On Kinetic Constraints That Catalysis Imposes on Elementary Processes.

Catalysis, the acceleration of product formation by a substance that is left unchanged, typically results from multiple elementary processes, including diffusion of the reactants toward the catalyst, chemical steps, and release of the products. While efforts to design catalysts are often focused on accelerating the chemical reaction on the catalyst, catalysis is a global property of the catalytic cycle that involves all processes. These are controlled by both intrinsic parameters such as the composition and shape of the catalyst and extrinsic parameters such as the concentration of the chemical species at play. We examine here the conditions that catalysis imposes on the different steps of a reaction cycle and the respective role of intrinsic and extrinsic parameters of the system on the emergence of catalysis by using an approach based on first-passage times. We illustrate this approach for various decompositions of a catalytic cycle into elementary steps, including non-Markovian decompositions, which are useful when the presence and nature of intermediate states are a priori unknown. Our examples cover different types of reactions and clarify the constraints on elementary steps and the impact of species concentrations on catalysis.

Computational design of a minimal catalyst using colloidal particles with programmable interactions.

Catalysis, the acceleration of chemical reactions by molecules that are not consumed in the process, is essential to living organisms but remains absent in physical systems that aspire to emulate biological functionalities with artificial components. Here we demonstrate how to design a catalyst using spherical building blocks interacting via programmable potentials, and show that a minimal catalyst design, a rigid dimer, can accelerate a ubiquitous elementary reaction, the cleaving of a bond. Combining coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations and theory, and by comparing the mean reaction time for bond dissociation in the presence and absence of the catalyst, we derive geometrical and physical constraints for its design and determine the reaction conditions under which catalysis emerges in the system. The framework and design rules that we introduce are general and can be applied to experimental systems on a wide range of scales, from micron size DNA-coated colloids to magnetic handshake materials in the macroscale, opening the door to the realization of self-regulated artificial systems with bio-inspired functionalities.

Self-assembly of emulsion droplets through programmable folding.

In the realm of particle self-assembly, it is possible to reliably construct nearly arbitrary structures if all the pieces are distinct1-3, but systems with fewer flavours of building blocks have so far been limited to the assembly of exotic crystals4-6. Here we introduce a minimal model system of colloidal droplet chains7, with programmable DNA interactions that guide their downhill folding into specific geometries. Droplets are observed in real space and time, unravelling the rules of folding. Combining experiments, simulations and theory, we show that controlling the order in which interactions are switched on directs folding into unique structures, which we call colloidal foldamers8. The simplest alternating sequences (ABAB...) of up to 13 droplets yield 11 foldamers in two dimensions and one in three dimensions. Optimizing the droplet sequence and adding an extra flavour uniquely encodes more than half of the 619 possible two-dimensional geometries. Foldamers consisting of at least 13 droplets exhibit open structures with holes, offering porous design. Numerical simulations show that foldamers can further interact to make complex supracolloidal architectures, such as dimers, ribbons and mosaics. Our results are independent of the dynamics and therefore apply to polymeric materials with hierarchical interactions on all length scales, from organic molecules all the way to Rubik's Snakes. This toolbox enables the encoding of large-scale design into sequences of short polymers, placing folding at the forefront of materials self-assembly.

Programming Directed Motion with DNA-Grafted Particles.

Colloidal particles can be programmed to interact in complex ways by functionalizing them with DNA oligonucleotides. Adding DNA strand-displacement reactions to the system allows these interparticle interactions to respond to specific changes in temperature. We present the requirements for thermally driven directed motion of colloidal particles, and we explore how these conditions can be realized experimentally using strand-displacement reactions. To evaluate the concept, we build and test a colloidal "dancer": a single particle that can be driven to move through a programmed sequence of steps along a one-dimensional track composed of other particles. The results of these tests reveal the capabilities and limitations of using DNA-mediated interactions for applications in dynamic systems. Specifically, we discuss how to design the substrate to limit complexity while permitting full control of the motile component, how to ratchet the interactions to move over many substrate positions with a limited regime of control parameters, and how to use technological developments to reduce the probability of detachment without sacrificing speed.

Natural Selection beyond Life? A Workshop Report.

Natural selection is commonly seen not just as an explanation for adaptive evolution, but as the inevitable consequence of "heritable variation in fitness among individuals". Although it remains embedded in biological concepts, such a formalisation makes it tempting to explore whether this precondition may be met not only in life as we know it, but also in other physical systems. This would imply that these systems are subject to natural selection and may perhaps be investigated in a biological framework, where properties are typically examined in light of their putative functions. Here we relate the major questions that were debated during a three-day workshop devoted to discussing whether natural selection may take place in non-living physical systems. We start this report with a brief overview of research fields dealing with "life-like" or "proto-biotic" systems, where mimicking evolution by natural selection in test tubes stands as a major objective. We contend the challenge may be as much conceptual as technical. Taking the problem from a physical angle, we then discuss the framework of dissipative structures. Although life is viewed in this context as a particular case within a larger ensemble of physical phenomena, this approach does not provide general principles from which natural selection can be derived. Turning back to evolutionary biology, we ask to what extent the most general formulations of the necessary conditions or signatures of natural selection may be applicable beyond biology. In our view, such a cross-disciplinary jump is impeded by reliance on individuality as a central yet implicit and loosely defined concept. Overall, these discussions thus lead us to conjecture that understanding, in physico-chemical terms, how individuality emerges and how it can be recognised, will be essential in the search for instances of evolution by natural selection outside of living systems.

Spontaneous emergence of catalytic cycles with colloidal spheres.

Colloidal particles endowed with specific time-dependent interactions are a promising route for realizing artificial materials that have the properties of living ones. Previous work has demonstrated how this system can give rise to self-replication. Here, we introduce the process of colloidal catalysis, in which clusters of particles catalyze the creation of other clusters through templating reactions. Surprisingly, we find that simple templating rules generically lead to the production of huge numbers of clusters. The templating reactions among this sea of clusters give rise to an exponentially growing catalytic cycle, a specific realization of Dyson's notion of an exponentially growing metabolism. We demonstrate this behavior with a fixed set of interactions between particles chosen to allow a catalysis of a specific six-particle cluster from a specific seven-particle cluster, yet giving rise to the catalytic production of a sea of clusters of sizes between 2 and 11 particles. The fact that an exponentially growing cycle emerges naturally from such a simple scheme demonstrates that the emergence of exponentially growing metabolisms could be simpler than previously imagined.

Mutation at Expanding Front of Self-Replicating Colloidal Clusters.

We construct a scheme for self-replicating square clusters of particles in two spatial dimensions, and validate it with computer simulations in a finite-temperature heat bath. We find that the self-replication reactions propagate through the bath in the form of Fisher waves. Our model reflects existing colloidal systems, but is simple enough to allow simulation of many generations and thereby the first study of evolutionary dynamics in an artificial system. By introducing spatially localized mutations in the replication rules, we show that the mutated cluster population can survive and spread with the expanding front in circular sectors of the colony.

Multifarious assembly mixtures: systems allowing retrieval of diverse stored structures.

Self-assembly materials are traditionally designed so that molecular or mesoscale components form a single kind of large structure. Here, we propose a scheme to create "multifarious assembly mixtures," which self-assemble many different large structures from a set of shared components. We show that the number of multifarious structures stored in the solution of components increases rapidly with the number of different types of components. However, each stored structure can be retrieved by tuning only a few parameters, the number of which is only weakly dependent on the size of the assembled structure. Implications for artificial and biological self-assembly are discussed.

Size limits of self-assembled colloidal structures made using specific interactions.

We establish size limitations for assembling structures of controlled size and shape out of colloidal particles with short-ranged interactions. Through simulations we show that structures with highly variable shapes made out of dozens of particles can form with high yield, as long as each particle in the structure binds only to the particles in their local environment. To understand this, we identify the excited states that compete with the ground-state structure and demonstrate that these excited states have a completely topological characterization, valid when the interparticle interactions are short-ranged. This allows complete enumeration of the energy landscape and gives bounds on how large a colloidal structure can assemble with high yield. For large structures the yield can be significant, even with hundreds of particles.

Contact changes near jamming.

We probe the onset and effect of contact changes in soft harmonic particle packings which are sheared quasistatically. We find that the first contact changes are the creation or breaking of contacts on a single particle. We characterize the critical strain, statistics of breaking versus making a contact, and ratio of shear modulus before and after such events, and explain their finite size scaling relations. For large systems at finite pressure, the critical strain vanishes but the ratio of shear modulus before and after a contact change approaches one: linear response remains relevant in large systems. For finite systems close to jamming the critical strain also vanishes, but here linear response already breaks down after a single contact change.

Self-replicating colloidal clusters.

We construct schemes for self-replicating clusters of spherical particles, validated with computer simulations in a finite-temperature heat bath. Each particle has stickers uniformly distributed over its surface, and the rules for self-replication are encoded into the specificity and strength of interactions. Geometrical constraints imply that a compact cluster can copy itself only with help of a catalyst, a smaller cluster that increases the surface area to form a template. Replication efficiency requires optimizing interaction energies to destabilize all kinetic traps along the reaction pathway, as well as initiating a trigger event that specifies when the new cluster disassociates from its parent. Although there is a reasonably wide parameter range for self-replication, there is a subtle balance between the speed of the reaction, and the error rate. As a proof of principle, we construct interactions that self-replicate an octahedron, requiring a two-particle dimer for a catalyst. The resulting self-replication scheme is a hypercycle, and computer simulations confirm the exponential growth of both octahedron and catalyst replicas.

Using shape anisotropy to toughen disordered nanoparticle assemblies.

Assemblies of disordered nanoparticles constitute an important class of materials that have numerous applications in energy conversion and storage, electronics, photonics, and sensing. One major roadblock that limits the widespread utilization of disordered nanoparticle assemblies (DNAs) is their poor damage tolerance; they fracture under small loads and, thus, have low toughness. The absence of fundamental understanding on the mechanical behavior and failure mechanism of disordered nanoparticle assemblies makes it even more challenging to develop new strategies to toughen these structures without compromising their mechanical strength. Here we show the formation of shear bands, highly localized regions of mechanical strain that prelude fracture, in disordered assemblies of spherical nanoparticles, which bear striking resemblance to the deformation mechanism of a different class of disordered materials, metallic glasses. We demonstrate that anisotropic nanoparticles greatly suppress shear band formation and toughen nanoparticle packings without sacrificing their strength, implying that tuning constituent anisotropy can be used to enhance toughness in disordered packings of nanoparticles.