Radiation-activated nanoparticles: Which combination to optimize radiosensitization?

Radiotherapy plays a crucial role in the treatment of various cancers. With the ongoing technological advancements in radiotherapy equipment, allowing for increasingly precise targeting of tumours, there are numerous strategies being explored to enhance its effectiveness by combining it with other therapies. Among these, metal nanoparticles seem to have a promising future driven by their ability to locally amplify the dose deposited by ionizing radiation, and to radiosensitize cells by modifying their oxidative status. Recent advancements in understanding the mechanisms of action of these nanoparticles have provided valuable insights for the development of new therapeutic combinations. Among these, the combination with immunotherapies would make it possible to benefit both from the amplified local effect of radiotherapy by nanoparticles and to induce a better antitumour immune response. In this article, we review shortly the existing literature on ongoing combinations and suggest potential novel therapies associated with the combination of radiotherapy and nanoparticles.

[Abscopal effect: Myth or reality?] / Effet abscopal : mythe ou réalité ?

The abscopal effect has been mentioned since 1953. The increase in knowledge about the immune system and the development of immunotherapies support its potential therapeutic interest. While it is accepted that radiotherapy induces an immune response, demonstrating its systemic impact is not easy. The preclinical basis is solid but its clinical validation pending. Radiotherapy rarely induces tumor reduction at a distance from the beams, probably due to its immunosuppressive effect. This is why a synergy between radiotherapy and systemic treatments targeting these immunosuppressive mechanisms was observed. Several parameters can modulate the induction of the abscopal effect. Among these, the fractionation of the dose seems to be determining with currently a pre-eminence of hypofractionated stereotaxis. On the other hand, even if the choice of more immunogenic targets (liver, lung) should be favoured, the optimal number of lesions to be irradiated remains to be defined as well as the minimum volume allowing sufficient release of tumor antigens. The impact of radiation-induced lymphopenia on radiotherapy/immunotherapy efficacy needs to be assessed more precisely, as does the effect of radiotherapy techniques on them. Finally, the choice of immunotherapy(ies) and the combination regimen with radiotherapy remain under discussion. A sequential scheme appears to provide less toxicities but the concomitant would lead to a better response. The study of these different parameters should allow us to deliver optimized radiotherapy/immunotherapy(ies) combinations to our metastatic patients in order to benefit as many people as possible from this abscopal effect.

In-vivo and in-vitro impact of high-dose rate radiotherapy using flattening-filter-free beams on the anti-tumor immune response.

INTRODUCTION: Modern accelerators have the "flattening filter-free" (FFF) technique to deliver RT with a moderate high-dose rate, currently used in limited clinical indications. No scientifically established data are currently available on the possible effects of this high dose rate on the anti-tumor immune response. We therefore propose here to study these effects in a preclinical CT26 murine colorectal tumor model. MATERIAL AND METHODS: In-vitro, CT26 cells were irradiated on a Varian TrueBeam® linac at 3 different dose rates (4; 12 or 24 Gy/min) using the FFF mode. Activation of the anti-tumor immune response was evaluated by the analysis of induction of genes of the type I interferon pathway by RT-qPCR, and by the study of the induction of immunogenic death biomarkers. In-vivo, an efficacy study of RT delivering 16.5 Gy at 2 different dose rates was performed in immunocompetent Balb/c mice carrying CT26 syngeneic tumors, as well as an immunomonitoring analysed by flow cytometry and a transcriptomic analysis using RNA sequencing. Statistical analyzes were performed using non-parametric tests. RESULTS: In-vitro, no significant influence of an increase in FFF dose rate was shown for the induction of genes of the type I interferon pathway as well as for the studied immunogenic death markers (HMGB1 secretion). In-vivo, no difference in terms of tumor growth retardation between the 2 dose rates used was demonstrated, as well as for the composition of immune cell infiltrates within tumor microenvironment and the expression of immune checkpoints in immunomonitoring and RNAseq. CONCLUSION: In this study involving the CT26 model, no influence of a moderate high dose rate in FFF technique on the anti-tumor immune response was demonstrated, which would make studies of associations between RT and checkpoint inhibitors fit with this technique of RT. However, further explorations using other cellular models seem to be of interest.

RILA blood biomarker as a predictor of radiation-induced sarcoma in a matched cohort study.

PURPOSE: Radiation-induced sarcoma (RIS) is a rare but serious event. Its occurrence has been discussed during the implementation of new radiation techniques and justified appropriate radioprotection requirements. New approaches targeting intrinsic radio-sensitivity have been described, such as radiation-induced CD8 T-lymphocyte apoptosis (RILA) able to predict late radio-induced toxicities. We studied the role of RILA as a predisposing factor for RIS as a late adverse event following radiation therapy (RT). PATIENTS AND METHODS: In this prospective biological study, a total of 120 patients diagnosed with RIS were matched with 240 control patients with cancer other than sarcoma, for age, sex, primary tumor location and delay after radiation. RILA was prospectively assessed from blood samples using flow cytometry. RESULTS: Three hundred and forty-seven patients were analyzed (118 RIS patients and 229 matched control patients). A majority (74%) were initially treated by RT for breast cancer. The mean RT dose was comparable with a similar mean (± standard deviation) for RIS (53.7 ±â€¯16.0 Gy) and control patients (57.1 ±â€¯15.1 Gy) (p = .053). Median RILA values were significantly lower in RIS than in control patients with respectively 18.5% [5.5-55.7] and 22.3% [3.8-52.2] (p = .0008). Thus, patients with a RILA >21.3% are less likely to develop RIS (p < .0001, OR: 0.358, 95%CI [0.221-0.599]. CONCLUSION: RILA is a promising indicator to predict an individual risk of developing RIS. Our results should be followed up and compared with molecular and genomic testing in order to better identify patients at risk. A dedicated strategy could be developed to define and inform high-risk patients who require a specific approach for primary tumor treatment and long term follow-up.

Tumor lymphocyte immune response to preoperative radiotherapy in locally advanced rectal cancer: The LYMPHOREC study.

Introduction: Some studies have suggested that baseline tumor-infiltrating-lymphocytes (TILs), such as CD8+ and FoxP3+ T-cells, may be associated with a better prognosis in colorectal cancer. We sought to investigate modulation of the immune response by preoperative radiotherapy (preopRT) and its impact on survival in locally advanced rectal cancer (LARC). Materials & Methods: We analyzed data for 237 patients with LARC who received RT. Density of TILS (CD8+ and FoxP3+) in intraepithelial (iTILs) and stromal compartments (sTILs) were evaluated from surgery pathological specimens and biopsies performed at baseline. The primary endpoint was to assess the impact of infiltration of the tumor or tumor site after preopRT on progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS). Secondary endpoints were the impact of dose fractionation scheme on TILs. Results: In univariate analysis, several factors significantly correlated (p<0.05) with PFS and/or OS (T-stage, M-stage, the delay between RT and surgery). A high level of post-treatment FoxP3+ TIL density correlated significantly with a better PFS (p = 0.007). In multivariate analysis, a decrease in the CD8+/FoxP3+ iTILs ratio after preopRT correlated with better PFS and OS (p = 0.049 and p = 0.024, respectively). More particularly, patients with a delta CD8+/FoxP3+ <-3.8 had better PFS and OS. Interestingly, the dose fractionation scheme significantly influenced the CD8+/FoxP3+ ratio after treatment (p = 0.027) with a lower ratio with hypofractionated RT (≥2 Gy). Conclusion: Patients with LARC who had a significant decrease in the CD8+/FoxP3+ ratio after preopRT were more likely to live longer. This ratio needs to be validated prospectively to guide physicians in adjuvant treatment decision-making.

[Sarcoma developed in irradiated area: Preliminary results of the SARI trial]. / Sarcomes développés en territoire irradié : résultats préliminaires de l'étude SARI.

Radiotherapy and surgery are the two main pillars of the locoregional treatment of cancer. The risk of second malignancy is better evaluated and constitutes a major issue regarding radioprotection of the patients. Among malignant disease observed in the surviving irradiated patients, the occurrence of sarcoma is a rare event but associated with a poor outcome since the 5 year overall survival is estimated at 10 to 35 %. The SARI protocol, written in 2011, included 120 patients and 240 controlled patients, irradiated in the same conditions but without sarcoma observed during the follow up. The main objective was to identify the clinical and biological factors associated with the occurrence of such a complication. The secondary objective was to identify the dosimetric characteristics of the treatment of the primary. Preliminary results will be presented during the 2016 meeting of the French radiation oncology society.

Correlation between radio-induced lymphocyte apoptosis measurements obtained from two French centres.

PURPOSE OF THE RESEARCH: In the era of modern treatment delivery, increasing the dose delivered to the target to improve local control might be modulated by the patient's intrinsic radio-sensitivity. A predictive assay based on radio-induced lymphocyte apoptosis quantification highlighted the significant correlation between CD4 and CD8 T-lymphocyte apoptosis and grade 2 or 3 radiation-induced late toxicities. By conducting this assay at several technical platforms, the aim of this study was to demonstrate that radio-induced lymphocyte apoptosis values obtained from two different platforms were comparable. MATERIALS AND METHODS: For 25 patients included in the PARATOXOR trial running in Dijon the radio-induced lymphocyte apoptosis results obtained from the laboratory of Montpellier (IRCM, Inserm U1194, France), considered as the reference (referred to as Lab 1), were compared with those from the laboratory located at the Institut de cancérologie de Lorraine (ICL, France), referred to as Lab 2. Different statistical methods were used to measure the agreement between the radio-induced lymphocyte apoptosis data from the two laboratories (quantitative data). The Bland-Altman plot was used to identify potential bias. RESULTS: All statistical tests demonstrated good agreement between radio-induced lymphocyte apoptosis values obtained from both sites and no major bias was identified. CONCLUSIONS: Since radio-induced lymphocyte apoptosis values, which predict tolerance to radiotherapy, could be assessed by two laboratories and showed a high level of robustness and consistency, we can suggest that this assay be extended to any laboratories that use the same technique.

A phase I dose escalation study using simultaneous integrated-boost IMRT with temozolomide in patients with unifocal glioblastoma.

PURPOSE: To evaluate the maximum tolerated dose of simultaneous integrated-boost intensity-modulated radiotherapy (SIB-IMRT) associated with temozolomide in patients with glioblastoma. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between November 2009 and January 2012, nine patients with malignant glioma were enrolled in this phase I clinical trial. Radiotherapy was delivered using fractions of 2.5Gy on the planning target volume b and of 1.9Gy on the planning target volume a. Volumes were defined as follow: gross tumour volume b: tumour taking up contrast on T1 weighted MRI images; clinical target volume b: gross tumour volume b+0.5cm (adapted to the anatomical structures) and lastly planning target volume b: clinical target volume b+0.5cm; gross tumour volume a: tumour (gross tumour volume b)+2cm and including oedema outlined on T2Flair MRI sequences; clinical target volume a gross tumour volume a+0.5cm (adapted to the anatomical structures); planning target volume a: clinical target volume a+0.5cm. Three patients were enrolled at each of the three levels of dose (70, 75 and 80Gy prescribed on the planning target volume b and 56, 60 and 60.8Gy on the planning target volume a). Radiotherapy was delivered with temozolomide according to the standard protocol. Dose-limiting toxicities were defined as any haematological toxicities at least grade 4 or as any radiotherapy-related non-haematological acute toxicities at least grade 3, according to the Common Terminology Criteria for Adverse Events, version 3.0. RESULTS: Until the last dose level of 80Gy, no patient showed dose-limiting toxicity. CONCLUSIONS: SIB-IMRT, at least until a dose of 80Gy in 32 daily fractions, associated with temozolomide is feasible and well tolerated.

[Reirradiations of head and neck cancers: state of the concept and ways of development]. / Ré-irradiations des cancers de la tête et du cou : état du concept et voies de développement.

The treatment of local recurrence or second primary developed in irradiated area in the field of head and neck carcinoma, should be planned and organized through multidisciplinary discussions. The outcome of such a clinical situations benefits from second line and advanced technology treatments. Only a few patients are amenable to salvage surgery, hence radiation therapy, combined or not with chemotherapy, takes a major role in these indications. This overview of the literature describes recent development in this field, aiming to improve local control while the sparing of organ at risk remains an important goal. Radiation therapy is currently implementing major new technologies set to improve external beam irradiation with new concepts on dose, fractionation, intensity modulated radiation therapy and stereotactic approach - as well as in brachytherapy. Apart from dedicated studies, the great heterogeneity of the treated patients should be underlined and taken into consideration. However, current data confirm the feasibility of reirradiation with acceptable local control and toxicity.

[The role of whole brain radiotherapy with hippocampal-sparing]. / Quelle place pour l'irradiation panencéphalique avec épargne des hippocampes ?

Hippocampi plays a fundamental role in immediate or long-term memory and the spatial learning. This structure is rarely involved by metastasis and their irradiation is at the origin of some impairment of the neurocognitive function. Sparing hippocampi during whole brain radiation therapy becomes possible with volumetric modulated arc therapy (VMAT) or with helical tomotherapy. The delineation of the structures should be performed after coregistration of gadolinium-enhanced T1-weighted MR-images with the planning. The D40 to both hippocampi should not be greater than 7.3 Gy. Patients who are more likely to benefit from a hippocampal-sparing strategy must have a 6 months or longer life expectancy and a Karnosky index above 70. Hence, patients who are more likely to be deemed fit for this strategy are frequently patients with NSCLC, breast cancer, gastointestinal cancers or patients. Patients with small cell lung carcinoma who are selected for prophylactic cerebral irradiation should be also considered, as they are unfit for ablative treatments such as stereotactic radiotherapy or brain surgery. Moreover, brain metastasis located in the area surrounding the hippocampi are unlikely. To date, no randomized study is available to confirm these assumptions. Two on-going prospective trials (RTOG 0933 and a French phase II trial) are currently investigating whether breast cancer patients with a single resected metastasis could benefit from the hippocampal-sparing strategy during whole brain radiotherapy.

The radiosensitization effect of titanate nanotubes as a new tool in radiation therapy for glioblastoma: a proof-of-concept.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: One of the new challenges to improve radiotherapy is to increase the ionizing effect by using nanoparticles. The interest of titanate nanotubes (TiONts) associated with radiotherapy was evaluated in two human glioblastoma cell lines (SNB-19 and U87MG). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Titanate nanotubes were synthetized by the hydrothermal treatment of titanium dioxide powder in a strongly basic NaOH solution. The cytotoxicity of TiONts was evaluated on SNB-19 and U87MG cell lines by cell proliferation assay. The internalization of TiONts was studied using Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM). Finally, the effect of TiONts on cell radiosensitivity was evaluated using clonogenic assay. Cell cycle distribution was evaluated by flow cytometry after DNA labeling. DNA double-stranded breaks were evaluated using γH2AX labeling. RESULTS: Cells internalized TiONts through the possible combination of endocytosis and diffusion with no cytotoxicity. Clonogenic assays showed that cell lines incubated with TiONts were radiosensitized with a decrease in the SF2 parameter for both SNB-19 and U87MG cells. TiONts decreased DNA repair efficiency after irradiation and amplified G2/M cell-cycle arrest. CONCLUSION: Our results indicated that further development of TiONts might provide a new useful tool for research and clinical therapy in the field of oncology.