Clinical, Radiologic, and Legal Significance of "Extensor Response" in Posttraumatic Coma.

OBJECTIVE: The timely detection of neurologic deterioration can be critical for the survival of a neurosurgical patient following head injury. Because little reliable evidence is available on the prognostic value of the clinical sign "extensor response" in comatose posttraumatic patients, we investigated the correlation of this clinical sign with outcome and with early radiologic findings from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). METHODS: This retrospective analysis of prospectively obtained data included 157 patients who had remained in a coma for a minimum of 24 hours after traumatic brain injury. All patients received a 1.5-T MRI within 10 days (median: 2 days) of the injury. The correlations between clinical findings 12 and 24 hours after the injury-in particular, extensor response and pupillary function, MRI findings, and outcome after 1 year-were investigated. Statistical analysis included contingency tables, Fisher exact test, odds ratios (ORs) with confidence intervals (CIs), and weighted κ values. RESULTS: There were 48 patients with extensor response within the first 24 hours after the injury. Patients with extensor response (World Federation of Neurosurgical Societies coma grade III) statistically were significantly more likely to harbor MRI lesions in the brainstem when compared with patients in a coma who had no further deficiencies (coma grade I; p = 0.0004 by Fisher exact test, OR 10.8 with 95% CI, 2.7-42.5) and patients with unilateral loss of pupil function (coma grade II; p = 0.0187, OR 2.8 with 95% CI, 1.2-6.5). The correlation of brainstem lesions as found by MRI and outcome according to the Glasgow Outcome Scale after 1 year was also highly significant (p ≤ 0.016). CONCLUSION: The correlation of extensor response and loss of pupil function with an unfavorable outcome and with brainstem lesions revealed by MRI is highly significant. Their sudden onset may be associated with the sudden onset of brainstem dysfunction and should therefore be regarded as one of the most fundamental warning signs in the clinical monitoring of comatose patients.

Controversies of diffusion weighted imaging in the diagnosis of brain death.

Imaging techniques as confirmatory tests may add safety to the diagnosis of brain death, but are partly not accepted either because they are too invasive, such as conventional arterial angiography, or because there is still lack of evidence of its reliability, such as magnetic resonance angiography. In this study the reliability of diffusion weighted imaging for the diagnosis of brain death was evaluated according in terms of its sensitivity and specificity. The apparent diffusion coefficients (ADC) of 18 brain dead patients were registered from 14 distinct brain areas. The mean ADC values of the brain dead patients were compared with normal controls of physiological ADC values of unaffected brain tissue. Despite a highly significant decrease of the mean ADC value in 16 patients, two patients showed mean ADC values that were within normal physiological range. An explanation may be the pseudonormalization of ADC values seen in stroke patients that depends on the time of the onset of the brain damage. We conclude, diffusion-weighted imaging may provide additional information on damage of the brain tissue but is not a practicable confirmatory test for the reliable diagnosis of brain death.

Laser Doppler flowmetry mapping of cerebrocortical microflow: characteristics and limitations.

The aim of this study was to quantitatively analyze the amount of methodological noise and the spatial and temporal variability of laser Doppler flowmetry (LDF) signals mapping cerebrocortical microflow. In an experimental setup with latex beads, the methodological LDF-signal variability was determined (coefficient of variation or CV(method)). The biological variability of the LDF signals was measured in animal experiments using 10 anesthetized rabbits. One stationary reference probe was used to assess temporal heterogeneity (CV(temp)) and a micromanipulator-driven scanning probe was used to assess spatial heterogeneity (CV(spat)) in a cortical area of 3.5 x 4.5 mm with 252 measurement points. CO(2) tests were used to modulate cerebrovascular resistance. CV(method) was found to be 4.94 +/- 1.7. The CV(temp) for the LDF-velocity signal was assessed to be 13.93 +/- 5.9 during normocapnia. Scanning of the brain surface with the scanning probe revealed a CV(spat) for LDF velocity of 65.0 +/- 16.2 during normocapnia. CO(2) modulation (hypocapnia --> normocapnia --> hypercapnia) of the cerebral resistance did not show a significant change in temporal heterogeneity (10.84 +/- 3.1 --> 13.93 +/- 5.9 --> 14.82 +/- 3.9), whereas spatial heterogeneity decreased significantly (81.31 +/- 12.0 --> 65.0 +/- 16.2 --> 54.04 +/- 21.8). Although the spatial and temporal variability of LDF signals evoked by cerebrocortical microflow is in the same range as with other methods and in other organs, LDF cerebrocortical mapping is restricted by the large temporal and spatial heterogeneity of the cerebrocortical vasculature. The definitions of sample volume, scanning step width, probe to brain surface distance, and average time per scanning point are critical concerning reliable LDF cerebrocortical mapping techniques.