Evidence for participation of RNA 1-encoded elicitor in Cowpea mosaic virus-mediated concurrent protection.

The cowpea (Vigna unguiculata) line Arlington, inoculated with Cowpea mosaic virus (CPMV), showed no symptoms, and no infectivity or accumulation of capsid antigen was detected at several days after inoculation. Coinoculation, but not sequential inoculation, of CPMV with similar concentrations of another Comovirus; Cowpea severe mosaic virus (CPSMV), resulted in reduced numbers of CPSMV-induced lesions. This apparent, CPMV-mediated reduction in number of CPSMV-induced infection centers was termed concurrent protection. We report results obtained by inoculating two nearly isogenic cowpea lines derived from a CPMV-susceptible cowpea crossed to Arlington, one line CPMV-susceptible and the other resistant. The CPMV virions B and M, encapsidating genomic RNAs 1 and 2, respectively, were extensively purified by gradient centrifugation. In the CPMV-resistant cowpea, either CPMV or CPMV B affected concurrent protection against CPSMV and against two distinct non-Comoviruses: Cherry leafroll virus and Southern bean mosaic virus. Adding CPMV M to the inoculum did not enhance CPMV-B-mediated protection. CPMV B was ineffective in protecting CPMV-susceptible cowpea. We postulate that CPMV-mediated concurrent protection is elicited in CPMV-resistant cowpea by a CPMV RNA-1-encoded factor and acts to reduce accumulation or spread of CPMV and certain coinoculated challenging viruses in or from the inoculated cell. Coinoculated CPMV did not protect CPMV-resistant cowpea against Tomato bushy stunt virus or Cucumber mosaic virus.

Chemical cleavage of 5'-linked protein from tobacco ringspot virus genomic RNAs and characterization of the protein-RNA linkage.

Each of the two genomic RNAs of tobacco ringspot nepovirus is known to have a 5'-linked protein, the VPg. We report a simplified analysis of the covalent VPg-RNA connection that allowed us to identify the 5' nucleotide residue of each genomic RNA and its phosphodiester link to a specific serine residue of the VPg, without resorting to in vivo labeling with 32P, in vitro radioiodination, or separation of the two genomic RNAs. Unfractionated genomic RNA was incubated with an oligodeoxyribonucleotide specific for the 5' region of either RNA 1 or RNA 2 and ribonuclease H. Reaction products were 3'-end-labeled and were fractionated by gel electrophoresis. The most highly labeled product derived from each genomic RNA was identified as a VPg-oligoribonucleotide (VPg-5'-oligo) by its sensitivity to proteinase. In a presumed beta-elimination reaction that apparently was more rapid than phosphodiester cleavage, incubation in alkaline sodium bicarbonate released a rapidly migrating product, 5'-oligo. Phosphatase-treated 5'-oligo accepted 5'-label in a polynucleotide kinase-catalyzed reaction, and uridylate was identified as the 5' terminal residue for both RNA 1 and RNA 2. Results from Edman degradation of the VPg suggest that the VPg is linked at serine 5 to the 5' uridylate of each genomic RNA.

Trace amount of satellite RNA associated with tobacco ringspot virus: increase stimulated by nonaccumulating satellite RNA mutants.

The small satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus (sTRSV RNA) is dependent on tobacco ringspot virus (TRSV) for replication and encapsidation. sTRSV RNA has appeared during serial passage of certain TRSV strains in some hosts. Co-inoculation of bean with TRSV and either of two related, nonaccumulating mutants of sTRSV RNA induced the appearance of sTRSV RNA in a single passage (van Tol et al., 1991, Virology 180, 23-30). The sTRSV RNA obtained after serial passage and after co-inoculation have the same nucleotide sequence, designated the endogenous sequence. The endogenous sTRSV RNA nucleotide sequence differs from that of each of the nonaccumulating sTRSV RNA at three positions. In order to detect possible trace amounts of endogenous satellite RNA in virion RNA preparations, RNA from two TRSV isolates was subjected to reverse transcription and polymerase chain reaction of the transcript (RT-PCR), using primers with sTRSV RNA terminal sequences. The yield of RT-PCR product suggests that the virion RNA preparations contained approximately 0.1 fg of sTRSV RNA per microgram of virion RNA. The nucleotide sequence of the RT-PCR product corresponded to that of the endogenous sTRSV RNA. The endogenous sTRSV RNA of TRSV inocula appears to be latent, being maintained in very small amounts during serial passage of TRSV in some hosts but capable of dramatic increase during serial passage in other hosts or when TRSV was co-inoculated with either of two specific sTRSV RNA mutants. Ten other nonaccumulating sTRSV RNA mutants did not induce a detected increase in sTRSV RNA.

Increase of satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA initiated by inoculating circular RNA.

A small satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus (sTRSV RNA) generates circular and linear molecules of unit length and repetitive sequence, linear multimers during replication. The phosphodiester junction joining the unit satellite RNA sequences in multimeric and circular RNA resisted base-catalyzed cleavage in circles but not in linear dimers. We postulate that junctions of multimeric satellite RNA form during synthesis of the polyribonucleotide chain, whereas those of circular RNA result from a ligation reaction that introduces a group blocking the junction 2'-hydroxyl. To test the relative effectiveness of linear and circular satellite RNAs in initiating replication, we inoculated onto bean (Phaseolus vulgaris cv Black Valentine) the four possible pairs of satellite RNA molecules, one member of each pair having the wild-type sTRSV RNA sequence and the other that of the replicating mutant 51AG/212CU, with each sequence provided as the unit circular or linear form. The relative amounts of wild-type and mutant satellite RNA sequence recovered from progeny virions reflected their relative abundances in the inoculum without regard to whether the sequence was supplied as a linear or a circular molecule. These results are consistent with models for the replication of the satellite RNA in which a circular form of the satellite RNA is a template for rolling circle transcription or is otherwise a replication intermediate or is readily converted to an intermediate. We also show that a circular form of a nonaccumulating satellite RNA mutant induced an increase in a satellite RNA that is endogenous to some tobacco ringspot virus virion preparations, as demonstrated previously for the linear form.

Evidence for spontaneous circle formation in the replication of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus.

Replication of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus (sTobRV RNA) has been postulated to require rolling circle transcription. The expected product of rolling circle transcription, multimeric sTobRV RNA, is known to undergo self-cleavage in vitro to release unit-length sTobRV RNA. A spontaneous, efficient, not enzymically-catalyzed in vitro circularization reaction is characteristic of unit-length sTobRV RNA of the less abundant, (-) polarity. We mutated sTobRV RNA at two sites that are distant from each other in the polyribonucleotide chain. A third form of the sTobRV RNA was mutated at both sites. Multimeric forms of the one-site mutants of sTobRV(+)RNA and sTobRV(-)RNA showed, respectively, undiminished and slightly diminished self-cleavage, whereas the spontaneous circularization of each one-site-mutated, unit-length sTobRV(-)RNA was greatly reduced, compared to the reactions of wild-type sTobRV RNA and the two-site mutant. The two-site mutant and the wild-type sTobRV RNAs replicated with similar efficiency. They reduced the titer of, and severity of, symptoms induced by coinoculated tobacco ringspot virus (TobRV). When coinoculated with TobRV, neither one-site mutant increased or provided protection against TobRV. Rather, each induced a substantial accumulation of what is apparently an endogenous form of sTobRV RNA. Our results are consistent with the formation of circular sTobRV(-)RNA as an essential step in sTobRV RNA replication.

Identification of a non-junction phosphodiester that influences an autolytic processing reaction of RNA.

Oligoribonucleotides with specific sequences derived from the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus undergo autolytic cleavage at the CpA phosphodiester that is the junction between unit sequences of multimeric satellite RNA. Buzayan et al. (Nucleic Acids Res., 16, 4009-4023 (1988)) showed that an oligoribonucleotide with 97 satellite RNA-derived nucleotide residues self-cleaved with greatly reduced efficiency when it was synthesized in vitro from adenosine-5'-O-(1-thiotriphosphate) (abbreviated rATP alpha S) and three rNTPs. No other substitution of one rNTP by the corresponding rNTP alpha S had this effect, suggesting that a phosphorothioate CpA junction inhibits self-cleavage. Here, we replaced the usual CpA junction of a small self-cleaving oligoribonucleotide with a CpU junction. Self-cleavage of this molecule was reduced not only by rUTP alpha S-substitution, as expected, but also by partial and complete rATP alpha S-substitution. By analysis of the locations of rAMPS residues in cleavage products derived from partially rATP alpha S-substituted oligoribonucleotides, we identified A26 as the residue contributing the non-junction phosphorothioate diester that most strongly inhibited self-cleavage. Manganese ions strongly stimulated the self-cleavage of the rATP alpha S-substituted, CpU-junction oligoribonucleotide but was less effective when the junction was CpA.

Two autolytic processing reactions of a satellite RNA proceed with inversion of configuration.

Both polarities of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus occur in infected cells in multimeric forms which are capable of autolytic processing, using different sequences and structures [Feldstein, P.A., et al., Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA (1990) 87 (in press)]. These transesterification reactions generate a 2',3'-cyclophosphate and a 5'-hydroxyl as the two new end groups. Cleavage is at a CpA for the (+) polarity RNA and at an ApG for the (-) polarity RNA. We enzymically synthesized oligoribonucleotides with processing capability and with specific 35S-labeled phosphorothioate diesters in the Rp configuration. After processing had occurred, the terminal nucleoside-2',3'-cyclophosphorothioate diester residues were recovered from the appropriate product by digestion with nuclease and phosphatase. Comparisons with specially prepared endo- and exoisomer reference compounds by thin layer chromatography and autoradiography revealed that the [35S]cytidine- and [35S]adenosine-2',3'-cyclophosphorothioate both were endo-isomers. The results are consistent with transesterification occurring by an inline SN2(P) attack of the 2'-hydroxyl group in the autolytic processing reactions of both polarities of the satellite RNA.

Specific association between an endoribonucleolytic sequence from a satellite RNA and a substrate analogue containing a 2'-5' phosphodiester.

Both polarities of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus are sources of self-cleaving sequences. RNA of the less abundant, negative polarity, designated sTobRV-(-)RNA, has cleaving activity that was mapped previously to two noncontiguous regions of the polyribonucleotide chain. Endoribonucleolytic oligoribonucleotides (E) corresponding to the larger of the two regions cleaved smaller substrate oligoribonucleotides, at the ApG phosphodiester that is cleaved in sTobRV(-)RNA. An analogue of the substrate, which has a 2'-5' ApG phosphodiester, was not cleaved by E but acted as a competitive inhibitor of the cleavage of substrate. The analogue served as a primer, and E served as template, for reverse transcriptase-catalyzed copying of specific E sequences. The sequences transcribed suggest base pairing between the 5' region of E and a portion of the substrate that is located 3' to, but does not include, the ApG phosphodiester. Results from other experiments indicate this base pairing is a part of the functional cleavage complex. The association of the ends of E and substrate anticipates a second, 4-base-pair association between E and a portion of substrate that is 5' to, but does not include, the ApG phosphodiester. The effects of compensating mutations in E and substrate oligoribonucleotides support the existence of this second association in the active cleavage complex.

Two sequences participating in the autolytic processing of satellite tobacco ringspot virus complementary RNA.

Circular and multimeric forms of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus and their autolytic processing reactions are well known. They suggest replication models in which key elements are rolling circle transcription and the processing of the resulting multimeric RNA to generate the unit, 'monomeric' satellite RNA sequence. We prepared plasmids bearing two distinct sequences of the satellite RNA. Each was arranged to allow transcription of an oligoribonucleotide (r-oligo) of the polarity that is complementary to encapsidated satellite RNA. One sequence has the autolytic processing phosphodiester bond, ApG, and the other is located at a distance of about 150 nucleotide (nt) residues. The second r-oligo accomplished cleavage of the first, in a catalytic fashion. Analysis of truncated forms showed that 10 nt of the ApG junction-containing r-oligo and 46 of the endoribonucleolytic r-oligo were sufficient for recognition in the cleavage reaction. These results map the sequences involved in autolytic processing of the complementary polarity satellite RNA to two regions.

RNA mediated formation of a phosphorothioate diester bond.

Previous results showed that multimeric, tandemly sequence-repeated forms of satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA of the encapsidated polarity (STobRV (+)RNA) autolytically process at a specific phosphodiester bond, the junction. Substituting a phosphorothioate diester bond for the STobRV (+)RNA junction drastically slowed autolytic processing. Here we show that for the complementary STobRV (-)RNA, in contrast, replacing sets of phosphodiester bonds with phosphorothioate diester bonds, even at the junction, did not greatly slow autolytic processing or spontaneous ligation, the usual reactions of the unmodified RNA. In the ligation reaction STobRV (-)RNA directed the formation of an ApG phosphorothioate diester bond.

Autolytic processing of a phosphorothioate diester bond.

A small satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus replicates in tissues infected with tobacco ringspot virus and accumulates in virus capsids, forming virus-like particles. Previous research showed that multimeric forms of this satellite RNA have tandem repeats of the "monomeric" satellite RNA sequence of 359 or 360 nucleotide residues. The multimeric RNAs undergo autolytic processing at a specific CpA phosphodiester bond, the junction, to generate the monomeric RNA. We substituted phosphorothioate diester bonds for various sets of phosphodiester bonds, in dimeric and truncated forms of the satellite RNA. The degree of reduction in autolytic cleavage varied both with the sites of substitution and the size of the RNA molecules. Analyses of a product of the autolysis reaction suggest that one phosphorothioate diester bond most strongly interferes with processing, the one introduced at the CpA junction during its synthesis from adenosine-5'-0-(1-thiotriphosphate). However, extensive introduction of phosphorothioate diester bonds elsewhere in the molecule also decreased processing, possibly by altering conformation.

A nucleotide sequence rearrangement distinguishes two isolates of satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA.

Several strains of tobacco ringspot virus (TobRV) support the replication and encapsidation of satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA (STobRV RNA). We have compared the nucleotide sequences of four STobRV RNAs, each initially associated with a different isolate of TobRV. A STobRV RNA from a geranium isolate of TobRV and STobRV RNA from the previously analyzed budblight isolate (J.M. Buzayan, W.L. Gerlach, G. Bruening, P. Keese, and A.R. Gould, 1986, Virology 151, 186-199) differed by a single nucleotide residue substitution. STobRV RNAs from TobRV isolates 62L and NC-87 have the same 360-residue nucleotide sequence. This sequence differs from that of the 359-nucleotide residue budblight STobRV RNA principally at locations 100 through 140. The differences between the two sequences in this region are consistent with a rearrangement of blocks of nucleotide residues. The two sequences can be folded with similar patterns of base pairing. All four STobRV RNAs share a sequence of eighty 5'-terminal and of twenty 3'-terminal residues, including the 5' hydroxyl group and 2':3'-cyclic phosphodiester group.

Nucleotide sequence and newly formed phosphodiester bond of spontaneously ligated satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA.

The satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus (STobRV RNA) replicates and becomes encapsidated in association with tobacco ringspot virus. Previous results show that the infected tissue produces multimeric STobRV RNAs of both polarities. RNA that is complementary to encapsidated STobRV RNA, designated as having the (-) polarity, cleaves autolytically at a specific ApG bond. Purified autolysis products spontaneously join in a non-enzymic reaction. We report characteristics of this RNA ligation reaction: the terminal groups that react, the type of bond in the newly formed junction and the nucleotide sequence of the joined RNA. The nucleotide sequence of the ligated RNA shows that joining of the reacting RNAs restored an ApG bond. The junction ApG has a 3'-to-5' phosphodiester bond. Thus the net ligation reaction of STobRV (-)RNA is the precise reversal of autolysis. We discuss this new type of RNA ligation reaction and its implications for the formation of multimeric STobRV RNAs during replication.

Satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA: A subset of the RNA sequence is sufficient for autolytic processing.

The satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus depends upon tobacco ringspot virus for its replication and source of coat protein. The satellite RNA reduces virus accumulation and the severity of virus-induced symptoms. Repetitive sequence, dimeric, and higher forms of the satellite RNA are known to autolytically process to form biologically active monomeric RNA of 359 nucleotide residues [Prody, G. A., Bakos, J. T., Buzayan, J. M., Schneider, I. R. & Bruening, G. (1986) Science 231, 1577-1580], with a 5'-hydroxyl and a 2',3'-cyclic phosphodiester as the new terminal groups. We show here that transcripts of full-length and truncated DNA clones of the satellite RNA sequence also process in a nonenzymic reaction. One such transcript was an RNA that has about one-fourth of the satellite RNA sequence, representing the 3'-terminal and 5'-terminal portions of monomeric RNA joined in the junction that is cleaved in dimeric RNA. This RNA autolytically processed more efficiently than molecules with a larger proportion of the satellite RNA nucleotide sequence.

Satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA: biological activity of DNA clones and their in vitro transcripts.

The satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus (STobRV RNA) replicates in association with tobacco ringspot virus (TobRV), apparently by means of intermediates that are multimeric, tandem repeats of STobRV RNA (M. C. Kiefer, S. D. Daubert, I. R. Schneider, and G. Bruening, 1982, Virology 121, 262-273) and which are capable of autolytic cleavage to produce active monomeric RNA (G. A. Prody, J. T. Bakos, J. M. Buzayan, I. R. Schneider, and G. Bruening, Science, in press). We have prepared plasmids that contain circularly permuted dimeric and trimeric cDNA forms of the 359 residue monomeric STobRV RNA sequence. The dimeric and trimeric DNA inserts contain contiguous, unpermuted monomeric and dimeric STobRV RNA sequences, respectively. Monomeric RNAs of both the encapsidated, (+), and the complementary, (-), polarities were prepared in vitro: transcripts of cloned sequences were initiated at the bacteriophage SP6 promoter, and these autolytically processed to generate RNA with the electrophoretic mobility of monomeric STobRV RNA. Monomeric (+)RNA transcripts and double-stranded DNA with a permuted trimeric sequence were biologically active, as judged by their ability to engender encapsidated STobRV RNA when inoculated to plants in the presence of TobRV. Biological activity was not detected with monometric RNA transcripts of the (-) polarity or with single-stranded DNAs that contained permuted dimeric sequences of either polarity.

Nucleotide sequence of satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA and its relationship to multimeric forms.

Tobacco ringspot virus, a member of the nepovirus group, supports the increase and encapsidation of coinoculated satellite tobacco ringspot virus RNA (STobRV RNA). The nucleotide sequence of the unit length STobRV RNA, found here to be 359 nucleotide residues for the budblight strain, occurs also in multimeric, repetitive sequence forms. These are able to undergo an autolytic processing reaction to generate biologically active, unit length STobRV RNA (G. A. Prody, J. T. Bakos, J. M. Buzayan, I. R. Schneider, and G. Bruening,1984, In "Abstracts of the 3rd Cold Spring Harbor RNA Processing Meeting, May 16-20,1 984," p. 8). We determined the nucleotide sequence of the monomeric STobRV RNA by combining results from partial enzymatic digestions of the RNA, partial chemical cleavage of cDNA transcribed from the RNA, and analyses of cDNA clones. Other analyses gave the terminal residues of monomeric STobRV RNA: a cytosine-2':3'-cyclic phosphodiester and a 5' terminal adenosine. The terminal residues of monomeric RNA and their adjacent nucleotide sequences are consistent with the sequence in the junction region of dimeric RNA, derived from transcripts and cDNA clones, and with the formation of two monomeric STobRV RNAs upon autolysis of dimer, without the gain or loss of a nucleotide residue.

Autolytic processing of dimeric plant virus satellite RNA.

Associated with some plant viruses are small satellite RNA's that depend on the plant virus to provide protective coat protein and presumably at least some of the proteins necessary for satellite RNA replication. Multimeric forms of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus are probable in vivo precursors of the monomeric satellite RNA. Evidence is presented for the in vitro autolytic processing of dimeric and trimeric forms of this satellite RNA. The reaction generates biologically active monomeric satellite RNA, apparently is reversible to form dimeric RNA from monomeric RNA, and does not require an enzyme for its catalysis.