Bioenergetic State of Escherichia coli Controls Aminoglycoside Susceptibility.

Aminoglycosides (AG) have been used against Gram-negative bacteria for decades. Yet, how bacterial metabolism and environmental conditions modify AG toxicity is poorly understood. Here, we show that the level of AG susceptibility varies depending on the nature of the respiratory chain that Escherichia coli uses for growth, i.e., oxygen, nitrate, or fumarate. We show that all components of the fumarate respiratory chain, namely, hydrogenases 2 and 3, the formate hydrogenlyase complex, menaquinone, and fumarate reductase are required for AG-mediated killing under fumarate respiratory conditions. In addition, we show that the AAA+ ATPase RavA and its Von Wildebrand domain-containing partner, ViaA, are essential for AG to act under fumarate respiratory conditions. This effect was true for all AG that were tested but not for antibiotics from other classes. In addition, we show that the sensitizing effect of RavA-ViaA is due to increased gentamicin uptake in a proton motive force-dependent manner. Interestingly, the sensitizing effect of RavA-ViaA was prominent in poor energy conservation conditions, i.e., with fumarate, but dispensable under high energy conservation conditions, i.e., in the presence of nitrate or oxygen. We propose that RavA-ViaA can facilitate uptake of AG across the membrane in low-energy cellular states. IMPORTANCE Antibiotic resistance is a major public health, social, and economic problem. Aminoglycosides (AG) are known to be highly effective against Gram-negative bacteria, but their use is limited to life-threatening infections because of their nephrotoxicity and ototoxicity at therapeutic dose. Elucidation of AG-sensitization mechanisms in bacteria would allow reduced effective doses of AG. Here, we have identified the molecular components involved in anaerobic fumarate respiration that are required for AG to kill. In addition to oxidoreductases and menaquinone, this includes new molecular players, RavA, an AAA+ ATPase, and ViaA, its partner that has the VWA motif. Remarkably, the influence of RavA-ViaA on AG susceptibility varies according to the type of bioenergetic metabolism used by E. coli. This is a significant advance because anaerobiosis is well known to reduce the antibacterial activity of AG. This study highlights the critical importance of the relationship between culture conditions, metabolism, and antibiotic susceptibility.

The ErpA/NfuA complex builds an oxidation-resistant Fe-S cluster delivery pathway.

Fe-S cluster-containing proteins occur in most organisms, wherein they assist in myriad processes from metabolism to DNA repair via gene expression and bioenergetic processes. Here, we used both in vitro and in vivo methods to investigate the capacity of the four Fe-S carriers, NfuA, SufA, ErpA, and IscA, to fulfill their targeting role under oxidative stress. Likewise, Fe-S clusters exhibited varying half-lives, depending on the carriers they were bound to; an NfuA-bound Fe-S cluster was more stable (t½ = 100 min) than those bound to SufA (t½ = 55 min), ErpA (t½ = 54 min), or IscA (t½ = 45 min). Surprisingly, the presence of NfuA further enhanced stability of the ErpA-bound cluster to t½ = 90 min. Using genetic and plasmon surface resonance analyses, we showed that NfuA and ErpA interacted directly with client proteins, whereas IscA or SufA did not. Moreover, NfuA and ErpA interacted with one another. Given all of these observations, we propose an architecture of the Fe-S delivery network in which ErpA is the last factor that delivers cluster directly to most if not all client proteins. NfuA is proposed to assist ErpA under severely unfavorable conditions. A comparison with the strategy employed in yeast and eukaryotes is discussed.

Turning Escherichia coli into a Frataxin-Dependent Organism.

Fe-S bound proteins are ubiquitous and contribute to most basic cellular processes. A defect in the ISC components catalyzing Fe-S cluster biogenesis leads to drastic phenotypes in both eukaryotes and prokaryotes. In this context, the Frataxin protein (FXN) stands out as an exception. In eukaryotes, a defect in FXN results in severe defects in Fe-S cluster biogenesis, and in humans, this is associated with Friedreich's ataxia, a neurodegenerative disease. In contrast, prokaryotes deficient in the FXN homolog CyaY are fully viable, despite the clear involvement of CyaY in ISC-catalyzed Fe-S cluster formation. The molecular basis of the differing importance in the contribution of FXN remains enigmatic. Here, we have demonstrated that a single mutation in the scaffold protein IscU rendered E. coli viability strictly dependent upon a functional CyaY. Remarkably, this mutation changed an Ile residue, conserved in prokaryotes at position 108, into a Met residue, conserved in eukaryotes. We found that in the double mutant IscUIM ΔcyaY, the ISC pathway was completely abolished, becoming equivalent to the ΔiscU deletion strain and recapitulating the drastic phenotype caused by FXN deletion in eukaryotes. Biochemical analyses of the "eukaryotic-like" IscUIM scaffold revealed that it exhibited a reduced capacity to form Fe-S clusters. Finally, bioinformatic studies of prokaryotic IscU proteins allowed us to trace back the source of FXN-dependency as it occurs in present-day eukaryotes. We propose an evolutionary scenario in which the current mitochondrial Isu proteins originated from the IscUIM version present in the ancestor of the Rickettsiae. Subsequent acquisition of SUF, the second Fe-S cluster biogenesis system, in bacteria, was accompanied by diminished contribution of CyaY in prokaryotic Fe-S cluster biogenesis, and increased tolerance to change in the amino acid present at the 108th position of the scaffold.

The iron-binding CyaY and IscX proteins assist the ISC-catalyzed Fe-S biogenesis in Escherichia coli.

In eukaryotes, frataxin deficiency (FXN) causes severe phenotypes including loss of iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster protein activity, accumulation of mitochondrial iron and leads to the neurodegenerative disease Friedreich's ataxia. In contrast, in prokaryotes, deficiency in the FXN homolog, CyaY, was reported not to cause any significant phenotype, questioning both its importance and its actual contribution to Fe-S cluster biogenesis. Because FXN is conserved between eukaryotes and prokaryotes, this surprising discrepancy prompted us to reinvestigate the role of CyaY in Escherichia coli. We report that CyaY (i) potentiates E. coli fitness, (ii) belongs to the ISC pathway catalyzing the maturation of Fe-S cluster-containing proteins and (iii) requires iron-rich conditions for its contribution to be significant. A genetic interaction was discovered between cyaY and iscX, the last gene of the isc operon. Deletion of both genes showed an additive effect on Fe-S cluster protein maturation, which led, among others, to increased resistance to aminoglycosides and increased sensitivity to lambda phage infection. Together, these in vivo results establish the importance of CyaY as a member of the ISC-mediated Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathway in E. coli, like it does in eukaryotes, and validate IscX as a new bona fide Fe-S cluster biogenesis factor.

Fe-S cluster biosynthesis controls uptake of aminoglycosides in a ROS-less death pathway.

All bactericidal antibiotics were recently proposed to kill by inducing reactive oxygen species (ROS) production, causing destabilization of iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters and generating Fenton chemistry. We find that the ROS response is dispensable upon treatment with bactericidal antibiotics. Furthermore, we demonstrate that Fe-S clusters are required for killing only by aminoglycosides. In contrast to cells, using the major Fe-S cluster biosynthesis machinery, ISC, cells using the alternative machinery, SUF, cannot efficiently mature respiratory complexes I and II, resulting in impendence of the proton motive force (PMF), which is required for bactericidal aminoglycoside uptake. Similarly, during iron limitation, cells become intrinsically resistant to aminoglycosides by switching from ISC to SUF and down-regulating both respiratory complexes. We conclude that Fe-S proteins promote aminoglycoside killing by enabling their uptake.