Structural determinants for activity of the antidepressant vortioxetine at human and rodent 5-HT3 receptors.

Vortioxetine (VTX) is a recently approved antidepressant that targets a variety of serotonin receptors. Here, we investigate the drug's molecular mechanism of operation at the serotonin 5-HT3 receptor (5-HT3R), which features two properties: VTX acts differently on rodent and human 5-HT3R, and VTX appears to suppress any subsequent response to agonists. Using a combination of cryo-EM, electrophysiology, voltage-clamp fluorometry and molecular dynamics, we show that VTX stabilizes a resting inhibited state of the mouse 5-HT3R and an agonist-bound-like state of human 5-HT3R, in line with the functional profile of the drug. We report four human 5-HT3R structures and show that the human receptor transmembrane domain is intrinsically fragile. We also explain the lack of recovery after VTX administration via a membrane partition mechanism.

How is Membrane Permeation of Small Ionizable Molecules Affected by Protonation Kinetics?

According to the pH-partition hypothesis, the aqueous solution adjacent to a membrane is a mixture of the ionization states of the permeating molecule at fixed Henderson-Hasselbalch concentrations, such that each state passes through the membrane in parallel with its own specific permeability. An alternative view, based on the assumption that the rate of switching ionization states is instantaneous, represents the permeation of ionizable molecules via an effective Boltzmann-weighted average potential (BWAP). Such an assumption is used in constant-pH molecular dynamics simulations. The inhomogeneous solubility-diffusion framework can be used to compute the pH-dependent membrane permeability for each of these two limiting treatments. With biased WTM-eABF molecular dynamics simulations, we computed the potential of mean force and diffusivity of each ionization state of two weakly basic small molecules: nicotine, an addictive drug, and varenicline, a therapeutic for treating nicotine addiction. At pH = 7, the BWAP effective permeability is greater than that determined by pH-partitioning by a factor of 2.5 for nicotine and 5 for varenicline. To assess the importance of ionization kinetics, we present a Smoluchowski master equation that includes explicitly the protonation and deprotonation processes coupled with the diffusive motion across the membrane. At pH = 7, the increase in permeability due to the explicit ionization kinetics is negligible for both nicotine and varenicline. This finding is reaffirmed by combined Brownian dynamics and Markov state model simulations for estimating the permeability of nicotine while allowing changes in its ionization state. We conclude that for these molecules the pH-partition hypothesis correctly captures the physics of the permeation process. The small free energy barriers for the permeation of nicotine and varenicline in their deprotonated neutral forms play a crucial role in establishing the validity of the pH-partitioning mechanism. Essentially, BWAP fails because ionization kinetics are too slow on the time scale of membrane crossing to affect the permeation of small ionizable molecules such as nicotine and varenicline. For the singly protonated state of nicotine, the computational results agree well with experimental measurements (P1 = 1.29 × 10-7 cm/s), but the agreement for neutral (P0 = 6.12 cm/s) and doubly protonated nicotine (P2 = 3.70 × 10-13 cm/s) is slightly worse, likely due to factors associated with the aqueous boundary layer (neutral form) or leaks through paracellular pathways (doubly protonated form).

Classifying Protein-Protein Binding Affinity with Free-Energy Calculations and Machine Learning Approaches.

Understanding the intricate phenomenon of neuronal wiring in the brain is of great interest in neuroscience. In the fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, the Dpr-DIP interactome has been identified to play an important role in this process. However, experimental data suggest that a merely limited subset of complexes, essentially 57 out of a total of 231, exhibit strong binding affinity. In this work, we sought to identify the residue-level molecular basis underlying the difference in binding affinity using a state-of-the-art methodology consisting of standard binding free-energy calculations with a geometrical route and machine learning (ML) techniques. We determined the binding affinity for two complexes using statistical mechanics simulations, achieving an excellent reproduction of the experimental data. Moreover, we predicted the binding free energy for two additional low-affinity complexes, devoid of experimental estimation, while simultaneously identifying key residues for the binding. Furthermore, through the use of ML algorithms, linear discriminant analysis, and random forest, we achieved remarkable accuracy, as high as 0.99, in discerning between strong (cognate) and weak (noncognate) binders. The presented ML approach encompasses easily transferable input features, enabling its broad application to any interactome while facilitating the identification of pivotal residues critical for binding interactions. The predictive power of the generated model was probed on similar protein families from 13 diverse species. Our ML model exhibited commendable performance on these additional data sets, showcasing its reliability and robustness across the species barrier.

Impact of the Unstirred Water Layer on the Permeation of Small-Molecule Drugs.

Over the last two decades, numerous molecular dynamics (MD) simulation-based investigations have attempted to predict the membrane permeability to small-molecule drugs as indicators of their bioavailability, a majority of which utilize the inhomogeneous solubility diffusion (ISD) model. However, MD-based membrane permeability is routinely 3-4 orders of magnitude larger than the values measured with the intestinal perfusion technique. There have been contentious discussions on the sources of the large discrepancies, and the two indisputable, potentially dominant ones are the fixed protonation state of the permeant and the neglect of the unstirred water layer (UWL). Employing six small-molecule drugs of different biopharmaceutical classification system classes, the current MD study relies on the ISD model but introduces the (de)protonation of the permeant by characterizing the permeation free energy of both neutral and charged states. In addition, the role of the UWL as a potential resistance against permeation is explored. The new MD protocol closely mimics the nature of small-molecule permeation and yields estimates that agree well with in vivo intestinal permeability.

A Rigorous Framework for Calculating Protein-Protein Binding Affinities in Membranes.

Calculating the binding free energy of integral transmembrane (TM) proteins is crucial for understanding the mechanisms by which they recognize one another and reversibly associate. The glycophorin A (GpA) homodimer, composed of two α-helical segments, has long served as a model system for studying TM protein reversible association. The present work establishes a methodological framework for calculating the binding affinity of the GpA homodimer in the heterogeneous environment of a membrane. Our investigation carefully considered a variety of protocols, including the appropriate choice of the force field, rigorous standardization reflecting the experimental conditions, sampling algorithm, anisotropic environment, and collective variables, to accurately describe GpA dimerization via molecular dynamics-based approaches. Specifically, two strategies were explored: (i) an unrestrained potential mean force (PMF) calculation, which merely enhances sampling along the separation of the two binding partners without any restraint, and (ii) a so-called "geometrical route", whereby the α-helices are progressively separated with imposed restraints on their orientational, positional, and conformational degrees of freedom to accelerate convergence. Our simulations reveal that the simplified, unrestrained PMF approach is inadequate for the description of GpA dimerization. Instead, the geometrical route, tailored specifically to GpA in a membrane environment, yields excellent agreement with experimental data within a reasonable computational time. A dimerization free energy of -10.7 kcal/mol is obtained, in fairly good agreement with available experimental data. The geometrical route further helps elucidate how environmental forces drive association before helical interactions stabilize it. Our simulations also brought to light a distinct, long-lived spatial arrangement that potentially serves as an intermediate state during dimer formation. The methodological advances in the generalized geometrical route provide a powerful tool for accurate and efficient binding-affinity calculations of intricate TM protein complexes in inhomogeneous environments.

Standard Binding Free-Energy Calculations: How Far Are We from Automation?

Recent success stories suggest that in silico protein-ligand binding free-energy calculations are approaching chemical accuracy. However, their widespread application remains limited by the extensive human intervention required, posing challenges for the neophyte. As such, it is critical to develop automated workflows for estimating protein-ligand binding affinities with minimum personal involvement. Key human efforts include setting up and tuning enhanced-sampling or alchemical-transformation algorithms as a preamble to computational binding free-energy estimations. Additionally, preparing input files, bookkeeping, and postprocessing represent nontrivial tasks. In this Perspective, we discuss recent progress in automating standard binding free-energy calculations, featuring the development of adaptive or parameter-free algorithms, standardization of binding free-energy calculation workflows, and the implementation of user-friendly software. We also assess the current state of automated standard binding free-energy calculations and evaluate the limitations of existing methods. Last, we outline the requirements for future algorithms and workflows to facilitate automated free-energy calculations for diverse protein-ligand complexes.

Chasing collective variables using temporal data-driven strategies.

The convergence of free-energy calculations based on importance sampling depends heavily on the choice of collective variables (CVs), which in principle, should include the slow degrees of freedom of the biological processes to be investigated. Autoencoders (AEs), as emerging data-driven dimension reduction tools, have been utilised for discovering CVs. AEs, however, are often treated as black boxes, and what AEs actually encode during training, and whether the latent variables from encoders are suitable as CVs for further free-energy calculations remains unknown. In this contribution, we review AEs and their time-series-based variants, including time-lagged AEs (TAEs) and modified TAEs, as well as the closely related model variational approach for Markov processes networks (VAMPnets). We then show through numerical examples that AEs learn the high-variance modes instead of the slow modes. In stark contrast, time series-based models are able to capture the slow modes. Moreover, both modified TAEs with extensions from slow feature analysis and the state-free reversible VAMPnets (SRVs) can yield orthogonal multidimensional CVs. As an illustration, we employ SRVs to discover the CVs of the isomerizations of N-acetyl-N'-methylalanylamide and trialanine by iterative learning with trajectories from biased simulations. Last, through numerical experiments with anisotropic diffusion, we investigate the potential relationship of time-series-based models and committor probabilities.

Predictions from First-Principles of Membrane Permeability to Small Molecules: How Useful Are They in Practice?

Predicting from first-principles the rate of passive permeation of small molecules across the biological membrane represents a promising strategy for screening lead compounds upstream in the drug-discovery and development pipeline. One popular avenue for the estimation of permeation rates rests on computer simulations in conjunction with the inhomogeneous solubility-diffusion model, which requires the determination of the free-energy change and position-dependent diffusivity of the substrate along the translocation pathway through the lipid bilayer. In this Perspective, we will clarify the physical meaning of the membrane permeability inferred from such computer simulations, and how theoretical predictions actually relate to what is commonly measured experimentally. We will also examine why these calculations remain both technically challenging and overly computationally expensive, which has hitherto precluded their routine use in nonacademic settings. We finally synopsize possible research directions to meet these challenges, increase the predictive power of physics-based rates of passive permeation, and, by ricochet, improve their practical usefulness.

Discovering Reaction Pathways, Slow Variables, and Committor Probabilities with Machine Learning.

A significant challenge faced by atomistic simulations is the difficulty, and often impossibility, to sample the transitions between metastable states of the free-energy landscape associated with slow molecular processes. Importance-sampling schemes represent an appealing option to accelerate the underlying dynamics by smoothing out the relevant free-energy barriers, but require the definition of suitable reaction-coordinate (RC) models expressed in terms of compact low-dimensional sets of collective variables (CVs). While most computational studies of slow molecular processes have traditionally relied on educated guesses based on human intuition to reduce the dimensionality of the problem at hand, a variety of machine-learning (ML) algorithms have recently emerged as powerful alternatives to discover meaningful CVs capable of capturing the dynamics of the slowest degrees of freedom. Considering a simple paradigmatic situation in which the long-time dynamics is dominated by the transition between two known metastable states, we compare two variational data-driven ML methods based on Siamese neural networks aimed at discovering a meaningful RC model─the slowest decorrelating CV of the molecular process, and the committor probability to first reach one of the two metastable states. One method is the state-free reversible variational approach for Markov processes networks (VAMPnets), or SRVs─the other, inspired by the transition path theory framework, is the variational committor-based neural networks, or VCNs. The relationship and the ability of these methodologies to discover the relevant descriptors of the slow molecular process of interest are illustrated with a series of simple model systems. We also show that both strategies are amenable to importance-sampling schemes through an appropriate reweighting algorithm that approximates the kinetic properties of the transition.

Improving Speed and Affordability without Compromising Accuracy: Standard Binding Free-Energy Calculations Using an Enhanced Sampling Algorithm, Multiple-Time Stepping, and Hydrogen Mass Repartitioning.

Accurate evaluation of protein-ligand binding free energies in silico is of paramount importance for understanding the mechanisms of biological regulation and providing a theoretical basis for drug design and discovery. Based on a series of atomistic molecular dynamics simulations in an explicit solvent, using well-tempered metadynamics extended adaptive biasing force (WTM-eABF) as an enhanced sampling algorithm, the so-called "geometrical route" offers a rigorous theoretical framework for binding affinity calculations that match experimental values. However, although robust, this strategy remains expensive, requiring substantial computational time to achieve convergence of the simulations. Improving the efficiency of the geometrical route, while preserving its reliability through improved ergodic sampling, is, therefore, highly desirable. In this contribution, having identified the computational bottleneck of the geometrical route, to accelerate the calculations we combine (i) a longer time step for the integration of the equations of motion with hydrogen-mass repartitioning (HMR), and (ii) multiple time-stepping (MTS) for collective-variable and biasing-force evaluation. Altogether, we performed 50 independent WTM-eABF simulations in triplicate for the "physical" separation of the Abl kinase-SH3 domain:p41 complex, following different HMR and MTS schemes, while tuning, in distinct protocols, the parameters of the enhanced-sampling algorithm. To demonstrate the consistency and reliability of the results obtained with the best-performing setups, we carried out quintuple simulations. Furthermore, we demonstrated the transferability of our method to other complexes by triplicating a 200 ns separation simulation of nine chosen protocols for the MDM2-p53:NVP-CGM097 complex. [Holzer et al. J. Med. Chem. 2015, 58, 6348-6358.] Our results, based on an aggregate simulation time of 14.4 µs, allowed an optimal set of parameters to be identified, able to accelerate convergence by a factor of three without any noticeable loss of accuracy.

Achieving Accurate Standard Protein-Protein Binding Free Energy Calculations through the Geometrical Route and Ergodic Sampling.

A new strategy for the prediction of binding free energies of protein-protein complexes is reported in the present article. By combining an ergodic-sampling algorithm with the so-called "geometrical route", which introduces a series of geometrical restraints as a preamble to the physical separation of the two partners, we achieve accurate binding free energy calculations for medium-sized protein-protein complexes within the microsecond timescale. The ergodic-sampling algorithm, namely, Gaussian-accelerated molecular dynamics (GaMD), implicitly helps explore the conformational change of the two binding partners as they associate reversibly by raising the energy wells. Therefore, independent simulations capturing the isomerization of proteins are no longer needed, reducing both the computational cost and human effort. Numerical applications indicate errors on the order of 0.1 kcal/mol for the Abl-SH3 domain binding a decapeptide, of 2.6 kcal/mol for the barnase-barstar complex, and of 0.2 kcal/mol for human leukocyte elastase binding the third domain of the turkey ovomucoid inhibitor. Compared with the classical geometrical route, which resorts to collective variables to describe the isomerization of proteins, our new strategy possesses remarkable convergence properties and robustness for protein-protein complexes owing to improved ergodic sampling. We are confident that the strategy presented in this study will have a broad range of applications, helping us understand recognition-association phenomena in the areas of physical, biological, and medicinal chemistry.

Free Energy Methods for the Description of Molecular Processes.

Efforts to combine theory and experiment to advance our knowledge of molecular processes relevant to biophysics have been considerably enhanced by the contribution of statistical-mechanics simulations. Key to the understanding of such molecular processes is the underlying free-energy change. Being able to accurately predict this change from first principles represents an appealing prospect. Over the past decades, the synergy between steadily growing computational resources and unrelenting methodological developments has brought free-energy calculations into the arsenal of tools commonly utilized to tackle important questions that experiment alone has left unresolved. The continued emergence of new options to determine free energies has also bred confusion amid the community of users, who may find it difficult to choose the best-suited algorithm to address the problem at hand. In an attempt to clarify the current landscape, this review recounts how the field has been shaped and how the broad gamut of methods available today is rooted in a few foundational principles laid down many years ago.Three examples of molecular processes central to biophysics illustrate where free-energy calculations stand and what are the conceptual and practical obstacles that we must overcome to increase their predictive power.

Enhancing sampling with free-energy calculations.

In recent years, considerable progress has been made to enhance sampling and help address biological questions, including, but not limited to conformational transitions in biomolecules and protein-ligand reversible binding, hitherto intractable by brute-force computer simulations. Many of these advances result from the development of a palette of methods aimed at exploring rare events through reliable free-energy calculations. The advent of new, often conceptually related methods has also rendered difficult the choice of the best suited option for a given problem. Here, we focus on geometrical transformations and algorithms designed to enhance sampling along adequately chosen progress variables, tracing their theoretical foundations, and showing how they are connected and can be blended together for improved performance.

When the Dust Has Settled: Calculation of Binding Affinities from First Principles for SARS-CoV-2 Variants with Quantitative Accuracy.

Accurate determination of binding free energy is pivotal for the study of many biological processes and has been applied in a number of theoretical investigations to compare the affinity of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 variants toward the host cell. Diversity of these variants challenges the development of effective general therapies, their transmissibility relying either on an increased affinity toward their dedicated human receptor, the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2), or on escaping the immune response. Now that robust structural data are available, we have determined with utmost accuracy the standard binding free energy of the receptor-binding domain to the most widespread variants, namely, Alpha, Beta, Delta, and Omicron BA.2, as well as the wild type (WT) in complex either with ACE2 or with antibodies, namely, S2E12 and H11-D4, using a rigorous theoretical framework that combines molecular dynamics and potential-of-mean-force calculations. Our results show that an appropriate starting structure is crucial to ensure appropriate reproduction of the binding affinity, allowing the variants to be compared. They also emphasize the necessity to apply the relevant methodology, bereft of any shortcut, to account for all the contributions to the standard binding free energy. Our estimates of the binding affinities support the view that while the Alpha and Beta variants lean on an increased affinity toward the host cell, the Delta and Omicron BA.2 variants choose immune escape. Moreover, the S2E12 antibody, already known to be active against the WT (Starr et al., 2021; Mlcochova et al., 2021), proved to be equally effective against the Delta variant. In stark contrast, H11-D4 retains a low affinity toward the WT compared to that of ACE2 for the latter. Assuming robust structural information, the methodology employed herein successfully addresses the challenging protein-protein binding problem in the context of coronavirus disease 2019 while offering promising perspectives for predictive studies of ever-emerging variants.

Committor-Consistent Variational String Method.

The treatment of slow and rare transitions in the simulation of complex systems poses a great computational challenge. A powerful approach to tackle this challenge is the string method, which represents the transition path as a one-dimensional curve in a multidimensional space of collective variables. Commonly used strategies for pathway optimization include aligning the tangent of the string to the local mean force or to the mean drift determined from swarms of short trajectories. Here, a novel strategy is proposed, allowing the string to be optimized based on a variational principle involving the unidirectional reactive flux expressed in terms of the time-correlation function of the committor. The method is illustrated with model systems and then probed with the alanine dipeptide and a coarse-grained model of the barstar-barnase protein complex. Successive iterations variationally refine the string toward an optimal transition pathway following the gradient of the committor between two metastable states.

Galvani Offset Potential and Constant-pH Simulations of Membrane Proteins.

A central problem in computational biophysics is the treatment of titratable residues in molecular dynamics simulations of large biological macromolecular systems. Conventional simulation methods ascribe a fixed ionization state to titratable residues in accordance with their pKa and the pH of the system, assuming that an effective average model will be able to capture the predominant behavior of the system. While this assumption may be justifiable in many cases, it is certainly limited, and it is important to design alternative methodologies allowing a more realistic treatment. Constant-pH simulation methods provide powerful approaches to handle titratable residues more realistically by allowing the ionization state to vary statistically during the simulation. Extending the molecular mechanical (MM) potential energy function to a family of potential functions accounting for different ionization states, constant-pH simulations are designed to sample all accessible configurations and ionization states, properly weighted according to their Boltzmann factor. Because protonation and deprotonation events correspond to a change in the total charge, difficulties arise when the long-range Coulomb interaction is treated on the basis of an idealized infinite simulation model and periodic boundary conditions with particle-mesh Ewald lattice sums. Charging free-energy calculations performed under these conditions in aqueous solution depend on the Galvani potential of the bulk water phase. This has important implications for the equilibrium and nonequilibrium constant-pH simulation methods grounded in the relative free-energy difference corresponding to the protonated and unprotonated residues. Here, the effect of the Galvani potential is clarified, and a simple practical solution is introduced to address this issue in constant-pH simulations of the acid-sensing ion channel (ASIC).

Perforin-2 clockwise hand-over-hand pre-pore to pore transition mechanism.

Perforin-2 (PFN2, MPEG1) is a pore-forming protein that acts as a first line of defense in the mammalian immune system, rapidly killing engulfed microbes within the phagolysosome in macrophages. PFN2 self-assembles into hexadecameric pre-pore rings that transition upon acidification into pores damaging target cell membranes. Here, using high-speed atomic force microscopy (HS-AFM) imaging and line-scanning and molecular dynamics simulation, we elucidate PFN2 pre-pore to pore transition pathways and dynamics. Upon acidification, the pre-pore rings (pre-pore-I) display frequent, 1.8 s-1, ring-opening dynamics that eventually, 0.2 s-1, initiate transition into an intermediate, short-lived, ~75 ms, pre-pore-II state, inducing a clockwise pre-pore-I to pre-pore-II propagation. Concomitantly, the first pre-pore-II subunit, undergoes a major conformational change to the pore state that propagates also clockwise at a rate ~15 s-1. Thus, the pre-pore to pore transition is a clockwise hand-over-hand mechanism that is accomplished within ~1.3 s. Our findings suggest a clockwise mechanism of membrane insertion that with variations may be general for the MACPF/CDC superfamily.