RESUMEN
Purpose: Achieving competency in cataract surgery is an essential component of ophthalmology residency training. Video-based analysis of surgery can change training through its objective, reliable, and timely assessment of resident performance. Methods: Using the Image Labeler application in MATLAB, the capsulorrhexis step of 208 surgical videos, recorded at the University of Michigan, was annotated for subjective and objective analysis. Two expert surgeons graded the creation of the capsulorrhexis based on the International Council of Ophthalmology's Ophthalmology Surgical Competency Assessment Rubric:Phacoemulsification (ICO-OSCAR:phaco) rating scale and a custom rubric (eccentricity, roundness, size, centration) that focuses on the objective aspects of this step. The annotated rhexis frames were run through an automated analysis to obtain objective scores for these components. The subjective scores were compared using both intra and inter-rater analyses to assess the consistency of a human-graded scale. The subjective and objective scores were compared using intraclass correlation methods to determine relative agreement. Results: All rhexes were graded as 4/5 or 5/5 by both raters for both items 4 and 5 of the ICO-OSCAR:phaco rating scale. Only roundness scores were statistically different between the subjective graders (mean difference = -0.149, p-value = 0.0023). Subjective scores were highly correlated for all components (>0.6). Correlations between objective and subjective scores were low (0.09 to 0.39). Conclusion: Video-based analysis of cataract surgery presents significant opportunities, including the ability to asynchronously evaluate performance and provide longitudinal assessment. Subjective scoring between two raters was moderately correlated for each component.
RESUMEN
Background: The capsulorhexis is one of the most important and challenging maneuvers in cataract surgery. Automated analysis of the anterior capsulotomy could aid surgical training through the provision of objective feedback and guidance to trainees. Purpose: To develop and evaluate a deep learning-based system for the automated identification and semantic segmentation of the anterior capsulotomy in cataract surgery video. Methods: In this study, we established a BigCat-Capsulotomy dataset comprising 1556 video frames extracted from 190 recorded cataract surgery videos for developing and validating the capsulotomy recognition system. The proposed system involves three primary stages: video preprocessing, capsulotomy video frame classification, and capsulotomy segmentation. To thoroughly evaluate its efficacy, we examined the performance of a total of eight deep learning-based classification models and eleven segmentation models, assessing both accuracy and time consumption. Furthermore, we delved into the factors influencing system performance by deploying it across various surgical phases. Results: The ResNet-152 model employed in the classification step of the proposed capsulotomy recognition system attained strong performance with an overall Dice coefficient of 92.21%. Similarly, the UNet model with the DenseNet-169 backbone emerged as the most effective segmentation model among those investigated, achieving an overall Dice coefficient of 92.12%. Moreover, the time consumption of the system was low at 103.37 milliseconds per frame, facilitating its application in real-time scenarios. Phase-wise analysis indicated that the Phacoemulsification phase (nuclear disassembly) was the most challenging to segment (Dice coefficient of 86.02%). Conclusion: The experimental results showed that the proposed system is highly effective in intraoperative capsulotomy recognition during cataract surgery and demonstrates both high accuracy and real-time capabilities. This system holds significant potential for applications in surgical performance analysis, education, and intraoperative guidance systems.
