Renewal of conditioned fear in male and female rats.

Pavlovian extinction reduces the performance of conditioned responses and occurs when the conditioned stimulus (CS) is repeatedly presented in the absence of the unconditioned stimulus (US). However, when the CS is experienced in a context that is different from the extinction context, there is a recovery of the conditioned response, a phenomenon known as renewal. There is some evidence that the renewal of appetitive conditioning is influenced by sex, with females failing to exhibit renewed responding. Further, there is recent evidence that renewal of fear might also not occur in female rats. In both appetitive and fear preparations, the lack of renewal in females has been postulated to be related to cycling ovarian hormones. Therefore, in Experiments 1 and 2, we directly compared fear renewal in males and females (Experiment 1) as well as ovariectomized (OVX) females (Experiment 2) when conditioning occurred in Context A, extinction in B, and testing in A (ABA renewal). Experiments 3 and 4 examined renewal when conditioning and extinction occurred in A and testing occurred in B (AAB renewal). In all experiments, renewal was not significantly different between male and female rats. Further, in Experiments 2 and 4, renewal did not differ between males, intact females, and OVX females. Additionally, in each experiment, there was no evidence that context excitation and/or inhibition contributed to renewal; instead suggesting that renewal was controlled by an occasion-setting mechanism. Overall, these results suggest little evidence for the role of sex in renewal of conditioned freezing and also indicate that cycling ovarian hormones have little role in the strength of renewal in female rats. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).

Effects of sex and retention interval on the retrieval and extinction of auditory fear conditioning.

Fear memory retrieval is relevant to psychiatric disorders such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). One of the hallmark symptoms of PTSD is the repeated retrieval and re-experiencing of the initial fear memory even long after the traumatic event has occurred. Women are nearly twice as likely to develop PTSD following a trauma than men, thus sex differences in the retrieval of fear memories is highly relevant for understanding the development and maintenance of PTSD. In the current study, we aimed to examine sex differences in the retrieval and extinction of either recent or remote fear memories. To do so, we conditioned male and female rats either 1 day (recent) or 28 days (remote) prior to testing retrieval and extinction. While there was no effect of sex or retention interval on initial retrieval, we found that remotely conditioned females exhibited higher rates of freezing than remotely conditioned males in later retrieval/extinction sessions, suggesting a sex difference in the retrieval and/or extinction of remote, but not recent, fear memories. Overall, these results are the first to demonstrate a sex difference in the extinction of remote fear memory, and this may contribute to the differential expression of fear-related disorders like PTSD in men and women.

Cyclic estrogen and progesterone during instrumental acquisition contributes to habit formation in female rats.

Habit formation is thought to involve two parallel processes that are mediated by distinct neural substates: one that suppresses goal-directed behavior, and one that facilitates stimulus-response (S-R) learning, which underscores habitual behavior. In previous studies we showed that habitual responding emerges early during instrumental training in gonadally-intact female, compared to male, rats. The present study aimed to determine the role of ovarian hormones during instrumental acquisition in the transition from goal-directed to habitual behavior in female rats. Ovariectomized (OVX) female rats were given subcutaneous silastic capsules that released low levels of 17-ß estradiol (E2) to maintain estrogen receptor availability. Rats were assigned to one of three hormone treatment conditions: no additional hormone replacement (Control group), replacement with high E2 (High E2 group), or replacement with high E2 followed by progesterone (High E2 + P4 group). Hormone replacement occurred twice during acquisition to mimic natural hormone fluctuations. At test, the Control and High E2 groups demonstrated responding that was sensitive to devaluation by lithium chloride-induced illness, indicating goal-directed behavior. In contrast, the High E2 + P4 group exhibited a pattern of devaluation-insensitive, habitual responding, that suggested the suppression of goal-directed processes. In a follow-up experiment, similar procedures were conducted, however during acquisition, OVX rats were given cyclic high E2 plus medroxy-progesterone (MPA), a form of progesterone that does not metabolize to neuroactive metabolites. In this group, goal-directed behavior was observed. These data indicate that habit formation is not facilitated in low estrogen states, nor in the presence of cyclic high E2. However, cyclic high E2, together with progesterone during acquisition, appears to facilitate the early emergence of habitual responding. Furthermore, these data suggest that a neuroactive progesterone metabolite, like allopregnanolone, in combination with high cyclic E2, supports this phenomenon.

Dopamine sensitization by methamphetamine treatment prior to instrumental training delays the transition into habit in female rats.

Early in instrumental learning, behavior is goal-directed and sensitive to changes in the value of the instrumental outcome. With sufficient repetition, responding becomes insensitive to changes in outcome value, or habitual. We have previously found that females transition into habit over a distinct range of training from 120 to 160 reinforced responses. This low level of instrumental training is markedly less than what has been shown to support habitual responding in male rats. To begin to investigate the early development of habit in females, we conducted a series of experiments in which we pretreated female rats with methamphetamine (METH) with the aim of sensitizing central dopamine, a major modulator of striatal function, prior to instrumental nose-poke training at the beginning and at the endpoint of the transition range in females. Following training, we tested for sensitivity to reinforcer devaluation (RD), which was conducted by repeatedly pairing reinforcers previously earned during training with lithium chloride (LiCl)-induced illness. As a counterpoint, a series of similar experiments was conducted separately in male rats. Additionally, in order to ascertain the validity of using nose-poke as an instrumental response, we compared sensitivity to devaluation between the Pavlovian approach towards the food magazine and the nose-poke response. In females, Vehicle groups responded in a habitual manner at both training levels (120 and 160 reinforced responses), whereas METH groups remained sensitive to devaluation. This suggests that increasing central dopamine delays habit formation in female rats. In male rats, Vehicle groups demonstrated goal-directed responding following training with 120 and 320 reinforced responses, and marginally goal-directed responding,with 160. METH-pretreated males were sensitive to devaluation at the 120 and 160 training levels, however, following more extended training to 320 reinforced responses, METH-pretreated males responded in a habitual manner, indicating that increasing central dopamine can advance habit formation in male rats. Overall, these results suggest that METH pretreatment maintains goal-directed responding in female rats when they are typically transitioning to habitual control of instrumental behavior and can advance habit formation in male rats given sufficient instrumental training. In addition, we found differential RD sensitivity of the nose-poke response used during instrumental training compared to Pavlovian approach towards the food magazine, confirming that there is a distinction between these two behaviors and that nose-poking is a valid instrumental response.

Female rats express habitual behavior earlier in operant training than males.

Habitual behavior can be advantageous by increasing the availability of cognitive resources for use in other tasks. However, habitual behaviors are problematic when they are coopted to prolong the maladaptive responding present in several psychopathologies such as substance abuse, dysregulated fear responding in posttraumatic stress disorder, and obsessive-compulsive disorder. Although sex differences exist in the occurrence or progression of these psychopathologies, there are no studies that compare the development of habitual behavior systematically in male and female animals. In the present study, male and female rats were identically trained on a variable interval 30-s (VI 30-s) schedule of reinforcement to nose-poke for sucrose pellet reinforcers. Subsequently, the sucrose was devalued in one half of the animals by pairing its presentation with injections of lithium chloride (LiCl) to induce nausea, thus conditioning a taste aversion. Habitual behavior was operationalized as continued operant responding in an extinction test following devaluation of the sucrose reinforcer. Successful devaluation was confirmed with both a consumption and reacquisition test. Given identical training to 240 sucrose pellets, female rats demonstrate habitual behavior whereas male rats remain goal-directed. Additionally, females are habitual after 200 or 160 reinforcers earned on a VI 30-s schedule, but remain goal-directed at 120 and 80 reinforcers on this schedule. These data suggest that behavioral flexibility may be compromised in female rats compared to males due to accelerated habit formation in females. These results are important because sex differences are present in several psychopathologies, which may be related to differences in the development of habitual behavior. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2019 APA, all rights reserved).