The Outliers: Metal-Mediated Radical Reagents for Biological Substrate Degradation.

The predictable and controllable interaction of small organic or peptidic molecules with biological substrates is the primary reason most pharmaceuticals are narrowly decorated carbon frameworks. The inhibition or activation binding models are measurable and without side reactions that can cause pathological angst. Yet many diseases, especially those involving rapid proliferation of cells (i.e., cancer) or aggregation of peptides (e.g., heart disease, Alzheimer's disease) have not yet been cured by inhibition therapeutics. Additionally, interventional medicine is often required to alleviate such maladies by physical removal first, followed by molecular-level therapy as a second stage. Thus, there appears to be a niche for more aggressive therapeutics that may employ harsher chemical processes to realize clinical efficacy, albeit without causing catastrophic side effects. Molecules that may be considered for this challenge are not typically biomimetic, nor do they fit the traditional pharmaceutical paradigm. They may have unusual modes of action or undesired reactivity that can be lethal if not controlled. These are the outliers; potential pharmacophores that biology does not know how to manage or adapt to. This is why they may be an intriguing class of agents that needs continuous development. In this Account, we connect the under-developed enediyne family of compounds and our metalloenediyne derivatives to existing radical-based therapeutics such as bleomycin and doxorubicin to illustrate that controlled diradical reactivity, although an outlier mechanism, has a place in the therapeutic portfolio. This is self-evident in that of the 11 natural product enediynes known, 2 have clinical impact, a strong ratio. We expand on the chemical diversity of potential enediyne constructs and focus on the accessible trigger mechanisms to activate diradical formation as a method to control toxicity. Moreover, we further illustrate how electromagnetic fields can be employed to activate both molecular and larger nanomaterial constructs that carry highly concentrated payloads of reactive reagent. Finally, we describe how controlled diradical reactivity can reach beyond traditional therapeutic targets such as DNA, to peptide aggregates found in blood clots, neural fibrils, and membrane scaffolds. It is our belief that cleverly constructed frameworks with well-designed and controlled activation/reaction schemes can lead to novel therapeutics that can challenge evolving viral and bacterial invaders. From this evangelical perspective, our hope is that the conceptual framework, if not the specific designs in this Account, stimulate the readership to develop out-of-the-box therapeutic designs that may combat resistant disease targets.

Metal-mediated diradical tuning for DNA replication arrest via template strand scission.

A series of M(PyED)·X (X = 2Cl-, SO42-) pyridine-metalloenediyne complexes [M = Cu(II), Fe(II), or Zn(II)] and their independently synthesized, cyclized analogs have been prepared to investigate their potential as radical-generating DNA-damaging agents. All complexes possess a 1:1 metal-to-ligand stoichiometry as determined by electronic absorption spectroscopy and X-ray diffraction. Solution structural analysis reveals a pπ Cl [Formula: see text] Cu(II) LMCT (22,026 cm-1) for Cu(PyED)·2Cl, indicating three nitrogens and a chloride in the psuedo-equatorial plane with the remaining pyridine nitrogen and solvent in axial positions. EPR spectra of the Cu(II) complexes exhibit an axially elongated octahedron. This spectroscopic evidence, together with density functional theory computed geometries, suggest six-coordinate structures for Cu(II) and Fe(II) complexes and a five-coordinate environment for Zn(II) analogs. Bergman cyclization via thermal activation of these constructs yields benzannulated product indicative of diradical generation in all complexes within 3 h at 37 °C. A significant metal dependence on the rate of the reaction is observed [Cu(II) > Fe(II) > Zn(II)], which is mirrored in in vitro DNA-damaging outcomes. Whereas in situ chelation of PyED leads to considerable degradation in the presence of all metals within 1 h under hyperthermia conditions, Cu(II) activation produces >50% compromised DNA within 5 min. Additionally, Cu(II) chelated PyED outcompetes DNA polymerase I to successfully inhibit template strand extension. Exposure of HeLa cells to Cu(PyBD)·SO4 (IC50 = 10 µM) results in a G2/M arrest compared with untreated samples, indicating significant DNA damage. These results demonstrate metal-controlled radical generation for degradation of biopolymers under physiologically relevant temperatures on short timescales.

The role of ligand covalency in the selective activation of metalloenediynes for Bergman cyclization.

One of the key concerns with the development of radical-generating reactive therapeutics is the ability to control the activation event within a biological environment. To that end, a series of quinoline-metal-loenediynes of the form M(QuiED)·2Cl (M = Cu(II), Fe(II), Mg(II), or Zn(II)) and their independently synthesized cyclized analogs have been prepared in an effort to elucidate Bergman cyclization (BC) reactivity differences in solution. HRMS(ESI) establishes a solution stoichiometry of 1:1 metal to ligand with coordination of one chloride counter ion to the metal center. EPR spectroscopy of Cu(QuiED)·2Cl and Cu (QuiBD)·2Cl denotes an axially-elongated tetragonal octahedron (g║ > g⊥ > 2.0023) with a dx2-y2 ground state, while the electronic absorption spectrum reveals a pπ Cl→Cu(II) LMCT feature at 19,000 cm -1, indicating a solution structure with three nitrogens and a chloride in the equatorial plane with the remaining quinoline nitrogen and solvent in the axial positions. Investigations into the BC activity reveal formation of the cyclized product from the Cu(II) and Fe(II) complexes after 12 h at 45 °C in solution, while no product is observed for the Mg(II) or Zn(II) complexes under identical conditions. The basis of this reactivity difference has been found to be a steric effect leading to metal-ligand bond elongation and thus, a retardation of solution reactivity. These results demonstrate how careful consideration of ligand and complex structure may allow for a degree of control and selective activation of these reactive agents.

Chelation-induced diradical formation as an approach to modulation of the amyloid-ß aggregation pathway.

Current approaches toward modulation of metal-induced Aß aggregation pathways involve the development of small molecules that bind metal ions, such as Cu(ii) and Zn(ii), and interact with Aß. For this effort, we present the enediyne-containing ligand (Z)-N,N'-bis[1-pyridin-2-yl-meth(E)-ylidene]oct-4-ene-2,6-diyne-1,8-diamine (PyED), which upon chelation of Cu(ii) and Zn(ii) undergoes Bergman-cyclization to yield diradical formation. The ability of this chelation-triggered diradical to modulate Aß aggregation is evaluated relative to the non-radical generating control pyridine-2-ylmethyl-(2-{[(pyridine-2-ylmethylene)-amino]-methyl}-benzyl)-amine (PyBD). Variable-pH, ligand UV-vis titrations reveal pKa = 3.81(2) for PyBD, indicating it exists mainly in the neutral form at experimental pH. Lipinski's rule parameters and evaluation of blood-brain barrier (BBB) penetration potential by the PAMPA-BBB assay suggest that PyED may be CNS+ and penetrate the BBB. Both PyED and PyBD bind Zn(ii) and Cu(ii) as illustrated by bathochromic shifts of their UV-vis features. Speciation diagrams indicate that Cu(ii)-PyBD is the major species at pH 6.6 with a nanomolar Kd, suggesting the ligand may be capable of interacting with Cu(ii)-Aß species. In the presence of Aß40/42 under hyperthermic conditions (43 °C), the radical-generating PyED demonstrates markedly enhanced activity (2-24 h) toward the modulation of Aß species as determined by gel electrophoresis. Correspondingly, transmission electron microscopy images of these samples show distinct morphological changes to the fibril structure that are most prominent for Cu(ii)-Aß cases. The loss of CO2 from the metal binding region of Aß in MALDI-TOF mass spectra further suggests that metal-ligand-Aß interaction with subsequent radical formation may play a role in the aggregation pathway modulation.

P-H activation using alkynylgold substrates: steric and electronic effects.

The susceptibility of a prototypical hydrogen phosphonate to undergo P-H activation upon treatment with alkynylgold complexes has been studied. Dynamic solution behavior was observed during reactions involving triphenylphosphine ligated substrates and was attributed to rapid phosphine exchange between the alkynylgold starting material and the gold phosphonate product. The use of bulky biaryldialkylphosphine ligands eliminated the fluxional behavior, but did not significantly slow the rate of P-H activation. Similarly, changing the supporting ligand to an N-heterocyclic carbene did not significantly slow the rate of the reaction. Despite a number of reports outlining the functionalization of propargyl alcohols using gold catalysts, incorporating these groups into the architecture of the alkynylgold substrates did not alter the product distributions. Although the chemistry tolerated a range of supporting ligands, incorporating electron donating groups into the alkyne increased the rate of the reaction while electron-withdrawing groups slowed the reaction. A possible mechanism for the process includes a transition state containing significant pi-contribution from the alkyne. Due to the high yields of gold phosphonates obtained in this chemistry as well as the mild conditions of the reactions, the interception of intermediates/catalysts by substrates or ligands containing labile P-H donors is an issue that must be circumvented when designing or developing a gold catalyzed reaction that proceeds through alkynylgold intermediates.