From minichaperone to GroEL 2: importance of avidity of the multisite ring structure.

Structural studies on minichaperones and GroEL imply a continuous ring of binding sites around the neck of GroEL. To investigate the importance of this ring, we constructed an artificial heptameric assembly of minichaperones to mimic their arrangement in GroEL. The heptameric Gp31 co-chaperonin from bacteriophage T4, an analogue of GroES, was used as a scaffold to display the GroEL minichaperones. A fusion protein, MC(7), was generated by replacing a part of the highly mobile loop of Gp31 (residues 23-44) with the sequence of the minichaperone (residues 191-376 of GroEL). The purified recombinant protein assembled into a heptameric ring composed of seven 30.6 kDa subunits. Although single minichaperones (residues 193-335 to 191-376 of GroEL) have certain chaperone activities in vitro and in vivo, they cannot refold heat and dithiothreitol-denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase (mtMDH), a reaction that normally requires GroEL, its co-chaperonin GroES and ATP. But, MC(7) refolded MDH in vitro. The expression of MC(7) complements in vivo two temperature-sensitive Escherichia coli alleles, groEL44 and groEL673, at 43 degrees C. Although MC(7) could not compensate for the complete absence of GroEL in vivo, it enhanced the colony-forming ability of cells containing limiting amounts of wild-type GroEL at 37 degrees C. MC(7 )also reduces aggregate formation and cell death in mammalian cell models of Huntington's disease. The assembly of seven minichaperone subunits on a heptameric ring significantly improves their activity, demonstrating the importance of avidity in GroEL function.

From minichaperone to GroEL 3: properties of an active single-ring mutant of GroEL.

The next step in our reductional analysis of GroEL was to study the activity of an isolated single seven-membered ring of the 14-mer. A known single-ring mutant, GroEL(SR1), contains four point mutations that prevent the formation of double-rings. That heptameric complex is functionally inactive because it is unable to release GroES. We found that the mutation E191G, which is responsible for the temperature sensitive (ts) Escherichia coli allele groEL44 and is located in the hinge region between the intermediate and apical domains of GroEL, appears to function by weakening the binding of GroES, without destabilizing the overall structure of GroEL44 mutant. We introduced, therefore, the mutation E191G into GroEL(SR1) in order to generate a single-ring mutant that may have weaker binding of GroES and hence be active. The new single-ring mutant, GroEL(SR44), was indeed effective in refolding both heat and dithiothreitol-denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase with great efficiency. Further, unlike all smaller constructs of GroEL, the expression of GroEL(SR44) in E. coli that contained no endogenous GroEL restored biological viability, but not as efficiently as does wild-type GroEL. We envisage the notional evolution of the structure and properties of GroEL. The minichaperone core acts as a primitive chaperone by providing a binding surface for denatured states that prevents their self-aggregation. The assembly of seven minichaperones into a ring then enhances substrate binding by introducing avidity. The acquisition of binding sites for ATP then allows the modulation of substrate binding by introducing the allosteric mechanism that causes cycling between strong and weak binding sites. This is accompanied by the acquisition by the heptamer of the binding of GroES, which functions as a lid to the central cavity and competes for peptide binding sites. Finally, dimerization of the heptamer enhances its biological activity.

Bacterial and yeast chaperones reduce both aggregate formation and cell death in mammalian cell models of Huntington's disease.

Huntington's disease (HD) is an autosomal dominant neurodegenerative condition caused by expansions of more than 35 uninterrupted CAG repeats in exon 1 of the huntingtin gene. The CAG repeats in HD and the other seven known diseases caused by CAG codon expansions are translated into long polyglutamine tracts that confer a deleterious gain of function on the mutant proteins. Intraneuronal inclusions comprising aggregates of the relevant mutant proteins are found in the brains of patients with HD and related diseases. It is crucial to determine whether the formation of inclusions is directly pathogenic, because a number of studies have suggested that aggregates may be epiphenomena or even protective. Here, we show that fragments of the bacterial chaperone GroEL and the full-length yeast heat shock protein Hsp104 reduce both aggregate formation and cell death in mammalian cell models of HD, consistent with a causal link between aggregation and pathology.

Effects on interaction kinetics of mutations at the VH-VL interface of Fabs depend on the structural context.

The influence of framework residues belonging to VH and VL modules of antibody molecules on antigen binding remains poorly understood. To investigate the functional role of such residues, we have performed semi-conservative amino acid replacements at the VH-VL interface. This work was carried out with (i) variants of the same antibody and (ii) with antibodies of different specificities (Fab fragments 145P and 1F1h), in order to check if functional effects are additive and/or similar for the two antibodies. Interaction kinetics of Fab mutants with peptide and protein antigens were measured using a BIACORE instrument. The substitutions introduced at the VH-VL interface had no significant effects on k(a) but showed small, significant effects on k(d). Mutations in the VH module affected k(d) not only for the two different antibodies but also for variants of the same antibody. These effects varied both in direction and in magnitude. In the VL module, the double mutation F(L37)L-Q(L38)L, alone or in combination with other mutations, consistently decreased k(d) about two-fold in Fab 145P. Other mutations in the VL module had no effect on k(d) in 145P, but always decreased k(d) in 1F1h. Moreover, in both systems, small-magnitude non-additive effects on k(d) were observed, but affinity variations seemed to be limited by a threshold. When comparing functional effects in antibodies of different specificity, no general rules could be established. In addition, no clear relationship could be pointed out between the nature of the amino acid change and the observed functional effect. Our results show that binding kinetics are affected by alteration of framework residues remote from the binding site, although these effects are unpredictable for most of the studied changes.

Interdomain interactions within the gene 3 protein of filamentous phage.

Infection of Escherichia coli by filamentous phage fd is mediated by the phage gene 3 protein (g3p). The g3p consists of three domains (g3p-D1, D2 and D3) linked by flexible glycine-rich linkers. All three domains are indispensable for phage infectivity; the g3p-D1 domain binds to the TolA receptor presumably at the inner face of the outer membrane, the g3p-D2 domain to the F-pilus and the g3p-D3 domain anchors g3p to the phage coat. The N-terminal domains g3p-D1 and D2 interact with each other; this interaction is abrogated by binding of g3p-D2 to the F-pilus leading to the release of g3p-D1 to bind to TolA. Here, using phages with deletions in g3p, we have discovered a specific interaction between the two N-terminal domains and g3p-D3, the C-terminal domain of g3p. We propose that these interdomain interactions within g3p lead to a compact and stable organisation when displayed on the phage tip, but that during infection, this compact state must be unraveled.

GroEL recognises sequential and non-sequential linear structural motifs compatible with extended beta-strands and alpha-helices.

The chaperonin GroEL binds a variety of polypeptides that share no obvious sequence similarity. The precise structural, chemical and dynamic features that are recognised remain largely unknown. Structural models of the complex between GroEL and its co-chaperonin GroES, and of the isolated apical domain of GroEL (minichaperone; residues 191-376) with a 17 residue N-terminal tag show that a linear sequential sequence (extended beta-strand) can be bound. We have analysed characteristics of the motifs that bind to GroEL by using affinity panning of immobilised GroEL minichaperones for a library of bacteriophages that display the fungal cellulose-binding domain of the enzyme cellobiohydrolase I. This protein has seven non-sequential residues in its binding site that form a linear binding motif with similar dimensions and characteristics to the peptide tag that was bound to the minichaperone GroEL(191-376). The seven residues thus form a constrained scaffold. We find that GroEL does bind suitable mutants of these seven residues. The side-chains recognised do not have to be totally hydrophobic, but polar and positively charged chains can be accommodated. Further, the spatial distribution of the side-chains is also compatible with those in an alpha-helix. This implies that GroEL can bind a wide range of structures, from extended beta-strands and alpha-helices to folded states, with exposed side-chains. The binding site can accommodate substrates of approximately 18 residues when in a helical or seven when in an extended conformation. The data support two activities of GroEL: the ability to act as a temporary parking spot for sticky intermediates by binding many motifs; and an unfolding activity of GroEL by binding an extended sequential conformation of the substrate.

NMR analysis of the binding of a rhodanese peptide to a minichaperone in solution.

A detailed structural analysis of interactions between denatured proteins and GroEL is essential for an understanding of its mechanism. Minichaperones constitute an excellent paradigm for obtaining high-resolution structural information about the binding site and conformation of substrates bound to GroEL, and are particularly suitable for NMR studies. Here, we used transferred nuclear Overhauser effects to study the interaction in solution between minichaperone GroEL(193-335) and a synthetic peptide (Rho), corresponding to the N-terminal alpha-helix (residues 11 to 23) of the mitochondrial rhodanese, a protein whose in vitro refolding is mediated by minichaperones. Using a 60 kDa maltose-binding protein (MBP)-GroEL(193-335) fusion protein to increase the sensitivity of the transferred NOEs, we observed characteristic sequential and mid-range transferred nuclear Overhauser effects. The peptide adopts an alpha-helical conformation upon binding to the minichaperone. Thus the binding site of GroEL is compatible with binding of alpha-helices as well as extended beta-strands. To locate the peptide-binding site on GroEL(193-335), we analysed changes in its chemical shifts on adding an excess of Rho peptide. All residues with significant chemical shift differences are localised in helices H8 and H9. Non-specific interactions were not observed. This indicates that the peptide Rho binds specifically to minichaperone GroEL(193-335). The binding region identified by NMR in solution agrees with crystallographic studies with small peptides and with fluorescence quenching studies with denatured proteins.

Minimal and optimal mechanisms for GroE-mediated protein folding.

We have analyzed the effects of different components of the GroE chaperonin system on protein folding by using a nonpermissive substrate (i.e., one that has very low spontaneous refolding yield) for which rate data can be acquired. In the absence of GroES and nucleotides, the rate of GroEL-mediated refolding of heat- and DTT-denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase was extremely low, but some three times higher than the spontaneous rate. This GroEL-mediated rate was increased 17-fold by saturating concentrations of ATP, 11-fold by ADP and GroES, and 465-fold by ATP and GroES. Optimal refolding activity was observed when the dissociation of GroES from the chaperonin complex was dramatically reduced. Although GroEL minichaperones were able to bind denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase, they were ineffective in enhancing the refolding rate. The spectrum of mechanisms for GroE-mediated protein folding depends on the nature of the substrate. The minimal mechanism for permissive substrates (i.e., having significant yields of spontaneous refolding), requires only binding to the apical domain of GroEL. Slow folding rates of nonpermissive substrates are limited by the transitions between high- and low-affinity states of GroEL alone. The optimal mechanism, which requires holoGroEL, physiological amounts of GroES, and ATP hydrolysis, is necessary for the chaperonin-mediated folding of nonpermissive substrates at physiologically relevant rates under conditions in which retention of bound GroES prevents the premature release of aggregation-prone folding intermediates from the chaperonin complex. The different mechanisms are described in terms of the structural features of mini- and holo-chaperones.

In vivo activities of GroEL minichaperones.

Fragments encompassing the apical domain of GroEL, called minichaperones, facilitate the refolding of several proteins in vitro without requiring GroES, ATP, or the cage-like structure of multimeric GroEL. We have identified the smallest minichaperone that is active in vitro in chaperoning the refolding of rhodanese and cyclophilin A: GroEL(193-335). This finding raises the question of whether the minichaperones are active under more stringent conditions in vivo. The smallest minichaperones complement two temperature-sensitive Escherichia coli groEL alleles, EL44 and EL673, at 43 degreesC. Although they cannot replace GroEL in cells in which the chromosomal groEL gene has been deleted by P1 transduction, GroEL(193-335) enhances the colony-forming ability of such cells when limiting amounts of GroEL are expressed from a tightly regulated plasmid. Surprisingly, we found that overexpression of GroEL prevents plaque formation by bacteriophage lambda and inhibits replication of the lambda origin-dependent plasmid, Lorist6. The minichaperones also inhibit Lorist6 replication, but less markedly. The complex quaternary structure of GroEL, its central cavity, and the structural allosteric changes that take place on the binding of nucleotides and GroES are not essential for all of its functions in vivo.

Measurement of antigen-antibody interactions with biosensors.

The introduction in 1990 of a new biosensor technology based on surface plasmon resonance has revolutionized the measurement of antigen-antibody binding interactions. In this technique, one of the interacting partners is immobilized on a sensor chip and the binding of the other is followed by the increase in refractive index caused by the mass of bound species. The following immunochemical applications of this new technology will be described: (1) functional mapping of epitopes and paratopes by mutagenesis; (2) analysis of the thermodynamic parameters of the interaction; (3) measurement of the concentration of biologically active molecules; (4) selection of diagnostic probes.

Cooperative effects of mutations in a recombinant Fab on the kinetics of antigen binding.

Recombinant Fabs, 57P and 174P, recognizing peptide 134-151 of the coat protein of tobacco mosaic virus, differ by 15 amino acid changes in the sequence of their variable region. Kinetic analysis using BIAcore showed that they recognized five peptide variants in the same ranking order, but that Fab 174P consistently dissociated faster from the peptides compared to Fab 57P. In order to identify amino acid substitutions that are responsible for differences in dissociation rates of the two Fabs, six hybrid Fabs have been constructed by exchanging three DNA segments. Four single and five multiple mutants were obtained by site-directed mutagenesis. All Fabs recognized variant peptides in a similar ranking order. The high precision of biosensor measurements made it possible to detect small contributions to dissociation kinetics of at least five substitutions, as well as the presence of small-magnitude non-additive effects of multiple substitutions. Our results demonstrate the cooperative influence on dissociation kinetics of amino acid residues located away from each other and away from the Fab combining site.

Uses of biosensors in the study of viral antigens.

The introduction in 1990 of a new biosensor technology based on surface plasmon resonance has greatly simplified the measurement of binding interactions in biology. This new technology known as biomolecular interaction analysis makes it possible to visualize the binding process as a function of time by following the increase in refractive index that occurs when one of the interacting partners binds to its ligand immobilized on the surface of a sensor chip. None of the reactants needs to be labelled, which avoids the artefactual changes in binding properties that often result when the molecules are labelled. Biosensor instruments are well-suited for the rapid mapping of viral epitopes and for identifying which combinations of capturing and detector Mabs will give the best results in sandwich assays. Biosensor binding data are also useful for selecting peptides to be used in diagnostic solid-phase immunoassays. Very small changes in binding affinity can be measured with considerable precision which is a prerequisite for analyzing the functional effect and thermodynamic implications of limited structural changes in interacting molecules. On-rate (ka) and off-rate (kd) kinetic constants of the interaction between virus and antibody can be readily measured and the equilibrium affinity constant K can be calculated from the ratio ka/kd = K.

Functional mapping of conserved residues located at the VL and VH domain interface of a Fab.

The interface between the VL and VH domains of antibodies is highly conserved. To investigate the influence of conserved interface residues on Fab function, 13 interface residues were subjected to codon-based combinatorial alanine scanning mutagenesis in Fab 57P, specific for peptide 134 to 151 of the coat protein of tobacco mosaic virus. The 13 single mutants were analysed by Western blot to determine the effect of interface modifications on Fab expression. The kinetic rate constants of peptide-Fab mutant interactions were measured using the biosensor technology. Alanine replacements did not prevent assembly of the mutated Fabs and led to a modification of their binding properties in every case. Twelve of the 13 target residues correspond to homologous positions in the VL and VH domains, which have similar folds. Mutation at homologous positions mostly had different effects on antigen binding affinity. The replacement of bulky side-chains had the most drastic effect on binding. When smaller side-chains were replaced by alanine, the binding properties of Fab mutants differed slightly (by less than a factor of two), but significantly from that of Fab 57P. Modification of some of these residues, which are located 9 to 12 A away from the base of CDR loops, is unlikely to alter loop conformation. They may affect antigen binding indirectly by influencing the relative position of the VL and VH domains. Our results demonstrate that residues situated at the VL-VH interface and which are remote from the paratope are able to influence the antigen binding properties of antibodies.

Comparative interaction kinetics of two recombinant Fabs and of the corresponding antibodies directed to the coat protein of tobacco mosaic virus.

Two recombinant Fab fragments, 57P and 174P, recognizing peptide 134-146 of the coat protein of tobacco mosaic virus have been cloned, sequenced and expressed in Escherichia coli. They differ by 15 amino acid changes in the sequence of their variable region. The interaction kinetics of the Fabs with the wild-type and four mutant peptides have been compared using a BIAcoreTM biosensor instrument. The recombinant Fab 174P had the same reactivity as the Fab fragment obtained by enzymatic cleavage of monoclonal antibody 174P. The two recombinant Fabs recognized the various peptides in the same ranking order but Fab 174P consistently dissociated somewhat faster from the peptides compared to Fab 57P. The two whole antibodies showed the same relative differences in reactivity as the two recombinant Fabs. The location of amino acid changes was visualized on a model structure of the Fab. Differences in dissociation rates of the two antibodies are most likely due to changes located at the periphery of the antigen-combining site and/or at the interface between the light and heavy chain domains. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of detecting very small differences in binding affinity by the biosensor technology, which is a prerequisite for assessing the functional effect of limited structural changes.

Codon-based combinatorial alanine scanning site-directed mutagenesis: design, implementation, and polymerase chain reaction screening.

Combinatorial alanine scanning mutagenesis is a powerful tool for the exploration of protein structure-function relationships. Unfortunately, combinatorial alanine replacement of multiple residues using standard site-directed mutagenesis is restricted to a subset of amino acids. To circumvent this limitation, an efficient procedure for combinatorial site-specific replacement by alanine of any residue in a given protein sequence has been established. The method, which involves simple procedures and commonly used materials, is based upon the use of codon-based mutagenesis. A defined ratio of alanine to wild-type codon was introduced at each predetermined triplet using the "column-splitting" technique during oligonucleotide synthesis. High-throughout genetic screening of mutant libraries was facilitated by the incorporation of diagnostic restriction sites at targeted codons followed by a PCR-based screening procedure. The method was tested on a set of 13 residues located at the interface between the variable domains of a Fab fragment of an antibody. The occurrence of alanine substitution was found to be comparable to the statistically predicted distribution.

Structural and functional roles of asparagine 175 in the cysteine protease papain.

The role of the asparagine residue in the Cys-His-Asn "catalytic triad" of cysteine proteases has been investigated by replacing Asn175 in papain by alanine and glutamine using site-directed mutagenesis. The mutants were expressed in yeast and kinetic parameters determined against the substrate carbobenzoxy-L-phenylalanyl-(7-amino-4-methylcoumarinyl)- L-arginine. At the optimal pH of 6.5, the specificity constant (k(cat)/KM)obs was reduced by factors of 3.4 and 150 for the Asn175-->Gln and Asn175-->Ala mutants, respectively. Most of this effect was the result of a decrease in k(cat), as neither mutation significantly affected KM. Substrate hydrolysis by these mutants is still much faster than the non-catalytic rate, and therefore Asn175 cannot be considered as an essential catalytic residue in the cysteine protease papain. Detailed analyses of the pH activity profiles for both mutants allow the evaluation of the role of the Asn175 side chain on the stability of the active site ion pair and on the intrinsic activity of the enzyme. Alteration of the side chain at position 175 was also found to increase aggregation and proteolytic susceptibility of the proenzyme and to affect the thermal stability of the mature enzyme, reflecting a contribution of the asparagine residue to the structural integrity of papain. The strict conservation of Asn175 in cysteine proteases might therefore result from a combination of functional and structural constraints.

In vivo biotinylated recombinant antibodies: construction, characterization, and application of a bifunctional Fab-BCCP fusion protein produced in Escherichia coli.

We describe a novel vector system suitable for the efficient preparation of in vivo biotinylated antibody Fab fragments in Escherichia coli. The previously described pGE20 vector used for the functional expression of truncated heavy (Fd) and light (L) chains of Fab into the bacterial culture medium was modified by inserting the C-terminal 101-amino-acid polypeptide of the biotin carboxyl carrier protein subunit of E. coli acetyl-CoA carboxylase (BCCP*). The secreted Fd-BCCP* fusion and L chain proteins were found to be disulfide linked and Fab-BCCP* complexes of an IgG1 antibody (Mab4) to human tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF) were shown to retain both antigen and streptavidin-binding activities. The capacity of the Fab4 linked to BCCP* to bind TNF was identical to that observed with unmodified Fab4. Up to 15% of the expressed hybrids were able to interact with streptavidin when exogeneous d-biotin was added into the bacterial culture medium. The Fab4-BCCP* molecules were found to be more efficient than Fab4 linked to an engineered streptavidin-affinity tag for the detection of antigen on solid phase. In addition, we show here that the bacterially expressed Fab4-BCCP* complexes, adsorbed to streptavidin-agarose beads, can be used for the one-step purification of recombinant TNF by immunoaffinity chromatography.

Expression of functional papain precursor in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: rapid screening of mutants.

A microbial expression system for the study of the cysteine protease papain has been developed as a more useful alternative to the insect cell/baculovirus expression system we have previously used. A synthetic papain precursor (propapain) gene was expressed in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae under the control of the alpha-factor promoter. Efficient expression required fusion of the propapain sequence with the yeast alpha-factor prepro region and a yeast host cell defective in the synthesis of vacuolar proteases. Surprisingly, the glycosylated form of the inactive papain precursor is not secreted, but accumulates within the yeast cell. Complete conversion of the intracellular zymogen into active mature papain could be achieved in vitro. Purified recombinant papain produced by the yeast system has kinetic characteristics similar to those of the natural enzyme. An advantage of the yeast expression system over the baculovirus/insect cell system is that we can perform mutagenesis and screening of papain mutants very efficiently. We have set up a 'one-tube' screening procedure for the simultaneous characterization of numerous mutants of the papain precursor. Yeast cells are grown and lysed in microtiter plate wells and the released papain precursor is then activated to mature papain. This assay allows easy discrimination between proteins with close to wild type properties and proteins that are not functional. We have applied this assay to investigate the spectrum of amino acids which are tolerated at Asn175 of papain using two independently derived libraries of mutants at this position. Many amino acid substitutions at this position are not accepted; only the reintroduction of Asn restored normal function.