Corrigendum: Absolute oxygen-guided radiation therapy improves tumor control in three preclinical tumor models.

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.3389/fmed.2023.1269689.].

Absolute oxygen-guided radiation therapy improves tumor control in three preclinical tumor models.

Background: Clinical attempts to find benefit from specifically targeting and boosting resistant hypoxic tumor subvolumes have been promising but inconclusive. While a first preclinical murine tumor type showed significant improved control with hypoxic tumor boosts, a more thorough investigation of efficacy from boosting hypoxic subvolumes defined by electron paramagnetic resonance oxygen imaging (EPROI) is necessary. The present study confirms improved hypoxic tumor control results in three different tumor types using a clonogenic assay and explores potential confounding experimental conditions. Materials and methods: Three murine tumor models were used for multi-modal imaging and radiotherapy: MCa-4 mammary adenocarcinomas, SCC7 squamous cell carcinomas, and FSa fibrosarcomas. Registered T2-weighted MRI tumor boundaries, hypoxia defined by EPROI as pO2 ≤ 10 mmHg, and X-RAD 225Cx CT boost boundaries were obtained for all animals. 13 Gy boosts were directed to hypoxic or equal-integral-volume oxygenated tumor regions and monitored for regrowth. Kaplan-Meier survival analysis was used to assess local tumor control probability (LTCP). The Cox proportional hazards model was used to assess the hazard ratio of tumor progression of Hypoxic Boost vs. Oxygenated Boost for each tumor type controlling for experimental confounding variables such as EPROI radiofrequency, tumor volume, hypoxic fraction, and delay between imaging and radiation treatment. Results: An overall significant increase in LTCP from Hypoxia Boost vs. Oxygenated Boost treatments was observed in the full group of three tumor types (p < 0.0001). The effects of tumor volume and hypoxic fraction on LTCP were dependent on tumor type. The delay between imaging and boost treatments did not have a significant effect on LTCP for all tumor types. Conclusion: This study confirms that EPROI locates resistant tumor hypoxic regions for radiation boost, increasing clonogenic LTCP, with potential enhanced therapeutic index in three tumor types. Preclinical absolute EPROI may provide correction for clinical hypoxia images using additional clinical physiologic MRI.

The optimal 18F-fluoromisonidazole PET threshold to define tumor hypoxia in preclinical squamous cell carcinomas using pO2 electron paramagnetic resonance imaging as reference truth.

PURPOSE: To identify the optimal threshold in 18F-fluoromisonidazole (FMISO) PET images to accurately locate tumor hypoxia by using electron paramagnetic resonance imaging (pO2 EPRI) as ground truth for hypoxia, defined by pO2 [Formula: see text] 10 mmHg. METHODS: Tumor hypoxia images in mouse models of SCCVII squamous cell carcinoma (n = 16) were acquired in a hybrid PET/EPRI imaging system 2 h post-injection of FMISO. T2-weighted MRI was used to delineate tumor and muscle tissue. Dynamic contrast enhanced (DCE) MRI parametric images of Ktrans and ve were generated to model tumor vascular properties. Images from PET/EPR/MRI were co-registered and resampled to isotropic 0.5 mm voxel resolution for analysis. PET images were converted to standardized uptake value (SUV) and tumor-to-muscle ratio (TMR) units. FMISO uptake thresholds were evaluated using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis to find the optimal FMISO threshold and unit with maximum overall hypoxia similarity (OHS) with pO2 EPRI, where OHS = 1 shows perfect overlap and OHS = 0 shows no overlap. The means of dice similarity coefficient, normalized Hausdorff distance, and accuracy were used to define the OHS. Monotonic relationships between EPRI/PET/DCE-MRI were evaluated with the Spearman correlation coefficient ([Formula: see text]) to quantify association of vasculature on hypoxia imaged with both FMISO PET and pO2 EPRI. RESULTS: FMISO PET thresholds to define hypoxia with maximum OHS (both OHS = 0.728 [Formula: see text] 0.2) were SUV [Formula: see text] 1.4 [Formula: see text] SUVmean and SUV [Formula: see text] 0.6 [Formula: see text] SUVmax. Weak-to-moderate correlations (|[Formula: see text]|< 0.70) were observed between PET/EPRI hypoxia images with vascular permeability (Ktrans) or fractional extracellular-extravascular space (ve) from DCE-MRI. CONCLUSION: This is the first in vivo comparison of FMISO uptake with pO2 EPRI to identify the optimal FMISO threshold to define tumor hypoxia, which may successfully direct hypoxic tumor boosts in patients, thereby enhancing tumor control.

Improving Tumor Hypoxia Location in 18F-Misonidazole PET with Dynamic Contrast-enhanced MRI Using Quantitative Electron Paramagnetic Resonance Partial Oxygen Pressure Images.

Purpose: To enhance the spatial accuracy of fluorine 18 (18F) misonidazole (MISO) PET imaging of hypoxia by using dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) MR images as a basis for modifying PET images and by using electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) partial oxygen pressure (pO2) as the reference standard. Materials and Methods: Mice (n = 10) with leg-borne MCa4 mammary carcinomas underwent EPR imaging, T2-weighted and DCE MRI, and 18F-MISO PET/CT. Images were registered to the same space for analysis. The thresholds of hypoxia for PET and EPR images were tumor-to-muscle ratios greater than or equal to 2.2 mm Hg and less than or equal to 14 mm Hg, respectively. The Dice similarity coefficient (DSC) and Hausdorff distance (d H ) were used to quantify the three-dimensional overlap of hypoxia between pO2 EPR and 18F-MISO PET images. A training subset (n = 6) was used to calculate optimal DCE MRI weighting coefficients to relate EPR to the PET signal; the group average weights were then applied to all tumors (from six training mice and four test mice). The DSC and d H were calculated before and after DCE MRI-corrected PET images were obtained to quantify the improvement in overlap with EPR pO2 images for measuring tumor hypoxia. Results: The means and standard deviations of the DSC and d H between hypoxic regions in original PET and EPR images were 0.35 mm ± 0.23 and 5.70 mm ± 1.7, respectively, for images of all 10 mice. After implementing a preliminary DCE MRI correction to PET data, the DSC increased to 0.86 mm ± 0.18 and the d H decreased to 2.29 mm ± 0.70, showing significant improvement (P < .001) for images of all 10 mice. Specifically, for images of the four independent test mice, the DSC improved with correction from 0.19 ± 0.28 to 0.80 ± 0.29 (P = .02), and the d H improved from 6.40 mm ± 2.5 to 1.95 mm ± 0.63 (P = .01). Conclusion: Using EPR information as a reference standard, DCE MRI information can be used to correct 18F-MISO PET information to more accurately reflect areas of hypoxia.Keywords: Animal Studies, Molecular Imaging, Molecular Imaging-Cancer, PET/CT, MR-Dynamic Contrast Enhanced, MR-Imaging, PET/MR, Breast, Oncology, Tumor Mircoenvironment, Electron Paramagnetic ResonanceSupplemental material is available for this article.© RSNA, 2021.

Biological validation of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) image oxygen thresholds in tissue.

Measuring molecular oxygen levels in vivo has been the cornerstone of understanding the effects of hypoxia in normal tissues and malignant tumors. Here we discuss the advances in a variety of partial pressure of oxygen ( PO2 ) measurements and imaging techniques and relevant oxygen thresholds. A focus on electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) imaging shows the validation of treating hypoxic tumours with a threshold of PO2  ≤ 10 Torr, and demonstrates utility for in vivo oxygen imaging, as well as its current and future role in cancer studies.

Small Animal IMRT Using 3D-Printed Compensators.

PURPOSE: Preclinical radiation replicating clinical intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) techniques can provide data translatable to clinical practice. For this work, treatment plans were created for oxygen-guided dose-painting in small animals using inverse-planned IMRT. Spatially varying beam intensities were achieved using 3-dimensional (3D)-printed compensators. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Optimized beam fluence from arbitrary gantry angles was determined using a verified model of the XRAD225Cx treatment beam. Compensators were 3D-printed with varied thickness to provide desired attenuation using copper/polylactic-acid. Spatial resolution capabilities were investigated using printed test-patterns. Following American Association of Physicists in Medicine TG119, a 5-beam IMRT plan was created for a miniaturized (∼1/8th scale) C-shape target. Electron paramagnetic resonance imaging of murine tumor oxygenation guided simultaneous integrated boost (SIB) plans conformally treating tumor to a base dose (Rx1) with boost (Rx2) based on tumor oxygenation. The 3D-printed compensator intensity modulation accuracy and precision was evaluated by individually delivering each field to a phantom containing radiochromic film and subsequent per-field gamma analysis. The methodology was validated end-to-end with composite delivery (incorporating 3D-printed tungsten/polylactic-acid beam trimmers to reduce out-of-field leakage) of the oxygen-guided SIB plan to a phantom containing film and subsequent gamma analysis. RESULTS: Resolution test-patterns demonstrate practical printer resolution of ∼0.7 mm, corresponding to 1.0 mm bixels at the isocenter. The miniaturized C-shape plan provides planning target volume coverage (V95% = 95%) with organ sparing (organs at risk Dmax < 50%). The SIB plan to hypoxic tumor demonstrates the utility of this approach (hypoxic tumor V95%,Rx2 = 91.6%, normoxic tumor V95%,Rx1 = 95.7%, normal tissue V100%,Rx1 = 7.1%). The more challenging SIB plan to boost the normoxic tumor rim achieved normoxic tumor V95%,Rx2 = 90.9%, hypoxic tumor V95%,Rx1 = 62.7%, and normal tissue V100%,Rx2 = 5.3%. Average per-field gamma passing rates using 3%/1.0 mm, 3%/0.7 mm, and 3%/0.5 mm criteria were 98.8% ± 2.8%, 96.6% ± 4.1%, and 90.6% ± 5.9%, respectively. Composite delivery of the hypoxia boost plan and gamma analysis (3%/1 mm) gave passing results of 95.3% and 98.1% for the 2 measured orthogonal dose planes. CONCLUSIONS: This simple and cost-effective approach using 3D-printed compensators for small-animal IMRT provides a methodology enabling preclinical studies that can be readily translated into the clinic. The presented oxygen-guided dose-painting demonstrates that this methodology will facilitate studies driving much needed biologic personalization of radiation therapy for improvements in patient outcomes.