Toward a data-driven evaluation of the 2010 American College of Rheumatology/European League Against Rheumatism criteria for rheumatoid arthritis: is it sensible to look at levels of rheumatoid factor?

OBJECTIVE: Recently, new classification criteria for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) have been devised by methodology that used first a quantitative approach (data from databases), then a qualitative approach (consensus; based on paper patients), and finally a common sense-based approach (evaluation of the former phases). Now the individual items that make up these criteria are being evaluated. This study was undertaken to analyze the item "autoantibodies," in particular rheumatoid factor (RF) level. METHODS: Three separate cohorts comprising a total of 972 patients with undifferentiated arthritis were studied for RA development (according to the 1987 American College of Rheumatology criteria) and arthritis persistence. The positive predictive value (PPV), negative predictive value (NPV), and likelihood ratios (LRs) were compared between different levels of RF and the presence of anti-citrullinated protein antibody (ACPA). A similar comparison was made in 686 RA patients for the rate of joint destruction and achievement of sustained disease-modifying antirheumatic drug-free remission during 7 years of followup. The variation in RF levels obtained by different measurement methods in the same RF-positive sera was explored. RESULTS: Compared to high RF levels, presence of ACPA had a better balance between positive LR and negative LR and between PPV and NPV for RA development. The additive value of ACPA assessment after testing for RF level was higher than vice versa. The association between high RF level and RA severity was not as strong as that between ACPA antibodies and RA severity. The RF level obtained by different methods in the same patients' sera varied considerably. CONCLUSION: Our findings indicate that determination of RF level is subject to large variation; high RF level has limited additive prognostic value compared to ACPA positivity. Thus, omitting RF level and using RF presence, ACPA presence, and ACPA level may improve the 2010 criteria for RA.

B-cell maturation and antibody responses in individuals carrying a mutated CD19 allele.

Homozygous CD19 mutations lead to an antibody deficiency due to disruption of the CD19 complex and consequent impaired signaling by the B-cell antigen receptor. We studied the effects of heterozygous CD19 mutations on peripheral B-cell development and antibody responses in a large family with multiple consanguineous marriages. Sequence analysis of 96 family members revealed 30 carriers of the CD19 mutation. Lymphocyte subset counts were not significantly different between carriers and noncarriers in three different age groups (0-10 years; 11-18 years; adults). B cells of carriers had reduced CD19 and CD21 median expression levels, and had reduced proportions of transitional (0-10 years) and CD5(+) B cells (adults). CD19 carriers did not show clinical signs of immunodeficiency; they were well capable to produce normal serum Ig levels and had normal responses to primary and booster vaccinations. The frequency of mutated Vκ alleles was not affected. Heterozygous loss of CD19 causes some changes in the naive B-cell compartment, but overall in vivo B-cell maturation or humoral immunity is not affected. Many antibody deficiencies are not monogenetic, but likely caused by a combination of multiple genetic variations. Therefore, functional analyses of immune cell function should be carried out to show whether heterozygous mutations contribute to disease.

Women with rheumatoid arthritis negative for anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide and rheumatoid factor are more likely to improve during pregnancy, whereas in autoantibody-positive women autoantibody levels are not influenced by pregnancy.

OBJECTIVES: To determine whether changes in levels of anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide (anti-CCP) and rheumatoid factor (RF) are associated with the spontaneous improvement of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) during pregnancy and with the subsequent flare post partum. METHODS: Disease activity scores from the Pregnancy-induced Amelioration of Rheumatoid Arthritis (PARA) study of 118 patients were available for analysis. Before conception (if applicable), at each trimester and at 6, 12 and 26 weeks post partum, levels of the autoantibodies anti-CCP, IgM-RF, IgG-RF and IgA-RF were determined. Responses in disease activity were classified according to European League Against Rheumatism (EULAR) response criteria during pregnancy and post partum, and associated with the presence or absence of autoantibodies. RESULTS: The median levels of anti-CCP and all subclasses of RF during pregnancy were stable, whereas post partum the levels of anti-CCP, IgM-RF and IgA-RF declined. A significantly higher percentage of women without autoantibodies (negative for anti-CCP and RF) improved compared with women positive for either or both autoantibodies (75% vs 39%, p = 0.01). The occurrence of a flare post partum was comparable between these groups. CONCLUSIONS: Improvement of disease activity of RA during pregnancy was not associated with changes in levels of autoantibodies during pregnancy, however, improvement may occur more frequently in the absence of anti-CCP and RF.

Anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide positivity in non-rheumatoid arthritis disease samples: citrulline-dependent or not?

BACKGROUND: Antibodies directed against citrullinated proteins (eg anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide (CCP)) have excellent diagnostic and good prognostic potential for rheumatoid arthritis. Type 1 autoimmune hepatitis (AIH-1) is a chronic liver disease characterised by a variety of serum autoantibodies. Recently, in a large group of patients with AIH-1 without clear rheumatoid arthritis overlap, a relatively high percentage (9%) of anti-CCP2 positivity was scored. OBJECTIVES: To characterise the citrulline-dependence of the observed anti-CCP2 positivity in AIH-1 sera as well as in other groups of patients without rheumatoid arthritis (mainly rheumatic diseases). METHODS: Serum samples of 57 patients with AIH-1 and 66 patients without rheumatoid arthritis, most of them reported as anti-CCP positive, were tested for citrulline-specific reactivity with a second generation anti-CCP kit, with the citrullinated and the corresponding non-citrullinated (arginine-containing) antigen. A subset of AIH-1 sera was also tested with a CCP1 ELISA (and arginine control). RESULTS: The anti-CCP2 reactivity of most non-rheumatoid arthritis rheumatic diseases samples (87-93%) was citrulline-specific, whereas a relatively high percentage of AIH-1 samples (42-50%) turned out to be reactive in a citrulline-independent manner. The use of citrullinated and non-citrullinated CCP1 peptides confirmed a high occurrence of citrulline-independent reactivity in AIH-1 samples. CONCLUSIONS: In rheumatoid arthritis and most non-rheumatoid arthritis rheumatologic disease sera, anti-CCP positivity is citrulline-dependent. However in some patients, particularly patients with AIH-1, citrulline-independent reactivity in the anti-CCP2 test can occur. A positive CCP test in a non-rheumatic disease (eg liver disease) should therefore be interpreted with care, and preferably followed by a control ELISA with a non-citrullinated antigen.

[A retrospective study on the role of antibodies against soluble liver antigen (anti-SLA antibodies) and other autoantibodies in the diagnostics of autoimmune hepatitis]. / Een retrospectieve studie naar de rol van antistoffen tegen oplosbaar ('soluble') leverantigeen (anti-sLA-antistoffen) en van andere autoantistoffen bij de diagnostiek van auto-immune hepatitis.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the diagnostic value of antibodies against soluble liver antigen (anti-SLA antibodies) and a number of other antibodies for the diagnosis ofautoimmune hepatitis (AIH). DESIGN: Retrospective. METHOD: Anti-SLA, antinuclear antibodies (ANA), antibodies against smooth muscle (anti-SMA), anti-neutrophil cytoplasm antibodies (peri-nuclear pattern; pANCA) and antibodies against liver-kidney microsomal antigen type 1 (anti-LKM-1) were determined in the sera of 97 patients with AIH and 121 patients with other liver disorders including viral, drug-related and alcoholic liver disease. The sensitivity and specificity of each of the antibodies, or a combination ofantibodies, were calculated for the diagnosis 'AIH'. RESULTS: Anti-SLA antibodies were found only in AIH patients (specificity: 100%); 1 in 7 AIH patients (14%) had these antibodies and in 2% they were the only detectable antibodies. Anti-LKM-1 antibodies also showed a 100% specificity for AIH although the sensitivity was much lower (2%). Whilst the sensitivity of ANA (53%), pANCA (39%) and SMA (39%) was higher, the specificity of these antibodies for AIH was lower. 20% of AIH patients tested negative for all autoantibodies. The simultaneous presence of more than one antibody increased the probability of AIH diagnosis. CONCLUSION: When AIH is suspected, the presence of one or a combination ofanti-SLA, ANA, anti-SMA, anti-LKM-1 and pANCA antibodies is helpful for the often difficult differential diagnosis between AIH and other liver disorders. Anti-SLA antibodies are specific for AIH and appear to be a useful diagnostic parameter.