Hydrochar and hydrochar co-compost from OFMSW digestate for soil application: 3. Toxicological evaluation.

Modern societies produce ever-increasing amounts of waste, e.g. organic fraction of municipal solid waste (OFMSW). According to the best available techniques, OFMSW should be treated through anaerobic digestion to recover biogas and subsequently composted. An innovative scheme is under investigation, where anaerobic digestion is combined with hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) and composting. The final product, referred to as hydrochar co-compost (HCO), is under study to be used as an unconventional soil improver/fertilizer. Recent studies showed that HCO is not phytotoxic. However, nothing is known about the toxicity of HCO on cells as part and organisms as a whole. This study aims to investigate in vitro genotoxicity and cytotoxicity of the HCO and its precursors in the production process. In particular, we tested water and methanolic extracts of HCO (WEHCO and MEHCO) from one side and methanolic extracts of hydrochar (MEH) and OFMSW digestate (MED) as well as liquor produced downstream HTC (HTCL) from the other side. Genotoxicity was investigated using cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay in Chinese Hamster Ovarian K1 (CHO-K1) cells. Cytotoxicity was tested in vitro against a panel of human cells line. Zebrafish embryo toxicity upon MEH treatment was also investigated. Results show that incubation of CHO-K1 cells with all the tested samples at different concentrations did not cause any induction of micronucleus formation compared to the vehicle-treated control. Treatment of cells with MEH, MED, HTCL and MEHCO, but not WEHCO, induced some degree of cytotoxicity and MEH showed to be more cytotoxic against tested cells compared to the MEHCO. Toxicity effect at the highest tested concentrations of MEH on zebrafish embryos resulted in coagulation, induction of pericardial edema and death. In conclusion, the hydrochar co-compost cytotoxicity is similar to standard compost cytotoxicity. Hence composting the hydrochar from OFMSW digestate is a good step to eliminate the cytotoxicity of hydrochar.

Hydrochar and hydrochar co-compost from OFMSW digestate for soil application: 2. agro-environmental properties.

The work concerns the study of the hydrochar from digestate and hydrochar co-compost characterization as amendments. The processes for hydrochar and co-compost production were described in Part 1 of this work (Scrinzi et al., 2022). The amendment properties of hydrochar (produced at 180-200-220 °C for 3 h) and co-composts (25%, 50%, and 75% hydrochar percentage of digestate substitution) were assessed by phytotoxicity, plant growth bioassay, and soil effect. Different seeds species (Lepidium sativum, Cucumis sativus, and Sorghum bicolor sp.) were dosed at increased concentrations using both wet raw amendments and their water extracts. The chemical characterization showed phytotoxic compounds content depending on both the initial feedstock (digestate) and the HTC process; at the same time, the analysis highlighted the reduction of these compounds by composting (organic acid, polyphenols, salt concentration). The dose-response was analyzed by the Cedergreen-Streibig-Ritz model and the half-maximal effective concentration (EC50) was calculated based on this equation. The soil properties and GHG emissions measurements (CH4, CO2, N2O, and NH3) highlighted the effect on N dynamics and on soil respiration induced by substrates. The HC200 soil application determined a significant impact on CO2 and N2O emission and NH3 volatilization (10.82 mol CO2/m2; 51.45 mmol N2O/m2; 112 mol NH3/m2) and a significant reduction of total N and TOC (46% of TKN and 49% of TOC). The co-compost (75%) showed specific effects after soil application compared to other samples an increase of available P (48%), a greater content of nitrogen (1626 mg/kg dry basis), and a reduction of organic carbon (17%). Our results demonstrate the good quality of co-compost and at the same time the validity of this post-treatment for addressing many issues related to hydrochar use in the soil as an amendment, confirming the suitability of HTC process integration for digestate treatment in anaerobic digestion plants.

Hydrochar and hydrochar co-compost from OFMSW digestate for soil application: 1. production and chemical characterization.

The best available technique (BAT) for managing the organic fraction of municipal solid waste (OFMSW) is represented by anaerobic digestion (AD) and subsequent composting. This research explored a new industrial model in the framework of the C2Land international project, with the insertion of hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) as a post-treatment for OFMSW digestate. The reaction was set for 3 h at three different temperatures (180 ÷ 220 °C); the wet solid hydrochar obtained after filtration was then co-composted with greenery waste as a bulking agent and untreated OFMSW digestate in four different proportions in bench-scale bioreactors. The hydrochars and the hydrochar co-composts were suitable for agro-industrial applications, while the HTC liquors were tested in biochemical methane potential (BMP) for internal recirculation to AD. The scenarios proposed can be beneficial for plant enhancement and increased biogas production. This study reports results connected to the production phase. Mass balances confirmed that, during HTC, phosphorus precipitated into the solid products, organic nitrogen partially mineralized into ammonium, and oxidizable organic matter solubilized. The selected hydrochar obtained at 200 °C had mean (dry) solid, liquid, and gaseous yields equal to 77, 20, and 3 %db, respectively. The dynamic respirometric index (DRI) confirmed that the reproduced BAT for the composting process was effective in producing high-quality hydrochar co-composts in terms of biological stability. The BMP tests on HTC liquors showed some inhibitory effects, suggesting the need for future studies with inoculum adaptation and co-digestion, to dilute toxic compounds and enhance biogas production. Part 2 of this study describes the agro-environmental properties of hydrochars and hydrochar co-composts, including the beneficial effect of composting on hydrochars phytotoxicity.