Guidelines for the use of spiral computed tomography in screening for lung cancer.

Screening should be considered in lung cancer, more than any other cancer. Not only is the disease highly fatal, essentially incurable, when diagnosed on the prompting of symptoms and/or clinical signs, but its occurrence is also highly concentrated in identifiably high-risk persons. The degree of usefulness of computed tomography (CT)-based screening for lung cancer must be thought of in reference to a particular, presumably optimal, regimen of pursuing early stage diagnosis. This is an algorithm that begins with the initial test ("screening CT") and ends in either discontinuation of the diagnostic pursuit or in diagnosis of lung cancer. A carefully developed, extensively pilot tested and critically reviewed, updated protocol for CT-based screening for lung cancer is presented here. Its implementation is addressed, together with quality assurance. Finally, the associated curability rate for lung cancer is addressed in the light of what is known or can be surmised from evidence already available. However, recommendation for or against screening requires further information. Principally, the patients risk for lung cancer (in the near future) and the patients life expectancy (when spared of death from lung cancer). These two factors influence when, if ever, to begin screening, and if it is initiated, when to discontinue it. Finally, cost-effectiveness of the screening program should also be considered.

Early lung cancer action project: initial findings on repeat screenings.

BACKGROUND: The Early Lung Cancer Action Project (ELCAP) was designed to evaluate the usefulness of annual computed tomography (CT) screening for lung carcinoma. With the baseline results having been reported previously, the focus of the current study was on the early results of the repeat screenings. METHODS: A cohort of 1000 high-risk individuals was recruited for baseline and annual repeat CT screening. At last follow-up, a total of 1184 annual repeat screenings had been performed. A positive result from the screening test was defined as newly detected, one to six noncalcified pulmonary nodules with interim growth. The diagnostic workup of the individuals was guided by recommendations supplied by the ELCAP investigators to the collaborating clinicians. RESULTS: Of the 1184 repeat CT screenings, the test result was positive in 30 (2.5%). In 2 of these 30 cases, the individual died (of an unrelated cause) before diagnostic workup and the nodule(s) resolved in another 12 individuals. In the remaining 16 individuals, the absence of further growth was documented by repeat CT in 8 individuals and further growth was documented in the remaining 8 individuals. All eight individuals with further nodular growth underwent biopsy and malignancy was diagnosed in seven. Six of these seven malignancies were nonsmall cell carcinomas (five of which were Stage IA and one of which was Stage IIIA) and the one small cell carcinoma was found to be of limited stage. The median size dimension of these malignancies was 8 mm. In another two subjects, symptoms prompted the interim diagnosis of lung carcinoma. Neither of these malignancies was nodule-associated but rather were endobronchial; one was a Stage IIB nonsmall cell carcinoma and the other was a small cell carcinoma of limited stage. CONCLUSIONS: False-positive screening test results are uncommon and usually manageable without biopsy; compared with no screening, such screenings permit diagnosis at substantially earlier and thus more curable stages. Annual repetition of CT screening is sufficient to minimize symptom-prompted interim diagnoses of nodule-associated malignancies.

Early lung cancer action project: a summary of the findings on baseline screening.

PURPOSE: The Early Lung Cancer Action Project (ELCAP) is designed to evaluate baseline and annual repeat screening by low radiation dose computed tomography (low-dose CT) in persons at high-risk for lung cancer. METHODS: Since starting in 1993, the ELCAP has enrolled 1,000 asymptomatic persons, 60 years of age or older, with at least 10 pack-years (1 pack per day for 10 years, or 2 packs per day for 5 years) of cigarette smoking, no prior cancer, and medically fit to undergo thoracic surgery. After a structured interview and informed consent, baseline chest radiographs and low-dose CT were obtained on each subject. The diagnostic work-up of screen-detected noncalcified pulmonary nodules (NCN) was guided by ELCAP recommendations which included short-term high-resolution CT follow-up for the smallest nodules. Baseline RESULTS: On low-dose CT at baseline compared to chest radiography, NCN were detected three times as commonly (23% versus 7%), malignancies four times as commonly (2.7% versus 0.7%), and stage I malignancies six times as commonly (2.3% versus 0.4%). Of the 27 CT-detected cancers, 96% (26/27) were resectable; 85% (23/27) were stage I, and 83% (19 of the 23 stage I) were not seen on chest radiography. Following the ELCAP recommendations, biopsies were performed on 28 of the 233 subjects with NCN; 27 had a malignant and one a benign NCN. Another three individuals underwent biopsy outside of the ELCAP recommendations; all had benign NCNS: No one had thoracotomy for a benign nodule. CONCLUSION: Baseline CT screening for lung cancer provides for detecting the disease at earlier and presumably more commonly curable stages in a cost-effective manner.

Early Lung Cancer Action Project: overall design and findings from baseline screening.

BACKGROUND: The Early Lung Cancer Action Project (ELCAP) is designed to evaluate baseline and annual repeat screening by low-radiation-dose computed tomography (low-dose CT) in people at high risk of lung cancer. We report the baseline experience. METHODS: ELCAP has enrolled 1000 symptom-free volunteers, aged 60 years or older, with at least 10 pack-years of cigarette smoking and no previous cancer, who were medically fit to undergo thoracic surgery. After a structured interview and informed consent, chest radiographs and low-dose CT were done for each participant. The diagnostic investigation of screen-detected non-calcified pulmonary nodules was guided by ELCAP recommendations, which included short-term high-resolution CT follow-up for the smallest non-calcified nodules. FINDINGS: Non-calcified nodules were detected in 233 (23% [95% CI 21-26]) participants by low-dose CT at baseline, compared with 68 (7% [5-9]) by chest radiography. Malignant disease was detected in 27 (2.7% [1.8-3.8]) by CT and seven (0.7% [0.3-1.3]) by chest radiography, and stage I malignant disease in 23 (2.3% [1.5-3.3]) and four (0.4% [0.1-0.9]), respectively. Of the 27 CT-detected cancers, 26 were resectable. Biopsies were done on 28 of the 233 participants with non-calcified nodules; 27 had malignant non-calcified nodules and one had a benign nodule. Another three individuals underwent biopsy against the ELCAP recommendations; all had benign non-calcified nodules. No participant had thoracotomy for a benign nodule. INTERPRETATION: Low-dose CT can greatly improve the likelihood of detection of small non-calcified nodules, and thus of lung cancer at an earlier and potentially more curable stage. Although false-positive CT results are common, they can be managed with little use of invasive diagnostic procedures.

Pulmonary nodule detection: low-dose versus conventional CT.

PURPOSE: To quantitate the effectiveness of low-dose computed tomography (CT) in the identification of pulmonary nodules while controlling for anatomic nodule characteristics and to establish what factors lead to reduced diagnostic sensitivity at low-dose CT. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Each of six participating radiologist independently rated 200 image panels by using a four-point confidence scale. Conventional images were obtained at 200 mAs; low-dose images were obtained at 20 mAs. To fully control their characteristics, nodules were simulated with a given diameter, shape, and section thickness while preserving the resolution, noise level, and reconstruction artifacts of the original images. Panels were matched so that nodules on low-dose and conventional images had equivalent sizes, locations, and relationships to blood vessels. RESULTS: Among 864 positive panels, 259 (60%) of 432 low-dose panels and 272 (63%) of 432 conventional panels were correctly interpreted (P = .259). Lowering the x-ray dose significantly reduced the detectability of peripheral nodules (P = .019) and nodules separated from blood vessels (P = .044). Surprisingly, 3-mm nodules were detected with approximately equal sensitivity (P = .181) at conventional and low-dose CT. The specificity of low-dose images was 88% (148 of 168 panels) versus 91% (153 of 168 panels) for conventional images (P = .372). CONCLUSION: Low-dose CT is acceptable for pulmonary nodule identification, making it suitable for primary screening. These results confirm the strong effect of size, location, and angiocentricity on the sensitivity of nodule detection with conventional CT.

Volumetric (helical/spiral) CT (VCT) of the airways.

Volumetric computed tomography (VCT) represents an important improvement over conventional CT for assessing most airway abnormalities. Elimination of misregistration due to variations in respiration coupled with decreased motion artifact and the ability to obtain routine overlapping sections allow a more confident estimation of the presence and extent of disease. Recently, attention has focused on newer reconstruction techniques including: multiplanar reconstructions (MPRs), including curved multiplanar reformations; multiplanar volume reconstructions (MPVRs) using ray projection techniques, such as maximum and minimum projection imaging; external rendering, or 3D-shaded surface displays; and, most recently, internal rendering or so-called "virtual bronchoscopy". Given the often redundant nature of many of these methodologies determining indications for their use remains to be established, especially by comparison to axial imaging. The purpose of this article is to review these various reconstruction techniques and, based on current knowledge, place them in an appropriate clinical context.

Diffuse lung disease: assessment with helical CT--preliminary observations of the role of maximum and minimum intensity projection images.

PURPOSE: To evaluate assessment of diffuse lung disease with helical computed tomography (CT) and maximum intensity projection (MIP) and minimum intensity projection images. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Six patients with suspected lung disease (the control group) and 20 patients with documented disease underwent axial helical CT through the upper and lower lung fields. Findings on the MIP and minimum intensity projection images of each helical data set were compared with findings on the thin-section scan obtained at the midplane of the series. RESULTS: Owing to markedly improved visualization of peripheral pulmonary vessels (n = 26) and improved spatial orientation, MIP images were superior to helical scans to help identify pulmonary nodules and characterize them as peribronchovascular (n = 2) or centrilobular (n = 7). Minimum intensity projection images were more accurate than thin-section scans to help identify lumina of central airways (n = 23) and define abnormal low (n = 15) and high (ground-glass) (n = 8) lung attenuation. Conventional thin-section scans depicted fine linear structures more clearly than either MIP or minimum intensity projection images, including the walls of peripheral, dilated airways (n = 3) and interlobular septa (n = 3). MIP and minimum intensity projection images added additional diagnostic findings to those on thin-section scans in 13 (65%) of 20 cases. CONCLUSION: MIP and minimum intensity projection images of helical data sets may help diagnosis of a wide spectrum of diffuse lung diseases.

Unusual lymphoproliferative disorders in nine adults with HIV or AIDS: CT and pathologic findings.

PURPOSE: To identify characteristic computed tomographic (CT) findings in unusual pulmonary lymphoproliferative disorders seen in adults with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) or acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS). MATERIALS AND METHODS: The authors retrospectively reviewed the CT scans and pathologic specimens from nine patients with pulmonary lymphoproliferative disorders. CT scans were evaluated for nodules, reticulation, areas of ground-glass attenuation, consolidation, and bronchial disease. Changes seen in pathologic specimens were classified as consistent with classic lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis (LIP), mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphoma (MALTOMA), or atypical lymphoproliferative disorder (ALD). Immunopathologic results were reviewed when available. RESULTS: Eight patients had AIDS. Five patients had classic LIP. One patient had MALTOMA, and three patients had ALD. Altogether, 2-4-mm-diameter nodules were the predominant CT finding in eight patients; these were peribronchovascular in four patients. The presence of interstitial nodules correlated with the pathologic finding of nodular disease in seven patients. CONCLUSION: Familiarity with these AIDS-related disorders and their CT appearance should assist in the differential diagnosis.

Cytomegalovirus pneumonitis: spectrum of parenchymal CT findings with pathologic correlation in 21 AIDS patients.

PURPOSE: To identify characteristic features of cytomegalovirus (CMV) pneumonitis at computed tomography (CT), particularly markers that may help differentiate CMV from Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) and biopsy results in 21 patients with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome, cytopathologic evidence of CMV infection without other infections, and available CT scans were retrospectively evaluated. CT findings were correlated with radiographic and pathologic findings when available. RESULTS: BAL findings were positive for CMV in only six cases, 13 patients had extrathoracic CMV infection, and 10 had Kaposi sarcoma. CT findings included ground-glass attenuation, dense consolidation, bronchial wall thickening or bronchiectasis, and interstitial reticulation without air-space disease (12 patients had discrete pulmonary nodules or masses). Biopsy revealed air-space disease as the dominant process in eight cases. Histopathologic findings correlated well with CT appearances. CONCLUSION: CMV pneumonitis should be suspected in patients with either extrathoracic CMV or documented Kaposi sarcoma, especially when radiographic or CT evidence of pulmonary nodules or masses exists.

AIDS associated bronchiectasis: CT features.

The occurrence of bronchiectasis has only rarely been noted among the protean manifestations of HIV infection in the lungs. We retrospectively identified bronchiectasis on CT scans in 12 HIV + and/or AIDS patients in the absence of either documented mycobacterial infection or a history of prior recurrent pyogenic infection. Pneumonitis was documented in 10 of 12 cases. In eight cases, bronchiectasis was associated with episodes of pyogenic infection; four of these patients also had documented opportunistic infections, including three cases of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP). Two patients had infection due solely to PCP. In two cases, bronchiectasis was found in association with one case each of lymphocytic interstitial pneumonitis and nonspecific interstitial pneumonitis, respectively. Although the true incidence of bronchiectasis in this population remains to be established, in our experience bronchiectasis should be considered among the varied pulmonary manifestations of HIV infection. Furthermore, the seemingly rapid development and extent of bronchiectasis in this population suggest an accelerated form of the disease.

Bronchiectasis: CT evaluation.

CT is the imaging method of choice after standard chest radiography for examining patients with suspected bronchiectasis. In most institutions throughout the world, CT has largely eliminated the need for bronchography in the diagnosis of bronchiectasis. Nonetheless, controversy persists concerning the overall accuracy of CT. In an effort to improve overall diagnostic accuracy, we review the wide range of CT appearances of this protean disorder, and emphasize potential problems and technical pitfalls that may arise in routine clinical imaging.

Variables affecting pulmonary nodule detection with computed tomography: evaluation with three-dimensional computer simulation.

To meaningfully evaluate factors determining the overall accuracy of computed tomography (CT) for identifying pulmonary nodules, computer-generated nodules were superimposed on normal CT scans and interpreted independently by three experienced chest radiologists. Variables evaluated included nodule size, shape, number, density, location, edge characteristics, and relationship to adjacent vessels, as well as technical factors, including slice thickness and electronic windowing. The overall sensitivity in identifying nodules was 62% and the specificity was 80%. On average, the observers identified 56, 67, and 63% of nodules on 1.5-, 5-, and 10-mm-thick sections, respectively (p = 0.037). Nodules were more difficult to identify on 1.5-mm-thick sections. On average, observers identified 1, 48, 82, and 91% of nodules < 1.5, < 3, < 4.5, and < 7 mm in diameter, respectively (p < 0.001). Other factors that made a significant contribution (p < 0.01) in identifying nodules, as determined by linear discriminant function analysis, included nodule location, angiocentricity, and density. We concluded that computer-generated nodules can be used to assess a large number of imaging variables. We anticipate that this approach will be of considerable utility in assessing the accuracy of interpretation of a wide range of pathologic entities as well as in optimizing three-dimensional scan protocols within the thorax.

The left atrial catheter: its uses and complications.

The authors describe the radiographic appearance of the left atrial catheter, a widely used postsurgical intracardiac device. Recognition of the characteristic appearance of this catheter should be of value in detection of potential complications, including line fracture with resultant retention and/or embolization, infection, prosthetic valve dysfunction, and even cardiac tamponade.

High resolution CT findings in miliary lung disease.

High-resolution CT (HRCT) and chest radiographs were compared in nine patients with miliary lung disease. In all cases, miliary disease was documented to be infectious in etiology; six of these patients proved to be human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) positive. A mixture of both sharply and poorly defined 1-3 mm nodules was seen in all cases, many of the latter having an appearance indistinguishable from airspace nodules. Other features attributable to the presence of nodules included nodular interlobular septae, nodular irregularity of vessels, subpleural dots, and studded fissures. Diffuse intra- and interlobular septal thickening also proved common, seen in all but one case (91%). Based on limited HRCT-pathologic correlation, CT findings appear primarily to be due to granulomatous foci developing in a seemingly random distribution involving both pulmonary airspaces as well as the interstitium. It is concluded that in the appropriate clinical setting this constellation of findings is characteristic of miliary disease; the role of HRCT especially in the early diagnosis of miliary disease in HIV positive patients remains to be determined prospectively.

Cystic fibrosis: scoring system with thin-section CT.

The progression of lung disease in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) was evaluated with chest radiography. The severity and extent of the various radiographic changes were scored with the Chrispin or the Birmingham method, which involves the use of imprecise and subjective terms, such as line shadows, large pulmonary shadows, and nodular cystic lesions. Although computed tomography (CT) has been shown to be helpful in the evaluation of lung disease in CF, no scoring system or other objective criteria have been developed for the evaluation of the wide range of pulmonary changes in these patients. A CT scoring system was devised that incorporates all of the changes seen in the lungs of patients with CF. Such a scoring system may facilitate objective evaluation of existing and newly developed therapeutic regimens and may be a valuable tool in the preoperative evaluation of patients being considered for lobectomy or bullectomy and in the selection of patients for lung transplantation.

Low-dose CT of the lungs: preliminary observations.

The potential of low-dose computed tomography (CT) of the lungs was critically evaluated in two patients with normal-appearing lungs and 10 patients with a wide diversity of underlying parenchymal abnormalities. At each of five levels, in addition to routine scans obtained at 120 kVp and 140 mA, a scan at 10 mA and a half scan at 10 mA were obtained, with all other parameters held constant. Each scan was evaluated visually to assess anatomic clarity as well as the presence of artifacts and the extent of graininess. At all levels of the thorax, visualization of parenchymal structures was not affected by decreasing the milliamperage. It appears that high-quality, diagnostic images of the lung can be obtained with a very low radiation dose. Although further evaluation is necessary, the potential of low-dose CT for use in the pediatric population in particular, as well as for screening in patients at high risk for developing lung cancer, is apparent.

Lung hernia: radiographic features.

Lung hernia is an abnormal protrusion of the lung beyond the confines of the thoracic cage. Hernias are classified as cervical, intercostal, or diaphragmatic. Each of these types can be either congenital or acquired. Acquired hernias can be spontaneous, posttraumatic, or pathologic as a result of a neoplastic or inflammatory process. This report describes five cases of lung hernias. Two were congenital cervical hernias, detected as incidental findings on chest radiographs of infants. One was a posttraumatic intercostal hernia detected on a chest radiograph and confirmed with CT. The remaining two were acquired intercostal hernias at the site of prior chest-tube drainage of tuberculous empyemas. Although both of these were clearly shown on CT scans, only one was visible on chest radiographs.

Spontaneous intramural hematoma of the esophagus.

Spontaneous intramural hematoma of the esophagus (SIHE) is a rare condition usually affecting middle-aged or elderly women. It presents as acute substernal or epigastric pain, typically accompanied by dysphagia or hematemesis. SIHE is not usually associated with vomiting, and is therefore clearly distinguished from emetogenic esophageal disorders, such as the Mallory-Weiss lesion and the Boerhaave syndrome. The diagnosis has traditionally been made by barium esophagram. Therapy is conservative; a favorable prognosis is the rule. The pathogenesis is in dispute. We present a case of SIHE without a discernible mucosal breach, suggesting a primary intramural bleed as the initiating event. We document the utility of computed tomographic scan and magnetic resonance imaging in the diagnosis of SIHE.

Septic pulmonary emboli: CT-radiographic correlation.

Radiographic and CT findings in 15 patients with clinically documented septic pulmonary emboli were compared retrospectively. In most cases, radiographic changes were nonspecific. In comparison, on CT a combination of specific signs could be identified in all patients. These included peripheral nodules with clearly identifiable feeding vessels associated with metastatic lung abscesses (10 [67%] of 15 cases), and subpleural, wedge-shaped densities with and without necrosis caused by septic infarcts (11 [73%] of 15 cases). Ancillary pleural, mediastinal, axillary, and pericardial abnormalities also were more easily identified with CT. We conclude that CT is complementary to other imaging techniques in the recognition of septic pulmonary emboli.