General Characterization of Properties of Ordered and Disordered Proteins by Wide-Line 1H NMR.

Wide-line 1H NMR is an efficient spectroscopic method to determine the disorder tendency of a protein. It directly measures the properties of the hydration shell of proteins, delivering exact and measurable values of their disorder/order content. A comparison is performed between several globular and disordered proteins. The common properties of the subzero mobile hydration water of these two groups were investigated. The amount of the mobile hydration water and the shape of the melting diagram at subzero temperatures together provide a possibility to distinguish globular proteins from disordered proteins. The shape of the melting diagram also gives information about the presence of secondary structural elements. The disordered and globular protein regions' fundamentally different structures are reflected in their melting diagrams, allowing one to directly determine the level of disorder in a specific protein structure. Intrinsically disordered proteins bind water more strongly than globular proteins, which is shown by the somewhat higher temperature values where mobile hydration water first appears but with a significantly higher heterogeneity in the energy distributions of protein-water interactions.

Wide-Line NMR Melting Diagrams, Their Thermodynamic Interpretation, and Secondary Structure Predictions for A30P and E46K α-Synuclein.

Parkinson's disease is thought to be caused by aggregation of the intrinsically disordered protein, α-synuclein. Two amyloidogenic variants, A30P, and E46K familial mutants were investigated by wide-line 1H NMR spectrometry as a completion of our earlier work on wild-type and A53T α-synuclein (Bokor M. et al. WT and A53T α-synuclein systems: melting diagram and its new interpretation. Int. J. Mol. Sci.2020, 21, 3997.). A monolayer of mobile water molecules hydrates A30P α-synuclein at the lowest potential barriers (temperatures), while E46K α-synuclein has here third as much mobile hydration, insufficient for functionality. According to wide-line 1H NMR results and secondary structure predictions, E46K α-synuclein is more compact than the A30P variant and they are more compact than the wild type (WT) and A53T variants. Linear hydration vs potential barrier sections of A30P α-synuclein shows one and E46K shows two slopes. The different slopes of the latter between potential barriers E a,1 and E a,2 reflect a change in water-protein interactions. The 31-32% homogeneous potential barrier distribution of the protein-water bonds refers to a non-negligible amount of secondary structures in all four α-synuclein variants. The secondary structures detected by wide-line 1H NMR are solvent-exposed α-helices, which are predicted by secondary structure models. ß-sheets are only minor components of the protein structures as three- and eight-state predicted secondary structures are dominated by α-helices and coils.

Protein-Protein Connections-Oligomer, Amyloid and Protein Complex-By Wide Line 1H NMR.

The amount of bonds between constituting parts of a protein aggregate were determined in wild type (WT) and A53T α-synuclein (αS) oligomers, amyloids and in the complex of thymosin-ß4-cytoplasmic domain of stabilin-2 (Tß4-stabilin CTD). A53T αS aggregates have more extensive ßsheet contents reflected by constant regions at low potential barriers in difference (to monomers) melting diagrams (MDs). Energies of the intermolecular interactions and of secondary structures bonds, formed during polymerization, fall into the 5.41 kJ mol-1 ≤ Ea ≤ 5.77 kJ mol-1 range for αS aggregates. Monomers lose more mobile hydration water while forming amyloids than oligomers. Part of the strong mobile hydration water-protein bonds break off and these bonding sites of the protein form intermolecular bonds in the aggregates. The new bonds connect the constituting proteins into aggregates. Amyloid-oligomer difference MD showed an overall more homogeneous solvent accessible surface of A53T αS amyloids. From the comparison of the nominal sum of the MDs of the constituting proteins to the measured MD of the Tß4-stabilin CTD complex, the number of intermolecular bonds connecting constituent proteins into complex is 20(1) H2O/complex. The energies of these bonds are in the 5.40(3) kJ mol-1 ≤ Ea ≤ 5.70(5) kJ mol-1 range.

Secondary Structures of Proteins: A Comparison of Models and Experimental Results.

Secondary structure predictions of proteins were compared to experimental results by wide-line 1H NMR. IUPred2A was used to generate predictions of disordered protein or binding regions. Thymosin-ß4 and the stabilin-2 cytoplasmic domain were found to be mainly disordered, in agreement with the experimental results. α-Synuclein variants were predicted to be disordered, as in the experiments, but the A53T mutant showed less predicted disorder, in contrast with the wide-line 1H NMR result. A disordered binding site was found for thymosin-ß4, whereas the stabilin-2 cytoplasmic domain was indicated as such in its entire length. The last third of the α-synuclein variant's sequence was a disordered binding site. Thymosin-ß4 and the stabilin-2 cytoplasmic domain contained only coils and helices according to five secondary structure prediction methods (SPIDER3-SPOT-1D, PSRSM, MUFold-SSW, Porter 5, and RaptorX). ß-Sheets are present in α-synucleins, and they extend to more amino acid residues in the A53T mutant according to the predictions. The latter is verified by experiments. The comparison of the predictions with the experiments suggests that helical parts are buried.

WT and A53T α-Synuclein Systems: Melting Diagram and Its New Interpretation.

The potential barriers governing the motions of α-synuclein (αS) variants' hydration water, especially energetics of them, is in the focus of the work. The thermodynamical approach yielded essential information about distributions and heights of the potential barriers. The proteins' structural disorder was measured by ratios of heterogeneous water-binding interfaces. They showed the αS monomers, oligomers and amyloids to possess secondary structural elements, although monomers are intrinsically disordered. Despite their disordered nature, monomers have 33% secondary structure, and therefore they are more compact than a random coil. At the lowest potential barriers with mobile hydration water, monomers are already functional, a monolayer of mobile hydration water is surrounding them. Monomers realize all possible hydrogen bonds with the solvent water. αS oligomers and amyloids have half of the mobile hydration water amount than monomers because aggregation involves less mobile hydration. The solvent-accessible surface of the oligomers is ordered or homogenous in its interactions with water to 66%. As a contrast, αS amyloids are disordered or heterogeneous to 75% of their solvent accessible surface and both wild type and A53T amyloids show identical, low-level hydration. Mobile water molecules in the first hydration shell of amyloids are the weakest bound compared to other forms.

Hydration shell differentiates folded and disordered states of a Trp-cage miniprotein, allowing characterization of structural heterogeneity by wide-line NMR measurements.

Hydration properties of folded and unfolded/disordered miniproteins were monitored in frozen solutions by wide-line 1H-NMR. The amount of mobile water as function of T (-80 °C < T < 0 °C) was found characteristically different for folded (TC5b), semi-folded (pH < 3, TCb5(H+)) and disordered (TC5b_N1R) variants. Comparing results of wide-line 1H-NMR and molecular dynamics simulations we found that both the amount of mobile water surrounding proteins in ice, as well as their thaw profiles differs significantly as function of the compactness and conformational heterogeneity of their structure. We found that (i) at around -50 °C ~50 H2Os/protein melt (ii) if the protein is well-folded then this amount of mobile water remains quasi-constant up to -20 °C, (iii) if disordered then the quantity of the lubricating mobile water increases with T in a constant manner up to ~200 H2Os/protein by reaching -20 °C. Especially in the -55 °C ↔ -15 °C temperature range, wide-line 1H-NMR detects the heterogeneity of protein fold, providing the size of the hydration shell surrounding the accessible conformers at a given temperature. Results indicate that freezing of protein solutions proceeds by the gradual selection of the enthalpically most favored states that also minimize the number of bridging waters.

The Melting Diagram of Protein Solutions and Its Thermodynamic Interpretation.

Here we present a novel method for the characterization of the hydration of protein solutions based on measuring and evaluating two-component wide-line ¹H NMR signals. We also provide a description of key elements of the procedure conceived for the thermodynamic interpretation of such results. These interdependent experimental and theoretical treatments provide direct experimental insight into the potential energy surface of proteins. The utility of our approach is demonstrated through the examples of two proteins of distinct structural classes: the globular, structured ubiquitin; and the intrinsically disordered ERD10 (early response to dehydration 10). We provide a detailed analysis and interpretation of data recorded earlier by cooling and slowly warming the protein solutions through thermal equilibrium states. We introduce and use order parameters that can be thus derived to characterize the distribution of potential energy barriers inhibiting the movement of water molecules bound to the surface of the protein. Our results enable a quantitative description of the ratio of ordered and disordered parts of proteins, and of the energy relations of protein⁻water bonds in aqueous solutions of the proteins.

Molecular Motions and Interactions in Aqueous Solutions of Thymosin-ß4 , Stabilin C-Terminal Domain (CTD) and Their 1:1 Complex Studied by 1 H†NMR Spectroscopy.

Wide-line 1 H NMR measurements were extended and all results were reinterpreted in a new thermodynamics-based approach to study aqueous solutions of thymosin-ß4 (Tß4 ), stabilin C-terminal domain (CTD) and their 1:1 complex. The energy distributions of the potential barriers, which control motion of protein-bound water molecules, were determined. Heterogeneous and homogeneous regions were found at the protein-water interface. The measure of heterogeneity gives a quantitative value for the portion of disordered parts in the protein. Ordered structural elements were found extending up to 20 % of the whole proteins. About 40 % of the binding sites of free Tß4 become involved in bonds holding the complex together. The complex has the most heterogeneous solvent accessible surface (SAS) in terms of protein-water interactions. The complex is more disordered than Tß4 or stabilin CTD. The greater SAS area of the complex is interpreted as a clear sign of its open structure.

Hydrogen Mobility and Protein-Water Interactions in Proteins in the Solid State.

In this work the groundwork is laid for characterizing the mobility of hydrogen-hydrogen pairs (proton-proton radial vectors) in proteins in the solid state that contain only residual water. In this novel approach, we introduce new ways of analyzing and interpreting data: 1) by representing hydrogen mobility (HM) and melting diagram (MD) data recorded by wide-line 1 H NMR spectroscopic analysis as a function of fundamental temperature (thermal excitation energy); 2) by suggesting a novel mode of interpretation of these parameters that sheds light on details of protein-water interactions, such as the exact amount of water molecules and the distribution of barrier potentials pertaining to their rotational and surface translational mobility; 3) by relying on directly determined physical observables. We illustrate the power of this approach by studying the behavior of two proteins, the structured enzyme lysozyme and the intrinsically disordered ERD14.

Wide-line NMR and DSC studies on intrinsically disordered p53 transactivation domain and its helically pre-structured segment.

Wide-line 1H NMR intensity and differential scanning calorimetry measurements were carried out on the intrinsically disordered 73-residue full transactivation domain (TAD) of the p53 tumor suppressor protein and two peptides: one a wild type p53 TAD peptide with a helix pre-structuring property, and a mutant peptide with a disabled helix-forming propensity. Measurements were carried out in order to characterize their water and ion binding characteristics. By quantifying the number of hydrate water molecules, we provide a microscopic description for the interactions of water with a wild-type p53 TAD and two p53 TAD peptides. The results provide direct evidence that intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and a less structured peptide not only have a higher hydration capacity than globular proteins, but are also able to bind a larger amount of charged solute ions. [BMB Reports 2016; 49(9): 497-501].

Structural disorder and local order of hNopp140.

Human nucleolar phosphoprotein p140 (hNopp 140) is a highly phosphorylated protein inhibitor of casein kinase 2 (CK2). As in the case of many kinase-inhibitor systems, the inhibitor has been described to belong to the family of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs), which often utilize transient structural elements to bind their cognate enzyme. Here we investigated the structural status of this protein both to provide distinct lines of evidence for its disorder and to point out its transient structure potentially involved in interactions and also its tendency to aggregate. Structural disorder of hNopp140 is apparent by its anomalous electrophoretic mobility, protease sensitivity, heat stability, hydrodynamic behavior on size-exclusion chromatography, (1)H NMR spectrum and differential scanning calorimetry scan. hNopp140 has a significant tendency to aggregate and the change of its circular dichroism spectrum in the presence of 0-80% TFE suggests a tendency to form local helical structures. Wide-line NMR measurements suggest the overall disordered character of the protein. In all, our data suggest that this protein falls into the pre-molten globule state of IDPs, with a significant tendency to become ordered in the presence of its partner as demonstrated in the presence of transcription factor IIB (TFIIB).

Hydrogen skeleton, mobility and protein architecture.

The mobility of the proton-proton radial vectors is introduced as a quantitative measure for the structural dynamics of organic materials, especially protein molecules. As defined for the entire molecule, the hydrogen mobility (HM) is proposed as an "order parameter," which describes the effect of motional narrowing on inter-proton dipole-dipole interactions. HM satisfies all requirements of an order parameter in the Landau molecular field theory of phase transitions. The wide-line NMR second moments needed to obtain HM are exactly defined and measurable physical quantities, which are not produced by mathematical fitting and do not carry the limitations and restrictions of any model (theoretical formalism). We first demonstrate the usefulness of HM on small organic molecules with data taken form the literature. We outline its link with structural and functional characteristics on a range of proteins: HM provides a model-free parameter based on first principles that can clearly distinguish between globular and intrinsically disordered proteins, and can also provide insight into the behavior of disease-related mutants.

Multiple fuzzy interactions in the moonlighting function of thymosin-ß4.

Thymosine ß4 (Tß4) is a 43 amino acid long intrinsically disordered protein (IDP), which was initially identified as an actin-binding and sequestering molecule. Later it was described to have multiple other functions, such as regulation of endothelial cell differentiation, blood vessel formation, wound repair, cardiac cell migration, and survival.1 The various functions of Tß4 are mediated by interactions with distinct and structurally unrelated partners, such as PINCH, ILK, and stabilin-2, besides the originally identified G-actin. Although the cellular readout of these interactions and the formation of these complexes have been thoroughly described, no attempt was made to study these interactions in detail, and to elucidate the thermodynamic, kinetic, and structural underpinning of this range of moonlighting functions. Because Tß4 is mostly disordered, and its 4 described partners are structurally unrelated (the CTD of stabilin-2 is actually fully disordered), it occurred to us that this system might be ideal to characterize the structural adaptability and ensuing moonlighting functions of IDPs. Unexpectedly, we found that Tß4 engages in multiple weak, transient, and fuzzy interactions, i.e., it is capable of mediating distinct yet specific interactions without adapting stable folded structures.

High levels of structural disorder in scaffold proteins as exemplified by a novel neuronal protein, CASK-interactive protein1.

CASK-interactive protein1 is a newly recognized post-synaptic density protein in mammalian neurons. Although its N-terminal region contains several well-known functional domains, its entire C-terminal proline-rich region of 800 amino acids lacks detectable sequence homology to any previously characterized protein. We used multiple techniques for the structural characterization of this region and its three fragments. By bioinformatics predictions, CD spectroscopy, wide-line and 1H-NMR spectroscopy, limited proteolysis and gel filtration chromatography, we provided evidence that the entire proline-rich region of CASK-interactive protein1 is intrinsically disordered. We also showed that the proline-rich region is biochemically functional, as it interacts with the adaptor protein Abl-interactor-2. To extend the finding of a high level of disorder in this scaffold protein, we collected 74 scaffold proteins (also including proteins denoted as anchor and docking), and predicted their disorder by three different algorithms. We found that a very high fraction (53.6; on average) of the residues fall into local disorder and their ordered domains are connected by linker regions which are mostly disordered (64.5 on average). Because of this high frequency of disorder, the usual design of scaffold proteins of short globular domains (86 amino acids on average) connected by longer linker regions (140 amino acids on average) and the noted binding functions of these regions in both CASK-interactive protein1 and the other proteins studied, we suggest that structurally disordered regions prevail and play key recognition roles in scaffold proteins.

Interfacial water at protein surfaces: wide-line NMR and DSC characterization of hydration in ubiquitin solutions.

Wide-line 1H-NMR and differential scanning calorimetry measurements were done in aqueous solutions and on lyophilized samples of human ubiquitin between -70 degrees C and +45 degrees C. The measured properties (size, thermal evolution, and wide-line NMR spectra) of the protein-water interfacial region are substantially different in the double-distilled and buffered-water solutions of ubiquitin. The characteristic transition in water mobility is identified as the melting of the nonfreezing/hydrate water. The amount of water in the low-temperature mobile fraction is 0.4 g/g protein for the pure water solution. The amount of mobile water is higher and its temperature dependence more pronounced for the buffered solution. The specific heat of the nonfreezing/hydrate water was evaluated using combined differential scanning calorimetry and NMR data. Considering the interfacial region as an independent phase, the values obtained are 5.0-5.8 J x g(-1) x K(-1), and the magnitudes are higher than that of pure/bulk water (4.2 J x g(-1) x K(-1)). This unexpected discrepancy can only be resolved in principle by assuming that hydrate water is in tight H-bond coupling with the protein matrix. The specific heat for the system composed of the protein molecule and its hydration water is 2.3 J x g(-1) x K(-1). It could be concluded that the protein ubiquitin and its hydrate layer behave as a highly interconnected single phase in a thermodynamic sense.

Intrinsic structural disorder of DF31, a Drosophila protein of chromatin decondensation and remodeling activities.

Protein disorder is predicted to be widespread in eukaryotic proteomes, although direct experimental evidence is rather limited so far. To fill this gap and to unveil the identity of novel intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs), proteomic methods that combine 2D electrophoresis with mass spectrometry have been developed. Here, we applied the method developed in our laboratory [ Csizmok et al., Mol. Cell. Proteomics 2006, 5, 265- 273 ] to the proteome of Drosophila melanogaster. Protein Df31, earlier described as a histone chaperone involved in chromatin decondensation and stabilization, was among the IDPs identified. Despite some hints at the unusual structural behavior of Df31, this protein has not yet been structurally characterized. Here, we provide evidence by a variety of techniques such as CD, NMR, gel-filtration, limited proteolyzsis and bioinformatics that Df31 is intrinsically disordered along its entire length. Further, by chemical cross-linking, we provide evidence that it is a monomeric protein, and suggest that its function(s) may benefit from having an extended and highly flexible structural state. The potential functional advantages and the generality of protein disorder among chromatin organizing proteins are discussed in detail. Finally, we also would like to point out the utility of our 2DE/MS technique for discoveringor, as a matter of fact, rediscoveringIDPs even from the complicated proteome of an advanced eukaryote.

Rotor-stator molecular crystals of fullerenes with cubane.

Cubane (C8H8) and fullerene (C60) are famous cage molecules with shapes of platonic or archimedean solids. Their remarkable chemical and solid-state properties have induced great scientific interest. Both materials form polymorphic crystals of molecules with variable orientational ordering. The idea of intercalating fullerene with cubane was raised several years ago but no attempts at preparation have been reported. Here we show that C60 and similarly C70 form high-symmetry molecular crystals with cubane owing to topological molecular recognition between the convex surface of fullerenes and the concave cubane. Static cubane occupies the octahedral voids of the face-centred-cubic structures and acts as a bearing between the rotating fullerene molecules. The smooth contact of the rotor and stator molecules decreases significantly the temperature of orientational ordering. These materials have great topochemical importance: at elevated temperatures they transform to high-stability covalent derivatives although preserving their crystalline appearance. The size-dependent molecular recognition promises selective formation of related structures with higher fullerenes and/or substituted cubanes.

Primary contact sites in intrinsically unstructured proteins: the case of calpastatin and microtubule-associated protein 2.

Intrinsically unstructured proteins (IUPs) exist in a disordered conformational state, often considered to be equivalent with the random-coil structure. We challenge this simplifying view by limited proteolysis, circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy, and solid-state (1)H NMR, to show short- and long-range structural organization in two IUPs, the first inhibitory domain of calpastatin (CSD1) and microtubule-associated protein 2c (MAP2c). Proteases of either narrow (trypsin, chymotrypsin, and plasmin) or broad (subtilisin and proteinase K) substrate specificity, applied at very low concentrations, preferentially cleaved both proteins in regions, i.e., subdomains A, B, and C in CSD1 and the proline-rich region (PRR) in MAP2c, that are destined to form contacts with their targets. For CSD1, nonadditivity of the CD spectra of its two halves and suboptimal hydration of the full-length protein measured by solid-state NMR demonstrate that long-range tertiary interactions provide the structural background of this structural feature. In MAP2c, such tertiary interactions are absent, which points to the importance of local structural constraints. In fact, urea and temperature dependence of the CD spectrum of its PRR reveals the presence of the extended and rather stiff polyproline II helix conformation that keeps the interaction site exposed. These data suggest that functionally significant residual structure exists in both of these IUPs. This structure, manifest as either transient local and/or global organization, ensures the spatial exposure of short contact segments on the surface. Pertinent data from other IUPs suggest that the presence of such recognition motifs may be a general feature of disordered proteins. To emphasize the possible importance of this structural trait, we propose that these motifs be called primary contact sites in IUPs.

NMR relaxation studies on the hydrate layer of intrinsically unstructured proteins.

Intrinsically unstructured/disordered proteins (IUPs) exist in a disordered and largely solvent-exposed, still functional, structural state under physiological conditions. As their function is often directly linked with structural disorder, understanding their structure-function relationship in detail is a great challenge to structural biology. In particular, their hydration and residual structure, both closely linked with their mechanism of action, require close attention. Here we demonstrate that the hydration of IUPs can be adequately approached by a technique so far unexplored with respect to IUPs, solid-state NMR relaxation measurements. This technique provides quantitative information on various features of hydrate water bound to these proteins. By freezing nonhydrate (bulk) water out, we have been able to measure free induction decays pertaining to protons of bound water from which the amount of hydrate water, its activation energy, and correlation times could be calculated. Thus, for three IUPs, the first inhibitory domain of calpastatin, microtubule-associated protein 2c, and plant dehydrin early responsive to dehydration 10, we demonstrate that they bind a significantly larger amount of water than globular proteins, whereas their suboptimal hydration and relaxation parameters are correlated with their differing modes of function. The theoretical treatment and experimental approach presented in this article may have general utility in characterizing proteins that belong to this novel structural class.