Clinical added value of drugs: An empirical survey of French transparency committee opinions.

OBJECTIVES: To identify criteria used by French health authorities to assess the clinical added value (ASMR) of drugs seeking reimbursement. METHODS: We conducted a systematic review of the opinions of the transparency committee (TC) of the French national authority for health (HAS) between March, 2014 and October, 2016 in ten therapeutic areas. TC opinions content was coded and analysed using descriptive statistics and logistic models. RESULTS: The database comprised 160 opinion texts, which included ASMR assessments using a 5 level scale (1=highest ASMR 5=no ASMR). Main elements that were linked with ASMR 1,2,3,4 as compared to ASMR 5 were appraisal of the medical need, population size (<5000 patients), and clinical relevance of the evaluated results. The factors associated with ASMR 4 as compared to ASMR 1-3 were the safety profile and clinical relevance of the results. However, the factors associated with ASMR level varied according to the therapeutic area considered. CONCLUSIONS: The assessment of the drug ASMR conducted by the French transparency commission of the HAS appears to be at least in part determined by criteria (medical need, population size) which reflect the burden of the disease but not reflect the ASMR of the medicine assessed. Other criteria used for the assessment of ASMR are not clearly defined and depend on the therapeutic domain. The lack of sufficient clarity and consistency in assessment of ASMR complicate the decision making process for drug development. Moreover, this situation can be a barrier for a harmonized process of ASMR assessment at European level.

Economic burden of thromboembolic and hemorrhagic complications in non-valvular atrial fibrillation in Algeria (the ELRAGFA study).

BACKGROUND: Atrial fibrillation (AF) is the most common cardiac arrhythmia, with substantial public health and economic impact on healthcare systems due to the prevention and management of thromboembolic and hemorrhagic complications. In Algeria, stroke is a leading cause of death, representing 15.6% of all deaths in 2012. Current data on the epidemiology and costs associated with non-valvular AF (NVAF) in Algeria are not available. METHODS: A three-step approach was undertaken to estimate the economic burden of NVAF in Algeria. First, a literature review identified the epidemiological burden of the disease. Second, expert clinicians practicing in Algerian hospitals were surveyed on consumed resources and unit costs of treatment and management of complications and prevention. Finally, these data were combined with event probabilities in an economic model to estimate the annual cost of NVAF prevention and complications for the Algerian healthcare system. RESULTS: Based on literature and demographics data, it was estimated that there are currently 187,686 subjects with NVAF in Algeria. Seventy per cent of this population was treated for prevention, half of which were controlled. Cost of prevention was estimated at 203 million DZD (€1.5 million) for drugs and 349 million DZD (€2.6 million) for examinations. Mean hospitalization costs for complications ranged between 123,500 and 435,500 DZD (€910-3,209), according to the type and severity of complications. Hospitalization costs for thromboembolic and hemorrhagic complications were estimated at 8,313 million DZD (€62 million), half of which was for untreated patients. Finally, the economic burden of NVAF was estimated at 8,865 million DZD (>€65 million) annually. CONCLUSION: The economic burden of NVAF is important in Algeria, largely driven by untreated and INR-uncontrolled patients. There is a lack of information on the Algerian healthcare system that could increase uncertainty around this assessment, but it clearly establishes the importance of NVAF as a public health concern.

Economic impact of ulipristal acetate on surgical procedures for uterine fibroids in France.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the budget impact of using ulipristal acetate (UPA) 5 mg to treat women with uterine fibroids (UF) causing moderate to severe symptoms. DESIGN: We modelled trends in the number of surgical procedures for symptomatic UF, with and without the use of UPA for preoperative or intermittent treatment and assessed the budget impact of UPA use from the French national healthcare insurance system perspective. SETTING: A French national hospital database (PMSI) that records admissions and relative procedures to public and private hospitals. PARTICIPANTS: Women eligible for surgical procedures for uterine fibroids. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Economic impact of UPA treatment. RESULTS: This study based on observational retrospective data shows that the current use of UPA in its preoperative indication was associated with 5645 fewer surgeries from 2013 to 2015. Extrapolation suggests 17 885 fewer surgeries from 2016 to 2019. Overall, preoperative use of UPA results in substantial cost savings for the French national healthcare insurance system, with a cumulated budget impact estimated at €-5 million from 2013 to 2015 and €-13.5 million from 2016 to 2019. In addition, treating women nearing the menopause (≥48 years old) with intermittent treatment from 2017 to 2019 could produce an incremental cost saving of €19 million. CONCLUSIONS: This study shows that the use of UPA in women eligible for surgical procedures for UF is associated with considerable savings for the French national healthcare insurance system in both preoperative and intermittent indications by decreasing the need to perform surgeries.