Comparative transcriptome analysis of bone marrow resident versus culture-expanded mouse mesenchymal stem/stromal cells.

BACKGROUND AIMS: Mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (MSCs) are defined as culture-expanded populations, and although these cells recapitulate many properties of bone marrow (BM) resident skeletal stem/progenitor cells, few studies have directly compared these populations to evaluate how culture adaptation and expansion impact critical quality attributes. METHODS: We analyzed by RNA sequencing Lin-SCA1+ MSCs enriched from BM by immunodepletion (ID) and after subsequent culture expansion (Ex) and Lin-LEPR+ MSCs sorted (S) directly from BM. Pairwise comparisons were used to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs) between populations, and gene set enrichment analysis was employed to identify biological pathways/processes unique to each population. K-means cluster analysis resolved isolation status-dependent changes in transcription in pseudotime. RESULTS: Hierarchical clustering segregated populations by isolation process, and principal component analysis identified transcripts related to vasculature development, ossification and inflammatory/cytokine signaling as key drivers of population variance. Pairwise comparisons identified 3849 DEGs in ID versus S BM-MSCs mapping to Gene Ontology (GO) terms related to immune and metabolic processes and 334 DEGs in Ex versus ID BM-MSCs mapping to GO terms related to tissue development, cell growth and replication and organelle organization. K-means cluster analysis revealed significant differences in transcripts encoding stemness and differentiation markers, extracellular matrix structural constituents and remodeling enzymes and paracrine-acting factors between populations. CONCLUSIONS: These comparative analyses reveal significant differences in gene expression signatures between BM resident and culture-expanded MSCs, thereby providing new insight into how culture adaptation/expansion endows the latter with unique quality attributes.

Novel role for alpha-2-macroglobulin (A2M) as a disease modifying protein in senile osteoporosis.

Introduction: In the rapidly aging U.S. population, age-induced bone loss (senile osteoporosis) represents a major public health concern that is associated with a significant increased risk for low trauma fragility fractures, which are debilitating to patients, cause significant morbidity and mortality, and are costly to treat and manage. While various treatments exist to slow bone loss in osteoporosis patients, these suffer from poor tolerability and label restrictions that limit their overall effectiveness. Over the past decade, skeletal stem/progenitor cells (SSPCs), which are the main precursor of osteoblasts and adipocytes in adult bone marrow (BM), have emerged as important players in osteoporosis. Methods: Age-induced skeletal pathology was quantified in elderly (24-month-old) vs. mature (3-month-old) mice by micro-CT and changes in SSPC abundance in the BM of these mice was quantified by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). SSPCs from elderly vs. mature mice were also analyzed by RNA-Seq to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs), and gain and loss-of-function studies were performed in human BM-derived mesenchymal stromal cells (BM-MSCs) to assess A2M function. Results: Elderly mice were shown to exhibit significant age-induced skeletal pathology, which correlated with a significant increase in SSPC abundance in BM. RNA-seq analysis identified alpha-2-macroglobulin (A2M), a pan-protease inhibitor that also binds inflammatory cytokines, as one of the most downregulated transcripts in SSPCs isolated from the BM of elderly vs. mature mice, and silencing of A2M expression in human BM-MSCs induced their proliferation and skewed their lineage bifurcation toward adipogenesis at the expense of osteogenesis thereby recapitulating critical aspects of age-induced stem cell dysfunction. Conclusion: These findings identify A2M as a novel disease modifying protein in osteoporosis, downregulation of which in bone marrow promotes SSPC dysfunction and imbalances in skeletal homeostasis.

TWIST1 and TSG6 are coordinately regulated and function as potency biomarkers in human MSCs.

Mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (MSCs) have been evaluated in >1500 clinical trials, but outcomes remain suboptimal because of knowledge gaps in quality attributes that confer potency. We show that TWIST1 directly represses TSG6 expression that TWIST1 and TSG6 are inversely correlated across bone marrow-derived MSC (BM-MSC) donor cohorts and predict interdonor differences in their proangiogenic, anti-inflammatory, and immune suppressive activity in vitro and in sterile inflammation and autoimmune type 1 diabetes preclinical models. Transcript profiling of TWIST1HiTSG6Low versus TWISTLowTSG6Hi BM-MSCs revealed previously unidentified roles for TWIST1/TSG6 in regulating cellular oxidative stress and TGF-ß2 in modulating TSG6 expression and anti-inflammatory activity. TWIST1 and TSG6 levels also correlate to donor stature and predict differences in iPSC-derived MSC quality attributes. These results validate TWIST1 and TSG6 as biomarkers that predict interdonor differences in potency across laboratories and assay platforms, thereby providing a means to manufacture MSC products tailored to specific diseases.

Transcriptional Targets of TWIST1 in Human Mesenchymal Stem/Stromal Cells Mechanistically Link Stem/Progenitor and Paracrine Functions.

Despite extensive clinical testing, mesenchymal stem/stromal cell (MSC)-based therapies continue to underperform with respect to efficacy, which reflects the paucity of biomarkers that predict potency prior to patient administration. Previously, we reported that TWIST1 predicts inter-donor differences in MSC quality attributes that confer potency. To define the full spectrum of TWIST1 activity in MSCs, the present work employed integrated omics-based profiling to identify a high-confidence set of TWIST1 targets, which mapped to cellular processes related to ECM structure/organization, skeletal and circulatory system development, interferon gamma signaling, and inflammation. These targets are implicated in contributing to both stem/progenitor and paracrine activities of MSCs indicating these processes are linked mechanistically in a TWIST1-dependent manner. Targets implicated in extracellular matrix dynamics further implicate TWIST1 in modulating cellular responses to niche remodeling. Novel TWIST1-regulated genes identified herein may be prioritized for future mechanistic and functional studies.

Revisiting the Mesenchymal "Stem vs. Stromal" Cell Dichotomy and Its Implications for Development of Improved Potency Metrics.

Mesenchymal stem/stromal cell (MSC)-based therapies have been evaluated in over 1500 human clinical trials for a diverse array of disease indication, but outcomes remain unpredictable due to knowledge gaps in the quality attributes that confer therapeutic potency onto cells and their mode of action in vivo. Based on accumulated evidence from pre-clinical models, MSCs exert therapeutic effects by repressing inflammatory and immune-mediated response via paracrine action following reprogramming by the host injury microenvironment, and by polarization of tissue resident macrophages following phagocytosis to an alternatively activated (M2) state. An important tenet of this existing paradigm is that well-established stem/progenitor functions of MSCs are independent of paracrine function and dispensable for their anti-inflammatory and immune suppressive functions. Herein, we review evidence that stem/progenitor and paracrine functions of MSCs are mechanistically linked and organized hierarchically and describe how this link may be exploited to develop metrics that predict MSC potency across a spectrum of activities and regenerative medicine applications.

Mesenchymal stem/stromal cells from a transplanted, asymptomatic patient with Fanconi anemia exhibit an aging-like phenotype and dysregulated expression of genes implicated in hematopoiesis and myelodysplasia.

BACKGROUND AIMS: Fanconi anemia (FA) is an inherited bone marrow failure syndrome caused by defects in the repair of DNA inter-strand crosslinks and manifests as aplastic anemia, myelodysplastic syndrome and acute myeloid leukemia. FA also causes defects in mesenchymal stromal cell (MSC) function, but how different FA gene mutations alter function remains understudied. METHODS: We compared the growth, differentiation and transcript profile of a single MSC isolate from an asymptomatic patient with FA with a FANCG nonsense mutation who underwent hematopoietic stem cell transplantation 10 years prior to that from a representative healthy donor (HD). RESULTS: We show that FANCG-/- MSCs exhibit rapid onset of growth cessation, skewed bi-lineage differentiation in favor of adipogenesis and increased cellular oxidate stress consistent with an aging-like phenotype. Transcript profiling identified pathways related to cell growth, senescence, cellular stress responses and DNA replication/repair as over-represented in FANCG-/- MSC, and real-time polymerase chain reaction confirmed these MSCs expressed reduced levels of transcripts implicated in cell growth (TWIST1, FGFR2v7-8) and osteogenesis (TWIST1, RUNX2) and increased levels of transcripts regulating adipogenesis (GPR116) and insulin signaling. They also expressed reduced levels of mRNAs implicated in HSC self-maintenance and homing (KITLG, HGF, GDNF, PGF, CFB, IL-1B and CSF1) and elevated levels of those implicated in myelodysplasia (IL-6, GDF15). CONCLUSIONS: Together, these findings demonstrate how inactivation of FANCG impacts MSC behavior, which parallels observed defects in osteogenesis, HSC depletion and leukemic blast formation seen in patients with FA.

Pharmacological Inhibition of Inositol Hexakisphosphate Kinase 1 Protects Mice against Obesity-Induced Bone Loss.

Obesity and type II diabetes mellitus (T2DM) are prominent risk factors for secondary osteoporosis due to the negative impacts of hyperglycemia and excessive body fat on bone metabolism. While the armamentarium of anti-diabetic drugs is expanding, their negative or unknown impacts on bone metabolism limits effectiveness. The inactivation of inositol hexakisphosphate kinase 1 (IP6K1) protects mice from high-fat-diet (HFD)-induced obesity (DIO) and insulin resistance by enhancing thermogenic energy expenditure, but the role of this kinase and the consequences of its inhibition on bone metabolism are unknown. To determine if IP6K1 inhibition in obese mice affords protection against obesity-induced metabolic derangements and bone loss, we maintained 2-month-old mice on a normal chow control diet or HFD under thermal neutral conditions for 100 d. Beginning on day 40, HFD-fed mice were divided into two groups and administered daily injections of vehicle or the pan-IP6K inhibitor TNP [N2-(m-Trifluorobenzyl), N6-(p-nitrobenzyl) purine]. HFD-fed mice developed obesity, hyperglycemia, hyperlipidemia, and secondary osteoporosis, while TNP administration protected mice against HFD-induced metabolic and lipid derangements and preserved bone mass, mineral density, and trabecular microarchitecture, which correlated with reduced serum leptin levels, reduced marrow adiposity, and preservation of marrow resident skeletal stem/progenitor cells (SSPCs). TNP also exhibited hypotensive activity, an unrealized benefit of the drug, and its prolonged administration had no adverse impacts on spermatogenesis. Together, these data indicate that the inhibition of IP6K1 using selective inhibitors, such as TNP, may provide an effective strategy to manage obesity and T2DM due to its bone sparing effects.

Transcriptional responses of skeletal stem/progenitor cells to hindlimb unloading and recovery correlate with localized but not systemic multi-systems impacts.

Disuse osteoporosis (DO) results from mechanical unloading of weight-bearing bones and causes structural changes that compromise skeletal integrity, leading to increased fracture risk. Although bone loss in DO results from imbalances in osteoblast vs. osteoclast activity, its effects on skeletal stem/progenitor cells (SSCs) is indeterminate. We modeled DO in mice by 8 and 14 weeks of hindlimb unloading (HU) or 8 weeks of unloading followed by 8 weeks of recovery (HUR) and monitored impacts on animal physiology and behavior, metabolism, marrow adipose tissue (MAT) volume, bone density and micro-architecture, and bone marrow (BM) leptin and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) protein expression, and correlated multi-systems impacts of HU and HUR with the transcript profiles of Lin-LEPR+ SSCs and mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) purified from BM. Using this integrative approach, we demonstrate that prolonged HU induces muscle atrophy, progressive bone loss, and MAT accumulation that paralleled increases in BM but not systemic leptin levels, which remained low in lipodystrophic HU mice. HU also induced SSC quiescence and downregulated bone anabolic and neurogenic pathways, which paralleled increases in BM TH expression, but had minimal impacts on MSCs, indicating a lack of HU memory in culture-expanded populations. Although most impacts of HU were reversed by HUR, trabecular micro-architecture remained compromised and time-resolved changes in the SSC transcriptome identified various signaling pathways implicated in bone formation that were unresponsive to HUR. These findings indicate that HU-induced alterations to the SSC transcriptome that persist after reloading may contribute to poor bone recovery.

Mesenchymal stem cell-derived extracellular vesicles reduce senescence and extend health span in mouse models of aging.

Aging drives progressive loss of the ability of tissues to recover from stress, partly through loss of somatic stem cell function and increased senescent burden. We demonstrate that bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells (BM-MSCs) rapidly senescence and become dysfunctional in culture. Injection of BM-MSCs from young mice prolonged life span and health span, and conditioned media (CM) from young BM-MSCs rescued the function of aged stem cells and senescent fibroblasts. Extracellular vesicles (EVs) from young BM-MSC CM extended life span of Ercc1-/- mice similarly to injection of young BM-MSCs. Finally, treatment with EVs from MSCs generated from human ES cells reduced senescence in culture and in vivo, and improved health span. Thus, MSC EVs represent an effective and safe approach for conferring the therapeutic effects of adult stem cells, avoiding the risks of tumor development and donor cell rejection. These results demonstrate that MSC-derived EVs are highly effective senotherapeutics, slowing the progression of aging, and diseases driven by cellular senescence.

Chemical systems biology reveals mechanisms of glucocorticoid receptor signaling.

Glucocorticoids display remarkable anti-inflammatory activity, but their use is limited by on-target adverse effects including insulin resistance and skeletal muscle atrophy. We used a chemical systems biology approach, ligand class analysis, to examine ligands designed to modulate glucocorticoid receptor activity through distinct structural mechanisms. These ligands displayed diverse activity profiles, providing the variance required to identify target genes and coregulator interactions that were highly predictive of their effects on myocyte glucose disposal and protein balance. Their anti-inflammatory effects were linked to glucose disposal but not muscle atrophy. This approach also predicted selective modulation in vivo, identifying compounds that were muscle-sparing or anabolic for protein balance and mitochondrial potential. Ligand class analysis defined the mechanistic links between the ligand-receptor interface and ligand-driven physiological outcomes, a general approach that can be applied to any ligand-regulated allosteric signaling system.

Basal p53 expression is indispensable for mesenchymal stem cell integrity.

Marrow-resident mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) serve as a functional component of the perivascular niche that regulates hematopoiesis. They also represent the main source of bone formed in adult bone marrow, and their bifurcation to osteoblast and adipocyte lineages plays a key role in skeletal homeostasis and aging. Although the tumor suppressor p53 also functions in bone organogenesis, homeostasis, and neoplasia, its role in MSCs remains poorly described. Herein, we examined the normal physiological role of p53 in primary MSCs cultured under physiologic oxygen levels. Using knockout mice and gene silencing we show that p53 inactivation downregulates expression of TWIST2, which normally restrains cellular differentiation to maintain wild-type MSCs in a multipotent state, depletes mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels, and suppresses ROS generation and PPARG gene and protein induction in response to adipogenic stimuli. Mechanistically, this loss of adipogenic potential skews MSCs toward an osteogenic fate, which is further potentiated by TWIST2 downregulation, resulting in highly augmented osteogenic differentiation. We also show that p53-/- MSCs are defective in supporting hematopoiesis as measured in standard colony assays because of decreased secretion of various cytokines including CXCL12 and CSF1. Lastly, we show that transient exposure of wild-type MSCs to 21% oxygen upregulates p53 protein expression, resulting in increased mitochondrial ROS production and enhanced adipogenic differentiation at the expense of osteogenesis, and that treatment of cells with FGF2 mitigates these effects by inducing TWIST2. Together, these findings indicate that basal p53 levels are necessary to maintain MSC bi-potency, and oxygen-induced increases in p53 expression modulate cell fate and survival decisions. Because of the critical function of basal p53 in MSCs, our findings question the use of p53 null cell lines as MSC surrogates, and also implicate dysfunctional MSC responses in the pathophysiology of p53-related skeletal disorders.

Mesenchymal Stem Cells: The Moniker Fits the Science.

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have gained widespread use in regenerative medicine due to their demonstrated efficacy in a broad range of experimental animal models of disease and their excellent safety profile in human clinical trials. Outcomes from these studies suggest that MSCs achieve therapeutic effects in vivo in nonhomologous applications predominantly by paracrine action. This paracrine-centric viewpoint has become widely entrenched in the field, and has spurred a campaign to rename MSCs as "medicinal signaling cells" to better reflect this mode of action. In this Commentary, we argue that the paracrine-centric viewpoint and proposed name change ignores a wealth of old and new data that unequivocally demonstrate the stem cell nature of MSCs, and also overlooks a large effort to exploit homologous applications of MSCs in human clinical trials. Furthermore, we offer evidence that a stem cell-centric viewpoint of MSCs provides a comprehensive understanding of MSC biology that encompasses their paracrine activity, and provides a better foundation to develop metrics that quantify the biological potency of MSC batches for both homologous and nonhomologous clinical applications. Stem Cells 2018;36:7-10.

IP6K1 Reduces Mesenchymal Stem/Stromal Cell Fitness and Potentiates High Fat Diet-Induced Skeletal Involution.

Mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (MSCs) are the predominant source of bone and adipose tissue in adult bone marrow and play a critical role in skeletal homeostasis. Age-induced changes in bone marrow favor adipogenesis over osteogenesis leading to skeletal involution and increased marrow adiposity so pathways that prevent MSC aging are potential therapeutic targets for treating age-related bone diseases. Here, we show that inositol hexakisphosphate kinase 1 (Ip6k1) deletion in mice increases MSC yields from marrow and enhances cell growth and survival ex vivo. In response to the appropriate stimuli, Ip6k1-/- versus Ip6k1+/+ MSCs also exhibit enhanced osteogenesis and hematopoiesis-supporting activity and reduced adipogenic differentiation. Mechanistic-based studies revealed that Ip6k1-/- MSCs express higher MDM2 and lower p53 protein levels resulting in lower intrinsic mitochondrial reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels as compared to Ip6k1+/+ MSCs, but both populations upregulate mitochondrial ROS to similar extents in response to oxygen-induced stress. Finally, we show that mice fed a high fat diet exhibit reduced trabecular bone volume, and that pharmacological inhibition of IP6K1 using a pan-IP6K inhibitor largely reversed this phenotype while increasing MSC yields from bone marrow. Together, these findings reveal an important role for IP6K1 in regulating MSC fitness and differentiation fate. Unlike therapeutic interventions that target peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma and leptin receptor activity, which yield detrimental side effects including increased fracture risk and altered feeding behavior, respectively, inhibition of IP6K1 maintains insulin sensitivity and prevents obesity while preserving bone integrity. Therefore, IP6K1 inhibitors may represent more effective insulin sensitizers due to their bone sparing properties. Stem Cells 2017;35:1973-1983.

Isolation of Mouse Bone Marrow Mesenchymal Stem Cells.

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) were initially characterized as connective tissue progenitors resident in bone marrow, but have now been isolated from a variety of tissues and organs and shown to also exhibit potent tissue regenerative properties mediated largely via paracrine actions. These findings have spurred the development of MSC-based therapies for treating a diverse array of nonskeletal diseases. Although genetic and experimental rodent models of disease represent important tools for developing efficacious MSC-based therapies, development of reliable methods to isolate MSCs from mouse bone marrow has been hampered by the unique biological properties of these cells. Indeed, few isolation schemes afford high yields and purity while maintaining the genomic integrity of cells. We recently demonstrated that mouse MSCs are highly sensitive to oxidative stress, and long-term expansion of these cells in atmospheric oxygen selects for immortalized clones that lack a functional p53 protein. Herein, we describe a protocol for the isolation of primary MSCs from mouse bone marrow that couples immunodepletion with culture in a low-oxygen environment and affords high purity and yield while preserving p53 function.

A Clinical Indications Prediction Scale Based on TWIST1 for Human Mesenchymal Stem Cells.

In addition to their stem/progenitor properties, mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) also exhibit potent effector (angiogenic, antiinflammatory, immuno-modulatory) functions that are largely paracrine in nature. It is widely believed that effector functions underlie most of the therapeutic potential of MSCs and are independent of their stem/progenitor properties. Here we demonstrate that stem/progenitor and effector functions are coordinately regulated at the cellular level by the transcription factor Twist1 and specified within populations according to a hierarchical model. We further show that manipulation of Twist1 levels by genetic approaches or by exposure to widely used culture supplements including fibroblast growth factor 2 (Ffg2) and interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) alters MSC efficacy in cell-based and in vivo assays in a predictable manner. Thus, by mechanistically linking stem/progenitor and effector functions our studies provide a unifying framework in the form of an MSC hierarchy that models the functional complexity of populations. Using this framework, we developed a CLinical Indications Prediction (CLIP) scale that predicts how donor-to-donor heterogeneity and culture conditions impact the therapeutic efficacy of MSC populations for different disease indications.

Mesenchymal stem cells use extracellular vesicles to outsource mitophagy and shuttle microRNAs.

Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and macrophages are fundamental components of the stem cell niche and function coordinately to regulate haematopoietic stem cell self-renewal and mobilization. Recent studies indicate that mitophagy and healthy mitochondrial function are critical to the survival of stem cells, but how these processes are regulated in MSCs is unknown. Here we show that MSCs manage intracellular oxidative stress by targeting depolarized mitochondria to the plasma membrane via arrestin domain-containing protein 1-mediated microvesicles. The vesicles are then engulfed and re-utilized via a process involving fusion by macrophages, resulting in enhanced bioenergetics. Furthermore, we show that MSCs simultaneously shed micro RNA-containing exosomes that inhibit macrophage activation by suppressing Toll-like receptor signalling, thereby de-sensitizing macrophages to the ingested mitochondria. Collectively, these studies mechanistically link mitophagy and MSC survival with macrophage function, thereby providing a physiologically relevant context for the innate immunomodulatory activity of MSCs.

Pharmacological repression of PPARγ promotes osteogenesis.

The nuclear receptor peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor gamma (PPARγ) is the master regulator of adipogenesis and the pharmacological target of the thiazolidinedione (TZD) class of insulin sensitizers. Activation of PPARγ by TZDs promotes adipogenesis at the expense of osteoblast formation, contributing to their associated adverse effects on bone. Recently, we reported the development of PPARγ antagonist SR1664, designed to block the obesity-induced phosphorylation of serine 273 (S273) in the absence of classical agonism, to derive insulin-sensitizing efficacy with improved therapeutic index. Here we identify the structural mechanism by which SR1664 actively antagonizes PPARγ, and extend these findings to develop the inverse agonist SR2595. Treatment of isolated bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cells with SR2595 promotes induction of osteogenic differentiation. Together these results identify the structural determinants of ligand-mediated PPARγ repression, and suggest a therapeutic approach to promote bone formation.

The peculiar biology of mouse mesenchymal stromal cells--oxygen is the key.

Because of the ability to manipulate their genome, mice are the experimental tool of choice for many areas of scientific investigation. Moreover, established experimental mouse models of human disease are widely available and offer a valuable resource to obtain proof-of-concept for many cell-based therapies. Nevertheless, efforts to establish reliable methods to isolate mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) from mouse bone marrow have been elusive. Indeed, a variety of physical and genetic approaches have been described to fractionate MSCs from other cell lineages in bone marrow, but few have achieved high yields or purity while maintaining the genomic integrity of the cells. We provide a historic overview of published procedures dedicated to the isolation of mouse MSCs from bone marrow and compact bone. We also review current findings indicating that growth-restrictive conditions imposed by atmospheric oxygen promotes immortalization of mouse MSCs and how expansion in a low-oxygen environment enhances cell yields and maintains genomic stability. Finally, we provide basic recommendations for isolating primary mouse MSCs and discuss potential pitfalls associated with these isolation methods.