Evaluation of the mode of action and human relevance of liver tumors in male mice treated with epyrifenacil.

Epyrifenacil (trademark name: Rapidicil®), a novel protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPO)-inhibiting herbicide, induces hepatocellular adenomas and carcinomas in male CD-1 mice after 78 weeks treatment. The mode of action (MOA) of these mouse liver tumors and their relevance to humans was assessed based on the 2006 International Programme on Chemical Safety (IPCS) Human Relevance Framework. Epyrifenacil is not genotoxic and induced liver tumors via the postulated porphyria-mediated cytotoxicity MOA with the following key events: (#1) PPO inhibition; (#2) porphyrin accumulation; (#3) hepatocellular injury; with (#4) subsequent regenerative cell proliferation; and ultimately (#5) development of liver tumors. This article evaluates the weight of evidence for this MOA based on the modified Bradford Hill criteria. The MOA data were aligned with the dose and temporal concordance, biological plausibility, coherence, strength, consistency, and specificity for a porphyria-mediated cytotoxicity MOA while excluding other alternative MOAs. Although the postulated MOA could qualitatively potentially occur in humans, we demonstrate that it is unlikely to occur in humans because of quantitative toxicodynamic and toxicokinetic differences between mice and humans. Therefore, this MOA is considered not relevant to humans, utilizing the IPCS Human Relevance Framework; consequently, a nonlinear, threshold dose response would be appropriate for human risk assessment.

Comparative hepatotoxicity of a herbicide, epyrifenacil, in humans and rodents by comparing the dynamics and kinetics of its causal metabolite.

A new herbicide, epyrifenacil (S-3100), inhibits protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPO) in plants. Repeated administration of epyrifenacil in laboratory animals led to some toxicological changes related to PPO inhibition, e.g., hepatotoxicity caused by porphyrin accumulation and anemia caused by the inhibition of heme biosynthesis. In vitro studies revealed that an ester-cleaved metabolite, S-3100-CA, is predominant in mammals, exhibits PPO-inhibitory activity, and thus is the cause of epyrifenacil-induced toxicity. To assess the human risk, the effects of species differences on the dynamics (PPO inhibition) and kinetics (liver uptake) of epyrifenacil were evaluated separately. The results of in vitro assays revealed an approximately tenfold weaker inhibition of PPO by S-3100-CA in humans than in rodents and six- to thirteen-fold less hepatic uptake of S-3100-CA in humans than in mice. Finally, it was suggested that humans are less sensitive to the toxicity of epyrifenacil than are rodents, although further mechanistic research is highly anticipated.

Elucidation of the species differences of epyrifenacil-induced hepatotoxicity between mice and humans by mass spectrometry imaging analysis in chimeric mice with humanized liver.

Epyrifenacil, one of the protoporphyrinogen oxidase (PPO)-inhibiting herbicides, is hepatotoxic in rodents. Previous in vitro assays detected species differences in both kinetics (active hepatic uptake) and dynamics (PPO inhibitory activity) of S-3100-CA, which is a causal metabolite of the hepatotoxicity, suggesting that humans are less sensitive to the epyrifenacil-induced hepatotoxicity than are rats and mice. To elucidate the species differences in the epyrifenacil-induced hepatotoxicity between mice and humans simultaneously, this study fed epyrifenacil to chimeric mice with humanized liver with low replacement index of human hepatocytes. The distribution of S-3100-CA in the liver and subsequent protoporphyrin IX (PPIX) accumulation, an index of PPO inhibition, were compared between human and host mouse hepatocytes using mass spectrometry imaging (MSI) analysis of chimeric liver. The results showed that S-3100-CA and PPIX were significantly colocalized in regions of the liver slice containing host mouse hepatocytes, and thus it was suggested that epyrifenacil had significantly less effect on human livers than mouse livers because of the species differences in both kinetics and dynamics of S-3100-CA. Moreover, the hepatic uptake assay using cryopreserved primary hepatocytes of rats, mice and humans with inhibitors revealed that S-3100-CA is a substrate of organic anion transporting polypeptides (OATPs). These data corroborate the contribution of OATPs to hepatocellular uptake of S-3100-CA, especially in mice, and subsequent PPIX accumulation by more potent S-3100-CA-induced PPO inhibition in mice. MSI analysis of chimeric mice with humanized liver is a useful technique for elucidating species differences in pharmacokinetics and subsequent changes in toxicological biomarkers.