Towards precision medicine in sepsis: a position paper from the European Society of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases.

BACKGROUND: Our current understanding of the pathophysiology and management of sepsis is associated with a lack of progress in clinical trials, which partly reflects insufficient appreciation of the heterogeneity of this syndrome. Consequently, more patient-specific approaches to treatment should be explored. AIMS: To summarize the current evidence on precision medicine in sepsis, with an emphasis on translation from theory to clinical practice. A secondary objective is to develop a framework enclosing recommendations on management and priorities for further research. SOURCES: A global search strategy was performed in the MEDLINE database through the PubMed search engine (last search December 2017). No restrictions of study design, time, or language were imposed. CONTENT: The focus of this Position Paper is on the interplay between therapies, pathogens, and the host. Regarding the pathogen, microbiologic diagnostic approaches (such as blood cultures (BCs) and rapid diagnostic tests (RDTs)) are discussed, as well as targeted antibiotic treatment. Other topics include the disruption of host immune system and the use of biomarkers in sepsis management, patient stratification, and future clinical trial design. Lastly, personalized antibiotic treatment and stewardship are addressed (Fig. 1). IMPLICATIONS: A road map provides recommendations and future perspectives. RDTs and identifying drug-response phenotypes are clear challenges. The next step will be the implementation of precision medicine to sepsis management, based on theranostic methodology. This highly individualized approach will be essential for the design of novel clinical trials and improvement of care pathways.

Endothelial barrier dysfunction in septic shock.

The endothelium provides an essential and selective membrane barrier that regulates the movement of water, solutes, gases, macromolecules and the cellular elements of the blood from the tissue compartment in health and disease. Its structure and continuous function is essential for life for all vertebrate organisms. Recent evidence indicates that the endothelial surface does not have a passive role in systemic inflammatory states such as septic shock. In fact, endothelial cells are in dynamic equilibrium with a myriad of inflammatory mediators and elements of the innate immune and coagulation systems to orchestrate the host response in sepsis. The barrier function of the endothelial surface is almost uniformly impaired in septic shock, and it is likely that this contributes to adverse outcomes. In this review, we will highlight recent advances in the understanding of the signalling events that regulate endothelial function and molecular events that induce endothelial dysfunction in sepsis. Endothelial barrier repair strategies as a treatment for sepsis include modulation of C5a, high-mobility group box 1 and VEGF receptor 2; stimulation of angiopoietin-1, sphingosine 1 phosphate receptor 1 and Slit; and a number of other innovative approaches.

Treatment effects of high-dose antithrombin without concomitant heparin in patients with severe sepsis with or without disseminated intravascular coagulation.

BACKGROUND: Disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) is a serious complication of sepsis that is associated with a high mortality. OBJECTIVES: Using the adapted International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis (ISTH) diagnostic scoring algorithm for DIC, we evaluated the treatment effects of high-dose antithrombin (AT) in patients with severe sepsis with or without DIC. PATIENTS AND METHODS: From the phase III clinical trial in severe sepsis (KyberSept), 563 patients were identified (placebo, 277; AT, 286) who did not receive concomitant heparin and had sufficient data for DIC determination. RESULTS: At baseline, 40.7% of patients (229 of 563) had DIC. DIC in the placebo-treated patients was associated with an excess risk of mortality (28-day mortality: 40.0% vs. 22.2%, P < 0.01). AT-treated patients with DIC had an absolute reduction in 28-day mortality of 14.6% compared with placebo (P = 0.02) whereas in patients without DIC no effect on 28-day mortality was seen (0.1% reduction in mortality; P = 1.0). Bleeding complications in AT-treated patients with and without DIC were higher compared with placebo (major bleeding rates: 7.0% vs. 5.2% for patients with DIC, P = 0.6; 9.8% vs. 3.1% for patients without DIC, P = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: High-dose AT without concomitant heparin in septic patients with DIC may result in a significant mortality reduction. The adapted ISTH DIC score may identify patients with severe sepsis who potentially benefit from high-dose AT treatment.

Caring for the critically ill patient. High-dose antithrombin III in severe sepsis: a randomized controlled trial.

CONTEXT: Activation of the coagulation system and depletion of endogenous anticoagulants are frequently found in patients with severe sepsis and septic shock. Diffuse microthrombus formation may induce organ dysfunction and lead to excess mortality in septic shock. Antithrombin III may provide protection from multiorgan failure and improve survival in severely ill patients. OBJECTIVE: To determine if high-dose antithrombin III (administered within 6 hours of onset) would provide a survival advantage in patients with severe sepsis and septic shock. DESIGN AND SETTING: Double-blind, placebo-controlled, multicenter phase 3 clinical trial in patients with severe sepsis (the KyberSept Trial) was conducted from March 1997 through January 2000. PATIENTS: A total of 2314 adult patients were randomized into 2 equal groups of 1157 to receive either intravenous antithrombin III (30 000 IU in total over 4 days) or a placebo (1% human albumin). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: All-cause mortality 28 days after initiation of study medication. RESULTS: Overall mortality at 28 days in the antithrombin III treatment group was 38.9% vs 38.7% in the placebo group (P =.94). Secondary end points, including mortality at 56 and 90 days and survival time in the intensive care unit, did not differ between the antithrombin III and placebo groups. In the subgroup of patients who did not receive concomitant heparin during the 4-day treatment phase (n = 698), the 28-day mortality was nonsignificantly lower in the antithrombin III group (37.8%) than in the placebo group (43.6%) (P =.08). This trend became significant after 90 days (n = 686; 44.9% for antithrombin III group vs 52.5% for placebo group; P =.03). In patients receiving antithrombin III and concomitant heparin, a significantly increased bleeding incidence was observed (23.8% for antithrombin III group vs 13.5% for placebo group; P<.001). CONCLUSIONS: High-dose antithrombin III therapy had no effect on 28-day all-cause mortality in adult patients with severe sepsis and septic shock when administered within 6 hours after the onset. High-dose antithrombin III was associated with an increased risk of hemorrhage when administered with heparin. There was some evidence to suggest a treatment benefit of antithrombin III in the subgroup of patients not receiving concomitant heparin.

Lipopolyamines as a therapeutic strategy in experimental Gram-negative bacterial sepsis.

Lipopolyamines are a class of polycationic amphiphilic compounds that have been shown to bind with high affinity to polyanionic macromolecules, including both DNA and bacterial lipopoly-saccharide (LPS). One of these compounds, termed DOSPER (1,3-di-oleoyloxy-2-(6-carboxyl-spermyl)- propylamide), is non-cytotoxic and has been shown to inhibit LPS-mediated cytokine release and lethality in endotoxin challenge models. In the study reported here, the activity of DOSPER was tested in neutropenic rats with invasive Gram-negative bacteremia caused by Pseudomonas aeruginosa. DOSPER alone was ineffective (0/8) at influencing mortality, but provided a significant survival advantage if administered in combination with a bactericidal antibiotic, ceftazidime (10/12; P<0.05). Ceftazidime alone was partially protective (6/12) while the control group had no survivors (0/8). DOSPER administration markedly reduced circulating endotoxin levels (P<0.01) and interleukin-6 levels (P<0.05) but had no significant effect on bacteremia and bacterial concentrations of P. aeruginosa in liver or spleen tissue. Lipopolyamines may be potentially valuable as a therapeutic adjunct in treatment of Gram-negative bacterial sepsis.

Release of urokinase plasminogen activator receptor during urosepsis and endotoxemia.

BACKGROUND: The urokinase receptor (uPAR; CD87) is a multifunctional molecule involved in fibrinolysis, in proteolysis, in renal tubular functions, and in migration and adhesion of inflammatory cells to the site of infection. METHODS: To gain insight into systemic and local release of uPAR and into its regulation during urosepsis, which is one of the leading causes of chronic renal failure, uPAR was measured in urine and plasma of healthy human controls (N = 20), patients with culture-proven urosepsis (N = 30), and healthy human volunteers intravenously injected with endotoxin (N = 7). RESULTS: Patients had elevated uPAR levels in both plasma and urine. Three hours after endotoxin challenge in volunteers, there was also a significant increase of uPAR in plasma and in urine. The urine/plasma ratio for uPAR was highly elevated during urosepsis and experimental endotoxemia, suggesting local production in the kidney. Accordingly, damaged tubuli strongly expressed uPAR during pyelonephritis. Moreover, tubular epithelial cells produced uPAR in vitro, and this secretion was strongly up-regulated after stimulation with interleukin-1 beta or tumor necrosis factor-alpha. CONCLUSIONS: We found that uPAR is released systemically and in the urinary tract during urosepsis and experimental endotoxemia. This systemic and renal production of uPAR during pyelonephritis may play a central role in eliminating the infection and protecting renal function.

Evaluation of the safety of recombinant P-selectin glycoprotein ligand-immunoglobulin G fusion protein in experimental models of localized and systemic infection.

P-selectin is a major component in the early interaction between platelets, endothelial cells, and inflammatory cells in the initial phases of the innate immune response. The major ligand for P-selectin is P-selectin glycoprotein ligand-1 (PSGL-1) and this ligand is expressed on the surface of monocyte, lymphocyte, and neutrophil membranes. A truncated form of recombinant human P-selectin glycoprotein ligand-1 has been covalently linked to immunoglobulin G (rPSGL-Ig) and this fusion peptide functions as a competitive inhibitor of PSGL-1. As an inhibitor of neutrophil-endothelial cell adherence, rPSGL-Ig is in early clinical development for the treatment of ischemia reperfusion injury. To determine the potential for deleterious effects from inhibition in P-selectin-mediated neutrophil attachment in the presence of bacterial infection, the effects of therapeutic doses of rPSGL-Ig were tested in three standard laboratory sepsis models. The experimental models included: the murine systemic Listeria monocytogenes infection model, the Pseudomonas aeruginosa bacteremia model in neutropenic rats, and the cecal ligation and puncture (CLP)-induced peritonitis model in rats. Recombinant human PSGL-Ig had no adverse effects on mortality or immune clearance in systemic bacterial infection in any of the three infection models. The PSGL-1 inhibitor did significantly decrease local neutrophil infiltration and bacterial clearance in the peritoneum following CLP, but this did not increase the systemic levels of proinflammatory cytokines, the quantitative levels of bacteremia, or the overall mortality rate following CLP. The results indicate that rPSGL-Ig did not exacerbate infection in these experimental sepsis models.

Active immunization with a detoxified Escherichia coli J5 lipopolysaccharide group B meningococcal outer membrane protein complex vaccine protects animals from experimental sepsis.

The passive infusion of antibodies elicited in rabbits with a detoxified J5 lipopolysaccharide (LPS)/group B meningococcal outer membrane protein complex vaccine protected neutropenic rats from heterologous lethal gram-negative bacterial infection. In this study, active immunization was studied in neutropenic rats infected with Pseudomonas aeruginosa, in the presence or absence of ceftazidime therapy, and with Klebsiella pneumoniae. This vaccine elicited a > 200-fold increase in anti-J5 LPS antibody, which remained elevated throughout the duration of cyclophosphamide-induced neutropenia and for < or = 3 months. There was improved survival among immunized versus control animals: 48% (13/28) versus 7% (2/29) in Pseudomonas-challenged rats; 61% (11/18) versus 0% (0/10) in Pseudomonas- and ceftazidime-treated rats; and 64% (9/14) versus 13% (2/15) in Klebsiella-challenged rats (P < 0.01 for each comparison). Immunized animals had lower levels of bacteria in organs and lower levels of circulating endotoxin at the onset of fever. In conclusion, active immunization with an anti-endotoxin vaccine improved survival after infection with > or = 2 heterologous, clinically relevant bacterial species in immunocompromised animals. Active immunization with this vaccine merits further investigation.

The activity of tissue factor pathway inhibitor in experimental models of superantigen-induced shock and polymicrobial intra-abdominal sepsis.

OBJECTIVES: To study recombinant human tissue factor pathway inhibitor (rhTFPI) in a superantigen-induced shock model and in a cecal ligation and puncture (CLP) model of peritonitis in mice. DESIGN: Prospective, randomized, experimental study. SETTING: An experimental animal research laboratory. SUBJECTS: Eighty BALB/c mice for the superantigen model, and 56 BALB/c mice for the CLP model. INTERVENTIONS: In the superantigen-induced shock model, animals received rhTFPI (350 mg/kg) subcutaneously every 12 hrs (n = 30) or saline control (n = 30) for 60 hrs after staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB; 10 microg iv) and a sublethal dose of E. coli 0111:B4 lipopolysaccharide (LPS; 75 microg ip). Control groups received SEB alone (n = 10) and LPS alone (n = 10). In the CLP model, rhTFPI or saline was given every 8 hrs for 48 hrs by using a 21-gauge needle (n = 9) or 23-gauge needle (n = 14) for CLP. A sham surgery control group (n = 10) was also included. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: There was 0% mortality in the SEB and LPS control groups. The mortality rate was 64% in the saline control group that received both SEB and LPS (19 of 30), whereas the rhTFPI- treated animals had a mortality rate of 20% (6 of 30; p < .01). The rhTFPI-treated group had significantly lower interleukin-6 levels (61.8 +/- 41 pg/mL vs. 285 +/- 63 pg/mL; p < .05) than the control group but no differences in tumor necrosis factor-alpha or interferon-gamma levels. In the CLP experiment, rhTFPI-treated animals did not have any survival advantage over the control group after the large-bore (21-gauge) needle puncture. The rhTFPI group had significantly improved 7-day mortality rate after CLP with the small-bore needle (23-gauge; 21.4% [rhTFPI] vs. 71.4% [control], p < .01). Plasma LPS, interleukin-6, interferon-gamma, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha levels were unchanged by rhTFPI treatment, but significantly reduced LPS (p = .006) and IFNgamma (p = .001) levels were found in the peritoneal fluid. CONCLUSIONS: Tissue factor pathway inhibitor significantly improves the mortality rate in models of superantigen-induced shock and polymicrobial intra-abdominal infection, supporting its potential use in clinical trials for septic shock.

Clinical impact of novel anticoagulation strategies in sepsis.

Derangements in coagulation and fibrinolysis are frequent complications of systemic infection, and septic shock is the most common recognized cause of disseminated intravascular coagulation. Anticoagulant therapy has been used as a treatment strategy for severe sepsis for several decades without compelling evidence of efficacy until the 2001 publication of the phase III trial with recombinant human activated protein C. Major phase III international trials with antithrombin and tissue factor pathway inhibitor also have been completed recently. The molecular mechanisms by which the clotting system interacts with the innate immune response have greatly facilitated the understanding of coagulation and the pathophysiology of septic shock. Anticoagulants such as recombinant human activated protein C and related agents may become the mainstay of adjuvant therapies for severe sepsis in the near future.

Chemotactic activity of CXC chemokines interleukin-8, growth-related oncogene-alpha, and epithelial cell-derived neutrophil-activating protein-78 in urine of patients with urosepsis.

CXC chemokines are chemotactic cytokines that specifically act on neutrophils. To obtain insight into the extent of local production of CXC chemokines during acute pyelonephritis, interleukin (IL)-8, growth-related oncogene (GRO)-alpha, and epithelial cell-derived neutrophil-activating protein (ENA)-78 were measured in urine and plasma samples from patients with culture-proven urosepsis (n=33), healthy human control subjects with sterile urine (n=31), and human volunteers intravenously injected with endotoxin (n=11). Patients had profoundly elevated urine concentrations of chemokines with no (GRO-alpha and ENA-78) or little (IL-8) elevation in plasma. Endotoxin-challenged subjects demonstrated transient increases in plasma chemokine concentrations, with no (GRO-alpha) or little (IL-8 and ENA-78) elevation in urine. Urine from patients exerted chemotactic activity toward neutrophils, which was partially inhibited by neutralizing antibodies against IL-8, GRO-alpha, or ENA-78. During urosepsis, CXC chemokines are predominantly produced within the urinary tract, where they are involved in the recruitment of neutrophils to the urinary compartment.

What are the microbial components implicated in the pathogenesis of sepsis? Report on a symposium.

Despite considerable efforts in the past quarter century to improve therapy for sepsis, mortality rates remain unacceptably high. Microbe-derived constituents can induce the host to produce many mediators that can contribute to immune dysregulation, tissue damage, and death. Although endotoxin-mediated events are clearly important in gram-negative infections, gram-positive bacteria can also play a dominant role. Understanding the interplay of microbial constituents and host immune or inflammatory responses prompted a meeting at Rockefeller University in May 1998. Participants discussed the relative merits of a "2-hit" hypothesis to explain the course of lethal septic shock and a "multihit" synergistic threshold hypothesis. Recommendations include the following: (1) developing animal models that closely mimic human sepsis; (2) further investigating antibiotic effects on bacteria; (3) assessing the relationships between endotoxin, prokaryotic DNA, and peptidoglycan (i.e., independent, additive, or synergistic) in inducing host responses; and (4) developing new strategies to improve outcomes. Studies are needed to better define which and how different microbial constituents lead to sepsis and to provide critical leads for therapeutic intervention.

Therapeutic rationale for antithrombin III in sepsis.

OBJECTIVE: To review the preclinical evidence that provides the therapeutic rationale for antithrombin as a novel treatment for human sepsis. DATA SOURCES: A summary of published medical literature from MEDLINE search files and other reviews published about antithrombin use in sepsis. DATA SUMMARY: Antithrombin has a variety of antiinflammatory properties in addition to its functions as an endogenous anticoagulant that appear to have an important therapeutic role in the prevention of microvascular dysfunction and multiple organ injury in sepsis. Appropriate timing and dosing of antithrombin III is critical to realize its full therapeutic potential as an anti-sepsis therapy. CONCLUSIONS: Antithrombin is a potent inhibitor of thrombin-mediated vascular injury in the microcirculation in severe sepsis. This endogenous anticoagulant is rapidly depleted in the early phases of sepsis as a result of decreased synthesis, increased destruction, and enhanced clearance by thrombin-antithrombin complex formation. The therapeutic efficacy of antithrombin in experimental sepsis is readily demonstrable in numerous animal systems. Appropriately defined patient populations with early onset severe sepsis and/or septic shock may benefit from antithrombin therapy if it is administered in adequate doses at the optimal time interval.

Phylogenetic and functional relationships between coagulation and the innate immune response.

Activation of the coagulation system frequently accompanies systemic inflammatory states and is an almost invariable consequence of septic shock. The simultaneous activation of the innate immune response and the coagulation system after injury is a phylogenetically ancient, adaptive response that can be traced back to the early stages of eukaryotic evolution. Most invertebrate species lack differentiated phagocytic cells and platelets. They possess a common cellular and humoral pathway of inflammation and clotting after a breach in their internal milieu by either trauma or infection. The close linkage between clotting and inflammation has been preserved throughout vertebrate evolution and is readily demonstrable in human physiologic responses to a variety of potentially injurious stimuli. The same proinflammatory stimuli that activate the human clotting cascade also activate the phagocytic effector cells (neutrophils, monocytes, and macrophages). The complex and highly integrated linkage between systemic inflammation and coagulation are reviewed in this article.

Anti-inflammatory cytokines.

The anti-inflammatory cytokines are a series of immunoregulatory molecules that control the proinflammatory cytokine response. Cytokines act in concert with specific cytokine inhibitors and soluble cytokine receptors to regulate the human immune response. Their physiologic role in inflammation and pathologic role in systemic inflammatory states are increasingly recognized. Major anti-inflammatory cytokines include interleukin (IL)-1 receptor antagonist, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, IL-11, and IL-13. Specific cytokine receptors for IL-1, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, and IL-18 also function as proinflammatory cytokine inhibitors. The nature of anti-inflammatory cytokines and soluble cytokine receptors is the focus of this review. The current and future therapeutic uses of these anti-inflammatory cytokines are also reviewed.

Differential antibiotic-induced endotoxin release in severe melioidosis.

Severe melioidosis is a life-threatening, systemic bacterial infection caused by Burkholderia pseudomallei. A prospective, randomized treatment trial was conducted in northeast Thailand to compare ceftazidime (a penicillin-binding protein [PBP]-3-specific agent that causes release of large amounts of endotoxin in vitro) and imipenem (a PBP-2-specific agent that kills B. pseudomallei more rapidly but releases low amounts of endotoxin) in severe melioidosis over a 6-h time course after the first dose of antibiotic. Despite similar clinical, microbiological, endotoxin, and cytokine measures at study entry, ceftazidime-treated patients (n=34) had significantly greater systemic endotoxin (P<.001) than patients treated with imipenem (n=34) after the first dose of antibiotic. No overall difference in mortality was observed (35% in both groups [95% confidence interval, 20%-50%]). Differential antibiotic-induced endotoxin release is demonstrable in severe melioidosis. These differences in endotoxin release did not appear to have a significant impact on survival in this group of patients.

Consensus conference definitions for sepsis, septic shock, acute lung injury, and acute respiratory distress syndrome: time for a reevaluation.

Definitions for sepsis, septic shock, acute lung injury (ALI), and acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) were developed by consensus conferences with the goal of achieving standardization of terminology and improved homogeneity of patient populations in clinical studies. Although such definitions have been useful in epidemiologic investigations, the criteria specified by the consensus conferences are broad and insufficiently specific to address the problem of heterogeneous mechanisms leading to clinical syndromes. An important challenge is to progress from clinical syndromes, as presently defined, to more specific entities that are delineated by alterations in specific immunologic or biochemical pathways. Such mechanistic definitions will provide more homogeneous groups of patients who can be identified at early stages of their clinical course. This approach encourages focused investigation of pathways leading to organ system dysfunction and death and, also, provides an efficient framework for the development of new therapies useful in critically ill patients.

Recombinant human interleukin-11 has anti-inflammatory actions yet does not exacerbate systemic Listeria infection.

To determine whether recombinant human (rh) interleukin (IL)-11 disrupts the clearance of microbial pathogens, mice were challenged with Listeria monocytogenes after receiving high-dose rhIL-11, anti-tumor necrosis factor (TNF) monoclonal antibody (MAb), anti-IL-11 MAb, or saline control. The LD50 was not affected by rhIL-11 but was 10-fold lower in the anti-TNF MAb group (P<.001). Plasma IL-6, IL-1beta, and TNF-alpha levels were not different between rhIL-11-treated animals and the control group; however, interferon-gamma levels were significantly reduced by IL-11 treatment (2477 vs. 0 pg/mL, P<.01). Compared with the control group, the quantitative level of L. monocytogenes in hepatic and splenic tissue was unchanged by rhIL-11 but was significantly increased by TNF or IL-11 inhibition. The results indicate that IL-11 down-regulates cytokine production but does not exacerbate systemic infection in the murine Listeria infection model.