Looking at COVID-19 effects on intimate partner and sexual violence organizations in Canada through a feminist political economy lens: a qualitative study.

OBJECTIVES: Intimate partner violence and sexual violence organizations such as women's shelters play a crucial role in advancing gender equality in Canada. COVID-19 has challenged how such organizations operate. This study explored how intimate partner violence and sexual violence organizations in Canada have been affected by COVID-19 and the consequences on service delivery. METHODS: We interviewed 17 frontline and management staff from intimate partner violence and sexual violence organizations and programs across Canada, and analyzed the data using thematic analysis and applying a feminist political economy lens. RESULTS: We identified the following themes: (1) Adapting; (2) Struggling financially; (3) Resourcefulness; (4) Troubles connecting; (5) Narrowing scope of work; and (6) Burden of care. CONCLUSION: A feminist political economy framework considers the gendered impact of the pandemic and related measures on the workforce. Both the pandemic and measures to control it have affected intimate partner violence and sexual violence organizations in Canada, the staff working in these organizations, and the quality of relationships between staff and clients. Intimate partner and sexual violence organizations in Canada have been chronically underfunded and their predominantly female staff underpaid, affecting their ability to meet the needs of women. The onset of COVID-19 not only worsened these issues but converged with a shift in focus to more pandemic-related tasks, further limiting the scope and reach of organizations. Whether the adaptations, innovations, and perseverance demonstrated by such organizations and staff can tip the balance in favour of more equitable policy and outcomes remains to be seen.

RéSUMé: OBJECTIFS: Les organismes de lutte contre la violence conjugale et la violence sexuelle, comme les hébergements pour femmes, jouent un rôle crucial dans la promotion de l'égalité des genres au Canada. La COVID-19 a remis en question le mode de fonctionnement de ces organisations. Cette étude a examiné la manière dont les organismes de lutte contre la violence conjugale et sexuelle au Canada ont été affectés par la COVID-19 et les conséquences sur la prestation de services. MéTHODES: Nous avons mené des entrevues avec 17 intervenantes de première ligne et membres de la direction d'organismes et de programmes de lutte contre la violence conjugale et sexuelle à travers le Canada. Les données ont été analysées à l'aide d'une analyse thématique et en appliquant une optique d'économie politique féministe. RéSULTATS: Nous avons identifié les thèmes suivants : 1) adaptation; 2) difficultés financières; 3) ingéniosité; 4) difficultés à établir des liens; 5) réduction du champ d'action; et 6) charge de travail. CONCLUSION: Un cadre d'économie politique féministe permet d'examiner l'impact genré de la pandémie et des mesures connexes sur le personnel. La pandémie a eu des répercussions sur les organismes de lutte contre la violence conjugale et la violence sexuelle au Canada, sur le personnel qui y travaille et sur la qualité des relations entre le personnel et les clients. Les organisations de lutte contre la violence ont souffert d'un sous-financement chronique et leur personnel, majoritairement féminin, a été sous-payé, ce qui a nui à leur capacité de répondre aux besoins des femmes. L'apparition du COVID-19 a non seulement aggravé ces problèmes, mais a aussi entraîné un changement d'orientation vers des tâches plus liées à la pandémie, ce qui a limité encore davantage le champ d'action des organismes. Il reste à voir si les adaptations, les innovations et la persévérance dont font preuve ces organisations et leur personnel peuvent faire pencher la balance en faveur d'une politique et de résultats plus équitables.

Service provider perspectives on how COVID-19 and pandemic restrictions have affected intimate partner and sexual violence survivors in Canada: a qualitative study.

BACKGROUND: The COVID-19 pandemic may increase risk of intimate partner and sexual violence and make relevant services less accessible. This study explored the perspectives of intimate partner and sexual violence workers across Canada on how the COVID-19 pandemic has affected the survivors with whom they work. METHODS: Using a qualitative descriptive design, we interviewed 17 management and frontline staff of organizations supporting survivors of intimate partner and sexual violence across Canada. RESULTS: We identified 4 themes that describe the impacts of COVID-19 on intimate partner and sexual violence survivors, from the perspective of service providers: (1) No escape; (2) Isolation; (3) Tough decisions; and (4) Heightened vulnerability. These narrative findings are presented first, followed by an analysis within a social determinants of health framework. Interpreting our findings against such a framework revealed a complex interplay of social determinants, notably social support, access to services, and poverty, that produced several challenges for intimate partner and sexual violence survivors during COVID-19. CONCLUSION: According to service providers, intimate partner and sexual violence survivors in Canada faced several challenges during the pandemic, including reduced ability to escape their situations, increased isolation, increasingly complex decisions, and heightened vulnerability. Our findings demonstrate the critical need to adopt a broader, more holistic approach in tackling  intimate partner and sexual violence by also addressing socioeconomic issues such as poverty and marginalization.