Human mitochondrial tRNAs in health and disease.

The human mitochondrial genome encodes 13 proteins, all subunits of the respiratory chain complexes and thus involved in energy metabolism. These genes are translated by 22 transfer RNAs (tRNAs), also encoded by the mitochondrial genome, which form the minimal set required for reading all codons. Human mitochondrial tRNAs gained interest with the rapid discovery of correlations between point mutations in their genes and various neuromuscular and neurodegenerative disorders. In this review, emerging fundamental knowledge on the structure/function relationships of these particular tRNAs and an overview of the large variety of mechanisms within translation, affected by mutations, are summarized. Also, initial results on wide-ranging molecular consequences of mutations outside the frame of mitochondrial translation are highlighted. While knowledge of mitochondrial tRNAs in both health and disease increases, deciphering the intricate network of events leading different genotypes to the variety of phenotypes requires further investigation using adapted model systems.

Novel features in the tRNA-like world of plant viral RNAs.

tRNA-like domains are found at the 3' end of genomic RNAs of several genera of plant viral RNAs. Three groups of tRNA mimics have been characterized on the basis of their aminoacylation identity (valine, histidine and tyrosine) for aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Folding of these domains deviates from the canonical tRNA cloverleaf. The closest sequence similarities with tRNA are those found in valine accepting structures from tymoviruses (e.g. TYMV). All the viral tRNA mimics present a pseudoknotted amino acid accepting stem, which confers special structural and functional characteristics. In this review emphasis is given to newly discovered tRNA-like structures (e.g. in furoviruses) and to recent advances in the understanding of their three-dimensional architecture, which mimics L-shaped tRNA. Identity determinants in tRNA-like domains for aminoacylation are described, and evidence for their functional expression, as in tRNAs, is given. Properties of engineered tRNA-like domains are discussed, and other functional mimicries with tRNA are described (e.g. interaction with elongation factors and tRNA maturation enzymes). A final section reviews the biological role of the tRNA-like domains in amplification of viral genomes. In this process, in which the mechanisms can vary in specificity and efficiency according to the viral genus, function can be dependent on the aminoacylation properties of the tRNA-like domains and/or on structural properties within or outside these domains.

Disease-related versus polymorphic mutations in human mitochondrial tRNAs. Where is the difference?

A number of point mutations in human mitochondrial (mt) tRNA genes are correlated with a variety of neuromuscular and other severe disorders including encephalopathies, myopathies, cardiopathies and diabetes. The complexity of the genotype/phenotype relationships, the diversity of possible molecular impacts of the different mutations at the tRNA structure/function levels, and the exponential discovery of new mutations call for the search for unifying features. Here, the basic features (at the levels of primary and secondary structure) of 68 'pathogenic' mutations are compared with those of 64 'polymorphic' neutral mutations, revealing that these standard parameters for mutant analysis are not sufficient to predict the pathogenicity of mt tRNA mutations. Thus, case by case molecular investigation remains the only means of assessing the growing family of pathogenic mutations in mt tRNAs. New lines of research are suggested.

Search for characteristic structural features of mammalian mitochondrial tRNAs.

A number of mitochondrial (mt) tRNAs have strong structural deviations from the classical tRNA cloverleaf secondary structure and from the conventional L-shaped tertiary structure. As a consequence, there is a general trend to consider all mitochondrial tRNAs as "bizarre" tRNAs. Here, a large sequence comparison of the 22 tRNA genes within 31 fully sequenced mammalian mt genomes has been performed to define the structural characteristics of this specific group of tRNAs. Vertical alignments define the degree of conservation/variability of primary sequences and secondary structures and search for potential tertiary interactions within each of the 22 families. Further horizontal alignments ascertain that, with the exception of serine-specific tRNAs, mammalian mt tRNAs do fold into cloverleaf structures with mostly classical features. However, deviations exist and concern large variations in size of the D- and T-loops. The predominant absence of the conserved nucleotides G18G19 and T54T55C56, respectively in these loops, suggests that classical tertiary interactions between both domains do not take place. Classification of the tRNA sequences according to their genomic origin (G-rich or G-poor DNA strand) highlight specific features such as richness/poorness in mismatches or G-T pairs in stems and extremely low G-content or C-content in the D- and T-loops. The resulting 22 "typical" mammalian mitochondrial sequences built up a phylogenetic basis for experimental structural and functional investigations. Moreover, they are expected to help in the evaluation of the possible impacts of those point mutations detected in human mitochondrial tRNA genes and correlated with pathologies.

Selection of viral RNA-derived tRNA-like structures with improved valylation activities.

The tRNA-like structure (TLS) of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) RNA was previously shown to be efficiently charged by yeast valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS). This RNA has a noncanonical structure at its 3'-terminus but mimics a tRNA L-shaped fold, including an anticodon loop containing the major identity nucleotides for valylation, and a pseudoknotted amino acid accepting domain. Here we describe an in vitro selection experiment aimed (i) to verify the completeness of the valine identity set, (ii) to elucidate the impact of the pseudoknot on valylation, and (iii) to investigate whether functional communication exists between the two distal anticodon and amino acid accepting domains. Valylatable variants were selected from a pool of 2 x 10(13) RNA molecules derived from the TYMV TLS randomized in the anticodon loop nucleotides and in the length (1-6 nucleotides) and sequence of the pseudoknot loop L1. After nine rounds of selection by aminoacylation, 42 have been isolated. Among them, 17 RNAs could be efficiently charged by yeast ValRS. Their sequence revealed strong conservation of the second and the third anticodon triplet positions (A(56), C(55)) and the very 3'-end loop nucleotide C(53). A large variability of the other nucleotides of the loop was observed and no wild-type sequence was recovered. The selected molecules presented pseudoknot domains with loop L1 varying in size from 3-6 nucleotides and some sequence conservation, but did neither reveal the wild-type combination. All selected variants are 5-50 times more efficiently valylated than the wild-type TLS, suggesting that the natural viral sequence has emerged from a combination of evolutionary pressures among which aminoacylation was not predominant. This is in line with the role of the TLS in viral replication.

Effect of modified nucleotides on Escherichia coli tRNAGlu structure and on its aminoacylation by glutamyl-tRNA synthetase. Predominant and distinct roles of the mnm5 and s2 modifications of U34.

Overproducing Escherichia coli tRNAGlu in its homologous host results in the presence of several distinctly modified forms of this molecule that we name modivariants. The predominant tRNAGlu modivariant in wild-type E. coli contains five modified nucleosides: Psi13, mnm5s2U34, m2A37, T54 and Psi55. Four other overproduced modivariants differ from it by, respectively, either the presence of an additional Psi, or the presence of s2U34, or the lack of A37 methylation combined with either s2U34 or U34. Chemical probing reveals that the anticodon loop of the predominant modivariant is less reactive to the probes than that of the four others. Furthermore, the modivariant with neither mnm5s2U34 nor m2A37 has additional perturbations in the D- and T-arms and in the variable region. The lack of a 2-thio group in nucleoside 34, which is mnm5s2U in the predominant tRNAGlu modivariant, decreases by 520-fold the specificity of E. coli glutamyl-tRNA synthetase for tRNAGlu in the aminoacylation reaction, showing that this thio group is the identity element in the modified wobble nucleotide of E. coli tRNAGlu. The modified nucleosides content also influences the recognition of ATP and glutamate by this enzyme, and in this case also, the predominant modivariant is the one that allows the best specificity for these two substrates. These structural and kinetic properties of tRNAGlu modivariants indicate that the modification system of tRNAGlu optimizes the stability of tRNAGlu and its action as cofactor of the glutamyl-tRNA synthetase for the recognition of glutamate and ATP.

A Watson-Crick base-pair-disrupting methyl group (m1A9) is sufficient for cloverleaf folding of human mitochondrial tRNALys.

We have previously shown by chemical and enzymatic structure probing that, opposite to the native human mitochondrial tRNA(Lys), the corresponding in vitro transcript does not fold into the expected tRNA-specific cloverleaf structure. This RNA folds into a bulged hairpin, including an extended amino acid acceptor stem, an extra large loop instead of the T-stem and loop, and an anticodon-like domain. Hence, one or several of the six modified nucleotides present in the native tRNA are required and responsible for its cloverleaf structure. Phylogenetic comparisons as well as structural analysis of variant transcripts had pointed to m(1)A9 as the most likely important modified nucleotide in the folding process. Here we describe the synthesis of a chimeric tRNA(Lys) with m(1)A9 as the sole modified base and its structural analysis by chemical and enzymatic probing. Comparison of this structure to that of the unmodified RNA, the fully modified native tRNA, and a variant designed to mimic the effect of m(1)A9 demonstrates that the chimeric RNA folds indeed into a cloverleaf structure that resembles that of the native tRNA. Thus, due to Watson-Crick base-pair disruption, a single methyl group is sufficient to induce the cloverleaf folding of this unusual tRNA. This is the first direct evidence of the role of a modified nucleotide in RNA folding.

Mimics of yeast tRNAAsp and their recognition by aspartyl-tRNA synthetase.

Assuming that the L-shaped three-dimensional structure of tRNA is an architectural framework allowing the proper presentation of identity nucleotides to aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases implies that altered and/or simplified RNA architectures can fulfill this role and be functional substrates of these enzymes, provided they contain correctly located identity elements. In this work, this paradigm was submitted to new experimental verification. Yeast aspartyl-tRNA synthetase was the model synthetase, and the extent to which the canonical structural framework of cognate tRNAAsp can be altered without losing its ability to be aminoacylated was investigated. Three novel architectures recognized by the synthetase were found. The first resembles that of metazoan mitochondrial tRNASer lacking the D-arm. The second lacks both the D- and T-arms, and the 5'-strand of the amino acid acceptor arm. The third structure is a construct in which the acceptor and anticodon helices are joined by two connectors. Aspartylation specificity of these RNAs is verified by the loss of aminoacylation activity upon mutation of the putative identity residues. Kinetic data indicate that the first two architectures are mimics of the whole tRNAAsp molecule, while the third one behaves as an aspartate minihelix mimic. Results confirm the primordial role of the discriminator nucleotide G73 in aspartylation and demonstrate that neither a helical structure in the acceptor domain nor the presence of a D- or T-arm is mandatory for specific aspartylation, but that activity relies on the presence of the cognate aspartate GUC sequence in the anticodon loop.

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases: a new image for a classical family.

The aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) are a family of enzymes well known for their role in protein synthesis. More recent investigations have discovered that this classic family of enzymes is actually capable of a broad repertoire of functions which not only impact protein synthesis, but extend to a number of other critical cellular activities. Specific aaRSs play roles in cellular fidelity, tRNA processing, RNA splicing, RNA trafficking, apoptosis, transcriptional and translational regulation. A recent EMBO workshop entitled 'Structure and Function of Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases' (Mittelwihr, France, October 10-15, 1998), highlighted the diversity of the aaRSs' role within the cell. These novel activities as well as significant advances in delineating mechanisms of substrate specificity and the aminoacylation reaction affirm the family of aaRSs as pharmaceutical targets.

Magnesium-dependent alternative foldings of active and inactive Escherichia coli tRNA(Glu) revealed by chemical probing.

A stable conformer of Escherichia coli tRNA(Glu), obtained in the absence of Mg(2+), is inactive in the aminoacylation reaction. Probing it with diethylpyrocarbonate, dimethyl sulfate and ribonuclease V1 revealed that it has a hairpin structure with two internal loops; the helical segments at both extremities have the same structure as the acceptor stem and the anticodon arm of the native conformer of tRNA(Glu)and the middle helix is formed of nucleotides from the D-loop (G15-C20:2) and parts of the T-loop and stem (G51-C56), with G19 bulging out. This model is consistent with other known properties of this inactive conformer, including its capacity to dimerize. Therefore, this tRNA requires magnesium to acquire a conformation that can be aminoacylated, as others require a post-transcriptional modification to reach this active conformation.

Search for differences in post-transcriptional modification patterns of mitochondrial DNA-encoded wild-type and mutant human tRNALys and tRNALeu(UUR).

Post-transcriptional modifications are characteristic features of tRNAs and have been shown in a number of cases to influence both their structural and functional properties, including structure stabilization, amino-acylation and codon recognition. We have developed an approach which allows the investigation of the post-transcriptional modification patterns of human mitochondrial wild-type and mutant tRNAs at both the qualitative and the quantitative levels. Specific tRNA species are long-term labeled in vivo with [32P]orthophosphate, isolated in a highly selective way, enzymatically digested to mononucleotides and then subjected to two-dimensional thin layer chromatographic analysis. The wild-type tRNALysand the corresponding tRNALyscarrying the A8344G mutation associated with the MERRF (Myoclonic Epilepsy with Ragged Red Fibers) syndrome exhibit the same modified nucleotides at the same molar concentrations. By contrast, a quantitatively different modification pattern was observed between the wild-type tRNALeu(UUR)and its counterpart carrying the A3243G mutation associated with the MELAS (Mitochondrial Myopathy, Encephalopathy with Lactic Acidosis and Stroke-like episodes) syndrome, the latter exhibiting a 50% decrease in m2G content. Complementary sequencing of tRNALeu(UUR)has allowed the localization of this modification at position 10 within the D-stem of the tRNA. The decreased level of this modification may have important implications for understanding the molecular mechanism underlying the MELAS-associated mitochondrial dysfunction.

Characterization and selectivity of catalytic antibodies from human serum with RNase activity.

IgG purified from sera of several patients with systemic lupus erythematosus and hepatitis B are shown to present RNA hydrolyzing activities that are different from the weak RNase A-type activities found in the sera of healthy donors. Further investigation brings evidence for two intrinsic activities, one observed in low salt conditions and another specifically stimulated by Mg2+ions and distinguishable from human sera RNases. Cleavage of RNA substrates by the latter activity is not sequence-specific but sensitive to both subtle conformational and/or drastic folding changes, as evidenced by comparative analysis of couples of structurally well-studied RNA substrates. These include yeast tRNAAsp and its in vitro transcript and human mitochondrial tRNALys-derived in vitro transcripts. The discovery of catalytic antibodies with RNase activities is a first step towards creation of a new generation of tools for the investigation of RNA structure.

Universal rules and idiosyncratic features in tRNA identity.

Correct expression of the genetic code at translation is directly correlated with tRNA identity. This survey describes the molecular signals in tRNAs that trigger specific aminoacylations. For most tRNAs, determinants are located at the two distal extremities: the anticodon loop and the amino acid accepting stem. In a few tRNAs, however, major identity signals are found in the core of the molecule. Identity elements have different strengths, often depend more on k cat effects than on K m effects and exhibit additive, cooperative or anti-cooperative interplay. Most determinants are in direct contact with cognate synthetases, and chemical groups on bases or ribose moieties that make functional interactions have been identified in several systems. Major determinants are conserved in evolution; however, the mechanisms by which they are expressed are species dependent. Recent studies show that alternate identity sets can be recognized by a single synthetase, and emphasize the importance of tRNA architecture and anti-determinants preventing false recognition. Identity rules apply to tRNA-like molecules and to minimalist tRNAs. Knowledge of these rules allows the manipulation of identity elements and engineering of tRNAs with switched, altered or multiple specificities.

Pseudouridine and ribothymidine formation in the tRNA-like domain of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA.

The last 82 nucleotides of the 6.3 kb genomic RNA of plant turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV), the so-called 'tRNA-like' domain, presents functional, structural and primary sequence homologies with canonical tRNAs. In particular, one of the stem-loops resembles the TPsi(pseudouridine)-branch of tRNA, except for the presence of a guanosine at position 37 (numbering is from the 3'-end) instead of the classical uridine-55 in tRNA (numbering is from the 5'-end). Both the wild-type TYMV-RNA fragment and a variant, TYMV-mut G37U in which G-37 has been replaced by U-37, have been tested as potential substrates for the yeast tRNA modification enzymes. Results indicate that two modified nucleotides were formed upon incubation of the wild-type TYMV-fragment in a yeast extract: one Psi which formed quantitatively at position 65, and one ribothymidine (T) which formed at low level at position U-38. In the TYMV-mutant G37U, besides the quantitative formation of both Psi-65 and T-38, an additional Psi was detected at position 37. Modified nucleotides Psi-65, T-38 and Psi-37 in TYMV RNA are equivalent to Psi-27, T-54 and Psi-55 in tRNA, respectively. Purified yeast recombinant tRNA:Psisynthases (Pus1 and Pus4), which catalyze respectively the formation of Psi-27 and Psi-55 in yeast tRNAs, are shown to catalyze the quantitative formation of Psi-65 and Psi-37, respectively, in the tRNA-like 3'-domain of mutant TYMV RNA in vitro . These results are discussed in relation to structural elements that are needed by the corresponding enzymes in order to catalyze these post-transcriptional modification reactions.

Sequences outside recognition sets are not neutral for tRNA aminoacylation. Evidence for nonpermissive combinations of nucleotides in the acceptor stem of yeast tRNAPhe.

Phenylalanine identity of yeast tRNAPhe is governed by five nucleotides including residues A73, G20, and the three anticodon nucleotides (Sampson et al., 1989, Science 243, 1363-1366). Analysis of in vitro transcripts derived from yeast tRNAPhe and Escherichia coli tRNAAla bearing these recognition elements shows that phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase is sensitive to additional nucleotides within the acceptor stem. Insertion of G2-C71 has dramatic negative effects in both tRNA frameworks. These effects become compensated by a second-site mutation, the insertion of the wobble G3-U70 pair, which by itself has no effect on phenylalanylation. From a mechanistic point of view, the G2-C71/G3-U70 combination is not a "classical" recognition element since its antideterminant effect is compensated for by a second-site mutation. This enlarges our understanding of tRNA identity that appears not only to be the outcome of a combination of positive and negative signals forming the so-called recognition/identity set but that is also based on the presence of nonrandom combinations of sequences elsewhere in tRNA. These sequences, we name "permissive elements," are retained by evolution so that they do not hinder aminoacylation. Likely, no nucleotide within a tRNA is of random nature but has been selected so that a tRNA can fulfill all its functions efficiently.

The RNA sequence context defines the mechanistic routes by which yeast arginyl-tRNA synthetase charges tRNA.

Arginylation of tRNA transcripts by yeast arginyl-tRNA synthetase can be triggered by two alternate recognition sets in anticodon loops: C35 and U36 or G36 in tRNA(Arg) and C36 and G37 in tRNA(Asp) (Sissler M, Giegé R, Florentz C, 1996, EMBO J 15:5069-5076). Kinetic studies on tRNA variants were done to explore the mechanisms by which these sets are expressed. Although the synthetase interacts in a similar manner with tRNA(Arg) and tRNA(Asp), the details of the interaction patterns are idiosyncratic, especially in anticodon loops (Sissler M, Eriani G, Martin F, Giegé R, Florentz C, 1997, Nucleic Acids Res 25:4899-4906). Exchange of individual recognition elements between arginine and aspartate tRNA frameworks strongly blocks arginylation of the mutated tRNAs, whereas full exchange of the recognition sets leads to efficient arginine acceptance of the transplanted tRNAs. Unpredictably, the similar catalytic efficiencies of native and transplanted tRNAs originate from different k(cat) and Km combinations. A closer analysis reveals that efficient arginylation results from strong anticooperative effects between individual recognition elements. Nonrecognition nucleotides as well as the tRNA architecture are additional factors that tune efficiency. Altogether, arginyl-tRNA synthetase is able to utilize different context-dependent mechanistic routes to be activated. This confers biological advantages to the arginine aminoacylation system and sheds light on its evolutionary relationship with the aspartate system.

The presence of modified nucleotides is required for cloverleaf folding of a human mitochondrial tRNA.

Direct sequencing of human mitochondrial tRNALysshows the absence of editing and the occurrence of six modified nucleotides (m1A9, m2G10, Psi27, Psi28 and hypermodified nucleotides at positions U34 and A37). This tRNA folds into the expected cloverleaf, as confirmed by structural probing with nucleases. The solution structure of the corresponding in vitro transcript unexpectedly does not fold into a cloverleaf but into an extended bulged hairpin. This non-canonical fold, established according to the reactivity to a large set of chemical and enzymatic probes, includes a 10 bp aminoacyl acceptor stem (the canonical 7 bp and 3 new pairs between residues 8-10 and 65-63), a 13 nt large loop and an anticodon-like domain. It is concluded that modified nucleotides have a predominant role in canonical folding of human mitochondrial tRNALys. Phylogenetic comparisons as well as structural probing of selected in vitro transcribed variants argue in favor of a major contribution of m1A9 in this process.