Structure of the C-terminal sterile alpha-motif (SAM) domain of human p73 alpha.

p73 is a homologue of the tumour suppressor p53 and contains all three functional domains of p53. The alpha-splice variant of p73 (p73 alpha) contains near its C-terminus an additional structural domain known as the sterile alpha-motif (SAM) that is probably responsible for regulating p53-like functions of p73. Here, the 2.54 A resolution crystal structure of this protein domain is reported. The crystal structure and the published solution structure have the same five-helix bundle fold that is characteristic of all SAM-domain structures, with an overall r.m.s.d. of 1.5 A for main-chain atoms. The hydrophobic core residues are well conserved, yet some large local differences are observed. The crystal structure reveals a dimeric organization, with the interface residues forming a mini four-helix bundle. However, analysis of solvation free energies and the surface area buried upon dimer formation indicated that this arrangement is more likely to be an effect of crystal packing rather than reflecting a physiological state. This is consistent with the solution structure being a monomer. The p73 alpha SAM domain also contains several interesting structural features: a Cys-X-X-Cys motif, a 3(10)-helix and a loop that have elevated B factors, and short tight inter-helical loops including two beta-turns; these elements are probably important in the normal function of this domain.

Ligand-independent assembly of recombinant human CD1 by using oxidative refolding chromatography.

CD1 is an MHC class I-like antigen-presenting molecule consisting of a heavy chain and beta(2)-microglobulin light chain. The in vitro refolding of synthetic MHC class I molecules has always required the presence of ligand. We report here the use of a folding method using an immobilized chaperone fragment, a protein disulphide isomerase, and a peptidyl-prolyl cis-trans isomerase (oxidative refolding chromatography) for the fast and efficient assembly of ligand-free and ligand-associated CD1a and CD1b, starting with material synthesized in Escherichia coli. The results suggest that "empty" MHC class I-like molecules can assemble and remain stable at physiological temperatures in the absence of ligand. The use of oxidative refolding chromatography thus is extended to encompass complex multisubunit proteins and specifically to members of the extensive, functionally diverse and important immunoglobulin supergene family of proteins, including those for which a ligand has yet to be identified.

From minichaperone to GroEL 3: properties of an active single-ring mutant of GroEL.

The next step in our reductional analysis of GroEL was to study the activity of an isolated single seven-membered ring of the 14-mer. A known single-ring mutant, GroEL(SR1), contains four point mutations that prevent the formation of double-rings. That heptameric complex is functionally inactive because it is unable to release GroES. We found that the mutation E191G, which is responsible for the temperature sensitive (ts) Escherichia coli allele groEL44 and is located in the hinge region between the intermediate and apical domains of GroEL, appears to function by weakening the binding of GroES, without destabilizing the overall structure of GroEL44 mutant. We introduced, therefore, the mutation E191G into GroEL(SR1) in order to generate a single-ring mutant that may have weaker binding of GroES and hence be active. The new single-ring mutant, GroEL(SR44), was indeed effective in refolding both heat and dithiothreitol-denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase with great efficiency. Further, unlike all smaller constructs of GroEL, the expression of GroEL(SR44) in E. coli that contained no endogenous GroEL restored biological viability, but not as efficiently as does wild-type GroEL. We envisage the notional evolution of the structure and properties of GroEL. The minichaperone core acts as a primitive chaperone by providing a binding surface for denatured states that prevents their self-aggregation. The assembly of seven minichaperones into a ring then enhances substrate binding by introducing avidity. The acquisition of binding sites for ATP then allows the modulation of substrate binding by introducing the allosteric mechanism that causes cycling between strong and weak binding sites. This is accompanied by the acquisition by the heptamer of the binding of GroES, which functions as a lid to the central cavity and competes for peptide binding sites. Finally, dimerization of the heptamer enhances its biological activity.

Design of highly stable functional GroEL minichaperones.

GroEL minichaperones have potential in the biotechnology industry for the refolding of recombinant proteins. With the aim of enhancing and widening their use, we have created two highly stable functional variants of minichaperone GroEL(193-345). A sequence alignment of 130 members of the chaperonin 60 (Cpn60) family was used to design 37 single mutations. Two small-to-large mutations, A223T, A223V and one similar-size mutation, M233L, all located in the hydrophobic core were found to stabilize the protein by more than 1 kcal mol(-1) each. Six stabilizing mutations were combined, yielding two multiple mutants that were 6.99 and 6.15 kcal mol(-1) more stable than wild-type protein. Even though some of the substituted residue pairs are close to each other in the protein structure, the energetic effects of mutation are approximately additive. In particular, the stabilizing substitution A223T is unexpected and would have been missed by purely structural analysis. In the light of previously reported successes employing similar methods with several other proteins, our results show that a homology based approach is a simple and efficient method of increasing the stability of a protein.

An irregular beta-bulge common to a group of bacterial RNases is an important determinant of stability and function in barnase.

Single amino acid residue substitutions rarely destroy the structural integrity of proteins. Substitution of glycine residues, however, is among the few sorts of alterations that can have such an effect. Here, we seek to understand what accounts for the extreme functional impairment of the bacterial ribonuclease barnase upon substitution of Gly52 or Gly53. We find that inactivation is caused by overall disruption of the folded state that manifests itself in three ways: (1) dramatically reduced stability (by 5.2 to 8.4 kcal mol-1 for mutants showing inactivation in vivo); (2) progressive loss of folded-state activity with increasing temperature, indicating a less well formed fold; and (3) substantial proteolytic degradation of mutant enzymes in vivo. Examination of two deletion mutants, missing either Gly53 or Asp54, shows that the irregular beta-bulge formed by these two residues is of vital importance to the structural integrity of barnase. The parallel behaviour of mutants carrying replacements of either of the two glycine residues therefore appears to arise from a common mechanism: disruption of local structure at the beta-bulge. The importance of this structural element to the function of barnase raises the question of whether it may be present in other RNases. The Streptomyces enzymes RNase Sa and RNase St differ considerably from barnase in both sequence and structure, yet both show significant sequence similarity to barnase over a region beginning at Gly53. Structural comparison indicates that the Streptomyces enzymes do have the barnase-like irregular beta-bulge, making this an important characteristic feature of a group of bacterial ribonucleases. The sensitivity of this feature demonstrates that detailed aspects of local structure may have a major role in determining the overall structural and functional properties of an enzyme, even where no explanation for this role is readily apparent. If this is a general characteristic of the structure-function relationship, it may pose a formidable obstacle to the de novo design of new enzymes.

A search for single substitutions that eliminate enzymatic function in a bacterial ribonuclease.

Exhaustive-substitution studies, where many amino acid replacements are individually tested at all positions in a natural protein, have proven to be very valuable in probing the relationship between sequence and function. The broad picture that has emerged from studies of this sort is one of functional tolerance of substitution. We have applied this approach to barnase, a 110-residue bacterial ribonuclease. Because the selection system used to score barnase mutants as active or inactive detects activity down to a level that can be approached by nonenzyme catalysts, mutants that test inactive are essentially devoid of enzymatic function. Of the 109 barnase positions subjected to substitution, only 15 (14%) are vulnerable to this extreme level of inactivation, and only 2 could not be substituted without such inactivation. A total of 33 substitutions (amounting to 5% of the explored substitutions) were found to render barnase wholly inactive. The profoundly disruptive effects of all of these inactivating substitutions appear to result from either (1) replacement of a side chain that is directly involved in substrate binding or catalysis, (2) replacement of a substantially buried side chain, (3) introduction of a proline residue, or (4) replacement of a glycine residue. Although substitutions of these types are functionally tolerated more often than not, the system used here indicates that only these sorts of substitution are capable of single-handedly reducing catalytic function to, or nearly to, levels that can be achieved by nonenzyme catalysts.

Active barnase variants with completely random hydrophobic cores.

The central structural feature of natural proteins is a tightly packed and highly ordered hydrophobic core. If some measure of exquisite, native-like core packing is necessary for enzymatic function, this would constitute a significant obstacle to the development of novel enzymes, either by design or by natural or experimental evolution. To test the minimum requirements for a core to provide sufficient structural integrity for enzymatic activity, we have produced mutants of the ribonuclease barnase in which 12 of the 13 core residues have together been randomly replaced by hydrophobic alternatives. Using a sensitive biological screen, we find that a strikingly high proportion of these mutants (23%) retain enzymatic activity in vivo. Further substitution at the 13th core position shows that a similar proportion of completely random hydrophobic cores supports enzyme function. Of the active mutants produced, several have no wild-type core residues. These results imply that hydrophobicity is nearly a sufficient criterion for the construction of a functional core and, in conjunction with previous studies, that refinement of a crudely functional core entails more stringent sequence constraints than does the initial attainment of crude core function. Since attainment of crude function is the critical initial step in evolutionary innovation, the relatively scant requirements contributed by the hydrophobic core would greatly reduce the initial hurdle on the evolutionary pathway to novel enzymes. Similarly, experimental development of novel functional proteins might be simplified by limiting core design to mere specification of hydrophobicity and using iterative mutation-selection to optimize core structure.