Characterization of a pathway of genomic instability induced by R-loops and its regulation by topoisomerases in E. coli.

The prototype enzymes of the ubiquitous type IA topoisomerases (topos) family are Escherichia coli topo I (topA) and topo III (topB). Topo I shows preference for relaxation of negative supercoiling and topo III for decatenation. However, as they could act as backups for each other or even share functions, strains lacking both enzymes must be used to reveal the roles of type IA enzymes in genome maintenance. Recently, marker frequency analysis (MFA) of genomic DNA from topA topB null mutants revealed a major RNase HI-sensitive DNA peak bordered by Ter/Tus barriers, sites of replication fork fusion and termination in the chromosome terminus region (Ter). Here, flow cytometry for R-loop-dependent replication (RLDR), MFA, R-loop detection with S9.6 antibodies, and microscopy were used to further characterize the mechanism and consequences of over-replication in Ter. It is shown that the Ter peak is not due to the presence of a strong origin for RLDR in Ter region; instead RLDR, which is partly inhibited by the backtracking-resistant rpoB*35 mutation, appears to contribute indirectly to Ter over-replication. The data suggest that RLDR from multiple sites on the chromosome increases the number of replication forks trapped at Ter/Tus barriers which leads to RecA-dependent DNA amplification in Ter and to a chromosome segregation defect. Overproducing topo IV, the main cellular decatenase, does not inhibit RLDR or Ter over-replication but corrects the chromosome segregation defect. Furthermore, our data suggest that the inhibition of RLDR by topo I does not require its C-terminal-mediated interaction with RNA polymerase. Overall, our data reveal a pathway of genomic instability triggered by R-loops and its regulation by various topos activities at different steps.

Supercoiling, R-loops, Replication and the Functions of Bacterial Type 1A Topoisomerases.

Type 1A topoisomerases (topos) are the only topos that bind single-stranded DNA and the only ones found in all cells of the three domains of life. Two subfamilies, topo I and topo III, are present in bacteria. Topo I, found in all of them, relaxes negative supercoiling, while topo III acts as a decatenase in replication. However, recent results suggest that they can also act as back-up for each other. Because they are ubiquitous, type 1A enzymes are expected to be essential for cell viability. Single topA (topo I) and topB (topo III) null mutants of Escherichia coli are viable, but for topA only with compensatory mutations. Double topA topB null mutants were initially believed to be non-viable. However, in two independent studies, results of next generation sequencing (NGS) have recently shown that double topA topB null mutants of Bacillus subtilis and E. coli are viable when they carry parC parE gene amplifications. These genes encode the two subunits of topo IV, the main cellular decatenase. Here, we discuss the essential functions of bacterial type 1A topos in the context of this observation and new results showing their involvement in preventing unregulated replication from R-loops.

R-loop-dependent replication and genomic instability in bacteria.

DNA replication, the faithful copying of genetic material, must be tightly regulated to produce daughter cells with intact copies of the chromosome(s). This regulated replication is initiated by binding of specific proteins at replication origins, such as DnaA to oriC in bacteria. However, unregulated replication can sometimes be initiated at other sites, which can threaten genomic stability. One of the first systems of unregulated replication to be described is the one activated in Escherichia coli mutants lacking RNase HI (rnhA). In fact, rnhA mutants can replicate their chromosomes in a DnaA- and oriC-independent process. Because this replication occurs in cells lacking RNase HI, it is proposed that RNA from R-loops is used as a DNA polymerase primer. Replication from R-loops has recently attracted increased attention due to the advent of DNA:RNA hybrid immunoprecipitation coupled with high-throughput DNA sequencing that revealed the high prevalence of R-loop formation in many organisms, and the demonstration that R-loops can severely threaten genomic stability. Although R-loops have been linked to genomic instability mostly via replication stress, evidence of their toxic effects via unregulated replication has also been presented. Replication from R-loops may also beneficially trigger stress-induced mutagenesis (SIM) that assists bacterial adaptation to stress. Here, we describe the cis- and trans-acting elements involved in R-loop-dependent replication in bacteria, with an emphasis on new data obtained with type 1A topoisomerase mutants and new available technologies. Furthermore, we discuss about the mechanism(s) by which R-loops can reshape the genome with both negative and positive outcomes.

Topoisomerases I and III inhibit R-loop formation to prevent unregulated replication in the chromosomal Ter region of Escherichia coli.

Type 1A topoisomerases (topos) are the only ubiquitous topos. E. coli has two type 1A topos, topo I (topA) and topo III (topB). Topo I relaxes negative supercoiling in part to inhibit R-loop formation. To grow, topA mutants acquire compensatory mutations, base substitutions in gyrA or gyrB (gyrase) or amplifications of a DNA region including parC and parE (topo IV). topB mutants grow normally and topo III binds tightly to single-stranded DNA. What functions topo I and III share in vivo and how cells lacking these important enzymes can survive is unclear. Previously, a gyrB(Ts) compensatory mutation was used to construct topA topB null mutants. These mutants form very long filaments and accumulate diffuse DNA, phenotypes that appears to be related to replication from R-loops. Here, next generation sequencing and qPCR for marker frequency analysis were used to further define the functions of type 1A topos. The results reveal the presence of a RNase HI-sensitive origin of replication in the terminus (Ter) region of the chromosome that is more active in topA topB cells than in topA and rnhA (RNase HI) null cells. The S9.6 antibodies specific to DNA:RNA hybrids were used in dot-blot experiments to show the accumulation of R-loops in rnhA, topA and topA topB null cells. Moreover topA topB gyrB(Ts) strains, but not a topA gyrB(Ts) strain, were found to carry a parC parE amplification. When a topA gyrB(Ts) mutant carried a plasmid producing topo IV, topB null transductants did not have parC parE amplifications. Altogether, the data indicate that in E. coli type 1A topos are required to inhibit R-loop formation/accumulation mostly to prevent unregulated replication in Ter, and that they are essential to prevent excess negative supercoiling and its detrimental effects on cell growth and survival.

Detection of oriC-Independent Replication in Escherichia coli Cells.

In bacteria, replication of the chromosome is normally initiated following the binding of DnaA proteins to the oriC region. However, under certain circumstances, replication can also be initiated independent of the oriC/DnaA system. This is the case, for example, in Escherichia coli cells lacking RNase HI (rnha mutants) or type 1A topoisomerase activity (topA topB mutants). Here, we present a protocol in which replication from the oriC/DnaA system is first inhibited by the addition of the protein synthesis inhibitor, spectinomycin, to exponentially growing bacterial cell cultures. The thymidine analog, 5-ethynyl-2'-deoxyurdine (EdU) is then added to the cells, and after 1 h the cells are fixed and the Alexa Fluor® 488 dye is conjugated to EdU by the click-iT® reaction. The oriC-independent replication is detected in fixed cells by flow cytometry and can be visualized by fluorescence microscopy.