Recent Advances in Agrobacterium-Mediated Maize Genetic Transformation Using Immature Embryos and Seedling Leaf Whorl Explants.

The introduction of maize genetic transformation in the 1990s brought forth a powerful tool for crop improvement and a deeper understanding of plant genetics. Despite decades of genetics research, however, and the promise of CRISPR-mediated gene editing, maize transformation currently faces several challenges, such as genotype dependence and limitations in explant availability. Indeed, although the most commonly used method, immature embryo transformation, has been improved through optimization of tissue culture media composition and selection methods, the approach is only applicable to a limited number of public genotypes, including B104 and Hi II. Recently, genotype-flexible methods have been developed using coexpression cassettes of morphogenic transcription factors (MTFs) Baby boom (Bbm) and Wushel2 (Wus2), which have enabled the successful transformation of many previously recalcitrant maize lines. This MTF-based transformation method has also allowed for the use of alternate explants, such as seedling leaf whorl, whose production is cost-effective and requires only minimum controlled growth space. In this review, we summarize recent advances in Agrobacterium-mediated maize transformation methods that use immature embryos or seedling leaf whorls as starting material.

A Rapid Agrobacterium-Mediated Transformation Method Using Maize B104 Immature Embryos.

Maize genetic transformation is a critical tool for functional genomics and crop improvement. Many laboratories, however, continue to face multiple challenges in attempting to achieve routine genetic transformation of maize inbred genotypes. Here, we describe a rapid and robust maize B104 transformation method using immature embryos as explants. This method uses an Agrobacterium ternary vector system, which includes a conventional T-DNA binary vector (pCBL101-RUBY) and a compatible ternary helper plasmid (pKL2299) that carries extra copies of essential virulence genes. The T-DNA binary vector carries the neomycin phosphotransferase II (NptII) gene for selection and a betalain biosynthesis marker, RUBY, for visual screening. We provide step-by-step instructions for immature embryo explant preparation, Agrobacterium infection, tissue culture procedures, and greenhouse care for acclimatization of regenerated plantlets.

Agrobacterium-mediated Transformation of Tropical Maize Using Seedling Leaf Whorl Explants.

Conventional maize transformation has largely relied on immature embryos as explants, and is thus often hampered by the limited access to high-quality immature embryos year-round. Here, we present a detailed protocol using seedling leaf whorls as alternative explants for tropical maize inbred transformation. This approach involves the use of a cassette that drives the expression of the morphogenic transcription factors (MTFs) Baby boom (Bbm) and Wuschel2 (Wus2), which have been shown to greatly enhance transformation efficiency. We outline here the steps required for the preparation of seedling leaf whorl explants and subsequent Agrobacterium infection, and describe the tissue culture regimen that results in transgenic plant regeneration. Because constitutive expression of Bbm and Wus2 prevents normal plant regeneration and the production of fertile plants, the cassette containing these genes must be excised. As such, we include the steps for the Cre/loxP-mediated excision of the MTF gene cassette. The protocol outlines a year-round, more affordable, and efficient approach for carrying out maize transformation for crop improvement.

Enhancing Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation efficiency through improved ternary vector systems and auxotrophic strains.

Agrobacterium-mediated transformation is an essential tool for functional genomics studies and crop improvements. Recently developed ternary vector systems, which consist of a T-DNA vector and a compatible virulence (vir) gene helper plasmid (ternary helper), demonstrated that including an additional vir gene helper plasmid into disarmed Agrobacterium strains significantly improves T-DNA delivery efficiency, enhancing plant transformation. Here, we report the development of a new ternary helper and thymidine auxotrophic Agrobacterium strains to boost Agrobacterium-mediated plant transformation efficiency. Auxotrophic Agrobacterium strains are useful in reducing Agrobacterium overgrowth after the co-cultivation period because they can be easily removed from the explants due to their dependence on essential nutrient supplementation. We generated thymidine auxotrophic strains from public Agrobacterium strains EHA101, EHA105, EHA105D, and LBA4404. These strains exhibited thymidine-dependent growth in the bacterial medium, and transient GUS expression assay using Arabidopsis seedlings showed that they retain similar T-DNA transfer capability as their original strains. Auxotrophic strains EHA105Thy- and LBA4404T1 were tested for maize B104 immature embryo transformation using our rapid transformation method, and both strains demonstrated comparable transformation frequencies to the control strain LBA4404Thy-. In addition, our new ternary helper pKL2299A, which carries the virA gene from pTiBo542 in addition to other vir gene operons (virG, virB, virC, virD, virE, and virJ), demonstrated consistently improved maize B104 immature embryo transformation frequencies compared to the original version of pKL2299 (33.3% vs 25.6%, respectively). Therefore, our improved Agrobacterium system, including auxotrophic disarmed Agrobacterium strains and a new ternary helper plasmid, can be useful for enhancing plant transformation and genome editing applications.

Enhancing Maize Transformation and Targeted Mutagenesis through the Assistance of Non-Integrating Wus2 Vector.

Efficient genetic transformation is a prerequisite for rapid gene functional analyses and crop trait improvements. We recently demonstrated that new T-DNA binary vectors with NptII/G418 selection and a compatible helper plasmid can efficiently transform maize inbred B104 using our rapid Agrobacterium-mediated transformation method. In this work, we implemented the non-integrating Wuschel2 (Wus2) T-DNA vector method for Agrobacterium-mediated B104 transformation and tested its potential for recalcitrant inbred B73 transformation and gene editing. The non-integrating Wus2 (NIW) T-DNA vector-assisted transformation method uses two Agrobacterium strains: one carrying a gene-of-interest (GOI) construct and the other providing an NIW construct. To monitor Wus2 co-integration into the maize genome, we combined the maize Wus2 expression cassette driven by a strong constitutive promoter with a new visible marker RUBY, which produces the purple pigment betalain. As a GOI construct, we used a previously tested CRISPR-Cas9 construct pKL2359 for Glossy2 gene mutagenesis. When both GOI and NIW constructs were delivered by LBA4404Thy- strain, B104 transformation frequency was significantly enhanced by about two-fold (10% vs. 18.8%). Importantly, we were able to transform a recalcitrant inbred B73 using the NIW-assisted transformation method and obtained three transgene-free edited plants by omitting the selection agent G418. These results suggest that NIW-assisted transformation can improve maize B104 transformation frequency and provide a novel option for CRISPR technology for transgene-free genome editing.

Strategies for genotype-flexible plant transformation.

Recent advances in the genome-editing tools have demonstrated a great potential for accelerating functional genomics and crop trait improvements, but the low efficiency and genotype dependence in plant transformation hinder practical applications of such revolutionary tools. Morphogenic transcription factors (MTFs) such as Baby boom, Wuschel2, GROWTH-REGULATING FACTOR5, GROWTH-REGULATING FACTOR4 and its cofactor GRF-INTERACTING FACTOR1, and Wuschel-homeobox 5 related have been shown to greatly enhance plant transformation efficiency and expand the range of amenable species and genotypes. This review will summarize recent advancements in plant transformation technologies with an emphasis on the strategies developed for genotype-flexible transformation methods utilizing MTFs for both monocots and dicot plant species. We highlight several breakthrough studies that demonstrated a wide range of applicability.

Identifying Factors that Determine Effectiveness of Delivery Agents in Biolistic Delivery Using a Library of Amine-Containing Molecules.

Biolistic transfection is a popular and versatile tool for plant transformation. A key step in the biolistic process is the binding of DNA to the heavy microprojectile using a delivery agent, usually a positively charged molecule containing amine groups. Currently, the choice of the commercial delivery agent is mostly limited to spermidine. In addition, the detailed delivery mechanism has not been reported. To help broaden the selection of the delivery agent and reveal the fundamental mechanisms that lead to high delivery performance, a library of amine-containing molecules was investigated. A double-barrel biolistic delivery device was utilized for testing hundreds of samples with much-improved consistency. The performance was evaluated on onion epidermis. The binding and release of DNA were measured via direct high-performance liquid chromatography analysis. This study shows that the overwhelming majority of the amine library performed at the same level as spermidine. To further interpret these results, correlations were performed with thousands of molecular descriptors generated by chemical modeling. It was discovered that the overall charge is most likely the key factor to a successful binding and delivery. Furthermore, even after increasing the amount of the DNA concentration 50-fold to stress the binding capacity of the molecules, the amines in the library continued to deliver at a near identical level while binding all the DNA. The increased DNA was also demonstrated with a Cas9 editing test that required a large amount of DNA to be delivered, and the result was consistent with the previously determined amine performance. This study greatly expands the delivery agent selection for biolistic delivery, allowing alternatives to a commercial reagent that are more shelf-stable and cheaper. The library also offers an approach to investigate more challenging delivery of protein and CRISPR-Cas via the biolistic process in the future.

CRISPR RNA-guided integrase enables high-efficiency targeted genome engineering in Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

Agrobacterium tumefaciens, the causal agent of plant crown gall disease, has been widely used to genetically transform many plant species. The inter-kingdom gene transfer capability made Agrobacterium an essential tool and model system to study the mechanism of exporting and integrating a segment of bacterial DNA into the plant genome. However, many biological processes such as Agrobacterium-host recognition and interaction are still elusive. To accelerate the understanding of this important plant pathogen and further improve its capacity in plant genetic engineering, we adopted a CRISPR RNA-guided integrase system for Agrobacterium genome engineering. In this work, we demonstrate that INsertion of Transposable Elements by Guide RNA-Assisted TargEting (INTEGRATE) can efficiently generate DNA insertions to enable targeted gene knockouts. In addition, in conjunction with Cre-loxP recombination system, we achieved precise deletions of large DNA fragments. This work provides new genetic engineering strategies for Agrobacterium species and their gene functional analyses.

An Improved Agrobacterium-Mediated Transformation and Genome-Editing Method for Maize Inbred B104 Using a Ternary Vector System and Immature Embryos.

For maize genome-editing and bioengineering, genetic transformation of inbred genotypes is most desired due to the uniformity of genetic background in their progenies. However, most maize inbred lines are recalcitrant to tissue culture and transformation. A public, transformable maize inbred B104 has been widely used for genome editing in recent years. This is primarily due to its high degree of genetic similarity shared with B73, an inbred of the reference genome and parent of many breeding populations. Conventional B104 maize transformation protocol requires 16-22 weeks to produce rooted transgenic plants with an average of 4% transformation frequency (number of T0 plants per 100 infected embryos). In this Method paper, we describe an advanced B104 transformation protocol that requires only 7-10 weeks to generate transgenic plants with an average of 6.4% transformation frequency. Over 66% of transgenic plants carried CRISPR/Cas9-induced indel mutations on the target gene, demonstrating that this protocol can be used for genome editing applications. Following the detailed and stepwise procedure described here, this quick and simplified method using the Agrobacterium ternary vector system consisting of a T-DNA binary vector and a compatible helper plasmid can be readily transferable to interested researchers.

Efficient Protoplast Isolation and DNA Transfection for Winter Oilseed Crops, Pennycress (Thlaspi arvense ) and Camelina (Camelina sativa ).

Pennycress (Thlaspi arvense) and camelina (Camelina sativa) are nonfood winter oilseed crops that have the potential to contribute to sustainable biofuel production. However, undesired agronomic traits of pennycress and camelina currently hinder broad cultivation of these plants in the field. Recently, genome editing using the CRISPR-Cas technology has been applied to improve poor agronomic traits such as the weedy phenotype of pennycress and the oxidation susceptible lipid profile of camelina. In these works, the CRISPR reagents were introduced into the plants using the Agrobacterium-mediated floral dipping method. For accelerated domestication and value improvements of these winter oilseed crops, DNA-free genome editing platform and easy evaluation method of the CRISPR-Cas reagents are highly desirable. Cell wall-free protoplasts are great material to expand the use of gene engineering tools. In this chapter, we present a step-by-step guide to the mesophyll protoplast isolation from in vitro culture-grown pennycress and soil-grown camelina. The protocol also includes procedures for DNA transfection and protoplast viability test using fluorescein diacetate. With this protocol, we can isolate an average of 6 × 106 cells from pennycress and 3 × 106 cells from camelina per gram of fresh leaf tissues. Using a 7.3 kb plasmid DNA carrying green and red fluorescent protein marker genes, we can achieve an average transfection rate of 40% validated by flow cytometry for both plants.

Transformation of Teosinte (Zea mays ssp. parviglumis) via Biolistic Bombardment of Seedling-Derived Callus Tissues.

Modern maize exhibits a significantly different phenotype than its wild progenitor teosinte despite many genetic similarities. Of the many subspecies of Zea mays identified as teosinte, Zea mays ssp. parviglumis is the most closely related to domesticated maize. Understanding teosinte genes and their regulations can provide great insights into the maize domestication process and facilitate breeding for future crop improvement. However, a protocol of genetic transformation, which is essential for gene functional analyses, is not available in teosinte. In this study, we report the establishment of a robust callus induction and regeneration protocol using whorl segments of seedlings germinated from mature seeds of Zea parviglumis. We also report, for the first time, the production of fertile, transgenic teosinte plants using the particle bombardment. Using herbicide resistance genes such as mutant acetolactate synthase (Als) or bialaphos resistance (bar) as selectable markers, we achieved an average transformation frequency of 4.17% (percentage of independent transgenic events in total bombarded explants that produced callus). Expression of visual marker genes of red fluorescent protein tdTomato and ß-glucuronidase (gus) could be detected in bombarded callus culture and in T1 and T2 progeny plants. The protocol established in this work provides a major enabling technology for research toward the understanding of this important plant in crop domestication.

An improved biolistic delivery and analysis method for evaluation of DNA and CRISPR-Cas delivery efficacy in plant tissue.

Biolistic delivery is widely used for genetic transformation but inconsistency between bombardment samples for transient gene expression analysis often hinders quantitative analyses. We developed a methodology to improve the consistency of biolistic delivery results by using a double-barrel device and a cell counting software. The double-barrel device enables a strategy of incorporating an internal control into each sample, which significantly decreases variance of the results. The cell counting software further reduces errors and increases throughput. The utility of this new platform is demonstrated by optimizing conditions for delivering DNA using the commercial transfection reagent TransIT-2020. In addition, the same approach is applied to test the efficacy of multiple gRNAs for CRISPR-Cas9-mediated gene editing. The novel combination of the bombardment device and analysis method allows simultaneous comparison and optimization of parameters in the biolistic delivery. The platform developed here can be broadly applied to any target samples using biolistics, including animal cells and tissues.

Development of a Transformable Fast-Flowering Mini-Maize as a Tool for Maize Gene Editing.

Maize (Zea mays ssp. mays) is a popular genetic model due to its ease of crossing, well-established toolkits, and its status as a major global food crop. Recent technology developments for precise manipulation of the genome are further impacting both basic biological research and biotechnological application in agriculture. Crop gene editing often requires a process of genetic transformation in which the editing reagents are introduced into plant cells. In maize, this procedure is well-established for a limited number of public lines that are amenable for genetic transformation. Fast-Flowering Mini-Maize (FFMM) lines A and B were recently developed as an open-source tool for maize research by reducing the space requirements and the generation time. Neither line of FFMM were competent for genetic transformation using traditional protocols, a necessity to its status as a complete toolkit for public maize genetic research. Here we report the development of new lines of FFMM that have been bred for amenability to genetic transformation. By hybridizing a transformable maize genotype high Type-II callus parent A (Hi-II A) with line A of FFMM, we introgressed the ability to form embryogenic callus from Hi-II A into the FFMM-A genetic background. Through multiple generations of iterative self-hybridization or doubled-haploid method, we established maize lines that have a strong ability to produce embryogenic callus from immature embryos and maintain resemblance to FFMM-A in flowering time and stature. Using an Agrobacterium-mediated standard transformation method, we successfully introduced the CRISPR-Cas9 reagents into immature embryos and generated transgenic and mutant lines displaying the expected mutant phenotypes and genotypes. The transformation frequencies of the tested genotypes, defined as the numbers of transgenic event producing T1 seeds per 100 infected embryos, ranged from 0 to 17.1%. Approximately 80% of transgenic plants analyzed in this study showed various mutation patterns at the target site. The transformable FFMM line, FFMM-AT, can serve as a useful genetic and genomic resource for the maize community.

High-frequency random DNA insertions upon co-delivery of CRISPR-Cas9 ribonucleoprotein and selectable marker plasmid in rice.

An important advantage of delivering CRISPR reagents into cells as a ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex is the ability to edit genes without reagents being integrated into the genome. Transient presence of RNP molecules in cells can reduce undesirable off-target effects. One method for RNP delivery into plant cells is the use of a biolistic gun. To facilitate selection of transformed cells during RNP delivery, a plasmid carrying a selectable marker gene can be co-delivered with the RNP to enrich for transformed/edited cells. In this work, we compare targeted mutagenesis in rice using three different delivery platforms: biolistic RNP/DNA co-delivery; biolistic DNA delivery; and Agrobacterium-mediated delivery. All three platforms were successful in generating desired mutations at the target sites. However, we observed a high frequency (over 14%) of random plasmid or chromosomal DNA fragment insertion at the target sites in transgenic events generated from both biolistic delivery platforms. In contrast, integration of random DNA fragments was not observed in transgenic events generated from the Agrobacterium-mediated method. These data reveal important insights that must be considered when selecting the method for genome-editing reagent delivery in plants, and emphasize the importance of employing appropriate molecular screening methods to detect unintended alterations following genome engineering.

Application of CRISPR-Cas12a temperature sensitivity for improved genome editing in rice, maize, and Arabidopsis.

BACKGROUND: CRISPR-Cas12a (formerly Cpf1) is an RNA-guided endonuclease with distinct features that have expanded genome editing capabilities. Cas12a-mediated genome editing is temperature sensitive in plants, but a lack of a comprehensive understanding on Cas12a temperature sensitivity in plant cells has hampered effective application of Cas12a nucleases in plant genome editing. RESULTS: We compared AsCas12a, FnCas12a, and LbCas12a for their editing efficiencies and non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) repair profiles at four different temperatures in rice. We found that AsCas12a is more sensitive to temperature and that it requires a temperature of over 28 °C for high activity. Each Cas12a nuclease exhibited distinct indel mutation profiles which were not affected by temperatures. For the first time, we successfully applied AsCas12a for generating rice mutants with high frequencies up to 93% among T0 lines. We next pursued editing in the dicot model plant Arabidopsis, for which Cas12a-based genome editing has not been previously demonstrated. While LbCas12a barely showed any editing activity at 22 °C, its editing activity was rescued by growing the transgenic plants at 29 °C. With an early high-temperature treatment regime, we successfully achieved germline editing at the two target genes, GL2 and TT4, in Arabidopsis transgenic lines. We then used high-temperature treatment to improve Cas12a-mediated genome editing in maize. By growing LbCas12a T0 maize lines at 28 °C, we obtained Cas12a-edited mutants at frequencies up to 100% in the T1 generation. Finally, we demonstrated DNA binding of Cas12a was not abolished at lower temperatures by using a dCas12a-SRDX-based transcriptional repression system in Arabidopsis. CONCLUSION: Our study demonstrates the use of high-temperature regimes to achieve high editing efficiencies with Cas12a systems in rice, Arabidopsis, and maize and sheds light on the mechanism of temperature sensitivity for Cas12a in plants.

An Agrobacterium-Mediated CRISPR/Cas9 Platform for Genome Editing in Maize.

Precise genome engineering can be efficiently made using the revolutionary tool named CRISPR/Cas (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat/CRISPR-associated protein) systems. Adapted from the bacterial immune system, CRISPR/Cas systems can generate highly specific double-strand breaks (DSBs) at the target site, and desired sequence modifications can be introduced during the DSB repair process, such as nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) or homology-directed repair (HDR) pathways. CRISPR/Cas9 is the most widely used genome editing tool for targeted mutagenesis, precise sequence modification, transcriptional reprogramming, epigenome editing, disease treatment, and many more. The ease of use and high specificity make CRISPR/Cas9 a great tool not only for basic researches but also for crop trait improvements, such as higher grain yield, better tolerance to abiotic stresses, enhanced disease resistance, and better nutritional contents. In this protocol, we present a step-by-step guide to the CRISPR/Cas9-mediated targeted mutagenesis in maize Hi II genotype. Detailed procedures will guide through the essential steps including gRNA design, CRISPR/Cas9 vector construction, Agrobacterium-mediated maize immature embryo transformation, and molecular analysis of the transgenic plants to identify desired mutant lines.

CRISPR/Cas9-mediated targeted T-DNA integration in rice.

KEY MESSAGE: Combining with a CRISPR/Cas9 system, Agrobacterium-mediated transformation can lead to precise targeted T-DNA integration in the rice genome. Agrobacterium-mediated T-DNA integration into the plant genomes is random, which often causes variable transgene expression and insertional mutagenesis. Because T-DNA preferentially integrates into double-strand DNA breaks, we adapted a CRISPR/Cas9 system to demonstrate that targeted T-DNA integration can be achieved in the rice genome. Using a standard Agrobacterium binary vector, we constructed a T-DNA that contains a CRISPR/Cas9 system using SpCas9 and a gRNA targeting the exon of the rice AP2 domain-containing protein gene Os01g04020. The T-DNA also carried a red fluorescent protein and a hygromycin resistance (hptII) gene. One version of the vector had hptII expression driven by an OsAct2 promoter. In an effort to detect targeted T-DNA insertion events, we built another T-DNA with a promoterless hptII gene adjacent to the T-DNA right border such that integration of T-DNA into the targeted exon sequence in-frame with the hptII gene would allow hptII expression. Our results showed that these constructs could produce targeted T-DNA insertions with frequencies ranging between 4 and 5.3% of transgenic callus events, in addition to generating a high frequency (50-80%) of targeted indel mutations. Sequencing analyses showed that four out of five sequenced T-DNA/gDNA junctions carry a single copy of full-length T-DNA at the target site. Our results indicate that Agrobacterium-mediated transformation combined with a CRISPR/Cas9 system can efficiently generate targeted T-DNA insertions.