ABSTRACT
Describes the application of a new analytical approach (derived from synergetics, a complex dynamic systems theory) to home observational data of mother-child interactions in average dyads and dyads with children referred for disruptive behavior problems at home and school (n = 11 in each group). Results show that (1) the two groups differed in their daily interactions in predictable ways, and (2) the most frequent patterns of interactions observed in the two groups brought them back repeatedly to behave in similar ways toward each other. The findings are in keeping with a body of literature on mother-child interactions. However, they add to it by providing multivariate. graphical representations of these interactions and by offering a conceptual framework within which to move from an observational to an inferential level of analysis. At that level, the transactional processes that are characteristic of functional and dysfunctional relationships may become apparent.
Subject(s)
Mother-Child Relations , Psychological Theory , Affect , Child , Female , Humans , Male , Transactional AnalysisABSTRACT
Presents a study in which three sets of photographs of socially competent, aggressive, and anxious preschoolers were rated by college students (n = 150 raters per set), blind to the children's group membership. This was done to assess the extent to which adults are able to make valid and reliable evaluations of children's psychological adjustment on the basis of physical appearance alone. Sets 1 and 2 were photographs of different children taken under the same conditions and providing both facial and nonfacial cues. Sets 2 and 3 were of the same children taken under conditions that varied as to the amount of nonfacial cues they provided. Results showed that (a) socially competent children were judged to be better adjusted than their dysfunctional peers (i.e., more competent, less aggressive, less anxious, and less likely to have emotional or behavioral problems); (b) within the dysfunctional group, aggressive and anxious children were distinguished in ways that correspond closely to what is known about them from behavioral and clinical research; (c) irrespective of group membership, girls and boys were generally distinguished in ways that reflect normative beliefs about gender differences from social and developmental research; (d) group differences in ratings of psychological adjustment were generally comparable across photograph sets and could not be accounted for by differences in the children's perceived physical attractiveness; and (e) raters reported that they relied mainly on the children's expression, eyes, and posture to make their judgments of adjustment. These results replicate and extend earlier findings based on 1 of the 3 photograph sets (Serketich & Dumas, 1997). They suggest that when first impressions matter, competent children are at an advantage and their dysfunctional peers at a disadvantage even before their actual behavior comes to confirm or to invalidate these impressions. Theoretical and clinical implications of the findings are discussed.
Subject(s)
Adaptation, Psychological , Beauty , Child Behavior Disorders/psychology , Social Adjustment , Social Behavior , Adolescent , Adult , Aggression/psychology , Anxiety/psychology , Child Behavior Disorders/etiology , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Self Concept , Social PerceptionABSTRACT
Family-based preventive intervention trials in the area of child conduct problems face serious challenges regarding the recruitment and subsequent retention of participants. This article focuses on the problems and strategies pertinent to recruitment and retention in prevention research. The issues are discussed first with respect to initiating and maintaining a longitudinal sample, and then engaging and sustaining families in a preventive intervention. General principles are illustrated by EARLY ALLIANCE, a recently launched preventive intervention trial aimed at reducing children's risk for conduct disorder, substance abuse, and school failure. Recommendations for enhancing recruitment and retention are offered.
Subject(s)
Child Behavior Disorders/prevention & control , Family , Personnel Selection/methods , Humans , Longitudinal Studies , Substance-Related Disorders/prevention & controlABSTRACT
Fidelity refers to the demonstration that an experimental manipulation is conducted as planned. In outcome research, an intervention can be said to satisfy fidelity requirements if it can be shown that each of its components is delivered in a comparable manner to all participants and is true to the theory and goals underlying the research. Demonstrating the fidelity of an intervention is a key methodologic requirement of any sound prevention trial. This paper summarizes key conceptual and methodologic issues associated with intervention fidelity, and describes the steps taken to promote fidelity in EARLY ALLIANCE, a large-scale prevention trial currently testing the effectiveness of family, peer, and school interventions to promote competence and reduce risk for conduct disorder, substance abuse, and school failure. The paper presents preliminary results (Trial Year 1) that demonstrate content and process fidelity for two of these interventions, and discusses how the EARLY ALLIANCE methodology may be generalized to address fidelity issues in other prevention studies.
Subject(s)
Child Behavior Disorders/prevention & control , Adaptation, Psychological , Child , Child, Preschool , Humans , Models, Theoretical , Outcome Assessment, Health Care , Personnel Selection , Program Development , Records , Substance-Related Disorders/prevention & controlABSTRACT
This paper describes a preventive intervention trial called EARLY ALLIANCE which is aimed at reducing risk for three adverse outcomes in childhood and adolescence: conduct problems, substance abuse, and school failure. The structure of the prevention trial is unique because two linked designs are being implemented concurrently. The primary design focuses on children at elevated risk for adverse outcomes, and compares a targeted, multicontextual preventive intervention with family, classroom, peer relational, and academic components to a universal, schoolwide preventive intervention that emphasizes peaceful conflict management and serves as a "usual care" control condition. The secondary design focuses on children at lower risk for adverse outcomes and compares a universally administered classroom program to the control condition. The paper describes the theoretical foundation for EARLY ALLIANCE, the goals of the prevention trial, the rationale for design choices, and the methods employed.
Subject(s)
Achievement , Conduct Disorder/prevention & control , Early Intervention, Educational/methods , Research Design , Students , Substance-Related Disorders/prevention & control , Adolescent , Child , Humans , Longitudinal Studies , RiskABSTRACT
Describes the EARLY ALLIANCE interventions, an integrated set of four programs designed to promote competence and reduce risk for early-onset conduct disorder, substance abuse, and school failure. These interventions are evaluated as part of a prevention trial that begins at school entry and targets child functioning and socializing practices across multiple contexts (school, peer group, family) and multiple domains (affective, social, and achievement coping-competence). The paper presents the conceptual foundation of the four interventions, including a synopsis of the risk and protective factors associated with conduct disorder and related outcomes, and of the coping-competence model driving EARLY ALLIANCE. The developmental rationale, intended impact, and procedures are described for each intervention: a universally administered classroom program and indicated, peer, reading-mentoring, and family programs. Interventions are currently being tested in a prevention trial, which is briefly summarized.
Subject(s)
Conduct Disorder/prevention & control , Primary Prevention , Substance-Related Disorders/prevention & control , Adolescent , Child , Educational Status , Female , Humans , Indiana , Male , Models, Educational , Poverty Areas , Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic , Research Design , Schools/organization & administration , Student Dropouts/psychologyABSTRACT
This study explored adults' judgments of competent and dysfunctional children's behavioral adjustment based solely on children's physical appearance. Adults rated photographs of preschoolers (6 boys, 6 girls) who previously had been classified as socially competent or dysfunctional on the basis of independent, standardized teacher ratings. Participants, who were not given any information about the stimulus children, rated their photographs one at a time on measures of attractiveness, aggression, anxiety, social competence, and overall adjustment. Results indicated that dysfunctional children were easily distinguished from their competent peers. Specifically, dysfunctional children were rated as less attractive, more aggressive, more anxious, less socially competent, and more likely to have an emotional or behavioral problem than competent children. These findings (especially strong for aggressive boys), remained significant when group differences in attractiveness were statistically controlled. Implications for interpreting the current literature on attractiveness and for modification of childhood behavior disorders are discussed.
Subject(s)
Beauty , Child Behavior Disorders/psychology , Personality Assessment , Social Adjustment , Social Perception , Adult , Aggression/psychology , Anger , Anxiety/diagnosis , Anxiety/psychology , Child , Child Behavior Disorders/diagnosis , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , MaleABSTRACT
This study investigated the short-term stability of teacher-rated aggression, peer-rated rejection, and peer-rated depressive symptoms in 478 elementary school children from 25 classrooms (first to third grades) in two geographical areas. Children who presented specific combinations of aggression, rejection, and depressive symptoms were tracked to determine the stability of these combinations from the beginning (Time 1) to the end (Time 2) of the school year. In addition, aggression, rejection, and depressive symptoms were treated as risk factors, and children were classified as displaying zero, one, two, or three risk factors at Times 1 and 2. Of the three risk factors, aggression appeared to be the most stable. Three-quarters of children who presented aggression at Time 1 (either alone or in combination with the other risk factors) were found to continue to have elevated levels of aggression at Time 2. Although specific combinations of aggression, rejection, and depressive symptoms were not very stable over time, the number of risk factors a child displayed at Time 1 was a good predictor of the number of risk factors the child displayed at Time 2. Stability of risk factors was comparable as a junction of child gender and ethnicity.
Subject(s)
Aggression/psychology , Depression/psychology , Peer Group , Personality Assessment/statistics & numerical data , Rejection, Psychology , Child , Depression/diagnosis , Female , Follow-Up Studies , Humans , Male , Personality Development , Psychometrics , Reproducibility of Results , Sociometric TechniquesABSTRACT
The authors compared mother-to-child and child-to-mother control exchanges in dyads involving socially competent, aggressive, and anxious children (aged 2.5-6.5 years) observed in a laboratory setting. Competent children and their mothers influenced each other positively and reciprocally, making prudent use of control exchanges and setting firm limits to coercive attempts. Aggressive children and their mothers were relatively positive, but children made regular use of coercive control and mothers responded indiscriminately and failed to oppose more extreme forms of coercion. Anxious children and their mothers were generally aversive: mothers attempted to control their children by being coercive and unresponsive, and children tried to manage their mothers by being resistant and coercive. Results show that young children are active agents who influence and are influenced by their relationship with their mother and who behave--across contexts and with different social partners--in ways that reflect this relationship.
Subject(s)
Aggression , Anxiety , Mother-Child Relations , Transactional Analysis , Child, Preschool , Family , Female , Humans , Male , Mothers/psychologyABSTRACT
We tested the proposition that mother-child relationships can be sources of support or stress, by comparing patterns of mother-child interactions in a problem-solving task that children completed with their own and with an unfamiliar mother. 4 groups of preschoolers (n = 30 in each group)--identified on the basis of teacher ratings as socially competent, average, aggressive, or anxious--participated. Mothers of competent and average children were highly positive and reciprocal toward their own and unfamiliar children. Mothers of aggressive and anxious children were only positive and reciprocal toward unfamiliar children but generally indiscriminate (aggressive group) or aversive and negatively reciprocal (anxious group) toward their own. Children in all 4 groups tended to be reciprocal toward their own mothers, but only competent and average children were reciprocal toward unfamiliar mothers also. Aggressive and anxious children generally responded to unfamiliar mothers by ignoring or actively rejecting their overtures. Results (1) indicate that the relationship with the primary caregiver may serve as a major source of support or stress in the preschool years; (2) focus attention on the dynamic organization of interactions rather than on the presence or frequency of particular behaviors, indicating that a dynamic of reciprocity enables children and mothers to adapt positively to the ever changing demands of new social situations; (3) point to the need to develop new means of assessing relationships to better understand how they influence development; and (4) highlight the importance of incorporating transactional models in the diagnosis and treatment of childhood dysfunctions rather than accounting for them solely in terms of limited skills in parents or children.
Subject(s)
Aggression , Anxiety , Mother-Child Relations , Stress, Psychological/psychology , Child , Child Behavior/psychology , Child Development , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Infant , Interpersonal Relations , Male , Maternal Behavior/psychology , Problem SolvingABSTRACT
This study tested a systemic hypothesis of the relation between maternal depressive symptomatology and the behavior of conduct-disordered children (n = 47) toward their mothers, fathers, and siblings. Maternal symptomatology interacted with the children's behavior toward all family members. Children whose mothers were distressed tended to be more compliant and less aversive toward them than toward their fathers, and the opposite applied to children whose mothers were not distressed. Comparable results were obtained in comparisons of child interactions with mothers and siblings, although in the latter case the children's behaviors differed in absolute magnitude as a function of their interaction partner.
Subject(s)
Child Behavior Disorders/psychology , Child of Impaired Parents/psychology , Depressive Disorder/psychology , Father-Child Relations , Mother-Child Relations , Sibling Relations , Adolescent , Child , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Infant , Male , Risk FactorsABSTRACT
We contrasted two predictive models of the impact of maternal depressive symptomatology on child behavior in a study of 51 mothers and their conduct-disorder children. Relations between global measures of maternal distress and child adjustment and observational measures of mother-child interaction were examined. Children of distressed mothers were more maladjusted than children of nondistressed mothers, when maladjustment was measured on the basis of a global rating, but "better" adjusted when measured on the basis of interactional measures. Measures of maternal indiscriminate responding to the child may account for these findings. Results suggest that (a) although conduct-disorder children are generally more maladjusted when their mothers are distressed, they display this maladjustment in a selective fashion, and (b) maternal distress acts as an adverse contextual factor that maintains mother-child interactional difficulties by disrupting the attentional and monitoring skills required for contingent responding.
Subject(s)
Child Behavior Disorders/psychology , Depression/psychology , Mother-Child Relations , Mothers/psychology , Adult , Child , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Male , Reinforcement, Psychology , Risk FactorsABSTRACT
A review of the literature on dysfunctional mother-child interactions indicates a consistent association between dysfunction and environmental stressors. The association does not always seem due to an absence of parenting skills but more so due to a stress-induced deficiency in maternal attention. Some mothers, who also live in the midst of stressors, are not in synchrony with cues offered through their children's various behaviors. The literature suggests that the stress-induced attention problem is mediated by organizational properties of a mother's response repertoire. These properties, conceptualized by the term response class, refer to covariations among the various behaviors composing the mother's repertoire. According to this interbehavioral model, mothers who manifest high response class intercorrelations will also be most susceptible to the attention-debilitating influences of stress. The heuristic value of this model is outlined in a section on clinical strategies geared to changing a mother's attention. Clinical teaching procedures described as analysis and synthesis are presented.
Subject(s)
Attention , Models, Psychological , Mother-Child Relations , Stress, Psychological/psychology , Child , Cues , Female , Humans , Parents/educationABSTRACT
This paper argues that the experimental paradigm which has dominated research and intervention in the prevention of psychosocial disorders needs to become more sensitive to contextual variables. Traditionally, this paradigm has (1) provided a piecemeal method to study and, ultimately, understand reality; (2) focused attention on outcomes at the expense of processes in behavior; and (3) assumed that the results obtained under experimental conditions are externally valid and will generalize across persons, settings, and time. Evidence from studies aimed at the primary prevention of delinquency is used to illustrate these issues. It is concluded that, while it is important to know which factors are reliably associated with the development of psychosocial disorders and interfere with prevention efforts, it is equally important to understand how such factors are organized and, in unison, influence behavior. Implications of this conclusion are discussed, with particular emphasis on emerging methodologies to study behavioral organization (structural equation modeling, meta-analysis), and on the possibility that, rather than searching for universal principles of behavior which would be applicable at all times, we may have to be satisfied with a search for preventive models that are consistent with the cultural context in which they are applied.
ABSTRACT
Fourteen mother-child dyads who had sought psychological help for severe interaction problems took part in a study that investigated the relationship between maternal social interactions with adults outside the family and mother-child interactions in the home. Social interactions outside the family were based on maternal self-reports; mother-child interactions in the home were based on direct observations and included both base-rate and sequential measures. Results indicated that mothers were significantly more aversive toward their children on days in which they had themselves experienced a high proportion of aversive interactions with adults than on days in which they had not. This higher level of aversiveness was evident in their responses to both aversive and nonaversive child behavior and could not be attributed to any corresponding change in child behavior. Implications for research and clinical practice are discussed.
Subject(s)
Interpersonal Relations , Mother-Child Relations , Mothers/psychology , Adult , Child , Child, Preschool , Environment , Female , Humans , MaleABSTRACT
Two stimulus control processes by which some parent-child dyads occasionally escalate their aversive exchanges into progressively more coercive interactions are described. The compliance hypothesis suggests that aversive actions have instructional properties for the dyad and that parent compliance with such child instructions maintains behavior chains of increasing aversiveness. The predictability hypothesis suggests that social interactions are most likely to function as aversive stimuli in the dyad when delivered in unpredictable fashion by either party and that responses instrumental in reducing dyadic unpredictability maintain aversive behavior chains. Expectations derived from both hypotheses are evaluated in a series of correlational analyses of mother-child interactions obtained in extended baseline observations of three dyads seeking psychological help for severe interactional problems. Results provide tentative support for the predictability hypothesis and suggest important avenues of further research.
Subject(s)
Child Abuse , Cooperative Behavior , Mother-Child Relations , Aggression/psychology , Attention , Behavior Therapy/methods , Child , Child Behavior Disorders/psychology , Child Behavior Disorders/therapy , Child, Preschool , Family Therapy/methods , Female , Humans , Male , Reinforcement, PsychologySubject(s)
Behavior Therapy , Child Behavior Disorders/therapy , Parent-Child Relations , Parents/education , Adolescent , Child , Child, Preschool , Female , Humans , Male , PrognosisABSTRACT
Fifty-two mother-child dyads took part in a parent training program to modify coercive, antisocial child behavior. Prior to intervention, scores on 14 measures of mother-child interaction and on an index of maternal community contacts (known as "insularity") were obtained for each dyad. This index was used to divide the sample into two groups (noninsular n = 21; insular n = 31). The interactional measures were then compared between the groups. Insular mothers were more aversive and indiscriminate than noninsular mothers in their use of aversive behavior toward their children, while their children were more aversive than noninsular children, especially in response to aversive maternal behavior. It was concluded that research and therapeutic work with deviant families should focus not only on immediate family interactions but also on the extrafamily environment in which these interactions take place.