A mobile application to facilitate implementation of programmatic assessment in anaesthesia training.

BACKGROUND: Programmatic assessment is a concept to support learning through continuously providing information about learner progress to trainees and supervisors. Central to the concept are multiple low-stakes workplace-based assessments and meaningful feedback opportunities. Mobile technology may facilitate frequent and concise workplace-based assessments and trigger meaningful feedback. We designed a mobile application (app) for real-time use at the workplace utilising the concept of entrustable professional activities. As the primary outcome, we analysed completion times and as the secondary outcome the quality of documented learning goals. METHODS: The prEPAred app requests trainees and supervisors to rate level of supervision of a professional activity directly after completion. Subsequently, ratings are compared, and supervisors may provide feedback via the app. We tested the app in five anaesthesiology departments at major teaching hospitals, analysing completion times, agreement on ratings, and quality of documented learning goals. RESULTS: We recorded 1518 assessments from 159 trainees and 89 supervisors. Median time for level of supervision rating was 56 (inter-quartile range: 39-85) s for trainees and 17 (11-30) s for supervisors. Learning goals via the app were documented in 767 cases (50.5%). Median feedback time was 2 min, 31 s (confidence interval [CI]: 1 min, 20 s to 5 min, 20 s). In 443 (29%) cases, a specific learning goal was documented. A post hoc analysis revealed that the odds of documenting learning goals increased if trainees rated the level of supervision higher than their supervisors (odds ratio 1.39; CI: 1.03-1.87). CONCLUSIONS: The prEPAred mobile app enabled frequent and concise documentation of workplace-based assessments. Disagreement in level of supervision rating stimulated documentation of specific learning goals indicating more meaningful feedback. Thus, the tool could advance workplace-based assessments towards programmatic assessment.

Bottom-up feedback to improve clinical teaching: validation of the Swiss System for Evaluation of Teaching Qualities (SwissSETQ).

AIMS OF THE STUDY: Clinical teaching is essential in preparing trainees for independent practice. To improve teaching quality, clinical teachers should be provided with meaningful and reliable feedback from trainees (bottom-up feedback) based on up-to-date educational concepts. For this purpose, we designed a web-based instrument, "Swiss System for Evaluation of Teaching Qualities" (SwissSETQ), building on a well-established tool (SETQsmart) and expanding it with current graduate medical education concepts. This study aimed to validate the new instrument in the field of anaesthesiology training. METHODS: Based on SETQsmart, we developed an online instrument (primarily including 34 items) with generic items to be used in all clinical disciplines. We integrated the recent educational frameworks of CanMEDS 2015 (Canadian Medical Educational Directives for Specialists), and of entrustable professional activities (EPAs). Newly included themes were "Interprofessionalism", "Patient centredness", "Patient safety", "Continuous professional development', and "Entrustment decisions". We ensured content validity by iterative discussion rounds between medical education specialists and clinical supervisors. Two think-aloud rounds with residents investigated the response process. Subsequently, the instrument was pilot-tested in the anaesthesia departments of four major teaching hospitals in Switzerland, involving 220 trainees and 120 faculty. We assessed the instrument's internal structure (to determine the factorial composition) using exploratory factor analysis, internal statistical consistency (by Cronbach's alpha as an estimate of reliability, regarding alpha >0.7 as acceptable, >0.8 as good, >0.9 as excellent), and inter-rater reliability (using generalisability theory in order to assess the minimum number of ratings necessary for a valid feedback to one single supervisor). RESULTS: Based on 185 complete ratings for 101 faculty, exploratory factor analysis revealed four factors explaining 72.3% of the variance (individual instruction 33.8%, evaluation of trainee performance 20.9%, teaching professionalism 12.8%; entrustment decisions 4.7%). Cronbach's alpha for the total score was 0.964. After factor analysis, we removed one item to arrive at 33 items for the final instrument. Generalisability studies yielded a minimum of five to six individual ratings to provide reliable feedback to one supervisor. DISCUSSION: The SwissSETQ possesses high content validity and an "excellent" internal structure for integrating up-to-date graduate medical education concepts. Thereby, the tool allows reliable bottom-up feedback by trainees to support clinical teachers in improving their teaching. Transfer to disciplines other than anaesthesiology needs to be further explored.

Agreement between trainees and supervisors on first-year entrustable professional activities for anaesthesia training.

BACKGROUND: Entrustable professional activities (EPAs) are commonly developed by senior clinicians and education experts. However, if postgraduate training is conceptualised as an educational alliance, the perspective of trainees should be included. This raises the question as to whether the views of trainees and supervisors on entrustability of specific EPAs differ, which we aimed to explore. METHODS: A working group, including all stakeholders, selected and drafted 16 EPAs with the potential for unsupervised practice within the first year of training. For each EPA, first-year trainees, advanced trainees, and supervisors decided whether it should be possible to attain trust for unsupervised practice by the end of the first year of anaesthesiology training (i.e. whether the respective EPA qualified as a 'first-year EPA'). RESULTS: We surveyed 23 first-year trainees, 47 advanced trainees, and 51 supervisors (overall response rate: 68%). All groups fully agreed upon seven EPAs as 'first-year EPAs' and on four EPAs that should not be entrusted within the first year. For all five remaining EPAs, a significantly higher proportion of first-year trainees thought these should be entrusted as first-year EPAs compared with advanced trainees and supervisors. We found no differences between advanced trainees and supervisors. CONCLUSIONS: The views of first-year trainees, advanced trainees, and supervisors showed high agreement. Differing views of young trainees disappeared after the first year. This finding provides a fruitful basis to involve trainees in negotiations of autonomy.

Established and potential predictors of blood loss during lung transplant surgery.

Lung transplantation is an established therapeutic procedure for end stage lung diseases. Its success may be impaired by perioperative complications. Intraoperative blood loss and the resulting blood transfusion are among the most common complications. The various factors contributing to increased blood loss during lung transplantation are only scarcely investigated and not yet completely understood. This is in sharp contrast to other surgical fields, as in orthopedic surgery, liver transplantation and cardiac surgery the contributors to blood loss are well identified. This narrative review article aims to highlight the acknowledged factors influencing blood loss in lung transplantation (such as double vs. single lung transplant) and to discuss potential factors that may be of interest for further research or helpful to develop strategies targeting risk factors in order to minimize blood loss during lung transplantation and finally improve patient outcome.

Sedation during bronchoscopy: data from a nationwide sedation and monitoring survey.

BACKGROUND: There is limited knowledge on practice patterns in procedural sedation and analgesia (PSA), the use of propofol, and monitoring during flexible bronchoscopy (FB). The purpose of this study was to assess the current practice patterns of FBs and to focus on the use of propofol, the education of the proceduralist, and the involvement of anaesthesiologists during FB. METHODS: An anonymous questionnaire was sent to 299 pulmonologists. Only respondents who were active physicians in adult respiratory medicine performing FB were subsequently analysed. RESULTS: The response rate was 78 % and 27,149 FB in the previous 12 months were analysed. The overall sedation-related morbidity rate was 0.02 % and mortality was 7/100'000 FB. Sedation was used in 95 % of bronchoscopies. The main drugs used for PSA were propofol (77 %) and midazolam (46 %). In 84 % of PSAs propofol was used without the attendance of an anaesthesiologist. The use of propofol was associated with high volume bronchoscopists (p < 0.010) and career-young pulmonologists (p < 0.001). While monitoring vital parameters has become standard practice, pulmonologists reported a very low rate of systematic basic education and training in the field of PSA (50 %). CONCLUSIONS: In Switzerland, PSA during FB is mostly performed with propofol without the attendance of an anaesthesiologist and the use of this drug is expected to increase in the future. While monitoring standards are very high there is need for policies to improve education, systematic training, and support for pulmonologists for PSA during FB.

Impact of cytokine release on ventricular function after hepatic reperfusion: a prospective observational echocardiographic study with tissue Doppler imaging.

BACKGROUND: Postreperfusion syndrome and haemodynamic instability are predictors for poor outcome after liver transplantation. Cytokine release has been claimed to be responsible for postreperfusion syndrome. However, the underlying pathophysiologic mechanism is not clarified. The aim of this prospective observational study was to correlate cardiac performance (measured by transoesophageal echocardiography (TEE), Doppler and Tissue Doppler Imaging (TDI)) to plasmatic cytokines: IL-6, IL-8, CXCL1, TGF-ß and CD40L at 5 different time points during liver transplantation. METHODS: Seventeen consecutive patients scheduled for orthotopic liver transplantation, age 18 to 75 years without contraindication for transoesophageal echocardiography were included. Patients were monitored with TEE and TDI. Systolic and diastolic cardiac function, MAP, MPAP, CVP, PCWP, CO and blood samples for cytokine assays were recorded or collected after induction, 15 min after vena cava inferior clamping, 2 to 5 min after reperfusion, 60 min after reperfusion and at the end of surgery. RESULTS: Mean arterial pressure and catecholamine requirements remained unchanged, MPAP, CVP and CO increased, SVR decreased after unclamping. Postreperfusion syndrome did not develop. The haemodynamic parameters and the variations of TEE parameters were consistent with the volume load changes during clamping and declamping and did not reveal systolic or diastolic cardiac dysfunction. All cytokines, except TGF-ß, increased. CONCLUSION: These findings suggest, that significant cytokine release during liver transplantation is not necessarily coincident with haemodynamic instability and impaired cardiac function. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov: NCT00547924.

Impact of restrictive intravenous fluid replacement and combined epidural analgesia on perioperative volume balance and renal function within a Fast Track program.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Key factors of Fast Track (FT) programs are fluid restriction and epidural analgesia (EDA). We aimed to challenge the preconception that the combination of fluid restriction and EDA might induce hypotension and renal dysfunction. METHODS: A recent randomized trial (NCT00556790) showed reduced complications after colectomy in FT patients compared with standard care (SC). Patients with an effective EDA were compared with regard to hemodynamics and renal function. RESULTS: 61/76 FT patients and 59/75 patients in the SC group had an effective EDA. Both groups were comparable regarding demographics and surgery-related characteristics. FT patients received significantly less i.v. fluids intraoperatively (1900 mL [range 1100-4100] versus 2900 mL [1600-5900], P < 0.0001) and postoperatively (700 mL [400-1500] versus 2300 mL [1800-3800], P < 0.0001). Intraoperatively, 30 FT compared with 19 SC patients needed colloids or vasopressors, but this was statistically not significant (P = 0.066). Postoperative requirements were low in both groups (3 versus 5 patients; P = 0.487). Pre- and postoperative values for creatinine, hematocrit, sodium, and potassium were similar, and no patient developed renal dysfunction in either group. Only one of 82 patients having an EDA without a bladder catheter had urinary retention. Overall, FT patients had fewer postoperative complications (6 versus 20 patients; P = 0.002) and a shorter median hospital stay (5 [2-30] versus 9 d [6-30]; P< 0.0001) compared with the SC group. CONCLUSIONS: Fluid restriction and EDA in FT programs are not associated with clinically relevant hemodynamic instability or renal dysfunction.

Impact of preoperative right-ventricular function and platelet transfusion on outcome after lung transplantation.

OBJECTIVE: Lung transplantation has become an established treatment option for end-stage pulmonary diseases. However, outcome depends on preoperative condition and co-morbidity. Furthermore, perioperative blood-product use is known to be associated with worse outcome even in transplant surgery. We investigated the impact of poor preoperative right-ventricular function and blood-product use on outcome after lung transplantation. METHODS: The medical records of 169 lung-transplant recipients from 1996 to 2006 were examined. Duration of hospital stay, hours on mechanical ventilation, duration of stay in the intensive care unit, perioperative complications, death during hospital stay, and long-term survival were recorded. These outcome parameters were analyzed regarding coherence with right-ventricular function and the perioperative administration of crystalloids, colloids, allogeneic red blood cells, fresh frozen plasma, and platelets. RESULTS: Patients with poor preoperative right-ventricular function had a significant increase in postoperative hours on ventilation (p=0.005), intensive care stay (p=0.003), and in-hospital death (p=0.012). The hours on ventilation increased also with high intra-operative fluid administration (p=0.026). Blood-product use was associated with prolonged mechanical ventilation and intensive care stay. After multivariate analysis, transfusion of platelets (p=0.022) was an independent prognostic factor for in-hospital death. Hours of mechanical ventilation was the only independent prognostic factor for long-term mortality (p=0.014). CONCLUSIONS: Perioperative transfusion of platelets is an independent prognostic factor for perioperative mortality. Furthermore, the study indicated that poor preoperative right-ventricular function might worsen perioperatively after lung transplantation. Therefore, pre-transplant treatment of pulmonary hypertension to protract right-ventricular failure and a restrictive use of allogeneic blood products may be options to improve outcome.

Anesthetic-induced improvement of the inflammatory response to one-lung ventilation.

BACKGROUND: Although one-lung ventilation (OLV) has become an established procedure during thoracic surgery, sparse data exist about inflammatory alterations in the deflated, reventilated lung. The aim of this study was to prospectively investigate the effect of OLV on the pulmonary inflammatory response and to assess possible immunomodulatory effects of the anesthetics propofol and sevoflurane. METHODS: Fifty-four adults undergoing thoracic surgery with OLV were randomly assigned to receive either anesthesia with intravenously applied propofol or the volatile anesthetic sevoflurane. A bronchoalveolar lavage was performed before and after OLV on the lung side undergoing surgery. Inflammatory mediators (tumor necrosis factor alpha, interleukin 1beta, interleukin 6, interleukin 8, monocyte chemoattractant protein 1) and cells were analyzed in lavage fluid as the primary endpoint. The clinical outcome determined by postoperative adverse events was assessed as the secondary endpoint. RESULTS: The increase of inflammatory mediators on OLV was significantly less pronounced in the sevoflurane group. No difference in neutrophil recruitment was found between the groups. A positive correlation between neutrophils and mediators was demonstrated in the propofol group, whereas this correlation was missing in the sevoflurane group. The number of composite adverse events was significantly lower in the sevoflurane group. CONCLUSIONS: This prospective, randomized clinical study suggests an immunomodulatory role for the volatile anesthetic sevoflurane in patients undergoing OLV for thoracic surgery with significant reduction of inflammatory mediators and a significantly better clinical outcome (defined by postoperative adverse events) during sevoflurane anesthesia.

A fast-track program reduces complications and length of hospital stay after open colonic surgery.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: A fast-track program is a multimodal approach for patients undergoing colonic surgery that combines stringent regimens of perioperative care (fluid restriction, optimized analgesia, forced mobilization, and early oral feeding) to reduce perioperative morbidity, hospital stay, and cost. We investigated the impact of a fast-track protocol on postoperative morbidity in patients after open colonic surgery. METHODS: A randomized trial of patients in 4 teaching hospitals in Switzerland included 156 patients undergoing elective open colonic surgery who were assigned to either a fast-track program or standard care. The primary end point was the 30-day complication rate. Secondary end points were severity of complications, hospital stay, and compliance with the fast-track protocol. RESULTS: The fast-track protocol significantly decreased the number of complications (16 of 76 in the fast-track group vs 37 of 75 in the standard care group; P = .0014), resulting in shorter hospital stays (median, 5 days; range, 2-30 vs 9 days, respectively; range, 6-30; P < .0001). There was a trend toward less severe complications in the fast-track group. A multiple logistic regression analysis revealed fluid administration greater than the restriction limits (odds ratio, 4.198; 95% confidence interval, 1.7-10.366; P = .002) and a nonfunctioning epidural analgesia (odds ratio, 3.365; 95% confidence interval, 1.367-8.283; P = .008) as independent predictors of postoperative complications. CONCLUSIONS: The fast-track program reduces the rate of postoperative complications and length of hospital stay and should be considered as standard care. Fluid restriction and an effective epidural analgesia are the key factors that determine outcome of the fast-track program.

The effect of clonidine on perioperative blood coagulation.

STUDY OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the influence of perioperative stress protection by clonidine on blood coagulation. DESIGN: Prospective, randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled clinical trial. SETTING: University hospital. PATIENTS: 50 patients scheduled for elective gynecoabdominal surgery. INTERVENTIONS AND MEASUREMENTS: Patients were randomly assigned to control (placebo) or clonidine group (single intravenous clonidine dose; 4 microg/kg(-1) or 3 microg/kg(-1) for age >65 years). Three measurement time points were defined: before administration of placebo/clonidine and anesthesia induction, (t1; baseline measurement); after surgery, before emergence of anesthesia (t2); and at the first postoperative day, 24 hours after anesthesia induction (t3). Blood coagulation was analyzed at all time points measuring international normalized ratio, platelets, thrombin-antithrombin complex, von Willebrand factor, soluble thrombomodulin, d-dimers, plasminogen activator inhibitor 1, and Thrombelastograph analysis. MAIN RESULTS: In the postoperative period (t2, t3), hypercoagulability was present in all patients compared with baseline measurements (t1) but without differences between the control and clonidine group. Regarding hematologic, laboratory blood coagulation, and Thrombelastograph parameters, there was no statistically and clinically relevant difference throughout the study period between the 2 groups. No hemodynamic adverse events of clonidine were observed in the perioperative period. Until day of discharge, no thrombotic or thromboembolic events were reported in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: Preoperative administration of a single dose of clonidine has no effect on perioperative blood coagulation.

Patterns of changes in arterial PO2 during one-lung ventilation: a comparison between patients with severe pulmonary emphysema and patients with preserved lung function.

OBJECTIVES: One-lung ventilation (OLV) during thoracoscopic surgery is associated with a significant decline in arterial PO(2) in patients with severe pulmonary emphysema and patients with preserved lung function. The authors hypothesized that patterns of arterial PO(2) changes are different in these 2 patient groups. DESIGN: Prospective nonrandomized study. SETTING: University hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-five patients undergoing thoracoscopic interventions: 16 with severe pulmonary emphysema and 9 patients without emphysema. INTERVENTIONS: Continuous arterial blood gas measurement (PaO(2), PaCO(2), pHa) during OLV of the left lung in left lateral position using the Paratrend 7 blood gas monitoring system (PT7; Pfizer Hospital Products Group, High Wycombe, UK). MAIN RESULTS: The decrease of PaO(2) was delayed in patients with severe emphysema. Steady state (defined as DeltaPaO(2) <7.5 mmHg/min) was reached after 18 +/- 4 minutes compared with 11 +/- 3 minutes (mean +/- standard deviation) in patients with normal lung function (p = 0.0002). PaO(2) values at steady state were comparable (p = 0.49); the pattern of changes in PaO(2) for the first 15 minutes of left-sided OLV was significantly different between the groups (p = 0.0004). The difference of predicted versus measured PaO(2) at steady state was -48 +/- 160 mmHg for patients with emphysema and -51 +/- 60 mmHg for patients with normal lung function (p = 0.019). CONCLUSION: During OLV, oxygenation is better preserved for a longer period of time in patients with severe pulmonary emphysema as compared with patients with normal lung function. In contrast to patients without emphysema, prediction of oxygenation during OLV for the individual patient with emphysema is unreliable because of large interindividual differences.

Accuracy and performance of a modified continuous intravascular blood gas monitoring device during thoracoscopic surgery.

OBJECTIVE: The only commercially available continuous intravascular blood gas monitoring system for adults, the Paratrend (Diametrics Medical Inc, High Wycombe, UK), was modified by the manufacturer to the Paratrend 7+ (PT7+) in 1999. The aim of this study was to evaluate the modified probe over a wide range of blood gas and pH values during thoracoscopic surgery in a similar setup as done with the previous model. DESIGN: Prospective methods comparison study. SETTING: University hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-three patients. INTERVENTIONS: Elective thoracoscopic surgery. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: One hundred thirteen PT7+ readings and their corresponding arterial blood gas and pH measurements (ABGA) were evaluated. The ranges for ABGA values were 50 to 474 mmHg for PO(2), 29 to 58 mmHg for PCO(2), and 7.28 to 7.49 for pH. Bland and Altman analysis revealed a bias +/- 2 standard deviation of -20 +/- 86 mmHg for PO(2), 3 +/- 9 mmHg for PCO(2), and -0.01 +/- 0.06 for pH. No specific complications attributable to the probe were observed. CONCLUSION: In patients undergoing thoracoscopic surgery with rapidly changing blood gas parameters, the PT7+ device is a valuable trend indicator and hence may be helpful for clinical decision making. However, the underestimation of PO(2) values by 20 mmHg on average and the wide limits of agreement documented in this study must be regarded as limiting factors.

Successful lung volume reduction surgery in a child with severe airflow obstruction and hyperinflation due to constrictive bronchiolitis.

Lung volume reduction surgery (LVRS) may improve pulmonary function in patients with severe emphysema. However, its effects in other types of obstructive lung disease are unknown. To delay the need for lung transplantation, we performed LVRS in a 14-year-old boy with disabling airflow obstruction/hyperinflation secondary to postinfectious bronchiolitis nonresponsive to medical therapy. Within days after LVRS, a major improvement of symptoms and lung function occurred and persisted for > 1 year. Our observation suggests that LVRS may be a novel treatment option in selected patients with extreme hyperinflation even if the underlying disease is not emphysema.

Preoperative clonidine blunts hyperadrenergic and hyperdynamic responses to prolonged tourniquet pressure during general anesthesia.

UNLABELLED: Although the mechanism of tourniquet-induced hypertension is still unclear, plasma norepinephrine concentrations continuously increase in parallel to arterial blood pressure during tourniquet inflation. Clonidine attenuates hyperadrenergic and hyperdynamic responses. We investigated the effects of clonidine on prolonged tourniquet inflation. Twenty-nine patients scheduled for elective orthopedic surgery were randomly assigned to receive IV clonidine (3 microg/kg; n = 14) or placebo (n = 15) before tourniquet inflation of the lower limbs under general anesthesia in a double-blinded manner. Arterial blood pressure, heart rate, epinephrine, and norepinephrine plasma concentrations were measured before tourniquet inflation, 60 min after tourniquet inflation, just before tourniquet deflation, and 20 min after tourniquet deflation. Mean arterial blood pressure and norepinephrine plasma-concentrations were significantly lower in the Clonidine group compared with Control after 60 min tourniquet inflation (P = 0.016; P = 0.006). Immediately before deflation of the tourniquet, the difference for mean arterial pressure between groups was even more pronounced (P = 0.005). Twenty minutes after deflation mean arterial blood pressure in the Control group was still increased and significantly higher compared with the Clonidine group (P = 0.002). In conclusion, preoperative IV clonidine blunts hyperadrenergic and hyperdynamic responses resulting from prolonged tourniquet inflation under general anesthesia in ASA class I--II patients. IMPLICATIONS: Tourniquet inflation is associated with a continuous increase in arterial blood pressure and sympathetic outflow. This study shows that IV clonidine effectively blunts increases of both arterial blood pressure and plasma norepinephrine concentrations.