Elevated ammonia cues hatching in red-eyed treefrogs: A mechanism for escape from drying eggs.

Egg dehydration can kill terrestrial frog embryos, and this threat is increasing with climate change and deforestation. In several lineages that independently evolved terrestrial eggs, and retained aquatic tadpoles, embryos accelerate hatching to escape from drying eggs, entering the water earlier and less developed. However, the cues that stimulate drying-induced early hatching are unknown. Ammonia is a toxic, water-soluble metabolic waste that accumulates within eggs as embryos develop and concentrates as eggs dehydrate. Thus, increasing ammonia concentration may be a direct threat to embryos in drying eggs. We hypothesized that it could serve as a cue, stimulating embryos to hatch and escape. The embryos of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, hatch early to escape from many threats, including dehydration, and are known to use mechanosensory, hypoxia, and light cues. To test if they also use high ammonia as a cue to hatch, we exposed stage-matched pairs of hatching-competent, well-hydrated sibling embryos to ammonia and control solutions in shallow water baths and recorded their behavior. Control embryos remained unhatched while ammonia-exposed embryos showed a rapid, strong hatching response; 95% hatched, on average in under 15 min. This demonstrates that elevated ammonia can serve as a hatching cue for A. callidryas embryos. This finding is a key step in understanding the mechanisms that enable terrestrial frog embryos to escape from egg drying, opening new possibilities for integrative and comparative studies on this growing threat.

Early onset of urea synthesis and ammonia detoxification pathways in three terrestrially developing frogs.

Frogs evolved terrestrial development multiple times, necessitating mechanisms to avoid ammonia toxicity at early stages. Urea synthesis from ammonia is a key adaptation that reduces water dependence after metamorphosis. We tested for early expression and plasticity of enzymatic mechanisms of ammonia detoxification in three terrestrial-breeding frogs: foam-nest-dwelling larvae of Leptodactylus fragilis (Lf) and arboreal embryos of Hyalinobatrachium fleischmanni (Hf) and Agalychnis callidryas (Ac). Activity of two ornithine-urea cycle (OUC) enzymes, arginase and CPSase, and levels of their products urea and CP in tissues were high in Lf regardless of nest hydration, but reduced in experimental low- vs. high-ammonia environments. High OUC activity in wet and dry nests, comparable to that under experimental high ammonia, suggests terrestrial Lf larvae maintain high capacity for urea excretion regardless of their immediate risk of ammonia toxicity. This may aid survival through unpredictably long waiting periods before rain enables their transition to water. Moderate levels of urea and CP were present in Hf and Ac tissues and enzymatic activities were lower than in Lf. In both species, embryos in drying clutches can hatch and enter the water early, behaviorally avoiding ammonia toxicity. Moreover, glutamine synthetase was active in early stages of all three species, condensing ammonia and glutamate to glutamine as another mechanism of detoxification. Enzyme activity appeared highest in Lf, although substrate and product levels were higher in Ac and Lf. Our results reveal that multiple biochemical mechanisms of ammonia detoxification occur in early life stages of anuran lineages that evolved terrestrial development.

Ontogeny of risk assessment and escape-hatching performance by red-eyed treefrog embryos in two threat contexts.

Arboreal embryos of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, hatch prematurely in response to hypoxia when flooded and to mechanosensory cues in snake attacks, but hatching later improves tadpole survival. We studied ontogenetic changes in risk assessment and hatching performance of embryos in response to flooding and physical disturbance. We hypothesized that risk assessment decreases as hatchling survival improves and hatching performance increases as embryos develop. Because snakes eat faster than embryos asphyxiate, we hypothesized that embryos decide to hatch sooner and hatch faster in response to mechanosensory cues. We video-recorded individual embryos hatching in response to each cue type, then compared the incidence and timing of a series of events and behaviors from cue onset to complete hatching across ages and stimuli. Latency from cue to hatching decreased developmentally in both contexts and was shorter with mechanosensory cues, but the elements contributing to those changes differed. Hypoxia assessment involved position changes, which decreased developmentally along with assessment time. Mechanosensory cue assessment occurred more rapidly, without movement, and decreased with age. The first stages of hatching, membrane rupture and head emergence, were surprisingly age independent but faster with mechanosensory cues, congruent with greater effort under more immediate risk. In contrast, body emergence and compression showed ontogenetic improvement consistent with morphological constraints but no cue effect. Both appropriate timing and effective performance of hatching are necessary for continued development. Different stages of the process vary with development and environmental context, suggesting combinations of adaptive context- and stage-dependent behavior, cue-related constraints on information acquisition, and ontogenetic constraints on elements of performance.

Heat-Induced Hatching of Red-Eyed Treefrog Embryos: Hydration and Clutch Structure Increase Behavioral Thermal Tolerance.

Climate change is increasing both environmental temperatures and droughts. Many ectotherms respond behaviorally to heat, thereby avoiding damage from extreme temperatures. Within species, thermal tolerance varies with factors such as hydration as well as ontogenetic stage. Many tropical anurans lay terrestrial eggs, relying on environmental moisture for embryonic development. These eggs are vulnerable to dehydration, and embryos of some species can hatch prematurely to escape from drying eggs. Warmer temperatures can accelerate development and thus hatching, but excess heat can kill embryos. Thus, we hypothesize that embryos may show a behavioral thermal tolerance limit, hatching prematurely to avoid potentially lethal warming. If so, because warming and drying are often associated, we hypothesize this limit, measurable as a voluntary thermal maximum, may depend on hydration. We manipulated the hydration of the terrestrial eggs of Agalychnis callidryas, in intact clutches and egg-groups isolated from clutch jelly, then warmed them to assess if embryos hatch early as a behavioral response to high temperatures and whether their thermal tolerance varies with hydration or surrounding structure. We discovered that heating induces hatching; these embryos show a behavioral escape-hatching response that enables them to avoid potentially lethal warming. Hydrated eggs and clutches lost more water and warmed more slowly than dehydrated ones, indicating that hydration buffers embryos from environmental warming via evaporative cooling. Embryos in hydrated clutches tolerated greater warming before hatching and suffered higher mortality, suggesting their behavioral Thermal Safety Margin is small. In contrast, lower thermal tolerance protected dry embryos, and those isolated from clutch jelly, from lethal warming. Heat-induced hatching offers a convenient behavioral assay for the thermal tolerance of terrestrial anuran embryos and the interactive effects of warming and dehydration at an early life stage. This work expands the set of threats against which embryos use hatching in self-defense, creating new opportunities for comparative studies of thermal tolerance as well as integrative studies of self-defense mechanisms at the egg stage.

El cambio climático está aumentando tanto las temperaturas ambientales como las sequías. Muchos ectotermos responden conductualmente al calor, evitando así los daños por temperaturas extremas. Dentro de las especies, la tolerancia térmica varía con factores como la hidratación y la ontogenia. Muchos anuros tropicales depositan huevos terrestres que dependen de la humedad ambiental para el desarrollo embrionario. Estos huevos son vulnerables a la deshidratación y los embriones de algunas especies pueden eclosionar prematuramente para escapar de la desecación de los huevos. Las temperaturas más cálidas pueden acelerar el desarrollo y, por lo tanto, la eclosión, pero el exceso de calor puede matar a los embriones. Por lo tanto, planteamos la hipótesis de que los embriones pueden mostrar un límite de tolerancia térmica conductual, eclosionando prematuramente para evitar un calentamiento potencialmente letal. Si es así, debido a que el calentamiento y la desecación a menudo están asociados, planteamos la hipótesis de que este límite, medible como una tolerancia térmica voluntaria, puede depender de la hidratación. Manipulamos la hidratación de los huevos terrestres de Agalychnis callidryas, en posturas intactas y grupos de huevos aislados de la gelatina de la postura. Luego, los calentamos para evaluar si los embriones eclosionan temprano como respuesta conductual a las altas temperaturas y si su tolerancia térmica varía con la hidratación o la estructura circundante. Descubrimos que el calentamiento induce la eclosión. Estos embriones muestran una respuesta conductual de eclosión de escape que les permite evitar un calentamiento potencialmente letal. Los huevos y las posturas hidratadas perdieron más agua y se calentaron más lentamente que los deshidratados, lo que indica que la hidratación protege a los embriones del calentamiento ambiental a través del enfriamiento por evaporación. Los embriones en posturas hidratadas toleraron un mayor calentamiento antes de la eclosión y sufrieron una mayor mortalidad, lo que sugiere que su margen de seguridad térmica conductual es pequeño. En contraste, la tolerancia térmica más baja protegió a los embriones deshidratados, y a los aislados de la gelatina, del calentamiento letal. La eclosión inducida por calor ofrece un ensayo de comportamiento conveniente para la tolerancia térmica de los embriones terrestres de anuros y los efectos integrados del calentamiento y la deshidratación en una etapa temprana de la vida. Este estudio amplía el conjunto de amenazas contra las cuales los embriones usan la eclosión en defensa propia, creando nuevas oportunidades para estudios comparativos de tolerancia térmica, así como estudios integradores de mecanismos de autodefensa en etapa de huevo.

As mudanças climáticas estão aumentando as temperaturas ambientais e as secas. Muitos ectotermos respondem comportamentalmente ao calor, evitando danos devido a temperaturas extremas. Dentro das espécies, a tolerância térmica varia com fatores como a hidratação e a ontogenia. Muitos anuros tropicais depositam ovos terrestres que dependem da umidade ambiental para o desenvolvimento embrionário. Esses ovos são vulneráveis à desidratação, e os embriões de algumas espécies podem eclodir prematuramente para escapar da dessecação dos ovos. Temperaturas mais altas podem acelerar o desenvolvimento e, portanto, a eclosão, mas o excesso de calor pode matar os embriões. Portanto, propomos a hipótese de que os embriões podem mostrar um limite de tolerância térmica comportamental, eclodindo prematuramente para evitar o aquecimento potencialmente letal. Nesse caso, como o aquecimento e a dessecação são frequentemente associados, propomos a hipótese de que esse limite, mensurável como uma tolerância térmica voluntária, pode depender da hidratação. Manipulamos a hidratação dos ovos terrestres de Agalychnis callidryas, em desovas completas e grupos de ovos isolados da geleia da desova. Depois, aquecemos os ovos para avaliar se os embriões eclodem cedo como uma resposta comportamental a altas temperaturas, e se sua tolerância térmica varia com a hidratação ou a estrutura circundante. Descobrimos que o aquecimento induz a eclosão. Esses embriões mostram uma resposta comportamental de eclosão que lhes permite evitar o aquecimento potencialmente letal. Ovos e desovas hidratadas perderam mais água e se aqueceram mais lentamente que os desidratados, indicando que a hidratação protege os embriões do aquecimento ambiental através do resfriamento por evaporação. Os embriões em desovas hidratadas toleraram maior aquecimento antes da eclosão e sofreram maior mortalidade, sugerindo que sua margem de segurança térmica comportamental é menor. Por outro lado, a menor tolerância térmica protegeu os embriões desidratados e os isolados da geleia, do aquecimento letal. A eclosão induzida pelo calor oferece um teste comportamental conveniente para a estimativa da tolerância térmica de embriões de anuros terrestres e dos efeitos integrados do aquecimento e da desidratação em um estágio inicial da vida. Este estudo expande o conjunto de ameaças contra as quais os embriões usam a eclosão como defesa, criando novas oportunidades para estudos comparativos de tolerância térmica, além de estudos integrativos dos mecanismos de autodefesa no estágio de ovo.

Paternal care regulates the timing, synchrony and success of hatching in a coral reef fish.

In oviparous species, the timing of hatching is a crucial decision, but for developing embryos, assessing cues that indicate the optimal time to hatch is challenging. In species with pre-hatching parental care, parents can assess environmental conditions and induce their offspring to hatch. We provide the first documentation of parental hatching regulation in a coral reef fish, demonstrating that male neon gobies (Elacatinus colini) directly regulate hatching by removing embryos from the clutch and spitting hatchlings into the water column. All male gobies synchronized hatching within 2 h of sunrise, regardless of when eggs were laid. Paternally incubated embryos hatched later in development, more synchronously, and had higher hatching success than artificially incubated embryos that were shaken to provide a vibrational stimulus or not stimulated. Artificially incubated embryos displayed substantial plasticity in hatching times (range: 80-224 h post-fertilization), suggesting that males could respond to environmental heterogeneity by modifying the hatching time of their offspring. Finally, paternally incubated embryos hatched with smaller yolk sacs and larger propulsive areas than artificially incubated embryos, suggesting that paternal effects on hatchling phenotypes may influence larval dispersal and fitness. These findings highlight the complexity of fish parental care behaviour and may have important, and currently unstudied, consequences for fish population dynamics.

Frog embryos use multiple levels of temporal pattern in risk assessment for vibration-cued escape hatching.

Stereotyped signals can be a fast, effective means of communicating danger, but animals assessing predation risk must often use more variable incidental cues. Red eyed-treefrog, Agalychnis callidryas, embryos hatch prematurely to escape from egg predators, cued by vibrations in attacks, but benign rain generates vibrations with overlapping properties. Facing high false-alarm costs, embryos use multiple vibration properties to inform hatching, including temporal pattern elements such as pulse durations and inter-pulse intervals. However, measures of snake and rain vibration as simple pulse-interval patterns are a poor match to embryo behavior. We used vibration playbacks to assess if embryos use a second level of temporal pattern, long gaps within a rhythmic pattern, as indicators of risks. Long vibration-free periods are common during snake attacks but absent from hard rain. Long gaps after a few initial vibrations increase the hatching response to a subsequent vibration series. Moreover, vibration patterns as short as three pulses, separated by long periods of silence, can induce as much hatching as rhythmic pulse series with five times more vibration. Embryos can retain information that increases hatching over at least 45 s of silence. This work highlights that embryo behavior is contextually modulated in complex ways. Identical vibration pulses, pulse groups, and periods of silence can be treated as risk cues in some contexts and not in others. Embryos employ a multi-faceted decision-making process to effectively distinguish between risk cues and benign stimuli.

Reproductive colonization of land by frogs: Embryos and larvae excrete urea to avoid ammonia toxicity.

Vertebrate colonization of land has occurred multiple times, including over 50 origins of terrestrial eggs in frogs. Some environmental factors and phenotypic responses that facilitated these transitions are known, but responses to water constraints and risk of ammonia toxicity during early development are poorly understood. We tested if ammonia accumulation and dehydration risk induce a shift from ammonia to urea excretion during early stages of four anurans, from three origins of terrestrial development. We quantified ammonia and urea concentrations during early development on land, under well-hydrated and dry conditions. Where we found urea excretion, we tested for a plastic increase under dry conditions and with ammonia accumulation in developmental environments. We assessed the potential adaptive role of urea excretion by comparing ammonia tolerance measured in 96h-LC50 tests with ammonia levels in developmental environments. Ammonia accumulated in foam nests and perivitelline fluid, increasing over development and reaching higher concentrations under dry conditions. All four species showed high ammonia tolerance, compared to fishes and aquatic-breeding frogs. Both nest-dwelling larvae of Leptodactylus fragilis and late embryos of Hyalinobatrachium fleischmanni excreted urea, showing a plastic increase under dry conditions. These two species can develop the longest on land and urea excretion appears adaptive, preventing their exposure to potentially lethal levels of ammonia. Neither late embryos of Agalychnis callidryas nor nest-dwelling larvae of Engystomops pustulosus experienced toxic ammonia levels under dry conditions, and neither excreted urea. Our results suggest that an early onset of urea excretion, its increase under dry conditions, and elevated ammonia tolerance can all help prevent ammonia toxicity during terrestrial development. High ammonia represents a general risk for development which may be exacerbated as climate change increases dehydration risk for terrestrial-breeding frogs. It may also be a cue that elicits adaptive physiological responses during early development.

La colonización del medio terrestre ha ocurrido en múltiples ocasiones, incluyendo más de 50 orígenes de oviposición terrestre en ranas. Algunos factores ambientales y respuestas fenotípicas que facilitaron estas transiciones se conocen, pero las respuestas a la restricción al agua y el riesgo de toxicidad por el amonio durante el desarrollo temprano no son bien entendidas. Examinamos si la acumulación de amonio y el riesgo de deshidratación inducen el cambio de excreción de amonio a urea en estadios tempranos del desarrollo de cuatro especies de anuros, en tres orígenes de desarrollo en tierra. Cuantificamos la concentración de amonio y urea durante el desarrollo temprano en tierra en condiciones de hidratación adecuada y de desecación. Cuando encontramos excreción de urea, evaluamos su incremento plástico en condiciones de desecación y de acumulación de amonio en los ambientes de desarrollo. Evaluamos el papel adaptativo de la excreción de urea comparando la tolerancia al amonio medida en pruebas LC50 por 96h con los niveles de amonio acumulados en los ambientes de desarrollo. El amonio se acumuló en los nidos de espuma y el fluido perivitelino, incrementando durante el desarrollo y alcanzando la concentración más alta en condiciones de desecación. Las cuatro especies presentan una elevada tolerancia al amonio al compararlas con peces y ranas con reproducción acuática. Las larvas nidícolas de Leptodactylus fragilis y los embriones avanzados de Hyalinobatrachium fleischmanni excretaron urea, mostrando un incremento plástico en condiciones de desecación. Estas dos especies pueden tener los periodos más extensos de desarrollo en tierra y la excreción de urea parece adaptativa, al prevenir su exposición a niveles de amonio potencialmente letales. Ni los embriones avanzados de Agalychnis callidryas ni las larvas nidícolas de Engystomops pustulosus experimentan niveles tóxicos de amonio en condiciones de desecación, y tampoco excretaron urea. Nuestros resultados sugieren que un inicio temprano en la excreción de urea, su incremento en condiciones de desecación y una elevada tolerancia al amonio pueden ayudar a prevenir la toxicidad del amonio durante el desarrollo terrestre. El amonio elevado es un riesgo común para el desarrollo que puede ser exacerbado a medida que el cambio climático incrementa el riesgo de desecación en ranas con reproducción terrestre. También puede ser una señal que lleva a respuestas fisiológicas adaptativas durante el desarrollo temprano.

Multimodal mechanosensing enables treefrog embryos to escape egg-predators.

Mechanosensory-cued hatching (MCH) is widespread, diverse and important for survival in many animals. From flatworms and insects to frogs and turtles, embryos use mechanosensory cues and signals to inform hatching timing, yet mechanisms mediating mechanosensing in ovo are largely unknown. The arboreal embryos of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, hatch prematurely to escape predation, cued by physical disturbance in snake attacks. When otoconial organs in the developing vestibular system become functional, this response strengthens, but its earlier occurrence indicates another sensor must contribute. Post-hatching, tadpoles use lateral line neuromasts to detect water motion. We ablated neuromast function with gentamicin to assess their role in A. callidryas' hatching response to disturbance. Prior to vestibular function, this nearly eliminated the hatching response to a complex simulated attack cue, egg jiggling, revealing that neuromasts mediate early MCH. Vestibular function onset increased hatching, independent of neuromast function, indicating young embryos use multiple mechanosensory systems. MCH increased developmentally. All older embryos hatched in response to egg jiggling, but neuromast function reduced response latency. In contrast, neuromast ablation had no effect on the timing or level of hatching in motion-only vibration playbacks. It appears only a subset of egg-disturbance cues stimulate neuromasts; thus, embryos in attacked clutches may receive unimodal or multimodal stimuli. Agalychnis callidryas embryos have more neuromasts than described for any other species at hatching, suggesting precocious sensory development may facilitate MCH. Our findings provide insight into the behavioral roles of two mechanosensory systems in ovo and open possibilities for exploring sensory perception across taxa in early life stages.

How do red-eyed treefrog embryos sense motion in predator attacks? Assessing the role of vestibular mechanoreception.

The widespread ability to alter timing of hatching in response to environmental cues can serve as a defense against threats to eggs. Arboreal embryos of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, can hatch up to 30% prematurely to escape predation. This escape-hatching response is cued by physical disturbance of eggs during attacks, including vibrations or motion, and thus depends critically on mechanosensory ability. Predator-induced hatching appears later in development than flooding-induced, hypoxia-cued hatching; thus, its onset is not constrained by the development of hatching ability. It may, instead, reflect the development of mechanosensor function. We hypothesize that vestibular mechanoreception mediates escape-hatching in snake attacks, and that the developmental period when hatching-competent embryos fail to flee from snakes reflects a sensory constraint. We assessed the ontogenetic congruence of escape-hatching responses and an indicator of vestibular function, the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR), in three ways. First, we measured VOR in two developmental series of embryos 3-7 days old to compare with the published ontogeny of escape success in attacks. Second, during the period of greatest variation in VOR and escape success, we compared hatching responses and VOR across sibships. Finally, in developmental series, we compared the response of individual embryos to a simulated attack cue with their VOR. The onset of VOR and hatching responses were largely concurrent at all three scales. Moreover, latency to hatch in simulated attacks decreased with increasing VOR. These results are consistent with a key role of the vestibular system in the escape-hatching response of A. callidryas embryos to attacks.

When and where to hatch? Red-eyed treefrog embryos use light cues in two contexts.

Hatching timing is under strong selection and environmentally cued in many species. Embryos use multiple sensory modalities to inform hatching timing and many have spontaneous hatching patterns adaptively synchronized to natural cycles. Embryos can also adaptively shift their hatching timing in response to environmental cues indicating immediate threats or opportunities. Such cued shifts in hatching are widespread among amphibians; however, we know little about what, if anything, regulates their spontaneous hatching. Moreover, in addition to selection on hatching timing, embryos may experience benefits or suffer costs due to the spatial orientation of hatching. Amphibian eggs generally lack internal constraints on hatching direction but embryos might, nonetheless, use external cues to inform hatching orientation. The terrestrial embryos of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, hatch rapidly and prematurely in response to vibrational cues in egg-predator attacks and hypoxia if flooded. Here we examined A. callidryas' use of light cues in hatching timing and orientation. To assess patterns of spontaneous hatching and the role of light cues in their diel timing, we recorded hatching times for siblings distributed across three light environments: continuous light, continuous dark, and a 12L:12D photoperiod. Under a natural photoperiod, embryos showed a clear diel pattern of synchronous hatching shortly after nightfall. Hatching was desynchronized in both continuous light and continuous darkness. It was also delayed by continuous light, but not accelerated by continuous dark, suggesting the onset of dark serves as a hatching cue. We examined hatching orientation and light as a potential directional cue for flooded embryos. Embryos flooded in their clutches almost always hatched toward open water, whereas individual eggs flooded in glass cups often failed to do so, suggesting the natural context provides a directional cue. To test if flooded embryos orient hatching toward light, we placed individual eggs in tubes with one end illuminated and the other dark, then flooded them and recorded hatching direction. Most embryos hatched toward the light, suggesting they use light as a directional cue. Our results support that A. callidryas embryos use light cues to inform both when and where to hatch. Both the spatial orientation of hatching and the timing of spontaneous hatching may affect fitness and be informed by cues in a broader range of species than is currently appreciated.

The hatching process and mechanisms of adaptive hatching acceleration in hourglass treefrogs, Dendropsophus ebraccatus.

Environmentally cued hatching is well documented in anurans, enabling embryos to escape diverse threats. However, knowledge of anuran hatching mechanisms is limited and based largely on aquatic-breeding species without known plasticity in hatching timing. Generally, hatching gland cells produce a hatching enzyme that degrades the vitelline membrane. We investigated hatching and its regulation in terrestrial embryos of hourglass treefrogs, Dendropsophus ebraccatus, which accelerate hatching to escape dehydration. We specifically tested if changes in hatching gland cell development or hatching enzyme gene expression are associated with accelerated hatching. We measured perivitelline chamber size of well-hydrated eggs over development as an indicator of breakdown of the vitelline membrane and found that the size of the perivitelline chamber increased steadily until hatching, suggesting gradual hatching enzyme release and vitelline membrane degradation. Hatching gland cells peaked in abundance and began regression substantially prior to hatching, but we found no developmental differences in the abundance or surface area of hatching gland cells between dry and well-hydrated embryos. Hatching enzyme gene expression also peaked early in development then declined, with no difference between hydration treatments. In D. ebraccatus breakdown of the vitelline membrane appears gradual, mediated by hatching enzyme release starting long before hatching. However, hatching acceleration is not associated with ontogenetic changes in hatching gland cell development or hatching enzyme gene expression. This hatching process contrasts with that of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, which appear to release enzyme acutely at hatching, yet both species are capable of hatching to escape acute threats.

Egg clutch dehydration induces early hatching in red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas.

Terrestrial eggs have evolved repeatedly in tropical anurans exposing embryos to the new threat of dehydration. Red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, lay eggs on plants over water. Maternally provided water allows shaded eggs in humid sites to develop to hatching without rainfall, but unshaded eggs and those in less humid sites can die from dehydration. Hatching responses of amphibian eggs to dry conditions are known from two lineages with independent origins of terrestrial eggs. Here, we experimentally tested for dehydration-induced early hatching in another lineage (Agalychnis callidryas, Phyllomedusidae), representing a third independent origin of terrestrial eggs. We also investigated how dehydration affected egg and clutch structure, and egg mortality. We collected clutches from a pond in Gamboa, Panama, and randomly allocated them to wet or dry treatments at age 1 day. Embryos hatched earlier from dry clutches than from wet clutches, accelerating hatching by ∼11%. Clutch thickness and egg diameter were affected by dehydration, diverging between treatments over time. Meanwhile, mortality in dry clutches was six-fold higher than in control clutches. With this study, early hatching responses to escape mortality from egg dehydration are now known from three anuran lineages with independent origins of terrestrial eggs, suggesting they may be widespread. Further studies are needed to understand how terrestrial amphibian eggs can respond to, or will be affected by, rapid changes in climate over the next decades.

How embryos escape from danger: the mechanism of rapid, plastic hatching in red-eyed treefrogs.

Environmentally cued hatching allows embryos to escape dangers and exploit new opportunities. Such adaptive responses require a flexibly regulated hatching mechanism sufficiently fast to meet relevant challenges. Anurans show widespread, diverse cued hatching responses, but their described hatching mechanisms are slow, and regulation of timing is unknown. Arboreal embryos of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, escape from snake attacks and other threats by very rapid premature hatching. We used videography, manipulation of hatching embryos and electron microscopy to investigate their hatching mechanism. High-speed video revealed three stages of the hatching process: pre-rupture shaking and gaping, vitelline membrane rupture near the snout, and muscular thrashing to exit through the hole. Hatching took 6.5-49 s. We hypothesized membrane rupture to be enzymatic, with hatching enzyme released from the snout during shaking. To test this, we displaced hatching embryos to move their snout from its location during shaking. The membrane ruptured at the original snout position and embryos became trapped in collapsed capsules; they either moved repeatedly to relocate the hole or shook again and made a second hole to exit. Electron microscopy revealed that hatching glands are densely concentrated on the snout and absent elsewhere. They are full of vesicles in embryos and release most of their contents rapidly at hatching. Agalychnis callidryas' hatching mechanism contrasts with the slow process described in anurans to date and exemplifies one way in which embryos can achieve rapid, flexibly timed hatching to escape from acute threats. Other amphibians with cued hatching may also have novel hatching mechanisms.

Risk assessment based on indirect predation cues: revisiting fine-grained variation.

To adaptively express inducible defenses, prey must gauge risk based on indirect cues of predation. However, the information contained in indirect cues that enable prey to fine-tune their phenotypes to variation in risk is still unclear. In aquatic systems, research has focused on cue concentration as the key variable driving threat-sensitive responses to risk. However, while risk is measured as individuals killed per time, cue concentration may vary with either the number or biomass killed. Alternatively, fine-grained variation in cue, that is, frequency of cue pulses irrespective of concentration, may provide a more reliable signal of risk. Here, we present results from laboratory experiments that examine the relationship between red-eyed treefrog tadpole growth and total cue, cue per pulse, and cue pulse frequency. We also reanalyze an earlier study that examined the effect of fine-grained variation in predator cues on wood frog tadpole growth. Both studies show growth declines with increasing cue pulse frequency, even though individual pulses in high-frequency treatments contained very little cue. This result suggests that counter to earlier conclusions, tadpoles are using fine-grained variation in cue arising from the number of predation events to assess and respond to predation risk, as predicted by consumer-resource theory.

Alternative competition-induced digestive strategies yield equal growth, but constrain compensatory growth in red-eyed treefrog larvae.

Compensatory growth is well documented across taxa and provides a fitness advantage to animals who would otherwise reach a smaller reproductive size. We investigated the role of competition-induced gut plasticity in facilitating a compensatory response in red-eyed treefrog larvae. We reared larvae at low, medium, and high densities with different per capita resources, environments known to produce individuals with long and short guts. We then transferred larvae to competitively equal environments to determine if longer guts provided an advantage when resources became available. We predicted that larvae from higher densities with longer guts would exhibit hyperphagia and compensatory growth. We measured growth over 1-week, as well as the time to and size at metamorphosis. To assess mechanisms underlying the growth response, we measured diet transit time and intake. Growth, development, and metamorph snout-vent length did not differ between larvae with long and short guts. Instead, different gut lengths were associated with dramatically different feeding strategies. Medium- and high-density larvae fed at rates far below what their guts could accommodate. However, the combination of low intake and longer guts extended diet transit times, presumably increasing digestibility. This unexpected strategy achieved the same results as that of low-density larvae, which ate twice as much food, but passed it more quickly through a shorter gut. The lack of a compensatory response may be attributed to the costs of accelerated growth and weak seasonal time constraints in the tropics. This suggests that although compensatory growth is widespread among animals, expression of the response may vary with environmental context. J. Exp. Zool. 323A: 778-788, 2015. © 2015 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Putting µ/g in a new light: plasticity in life history switch points reflects fine-scale adaptive responses.

Life history theory predicts that organisms with complex life cycles should transition between life stages when the ratio of growth rate (g) to risk of mortality (µ) in the current stage falls below that in the subsequent stage. Empirical support for this idea has been mixed. Implicit in both theory and empirical work is that the risk of mortality in the subsequent stage is unknown. However, some embryos and larvae of both vertebrates and invertebrates assess cues of post-transition predation risk and alter the timing of hatching or metamorphosis accordingly. Furthermore, although life history switch points of prey have traditionally been treated as discrete shifts in morphology or habitat, for many organisms they are continuous transitional periods within which the timing of specific developmental and behavioral events can be plastic. We studied red-eyed treefrogs (Agalychnis callidryas), which detect predators of both larvae and metamorphs, to test if plastic changes during the process of metamorphosis could reconcile the mismatch between life history theory and empirical data and if plasticity in an earlier stage transition (hatching) would affect plasticity at a subsequent stage transition (metamorphosis). We reared tadpoles from hatching until metamorphosis in a full-factorial cross of two hatching ages (early- vs. late-hatched) and the presence or absence of free-roaming predators of larvae (giant water bugs) and metamorphs (fishing spiders). Hatching age affected the times from oviposition to tail resorption and from hatching to emergence onto land, but did not alter responses to predators or developmental stage at emergence. Tadpoles did not alter their age at emergence or tail resorption in response to larval or metamorph predators, despite the fact that predators reduced tadpole density by ~30%. However, developmental stage at emergence and time needed to complete metamorphosis in the terrestrial environment were plastic and consistent with predictions of the "minimize µ/g" framework. Our results demonstrate that likely adaptive changes in life history transitions occur at previously unappreciated timescales. Consideration of plasticity in the developmental timing of ecologically important events within metamorphosis, rather than treating it as a discrete switch point, may help to reconcile inconsistencies between empirical studies of predator effects and expectations of long-standing ecological theory.

Behavioral plasticity mitigates risk across environments and predators during anuran metamorphosis.

Most animals metamorphose, changing morphology, physiology, behavior and ecological interactions. Size- and habitat-dependent mortality risk is thought to affect the evolution and plastic expression of metamorphic timing, and high predation during the morphological transition is posited as a critical selective force shaping complex life cycles. Nonetheless, empirical data on how risk changes across metamorphosis and stage-specific habitats, or how that varies with size, are rare. We examined predator-prey interactions of red-eyed treefrogs, Agalychnis callidryas, with an aquatic predator (giant water bug, Belostoma) and a semi-terrestrial predator (fishing spider, Thaumasia) across metamorphosis. We manipulated tadpole density to generate variation in metamorph size and conducted predation trials at multiple developmental stages. We quantified how frog behavior (activity) changes across metamorphic development, habitats, and predator presence or absence. In aquatic trials with water bugs, frog mortality increased with forelimb emergence, as hypothesized. In semi-terrestrial trials, contrary to predictions, predation by spiders increased, not decreased, with tail resorption. In neither case did frog size affect mortality. Frogs reduced activity upon forelimb emergence in the water, and further with emergence into air, then increased activity with tail resorption. Longer-tailed metamorphs were captured more often in spider attacks, but attacked less, as most attacks followed prey movements. Metamorphs behaviorally compensated for poor escape performance more effectively on land than in water, thus emergence timing may critically affect mortality. The developmental timing of the ecological transition between environments that select for different larval and juvenile phenotypes is an important, neglected variable in studies of complex life cycles.

Prey responses to predator chemical cues: disentangling the importance of the number and biomass of prey consumed.

To effectively balance investment in predator defenses versus other traits, organisms must accurately assess predation risk. Chemical cues caused by predation events are indicators of risk for prey in a wide variety of systems, but the relationship between how prey perceive risk in relation to the amount of prey consumed by predators is poorly understood. While per capita predation rate is often used as the metric of relative risk, studies aimed at quantifying predator-induced defenses commonly control biomass of prey consumed as the metric of risk. However, biomass consumed can change by altering either the number or size of prey consumed. In this study we determine whether phenotypic plasticity to predator chemical cues depends upon prey biomass consumed, prey number consumed, or both. We examine the growth response of red-eyed treefrog tadpoles (Agalychnis callidryas) to cues from a larval dragonfly (Anax amazili). Biomass consumed was manipulated by either increasing the number of prey while holding individual prey size constant, or by holding the number of prey constant and varying individual prey size. We address two questions. (i) Do prey reduce growth rate in response to chemical cues in a dose dependent manner? (ii) Does the magnitude of the response depend on whether prey consumption increases via number or size of prey? We find that the phenotypic response of prey is an asymptotic function of prey biomass consumed. However, the asymptotic response is higher when more prey are consumed. Our findings have important implications for evaluating past studies and how future experiments should be designed. A stronger response to predation cues generated by more individual prey deaths is consistent with models that predict prey sensitivity to per capita risk, providing a more direct link between empirical and theoretical studies which are often focused on changes in population sizes not individual biomass.

Spatial contagion drives colonization and recruitment of frogflies on clutches of red-eyed treefrogs.

Spatial contagion occurs when the perceived suitability of neighbouring habitat patches is not independent. As a result, organisms may colonize less-preferred patches near preferred patches and avoid preferred patches near non-preferred patches. Spatial contagion may thus alter colonization dynamics as well as the type and frequency of post-colonization interactions. Studies have only recently documented the phenomenon of spatial contagion and begun to examine its consequences for local recruitment. Here, we test for spatial contagion in the colonization of arboreal egg clutches of red-eyed treefrogs by a frogfly and examine the consequences of contagion for fly recruitment. In laboratory choice experiments, flies oviposit almost exclusively on clutches containing dead frog eggs. In nature, however, flies often colonize intact clutches without dead eggs. Consistent with predictions of contagion-induced oviposition, we found that flies more frequently colonize intact clutches near damaged clutches and rarely colonize intact clutches near other intact clutches. Moreover, contagion appears to benefit flies. Flies survived equally well and suffered less parasitism on clutches lacking dead eggs. This study demonstrates how reward contagion can influence colonization dynamics and suggests that colonization patterns caused by contagion may have important population- and community-level consequences.

Wasp predation drives the assembly of fungal and fly communities on frog egg masses.

Community ecology aims to understand how species interactions shape species diversity and abundance. Although less studied than predatory or competitive interactions, facilitative interactions can be important in communities associated with ephemeral microhabitats. Successful recruitment from these habitats requires species to rapidly colonize, develop, and disperse during brief periods of habitat suitability. Interactions between organisms, including processing chain interactions whereby initial consumers alter resources in ways that improve their quality for subsequent consumers, could aid these processes. The terrestrial egg masses of red-eyed treefrogs (Agalychnis callidryas) are a resource for predatory wasps (Agelaia spp., Polybia rejecta) and a microhabitat and resource for saprovoric and pathogenic fungi and saprovoric flies (Megaselia spp., Psychoda savaiiensis). We investigate how interactions with wasps might facilitate fly and fungal colonization of and survival on frog egg masses. Our results indicate that wasps facilitate fungal colonization, whereas flies appear not to, and that both wasps and fungi generate frog egg carrion that attracts saprovoric flies to oviposit and increases the survival of fly larvae. While studies of colonization order often focus on inhibition by early colonizers of subsequent arrivals, this study demonstrates how early colonizers can facilitate the establishment of later ones, by modifying resources in ways that promote the location of and survival in habitat patches. This research draws attention to the diversity of interactions that can occur within ephemeral communities and emphasizes the role that positive interactions may play. Processing chain interactions may be a generally important mechanism increasing the diversity of local communities, including very ephemeral ones.