Diffusion and structure of propylene carbonate-metal salt electrolyte solutions for post-lithium-ion batteries: From experiment to simulation.

The diffusion of cations in organic solvent solutions is important for the performance of metal-ion batteries. In this article, pulsed field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance experiments and fully atomistic molecular dynamic simulations were employed to study the temperature-dependent diffusive behavior of various liquid electrolytes representing 1M propylene carbonate solutions of metal salts with bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide (TFSI-) or hexafluorophosphate (PF6-) anions commonly used in lithium-ion batteries and beyond. The experimental studies revealed the temperature dependence of the diffusion coefficients for the propylene carbonate (PC) solvent and for the anions following an Arrhenius type of behavior. It was observed that the PC molecules are the faster species. For the monovalent cations (Li+, Na+, K+), the PC solvent diffusion was enhanced as the cation size increased, while for the divalent cations (Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+), the opposite trend was observed, i.e., the diffusion coefficients decreased as the cation size increased. The anion diffusion in LiTFSI and NaTFSI solutions was found to be similar, while in electrolytes with divalent cations, a decrease in anion diffusion with increasing cation size was observed. It was shown that non-polarizable charge-scaled force fields could correspond perfectly to the experimental values of the anion and PC solvent diffusion coefficients in salt solutions of both monovalent (Li+, Na+, K+) and divalent (Mg2+, Ca2+, Sr2+, Ba2+) cations at a range of operational temperatures. Finally, after calculating the radial distribution functions between cations, anions, and solvent molecules, the increase in the PC diffusion coefficient established with the increase in cation size for monovalent cations was clearly explained by the large hydration shell of small Li+ cations, due to their strong interaction with the PC solvent. In solutions with larger monovalent cations, such as Na+, and with a smaller solvation shell of PC, the PC diffusion is faster due to more liberated solvent molecules. In the salt solutions with divalent cations, both the anion and the PC diffusion coefficients decreased as the cation size increased due to an enhanced cation-anion coordination, which was accompanied by an increase in the amount of PC in the cation solvation shell due to the presence of anions.

Overdetermination method for accurate dynamic ion correlations in highly concentrated electrolytes.

Highly concentrated battery electrolytes exhibit a low flammability as well as a high thermal and electrochemical stability, and they typically form stable solid electrolyte interphases in contact with electrode materials. The transport properties of these electrolytes in batteries are strongly influenced by correlated movements of the ions. In the case of a binary electrolyte, the transport properties can be described by three Onsager coefficients and a thermodynamic factor. In order to determine these four target quantities, at least four experimental quantities are needed. Overdetermination by measuring five or more experimental quantities is uncommon. Here we have combined electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, electrophoretic NMR measurements and concentration cell measurements for characterizing two highly concentrated sulfolane/LiFSI electrolytes. Two sets of four experimental quantities and one set of five experimental quantities were compared with regard to the uncertainties of the resulting four target quantities. We show that the methods employing only four experimental quantities either lead to large uncertainties of the Onsager coefficients or to large uncertainties of the thermodynamic factor, while only the overdetermination by five experimental quantities leads to acceptable uncertainties of all four target quantities. The results for the Onsager coefficients are discussed with regard to dynamic ion correlations and to transport limitations in battery cells.

A volume-based description of transport in incompressible liquid electrolytes and its application to ionic liquids.

Transference numbers play an important role in understanding the dynamics of electrolytes and assessing their performance in batteries. Unfortunately, these transport parameters are difficult to measure in highly concentrated liquid electrolytes such as ionic liquids. Also, the interpretation of their sign and magnitude has provoked an ongoing debate in the literature further complicated by the use of different languages. In this work, we highlight the role of the reference frame for the interpretation of transport parameters using our novel thermodynamically consistent theory for highly correlated electrolytes. We argue that local volume conservation is a key principle in incompressible liquid electrolytes and use the volume-based drift velocity as a reference. We apply our general framework to electrophoretic NMR experiments. For ionic liquid based electrolytes, we find that the results of the eNMR measurements can be best described using this volume-based description. This highlights the limitations of the widely used center-of-mass reference frame which for example forms the basis for molecular dynamics simulations - a standard tool for the theoretical calculation of transport parameters. It shows that the assumption of local momentum conservation is incorrect in those systems on the macroscopic scale.

Local Volume Conservation in Concentrated Electrolytes Is Governing Charge Transport in Electric Fields.

While ion transport processes in concentrated electrolytes, e.g., based on ionic liquids (IL), are a subject of intense research, the role of conservation laws and reference frames is still a matter of debate. Employing electrophoretic NMR, we show that momentum conservation, a typical prerequisite in molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, is not governing ion transport. Involving density measurements to determine molar volumes of distinct ion species, we propose that conservation of local molar species volumes is the governing constraint for ion transport. The experimentally quantified net volume flux is found to be zero, implying a nonzero local momentum flux, as tested in pure ILs and IL-based electrolytes for a broad variety of concentrations and chemical compositions. This constraint is consistent with incompressibility, but not with a local application of momentum conservation. The constraint affects the calculation of transference numbers as well as comparisons of MD results to experimental findings.

Superionicity in Ionic-Liquid-Based Electrolytes Induced by Positive Ion-Ion Correlations.

In ionic-liquid (IL)-based electrolytes, relevant for current energy storage applications, ion transport is limited by strong ion-ion correlations, generally yielding inverse Haven ratios (ionicities) of below 1. In particular, Li is transported in anionic clusters into the wrong direction of the electric field, requiring compensation by diffusive anion fluxes. Here, we present a concept to exploit ion-ion correlations in concentrated IL electrolytes beneficially by designing organic cations with a Li-coordinating chain. 1H NMR and Raman spectra show that IL cations with seven or more ether oxygens in the side chain induce Li coordination to organic cations. An unusual behavior of an inverse Haven ratio of >1 is found, suggesting an ionicity larger than that of an ideal electrolyte with uncorrelated ion motion. This superionic behavior is consistently demonstrated in both NMR transport/conductivity measurements and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Key to this achievement is the formation of long-lived Li-IL cation complexes, which invert the Li drift direction, yielding positive Li+ ion mobilities for the first time in a single IL-solvent-based electrolyte. Onsager correlation coefficients are derived from MD simulations and demonstrate that the main contributions to the inverse Haven ratio, which induce superionicity, arise from enhanced Li-IL cation correlations and a sign inversion of Li-anion correlation coefficients. Thus, the novel concept of coordinating cations not only corrects the unfortunate anionic drift direction of Li in ILs but even exploits strong ion correlations in the concentrated electrolyte toward superionic transport.

Li Coordination of a Novel Asymmetric Anion in Ionic Liquid-in-Li Salt Electrolytes.

We analyze the influence of the asymmetry of the anion on coordination and transport processes in a Li salt/ionic liquid system. The relatively new asymmetric 2,2,2-trifluoromethylsulfonyl-N-cyanamide (TFSAM) anion was investigated in Pyr14TFSAM(1-x)LiTFSAMx over a broad concentration range (up to x = 0.7 Li salt) and was compared to the well-known bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)amide (TFSA) anion. In contrast to the TFSA-based system, the system with TFSAM has no phase transition over the whole concentration range. Raman spectroscopy and NMR chemical shifts elucidate the Li coordination in detail. Up to x = 0.3, the asymmetric anion coordinates to Li+ only via the cyano group. With increasing Li salt fraction, the contribution of Li-oxygen coordination increases. This coordination effects influence the transport properties of the system, as examined via pulsed-field-gradient NMR (PFG-NMR). Although the overall diffusivity of both systems is decreasing because of viscosity effects, the relative diffusivity of the Li cation is increasing with x. This suggests a change in the transport mechanism depending on the Li salt fraction. Interestingly, the contribution of structural diffusion at high Li salt concentrations (x ≥ 0.6) seems to be higher in the TFSAM system, influenced by the nonsymmetric coordination, while in the TFSA system, the vehicular transport seems to be still predominant at x ≥ 0.6.

Improved lithium ion dynamics in crosslinked PMMA gel polymer electrolyte.

Since PMMA-based gel polymer electrolytes could substitute PVDF-HFP based gels currently used in Li-ion batteries at lower financial and environmental costs, we investigate here the solvation and transport properties of the lithium ions in a crosslinked PMMA-based gel polymer electrolyte by a combination of thermal and electrochemical methods, Raman spectroscopy, pulse field gradient (PFG) and electrophoretic NMR (eNMR) techniques, as well as ab initio calculations. The conductivity of the gel containing 10 wt% polymer is only reduced by 14% relative to the liquid electrolyte. In addition, the co-solvation by polymer functional groups, a priori expected to slow lithium transport relatively to the anion, has instead a positive effect on lithium transport. Indeed, the ester groups not only participate in lithium solvation and increase ionic dissociation, but since this interaction is rather weak, rather than lowering the lithium diffusion relatively to other species, it mainly decorrelates lithium transport from anionic mobility. Compared to its liquid fraction, the gels show, at the same time, better dissociation and a higher lithium transference number, which results in a higher cationic conductivity, despite the overall conductivity loss.