be related to a higher risk of reoperation. New evidence-based treatments, such as annular repair, may be critical to advancing care in this unique population.

The Disability Cascade: A Preventable Consequence of the Loss of Disc Height following Lumbar Microdiscectomy.

Lumbar discectomy is a mainstay surgical treatment for herniation of the lumbar discs and is effective at treating radicular symptomology. Despite the overall success of the procedure; the potential for reherniation and reoperation is significant. To avoid this potential recurrence, surgeons often perform discectomy more aggressively, removing a larger volume of nuclear material in the hopes of minimizing the likelihood of reherniation. This approach, while beneficial in minimizing the chance of reherniation, is associated with a volumetric reduction of the nucleus within the disc space, making the disc more prone to collapse and thus inducing a significant post-operative loss of disc height. While potentially minor in isolation, the loss of disc height, in fact, impacts several aspects of overall patient well-being. We hypothesize that the loss of disc height following discectomy causes an increase in pain and subsequent disability, the combination of which ultimately impacts socioeconomic factors affecting both the patient and the healthcare system as a whole. In this report, we outline the evidence in support of this disability cascade and provide recommendations on methods for limiting its impact. Given the current focus on cost-effectiveness in healthcare decision-making, methods for limiting this potentially damaging sequence of events must be investigated.

Closing the Treatment Gap for Lumbar Disc Herniation Patients with Large Annular Defects: A Systematic Review of Techniques and Outcomes in this High-risk Population.

Lumbar disc herniation (LDH) is one of the most common spinal pathologies and can be associated with debilitating pain and neurological dysfunction. Discectomy is the primary surgical intervention for LDH and is typically successful. Yet, some patients experience recurrent LDH (RLDH) after discectomy, which is associated with worse clinical outcomes and greater socioeconomic burden. Large defects in the annulus fibrosis are a significant risk factor for RLDH and present a critical treatment challenge. It is essential to identify reliable and cost-effective treatments for this at-risk population. A systematic review of the PubMed and Embase databases was performed according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines to identify studies describing the treatment of LDH patients with large annular defects. The incidence of large annular defects, measurement technique, RLDH rate, and reoperation rate were compiled and stratified by surgical technique. The risk of bias was scored for each study and for the identification of RLDH and reoperation. Study heterogeneity and pooled estimates were calculated from the included articles. Fifteen unique studies describing 2,768 subjects were included. The pooled incidence of patients with a large annular defect was 44%. The pooled incidence of RLDH and reoperation following conventional limited discectomy in this population was 10.6% and 6.0%, respectively. A more aggressive technique, subtotal discectomy, tended to have lower rates of RLDH (5.8%) and reoperation (3.8%). However, patients treated with subtotal discectomy reported greater back and leg pain associated with disc degeneration. The quality of evidence was low for subtotal discectomy as an alternative to limited discectomy. Each report had a high risk of bias and treatments were never randomized. A recent randomized controlled trial with 550 subjects examined an annular closure device (ACD) and observed significant reductions in RLDH and reoperation rates (>50% reduction). Based on the available evidence, current discectomy techniques are inadequate for patients with large annular defects, leaving a treatment gap for this high-risk population. Currently, the strongest evidence indicates that augmenting limited discectomy with an ACD can reduce RLDH and revision rates in patients with large annular defects, with a low risk of device complications.

Reduction of direct costs in high-risk lumbar discectomy patients during the 90-day post-operative period through annular closure.

PURPOSE: Despite being an extremely successful procedure, recurrent disc herniation is one of the most common post-discectomy complications in the lumbar spine and contributes significant health care and socioeconomic costs. Patients with large annular defects are at a high risk for reherniation, but an annular closure device (ACD) has been designed to reduce reherniation risk in this population and may, in turn, help control direct health care costs after discectomy. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This analysis examined the 90-day post-discectomy cost estimates among ACD-treated (n=272) and control (discectomy alone; n=278) patients in a randomized controlled trial (RCT). Direct medical costs were estimated based on 2017 Humana and Medicare claims. Index discectomies were assumed to occur in an outpatient (OP) setting, whereas repeat discectomies were assumed to be 60% in OP and 40% in inpatient (IP). A sensitivity analysis was performed on this assumption. The device cost was not included in the analysis in order to focus on costs in the 90-day post-operative period. RESULTS: Within 90 days of follow-up, post-operative complications occurred in 3.3% of the ACD patients and 8.6% of the control patients (P=0.01). The average 90-day cost to treat an ACD patient was $10,257 compared to $11,299 per control patient for a 80:20 distribution of Commercial:Medicare coverage ($1,042 difference). This difference varied from $687 with 100% Medicare to $1,132 with 100% Commercial coverage. Varying the IP vs OP distribution resulted in a cost difference range of $968 to $1,156 with the ACD. CONCLUSION: Augmenting discectomy with an ACD in high-risk patients with a large annular defect reduced reherniation and reoperation rates, which translated to a reduction of direct health care costs between $687 and $1,156 per patient during the 90-day post-operative period. Large annular defect patients are an easily identifiable high-risk population. Operative strategies that reduce complication risks in these patients, such as the ACD, could be advantageous from both patient care and economic perspectives.

Improving healthcare value through clinical community and supply chain collaboration.

BACKGROUND: We hypothesized that integrating supply chain with clinical communities would allow for clinician-led supply cost reduction and improved value in an academic health system. METHODS: Three clinical communities (spine, joint, blood management) and one clinical community-like physician led team of surgeon stakeholders partnered with the supply chain team on specific supply cost initiatives. The teams reviewed their specific utilization and cost data, and the physicians led consensus-building conversations over a series of team meetings to agree to standard supply utilization. RESULTS: The spine and joint clinical communities each agreed upon a vendor capping model that led to cost savings of $3 million dollars and $1.5 million dollars respectively. The blood management decreased blood product utilization and achieved $1.2 million dollars savings. $5.6 million dollars in savings was achieved by a clinical community-like group of surgeon stakeholders through standardization of sutures and endomechanicals. CONCLUSIONS: Physician led clinical teams empowered to lead change achieved substantial supply chain cost savings in an academic health system. The model of combining clinical communities with supply chain offers hope for an effective, practical, and scalable approach to improving value and engaging physicians in other academic health systems. IMPLICATIONS: This clinician led model could benefit both private and academic health systems engaging in value optimization efforts. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: N/A.

The role of Osteocel Plus as a fusion substrate in minimally invasive instrumented transforaminal lumbar interbody fusion.

BACKGROUND: Instrumented lumbar fusion has become an accepted and effective surgical technique used to address a wide variety of conditions of the lumbar spine. Iliac crest autograft remains the gold standard with regards to bony fusion substrate. Unfortunately there are significant potential disadvantages associated with autograft harvest, including pain, infection, iatrogenic fracture and bleeding. Osteocel Plus (OC+) is an allograft cellular bone matrix containing mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and osteoprogenitor cells combined with DBM and cancellous bone. OC+ is designed to mimic the osteobiologic profile of human autograft bone, thereby eliminating the risks of autograft harvest. METHODS: A retrospective chart review was conducted to identify all patients who had undergone a MITLIF with OC+ for degenerative lumbar conditions. Patient demographics including age, sex, history of risk factors for nonunion including: osteoporosis documented on DEXA scanning, diabetes mellitus, smoking or steroid use were examined and recorded. Successful arthrodesis was judged based on post-operative X-ray imaging. RESULTS: 23 patients at 26 spinal levels underwent a MITLIF with OC+. Twenty-one patients (91.3%) and 24 levels (92.3%) went on to achieve radiographic evidence of solid bony arthrodesis by 12 months post-op. Six patients (26%) demonstrated clear evidence of early interbody bone growth within 6 months of surgery. CONCLUSION: OC+ results in robust and reproducible lumbar interbody fusion, in both young and older patients.

Acute tetraplegia and cardiac arrest following high cervical leptomeningeal metastasis of giant cell glioblastoma.

Giant cell glioblastoma multiforme (gcGBM) is an unusual subtype of high-grade glioma (grade IV, World Health Organization classification). We report a patient with a rare acute tetraplegia, followed by lethal cardiac arrest, who had undergone a prior resection of a supratentorial gcGBM. Neuroradiological workup revealed a large, high cervical compressive leptomeningeal mass consistent with a drop metastasis. Due to the possibility of a rapid clinical deterioration in patients with high cervical cord compression, the diagnosis of drop metastasis to the spine should be considered in patients with a previous history of supratentorial GBM who present with acute diffuse motor weakness.

Pathologic cervical burst fracture presenting with airway compromise.

Mechanical airway compromise following cervical spine injury or fracture is a rare but known entity. It most commonly is the result of the development of a retropharyngeal hematoma or prevertebral soft tissue edema that obstructs the airway, leading to respiratory distress and emergent need for airway management and possible surgical intervention. We present a novel case of airway compromise following a C3 burst fracture without associated retropharyngeal hematoma or prevertebral soft tissue edema. Surgical management is discussed, and a review of relevant literature is provided. Pathological cervical spine fracture must be included in the differential diagnosis of a patient presenting with acute airway obstruction of unknown etiology.

Cruciate paralysis secondary to traumatic atlantooccipital dislocation.

Cruciate paralysis is a clinical phenomenon thought to result from injury to decussating pyramidal tract fibers at the cervicomedullary junction, producing clinical findings of upper-extremity weakness out of proportion to the lower extremities. The authors present, to their knowledge, the first reported case of cruciate paralysis resulting from atlantooccipital dislocation.

Wrong-sided surgery.

OBJECT: Perhaps the single greatest error that a surgeon hopes to avoid is operating at the wrong site. In this report, the authors describe the incidence and possible determinants of incorrect-site surgery (ICSS) among neurosurgeons. METHODS: The authors asked neurosurgeons to complete an anonymous survey. These surgeons were asked to report the number of craniotomies and lumbar and cervical discectomies performed during the previous year, as well as whether ICSS had occurred. They were also asked detailed questions regarding the potential determinants of ICSS. RESULTS: There was a 75% response rate and a 68% survey completion rate. Participating neurosurgeons performed 4695 lumbar and 2649 cervical discectomies, as well as 10,203 craniotomies. Based on this self-reporting, the incidence of wrong-level lumbar surgery was estimated to be 4.5 occurrences per 10,000 operations. The ICSSs per 10,000 cervical discectomies and craniotomies were 6.8 and 2.2, respectively. Neurosurgeons recognized fatigue, unusual time pressure, and emergent operations as factors contributing to ICSS. For spine surgery, in particular, unusual patient anatomy and a failure to verify the operative site by radiography were also commonly reported contributors. CONCLUSIONS: Neurosurgical ICSSs do occur, but are rare events. Although there are significant limitations to the survey-based methodology, the data suggest that the prevention of such errors will require neurosurgeons to recognize risk factors and increase the use of intraoperative imaging.

A novel technique for the intraoperative monitoring of detrusor activity in intradural lesions of the cauda equina. Technical note.

BACKGROUND: Intradural pathology in the region of the cauda equina is uncommon and generally comes to attention secondary to pain or neurologic deficit. A number of surgeons choose to excise these lesions under EMG monitoring of the nerve roots supplying the lower extremity muscles, anal sphincter, and detrusor muscle. In this article, the authors describe a detrusor muscle monitoring technique that has been found to be simple, reliable, and cost-effective in the management of intradural pathology of the cauda equina. METHODS: Fourteen consecutive patients with tumors of the cauda equina who underwent surgical management performed using the standard Foley catheter monitoring technique were included in this study and their outcomes analyzed. RESULTS: In 86% of patients, a gross total resection was achieved. Subtotal resections were performed in 2 patients because of involvement of critical nerve roots. In all cases, the nerve roots supplying the detrusor muscle were successfully identified using this technique. No patient suffered a clinically apparent decline in bladder function during the postoperative period. CONCLUSION: The standard Foley catheter detrusor monitoring technique is a simple, reliable, and cost-effective method to identify and prevent injury to the sacral nerve roots innervating the urinary bladder during intradural exploration of the cauda equina.

Mechanisms of morbid hearing loss associated with tumors of the endolymphatic sac in von Hippel-Lindau disease.

CONTEXT: Endolymphatic sac tumors (ELSTs) are associated with von Hippel-Lindau disease and cause irreversible sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) and vestibulopathy. The underlying mechanisms of audiovestibular morbidity remain unclear and optimal timing of treatment is not known. OBJECTIVE: To define the mechanisms underlying audiovestibular pathophysiology associated with ELSTs. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PATIENTS: Prospective and serial evaluation of patients with von Hippel-Lindau disease and ELSTs at the National Institutes of Health between May 1990 and December 2006. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Clinical findings and audiologic data were correlated with serial magnetic resonance imaging and computed tomography imaging studies to determine mechanisms underlying audiovestibular dysfunction. RESULTS: Thirty-five patients with von Hippel-Lindau disease and ELSTs in 38 ears (3 bilateral ELSTs) were identified. Tumor invasion of the otic capsule was associated with larger tumors (P = .01) and occurred in 7 ears (18%) causing SNHL (100%). No evidence of otic capsule invasion was present in the remaining 31 ears (82%). SNHL developed in 27 of these 31 ears (87%) either suddenly (14 ears; 52%) or gradually (13 ears; 48%) and 4 ears had normal hearing. Intralabyrinthine hemorrhage was found in 11 of 14 ears with sudden SNHL (79%; P < .001) but occurred in none of the 17 ears with gradual SNHL or normal hearing. Tumor size was not related to SNHL (P = .23) or vestibulopathy (P = .83). CONCLUSIONS: ELST-associated SNHL and vestibulopathy may occur suddenly due to tumor-associated intralabyrinthine hemorrhage, or insidiously, consistent with endolymphatic hydrops. Both of these pathophysiologic mechanisms occur with small tumors that are not associated with otic capsule invasion.

A prospective evaluation of the role for intraoperative x-ray in lumbar discectomy. Predictors of incorrect level exposure.

BACKGROUND: Lumbar discectomy is among the most frequently performed procedures by spine surgeons. Among the potential difficulties encountered during this procedure, incorrect spinal level surgery remains a significant concern for surgeons and patients. Multiple groups have advocated the use of intraoperative x-ray to reduce the incidence of incorrect level surgery; however, this technique has not been prospectively evaluated. METHODS: In an effort to determine the incidence of incorrect level exposure during lumbar discectomy and to define patient characteristics predictive of wrong level exposure, we examined 100 consecutive patients who underwent lumbar discectomy by a single surgeon. After exposure, the surgeon was asked to identify the level exposed, which was confirmed by intraoperative x-ray. Several patient characteristics were then examined by logistical regression to identify features predictive of a mismatch between level of exposure and level of pathology. RESULTS: The study population was composed of 48 men and 52 women who were aged 18 to 83 years. Patient weights ranged from 105 to 410 lb. There were 51 patients who had pathology at the L5-S1 level; 44 patients, L4-L5; 3 patients, L3-L4; and 1 patient, L2-L3. Four patients had transitional vertebrae. The intended level was initially exposed in 85% of cases. Age and level of pathology (P < .05) were identified as factors predictive of a mismatch between intraoperative level of exposure and preoperative level of pathology. CONCLUSIONS: Pathology above L5-S1 and patient age have been shown to reliably predict incorrect level exposure. Based upon the findings of this study, the routine use of intraoperative x-ray to confirm the level of exposure should be considered in all cases of lumbar discectomy.

Multiple metachronous brain metastases from primary ureteral carcinoma.

Transitional cell carcinoma (TCC) of the ureter is an uncommon urologic malignancy, with approximately 150 cases diagnosed annually. Metastatic brain disease from ureteral TCC is exceedingly rare. To our knowledge, our case report represents only the second report of brain metastasis from ureteral TCC and the only reported patient to undergo resection of their TCC brain metastasis.