The effect on the performance of a dynamic navigation system of superimposing a standard tessellation language (STL) file obtained with an intraoral scan on a cone beam computer tomograph (CBCT). An experimental in vitro study.

ABSTRACT

OBJECTIVES: To compare the accuracy and operative time of implant placement using a dynamic computer assisted implant surgery (dCAIS) system based on a cone beam computer tomography (CBCT) image, with and without superimposing a standard tessellation language (STL) file of an intraoral scan of the patient. METHODS: Ten identical resin models simulating an upper maxilla with posterior edentulism were assigned to two groups. In the CBCT+STL group, a CBCT file and an intraoral STL file were superimposed and used for registration; in the CBCT group, registration was performed using CBCT images. Six implants were placed in each model using the Navident® dynamic navigation system. Anatomy registration was performed by tracing fiducial points on the CBCT or STL image, depending on the group. Preoperative and postoperative CBCT images were overlaid to assess implant placement accuracy. RESULTS: Sixty implants were analyzed (30 implants in each group). 3D platform deviation was significantly lower (mean difference (MD) 0.17 mm; 95 % confidence interval (CI) 0.01 to 0.23; P = 0.039) in the CBCT+STL group (mean 0.71 mm; standard deviation (SD) 0.29) than in the CBCT group (mean 0.88 mm; SD 0.39). The remaining accuracy outcome variables (angular deviation MD -0.01; platform lateral deviation MD 0.08 mm; apex global MD 0.01 mm; apex depth MD 0.33 mm) and surgery time (MD 3.383 min.) were similar in both groups (p > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The introduction of an intraoral scan (STL) seems to reduce deviations slightly in dental implant placement with dCAIS systems. However, the clinical repercussion of this improvement is questionable. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: Superimposing an intraoral scan on the CBCT image does not seem to increase the accuracy of dCAIS systems but can be useful when radiographic artifacts are present.