Multiple, simultaneous, independent gradients for a versatile multidimensional liquid chromatography. Part II: Application 3 - Scouting optimization strategies for separation of monoclonal antibodies by dual simultaneous independent gradients of pH & salt on a weak cation exchange stationary phase.

In previous publications we have described the pISep dual simultaneous, independent gradients (DSIGs) liquid chromatography (LC) for uncoupling gradients of non-buffering solute (NaCl, urea or acetonitrile) from externally generated pH gradients. In DSIGs the shape and slope of the [salute] gradient does not depend on the shape and slope of the pH gradient. The technique allows in a single run true simultaneous two dimensional LC separation of complex protein mixtures on various stationary phases including anion, cation exchangers (AEX, CEX), reversed phase (RP), mixed mode and mixed bed. Using a humanized IgG1 (HIgG1) monoclonal antibody (MAb) and a variety of pH & [NaCl] DSIGs, we show that most of MAb isoforms can be successfully separated from each other. These experimental observations are supported by an initial theoretical argument presented here predicting an overall improvement of all MAb isoforms separation by DSIGs of pH & [NaCl]. Theoretical calculations predict that, in general, there exists an optimal non-zero isocratic salt concentration in a pH gradient separation that will resolve isoforms close in binding energy, but a wide range of salt concentrations will be required for acceptable resolution of all isoforms. Theory also predicts better separation of weaker rather than stronger binding isoforms. Experimentally, we have found that no one set of DSIGs LC conditions could optimally baseline resolve all identifiable MAb isoforms in a single run of reasonable duration. The versatility and simplicity of the pH & [NaCl] pISep DSIGs LC allows fast, automated scouting of protein separations over any range of pH from 2.4 to 10.8 and [NaCl] from 0 to 1 M without changing the chemistry of the buffering system. Due to the universal applicability of the pISep buffering system in IEX LC, the researcher is given a powerful tool to easily develop pH & [NaCl] DSIGs protocols that vary mobile phase compositions to achieve high resolution separations of targeted proteins.

Multiple, simultaneous, independent gradients for a versatile multidimensional liquid chromatography. Part II: Application 2: Computer controlled pH gradients in the presence of urea provide improved separation of proteins: Stability influenced anion and cation exchange chromatography.

This paper details the use of a method of creating controlled pH gradients (pISep) to improve the separation of protein isoforms on ion exchange (IEX) stationary phases in the presence of various isocratic levels of urea. The pISep technology enables the development of computer controlled pH gradients on both cationic (CEX) and anionic (AEX) IEX stationary phases over the very wide pH range from 2 to 12. In pISep, titration curves generated by proportional mixing of the acidic and basic pISep working buffers alone, or in the presence of non-buffering solutes such as the neutral salt NaCl (0-1M), polar organics such as urea (0-8M) or acetonitrile (0-80 Vol%), can be fitted with high fidelity using high order polynomials which, in turn allows construction of a mathematical manifold %A (% acidic pISep buffer) vs. pH vs. [non-buffering solute], permitting precise computer control of pH and the non-buffering solute concentration allowing formation of dual uncoupled liquid chromatographic (LC) gradients of arbitrary shape (Hirsh and Tsonev, 2012 [1]). The separation of protein isoforms examined in this paper by use of such pH gradients in the presence of urea demonstrates the fractionation power of a true single step two dimensional liquid chromatography which we denote as Stability-Influenced Ion Exchange Chromatography (SIIEX). We present evidence that SIIEX is capable of increasing the resolution of protein isoforms difficult to separate by ordinary pH gradient IEX, and potentially simplifying the development of laboratory and production purification strategies involving on-column simultaneous pH and urea unfolding or refolding of targeted proteins. We model some of the physics implied by the dynamics of the observed protein fractionations as a function of both urea concentration and pH assuming that urea-induced native state unfolding competes with native state electrostatic interaction binding to an IEX stationary phase. Implications for in vivo protein-membrane interactions are discussed.

Multiple, simultaneous, independent gradients for a versatile multidimensional liquid chromatography. Part II: Application 1 - Large increases in isoform resolution of human transferrin by use of dual simultaneous independent gradients of pH & acetonitrile on a mixed bed (anion exchange plus reversed phase) stationary phase.

We have previously described a liquid chromatographic (LC) method for uncoupling controlled, wide range pH gradients and simultaneous controlled gradients of a non-buffering solute on ion exchange resins (Hirsh and Tsonev, 2012) [1]. Here we report the application of this two dimensional LC technique to the problem of resolving Human Transferrin (HT) isoforms. This important iron transporting protein should theoretically occur in several thousand glycoforms, but only about a dozen have been reported. Using dual simultaneous independent gradients (DSIGs) of acetonitrile (ACN) and pH on a mixed bed stationary phase (SP) consisting of a mixture of an anion exchange resin and a reversed phase (RP) resin we partially resolve about 60 isoforms. These are likely to be partially refolded glycoforms generated by interaction of HT with the highly hydrophobic RP SP, as well as distinct folded glycoforms. Thus this study should have interesting implications for both glycoform separation and the study of protein folding.

Multiple, simultaneous, independent gradients for versatile multidimensional liquid chromatography. Part I: Theory.

The general method for constructing coupled dual gradients in liquid chromatography (LC) is to begin by filling a reservoir A with a solution of one mobile phase (MP) component at concentration [c(1)(A)] and a second MP component at concentration [c(2)(A)], followed by filling a reservoir B with a solution containing MP component one at concentration [c(1)(B)] and the second MP component at concentration [c(2)(B)]. In another scenario the reservoirs A and B are filled with solutions of only one MP component at different concentrations [c(1)(A)] and [c(1)(B)] and the two solutions are titrated to a different pH value: pH (A) for the reservoir A and pH (B) for the reservoir B respectively. In either case, mixing of flows from the two reservoirs varies the concentrations of the two MP components (MP solutes) or the concentration of one MP component and pH along a particular compositional curve producing an eluent with two compositionally coupled gradients. This is a kind of a two dimensional LC utilizing dual simultaneous dependent gradients (DSDGs) wherein two parameters affecting the binding free energy of an analyte to a stationary phase (SP) are being altered simultaneously. Such a DSDG suffers from a significant limitation in that the gradient concentration of the two solutes or the concentration of one MP component and the pH cannot be varied independently. The only way to attain an optimal multigradient LC system, that promises a remarkable increase in chromatographic resolution of complex analyte mixtures, is to uncouple the multiple (dual) gradients, making each independent of the other(s). In this paper the theory of uncoupling of n such gradients, n ≥ 2 is developed. It is shown that for n solutes 2(n) reservoirs are required in concert with an LC eluent delivery system capable of freely apportioning the flows among the reservoirs according to equations we develop here. We go on to predict a substantial increase in chromatographic resolution when applying dual simultaneous independent gradients (DSIGs) of salt and pH to fractionate difficult to separate proteins. This prediction is naturally explained by the electrostatic interaction theory of protein binding to an ion exchanger. In subsequent experimental papers it will be shown that the algorithms presented here properly instruct a quad pump HPLC system to produce well controlled independent simultaneous gradients of pH and non-buffering solutes with attendant significant gain in chromatographic resolution of complex mixtures of protein isoforms.

Theory and applications of a novel ion exchange chromatographic technology using controlled pH gradients for separating proteins on anionic and cationic stationary phases.

pISep is a major new advance in low ionic strength ion exchange chromatography. It enables the formation of externally controlled pH gradients over the very broad pH range from 2 to 12. The gradients can be generated on either cationic or anionic exchangers over arbitrary pH ranges wherein the stationary phases remain totally charged. Associated pISep software makes possible the calculation of either linear, nonlinear or combined, multi-step, multi-slope pH gradients. These highly reproducible pH gradients, while separating proteins and glycoproteins in the order of their electrophoretic pIs, provide superior chromatographic resolution compared to salt. This paper also presents a statistical mechanical model for protein binding to ion exchange stationary phases enhancing the electrostatic interaction theory for the general dependence of retention factor k, on both salt and pH simultaneously. It is shown that the retention factors computed from short time isocratic salt elution data of a model protein can be used to accurately predict its salt elution concentration in varying slope salt elution gradients formed at varying isocratic pH as well as the pH at which it will be eluted from an anionic exchange column by a pISep pH gradient in the absence of salt.