The limitations of using the NTP chronic bioassay on vanadium pentoxide in risk assessments.

Regulatory interest in assessing the health effects of vanadium compounds is hindered by the limited chronic toxicity data available. The National Toxicology Program (NTP) conducted a robust chronic inhalation bioassay of crystalline vanadium pentoxide (V2O5), but this study has noteworthy limitations. Multiple dose range-finding studies were conducted at two separate laboratories that showed cross-laboratory differences in lung pathology (inflammation) in both species and likely complicated dose-selection. In mice, the only tissue pathology (inflammation and tumors) was at the site of entry, the respiratory system. Although significantly different from control, because lung tumor incidences were at a maximal level across all concentrations tested, the ability to extrapolate risks to the public is problematic. In rats, lung inflammation and vanadium lung burdens were comparable to those of mice, but lung tumorigenicity was not substantiated, further raising questions about appropriate species extrapolation. Open questions also exist regarding test material chemical characterization, as the laboratory relied on vanadium measurement in test chambers as a surrogate for V2O5. In sum, the NTP V2O5 study does not provide an appropriate dataset for purposes of classification and risk assessment. Additional repeat exposure studies of vanadium compounds are needed and recommendations for future studies are provided.

Evaluation of cII mutations in lung of male Big Blue mice exposed by inhalation to vanadium pentoxide for up to 8 weeks.

Chronic inhalation of vanadium pentoxide (V2O5) increases the incidence of alveolar/bronchiolar tumors in male and female B6C3F1 mice at 1, 2, or 4 mg/m(3). The genotoxicity of V2O5 has been extensively investigated in the literature with mixed results. In general, tests for gene mutations have been negative. Both positive and negative results were reported for clastogenicity in vitro with some reports suggesting aneugenic potential. In vivo, V2O5 was negative in the mouse micronucleus test (erythrocyte) and comet assay (lung). Previously, K-ras mutations have been detected in the lung tumors in mice exposed to V2O5. Recently, a short-term inhalation study in B6C3F1 mice reported slight induction of 8-oxodGuo DNA lesions in lungs. Because 8-oxodGuo DNA lesions can lead to gene mutations if not repaired or if misrepaired, we have used groups of transgenic Big Blue (BB) mice (B6C3F1) to test whether V2O5 has mutagenic potential in vivo in the tumor target tissue under the conditions of the bioassay. Groups of six male BB mice were exposed to particulate aerosols containing 0, 0.1, or 1 mg/m(3) (tumorigenic concentration) V2O5 for 4 or 8 weeks (6h/day, 5 days/week) and cII mutant frequencies (MFs) were evaluated in the right lungs. A significant increase in lung weight was noted in mice exposed to 1 mg/m(3) V2O5 (P ≤ 0.05) compared to sham control, confirming exposure to an inflammatory level of the test material. The mean MFs (× 10(-6)) of mice in the 4-week exposure groups were 30 (sham control), 39 (0.1 mg/m(3)), and 24 (1 mg/m(3)) while the corresponding values in the 8-week exposure groups were 29, 48, and 17, respectively. None of these cII MFs measured at any time point was significantly higher than the corresponding control MFs (P ≥ 0.1). Overall, these results suggest that mutagenicity is not likely to be an initial key event in the lung tumorigenicity of V2O5.

Quantification of Kras mutant fraction in the lung DNA of mice exposed to aerosolized particulate vanadium pentoxide by inhalation.

This study investigated whether Kras mutation is an early event in the development of lung tumors induced by inhalation of particulate vanadium pentoxide (VP) aerosols. A National Toxicology Program tumor bioassay of inhaled particulate VP aerosols established that VP-induced alveolar/bronchiolar carcinomas of the B6C3F1 mouse lung carried Kras mutations at a higher frequency than observed in spontaneous mouse lung tumors. Therefore, this study sought to: (1) characterize any Kras mutational response with respect to VP exposure concentration, and (2) investigate the possibility that amplification of preexisting Kras mutation is an early event in VP-induced mouse lung tumorigenesis. Male Big Blue B6C3F1 mice (6 mice/group) were exposed to aerosolized particulate VP by inhalation, 6h/day, 5 days/week for 4 or 8 weeks, using VP exposure concentrations of 0, 0.1, and 1 mg/m(3). The levels of two different Kras codon 12 mutations [GGT → GAT (G12D) and GGT → GTT (G12V)] were measured in lung DNAs by Allele-specific Competitive Blocker PCR (ACB-PCR). For both exposure concentrations (0.1 and 1.0mg/m(3)) and both time points (4 and 8 weeks), the mutant fractions observed in VP-exposed mice were not significantly different from the concurrent controls. Given that 8 weeks of inhalation of a tumorigenic concentration of particulate aerosols of VP did not result in a significant change in levels of lung Kras mutation, the data do not support either a direct genotoxic effect of VP on Kras or early amplification of preexisting mutation as being involved in the genesis of VP-induced mouse lung tumors under the exposure conditions used. Rather, the data suggest that accumulation of Kras mutation occurs later with chronic VP exposure and is likely not an early event in VP-induced mouse lung carcinogenesis.

Using gene expression profiling to evaluate cellular responses in mouse lungs exposed to V2O5 and a group of other mouse lung tumorigens and non-tumorigens.

Many compounds test positive for lung tumors in two-year NTP carcinogenicity bioassays in B6C3F1 mice. V2O5 was identified as a lung carcinogen in this assay, leading to its IARC (International Agency for Research on Cancer) classification as group 2b or a "possible" human carcinogen. To assess potential tumorigenic mode of action of V2O5, we compared gene expression and gene ontology enrichment in lung tissue of female B6C3F1 mice exposed for 13 weeks to a V2O5 particulate aerosol at a tumorigenic level (2.0 mg/m(3)). Relative to 12 other compounds also tested for carcinogenicity in 2-year bioassays in mice, there were 1026 differentially expressed genes with V2O5, of which 483 were unique to V2O5. Ontology analysis of the 1026 V2O5 differentially expressed genes showed enrichment for hyaluronan and sphingolipid metabolism, adenylate cyclase functions, c-AMP signaling and PKA activation/signaling. Enrichment of lipids/lipoprotein metabolism and inflammatory pathways were consistent with previously reported clinical findings. Enrichment of c-AMP and PKA signaling pathways may arise due to inhibition of phosphatases, a known biological action of vanadate. We saw no enrichment for DNA-damage, oxidative stress, cell cycle, or apoptosis pathway signaling in mouse lungs exposed to V2O5 which is in contrast with past studies evaluating in vivo gene expression in target tissues of other carcinogens (arsenic, formaldehyde, naphthalene and chloroprene).

Vanadium pentoxide: risk assessment implications of a treatment- but not dose-related tumorigenic response in B6C3F1 mice.

The US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) is currently conducting a toxicological review of vanadium pentoxide (V2O5). As part of that effort, the Agency will need to address the fact that while a National Toxicology Program (NTP) chronic inhalation bioassay of V2O5 produced clear evidence of treatment-related lung tumors in both male and female B6C3F1 mice, neither of these responses were dose-related across the groups exposed to 1, 2, and 4mg/m(3). While lung tumor incidence was significantly elevated in all three exposed groups relative to that in the control groups, it was essentially flat across them. Herein we report results from computing poly-3-adjusted Cochran-Armitage trend test statistics with and without inclusion of the lung tumor incidence data from control group mice. These results confirm the absence of any significant dose-related effect on mouse lung tumor incidence in the study groups exposed to V2O5. We also considered two estimates of area under the vanadium lung burden versus time curve as plausible alternative dose metrics to the V2O5 chamber concentration. However, these alternative dose metrics were so highly correlated with the V2O5 chamber concentration (r=0.998) that nothing is to be gained from their use in place of the V2O5 chamber concentration in attempts to perform dose-response modeling of the tumor incidence or unit cancer risk computations. At the present time, there is no scientific basis to support linear (or nonlinear) extrapolations of estimated cancer risks to V2O5 exposure levels below 1mg/m(3). Additional tumor data at multiple V2O5 concentrations lower than 1mg/m(3) are required to support such extrapolations.

Vanadium pentoxide: use of relevant historical control data shows no evidence for a carcinogenic response in F344/N rats.

The National Toxicology Program (NTP) chronic inhalation bioassay of vanadium pentoxide (V(2)O(5)) produced "clear" evidence of lung tumors in B6C3F1 mice, but only "some" and "equivocal" evidence in male and female F344/N rats, respectively. No significant pairwise differences or trends with V(2)O(5) concentration in male or female rat poly-3-adjusted tumor incidence were reported. The "some" and "equivocal" evidence descriptors arose from comparisons of V(2)O(5)-exposed group incidence rates with NTP-2000- and NIH-07-fed historical control (HC) group incidence ranges. NTP acknowledged that use of data from NIH-07-fed HC groups could be inappropriate because the V(2)O(5) study used the NTP-2000 diet, but few studies using this newer diet were available then. We supplemented the early NTP-2000 diet HC data with data from 25 additional NTP-2000 diet studies conducted subsequent to the V(2)O(5) bioassay. This widened the HC tumor incidence ranges, thereby weakening the limited evidence for the carcinogenicity of inhaled V(2)O(5) in rats relative to HCs. The male rat control group in the V(2)O(5) study also appeared to be a near-"outlier" relative to the expanded HC database, potentially invalidating any comparisons of exposed group incidence rates with those for HCs. We conclude that there is "no" evidence of V(2)O(5) carcinogenicity in male or female F344/N rats.

Dichlorvos--a comprehensive review of 11 rodent carcinogenicity studies.

Dichlorvos (DDVP) has been studied in 11 cancer bioassays. Only two studies, the National Toxicology Program (NTP) rat and mouse studies, show any indication of carcinogenic effects and these results, an increase in mononuclear cell leukemia in the rat and an increase in forestomach tumors in the mouse, appear to be related to the corn oil vehicle. The increase in mononuclear cell leukemia was confined to the male rat, was not dose-related, did not show an earlier onset than the controls, had no effect on survival, was within the range seen in historical controls, and was not confirmed in five other rat studies, four of which used higher doses. The increase in forestomach tumors in mice in the NTP study, in which DDVP was administered by corn oil gavage, was confined to the highest dose, occurred against a high background of hyperplasia and forestomach tumors in the control mice, and was not confirmed in 10 other studies. Sustained irritation from daily gavaging with the corn oil vehicle, in conjunction with this high background, likely explains this response in the forestomach, which does not exist in humans. These 11 rodent studies provide strong evidence that DDVP is not carcinogenic.

Humans appear no more sensitive than laboratory animals to the inhibition of red blood cell cholinesterase by dichlorvos.

Inhibition of red blood cell (RBC) cholinesterase is a consistent and sensitive indicator of exposure to dichlorvos (DDVP). Absent human data, default 10-fold adjustment factors for potential interspecies and intraspecies sensitivity differences would be used in developing a reference dose from the no observed effect levels for this endpoint obtained in toxicological assessments of laboratory animals. However, many studies of the cholinesterase-inhibiting effects associated with DDVP exposure have been conducted in humans, including healthy male volunteers, other healthy subpopulations, and diverse clinical subpopulations. Indeed, ample human data exist to permit a data-based assessment of potential interspecies sensitivity differences in RBC cholinesterase inhibition associated with DDVP exposure. In aggregate, these data demonstrate that the DDVP doses producing inhibition in humans are virtually identical to those eliciting the same levels of inhibition in laboratory rats, mice, monkeys, and dogs. Thus, healthy humans appear to be no more sensitive than laboratory animals to DDVP's effects on RBC cholinesterase, and an interspecies uncertainty factor of 1 is appropriate and scientifically warranted for use in DDVP risk assessments.