RESUMO
Water quality, critical for human survival and well-being, necessitates rigorous control to mitigate contamination risks, particularly from pathogens amid expanding urbanization. Consequently, the necessity to maintain the microbiological safety of water supplies demands effective surveillance strategies, reliant on the collection of representative samples and precise measurement of contaminants. This review critically examines the advancements of passive sampling techniques for monitoring pathogens in various water systems, including wastewater, freshwater, and seawater. We explore the evolution from conventional materials to innovative adsorbents for pathogen capture and the shift from culture-based to molecular detection methods, underscoring the adaptation of this field to global health challenges. The comparison highlights passive sampling's efficacy over conventional techniques like grab sampling and its potential to overcome existing sampling challenges through the use of innovative materials such as granular activated carbon, thermoplastics, and polymer membranes. By critically evaluating the literature, this work identifies standardization gaps and proposes future research directions to augment passive sampling's efficiency, specificity, and utility in environmental and public health surveillance.
Assuntos
Monitoramento Ambiental , Águas Residuárias , Águas Residuárias/microbiologia , Monitoramento Ambiental/métodos , Microbiologia da Água , Qualidade da Água , HumanosRESUMO
This study presents an updated analysis spanning over two decades (1999-2023) of climate, water quality, and operational data from two drinking water facilities in Atlantic Canada that previously experienced gradual increases in the natural organic matter (NOM) concentration and brownification. The goal was to assess the impact of recent extreme weather events on acute NOM concentration increases and drinking water treatment processes. In 2023, a dry spring combined with a warm and wet summer caused NOM in the water supplies to increase by >67% (as measured by color). To mitigate increased NOM concentration, the alum dose nearly doubled in 2023 compared to that in 2022. Disinfection byproducts were elevated following the event but remained within the compliance levels. From 1999 to 2023, the two plants responded to gradual climate change impacts and brownification, with alum dose increases of between 4.1 and 8.3 times. Equivalent CO2 emissions were estimated for alum usage, which increased by 3 to 7-fold in 2023 compared to when the plants were commissioned decades prior. The plants were not only adversely impacted by climate change but also contributed to the global CO2 burden. Thus, a paradigm shift toward sustainable alternatives for NOM removal is required in the water sector, and climate change adaptation and mitigation principles are urgently needed.
Assuntos
Mudança Climática , Água Potável , Purificação da Água , Água Potável/química , Abastecimento de Água , Qualidade da Água , CanadáRESUMO
Per- and poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are synthetic chemicals widely used in everyday products, causing elevated concentrations in drinking water and posing a global challenge. While adsorption methods are commonly employed for PFAS removal, the substantial cost and environmental footprint of commercial adsorbents highlight the need for more cost-effective alternatives. Additionally, existing adsorbents exhibit limited effectiveness, particularly against diverse PFAS types, such as short-chain PFAS, necessitating modifications to enhance adsorption capacity. Biochar can be considered a cost-effective and eco-friendly alternative to conventional adsorbents. With abundant feedstocks and favorable physicochemical properties, biochar shows significant potential to be applied as an adsorbent for removing contaminants from water. Despite its effectiveness in adsorbing different inorganic and organic contaminants from water environments, some factors restrict its effective application for PFAS adsorption. These factors are related to the biochar properties, and characteristics of PFAS, as well as water chemistry. Therefore, some modifications have been introduced to overcome these limitations and improve biochar's adsorption capacity. This review explores the preparation conditions, including the pyrolysis process, activation, and modification techniques applied to biochar to enhance its adsorption capacity for different types of PFAS. It addresses critical questions about the adsorption performance of biochar and its composites, mechanisms governing PFAS adsorption, challenges, and future perspectives in this field. The surge in research on biochar for PFAS adsorption indicates a growing interest, making this timely review a valuable resource for future research and an in-depth exploration of biochar's potential in PFAS remediation.
Assuntos
Carvão Vegetal , Fluorocarbonos , Poluentes Químicos da Água , Purificação da Água , Carvão Vegetal/química , Adsorção , Poluentes Químicos da Água/química , Poluentes Químicos da Água/análise , Purificação da Água/métodos , Fluorocarbonos/químicaRESUMO
This study assesses the efficacy of ultraviolet light-emitting diodes (UV LEDs) for deactivating Legionella pneumophila (pure culture) and Pseudomonas fluorescens (pure culture and biofilms) on relevant drinking water distribution system surfaces (cast iron and stainless steel). UV LED treatment at 280 nm demonstrated superior performance compared to that at 365 nm, achieving a 4.8 log reduction value (LRV) for P. fluorescens pure cultures and, for biofilms, 4.02 LRV for stainless steel and 2.96 LRV for cast iron at 280 nm. Conversely, the results were less effective at 365 nm, with suspected photolytic reactions on cast iron. Quantification of L. pneumophila yielded varying results: 4 LRV using standard plate counts, 1.8 LRV with Legiolert, and 1 LRV with quantitative polymerase chain reaction at 280 nm, while the results were less than 1.5 LRV at 365 nm. This study provides insights into managing opportunistic pathogens and biofilms, emphasizing the need for improved quantification tools to better assess treatment efficacy.
RESUMO
Human viruses pose a significant health risk in freshwater environments, but current monitoring methods are inadequate for detecting viral presence efficiently. We evaluated a novel passive in-situ concentration method using granular activated carbon (GAC). This study detected and quantified eight enteric and non-enteric, pathogenic viruses in a freshwater recreational lake in paired grab and GAC passive samples. The results found that GAC passive sampling had a higher detection rate for all viruses compared to grab samples, with adenovirus found to be the most prevalent virus, followed by respiratory syncytial virus, norovirus, enterovirus, influenza A, SARS-CoV-2, and rotavirus. GAC in-situ concentration allowed for the capture and recovery of viral gene copy targets that ranged from one to three orders of magnitude higher than conventional ex-situ concentration methods used in viral monitoring. This simple and affordable sampling method may have far-reaching implications for reducing barriers associated with viral monitoring across various environmental contexts.
Assuntos
COVID-19 , Enterovirus , Vírus , Humanos , COVID-19/epidemiologia , SARS-CoV-2/genética , Vírus/genética , Enterovirus/genética , Lagos , Água , Microbiologia da ÁguaRESUMO
Bioelectrochemical degradation is an environmentally friendly, cost-effective and controllable way of providing electron acceptor to the microorganisms. A two-chamber continuous-flow bioelectrochemical reactor (BER) was developed in this study. The objective was to investigate the potential for enhancing the bioelectrochemical degradation of 1,4-dioxane (DX) by Pseudonocardia dioxanivorans CB1190 (CB1190) and microbial community biofilm on conductive and non-conductive carriers in low potentials (1.0-1.2 V) and currents (<2 mA). In the case of CB1190, biodegradation experiments at 1.0 V did not result in any observable change in DX removal efficiency (32.63 ± 2.48%) compared to the 0.0 V (31.69 ± 2.33%). However, the removal efficiency was much higher at 1.2 V (59.08 ± 0.86%). The higher removal at 1.2 V was attributed to an increase in dissolved oxygen (DO) concentration from 3.77 ± 0.33 mg/L at 0.0 V to 5.40 ± 0.11 mg/L at 1.2 V, which resulted from water electrolysis. In the case of microbial community, on the other hand, DX removal efficiency increased at 1.0 V (30.98 ± 1.10%) compared to 0.0 V (23.40 ± 1.02%) that can be attributed to a simultaneous increase in microbial activity from 2389 ± 118.5 ngATP/mgVSS at 0.0 V to 2942 ± 109 ngATP/mgVSS at 1.0 V. Analysis of the changes in microbial composition indicated enrichment of Alistipes and Lutispora at 1.0 V due to the ability of these genera to directly transfer electrons with conductive surface. On the other hand, no change was observed in the microbial community in the case of non-conductive carriers. Results of this study showed that electro-assisted biodegradation of DX at low potentials is possible through two different mechanisms (oxygen production and direct electron transfer with electrode) which makes this technique flexible and cost-effective. The novelty of this work lies in exploring the use of electrical assistance to enhance the biodegradation of DX in the presence of CB1190 and the microbial community. This study more specifically investigated lower potential than required water electrolysis potential, allowing microorganisms to be stimulated through mechanisms unrelated to oxygen generation.
Assuntos
Actinomycetales , Microbiota , Actinomycetales/metabolismo , Biodegradação Ambiental , Biofilmes , Água/metabolismo , Oxigênio/metabolismoRESUMO
Cyanotoxins pose significant human health risks, but traditional monitoring approaches can be expensive, time consuming, and require analytical equipment or expertise that may not be readily available. Quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) is becoming an increasingly common monitoring strategy as detection of the genes responsible for cyanotoxin synthesis can be used as an early warning signal. Here we tested passive sampling of cyanobacterial DNA as an alternative to grab sampling in a freshwater drinking supply lake with a known history of microcystin-LR. DNA extracted from grab and passive samples was analyzed via a multiplex qPCR assay that included gene targets for four common cyanotoxins. Passive samples captured similar trends in total cyanobacteria and the mcyE/ndaF gene responsible for microcystin production when compared to traditional grab samples. Passive samples also detected genes associated with the production of cylindrospermopsin and saxitoxin that were not detected in grab samples. This sampling approach proved a viable alternative to grab sampling when used as an early warning monitoring tool. In addition to the logistical benefits of passive sampling, the detection of gene targets not detected by grab samples indicates that passive sampling may allow for a more complete profile of potential cyanotoxin risk.
Assuntos
Toxinas Bacterianas , Cianobactérias , Humanos , Toxinas Bacterianas/genética , Toxinas Bacterianas/análise , Microcistinas/análise , Toxinas de Cianobactérias , Cianobactérias/genética , Saxitoxina/análise , Saxitoxina/genética , Lagos/microbiologiaRESUMO
Manganese (Mn) control in surface water systems is a challenge for the drinking water industry, especially through a sustainability framework. Current methods for removing manganese from surface water use strong oxidants that embed carbon and can be expensive and harmful to human health and the environment. In this study, we used a simple biofilter design to remove manganese from lake water, without conventional surface water pre-treatments. Biofilters with aerated influent removed manganese to concentrations below 10 µg/L when receiving influent water containing > 120 µg/L of dissolved manganese. Manganese removal was not inhibited by high iron loadings or poor ammonia removal, suggesting that removal mechanisms may differ from groundwater biofilters. Experimental biofilters also achieved lower effluent manganese concentrations than the full-scale conventional treatment process, while receiving higher manganese concentrations. This biological approach could help achieve sustainable development goals.
RESUMO
A multiplex quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR)-based method was designed for the simultaneous detection of influenza A, SARS-CoV-2, respiratory syncytial virus, and measles virus. The performance of the multiplex assay was compared to four monoplex assays for relative quantification using standard quantification curves. Results showed that the multiplex assay had comparable linearity and analytical sensitivity to the monoplex assays, and the quantification parameters of both assays demonstrated minimal differences. Viral reporting recommendations for the multiplex method were estimated based on the corresponding limit of quantification (LOQ) and the limit of detection at 95 % confidence interval (LOD) values for each viral target. The LOQ was determined by the lowest nominal RNA concentrations where %CV values were ≤35 %. Corresponding LOD values for each viral target were between 15 and 25 gene copies per reaction (GC/rxn), and LOQ values were within 10 to 15 GC/rxn. The detection performance of a new multiplex assay was validated in the field by collecting composite wastewater samples from a local treatment facility and passive samples from three sewer shed locations. Results indicated that the assay could accurately estimate viral loads from various sample types, with samples collected from passive samplers showing a greater range of detectable viral concentrations than composite wastewater samples. This suggests that the sensitivity of the multiplex method may be improved when paired with more sensitive sampling methods. Laboratory and field results demonstrate the robustness and sensitivity of the multiplex assay and its applicability to detect the relative abundance of four viral targets among wastewater samples. Conventional monoplex RT-qPCR assays are suitable for diagnosing viral infections. However, multiplex analysis using wastewater provides a fast and cost-effective way to monitor viral diseases in a population or environment.
Assuntos
COVID-19 , Influenza Humana , Sarampo , Viroses , Humanos , Vírus Sinciciais Respiratórios , SARS-CoV-2 , Águas Residuárias , Sensibilidade e Especificidade , Reação em Cadeia da Polimerase Multiplex/métodosRESUMO
Ultraviolet (UV) disinfection has been incorporated into both drinking water and wastewater treatment processes for several decades; however, it comes with negative environmental consequences such as high energy demands and the use of mercury. Understanding how to scale and build climate responsive technologies is key in fulfilling the intersection of UN Sustainable Development Goals 6 and 13. One technology that addresses the drawbacks of conventional wastewater UV disinfection systems, while providing a climate responsive solution, is UV light emitting diodes (LEDs). The objective of this study was to compare performance of bench-scale 280 nm UV LEDs to bench-scale low pressure (LP) lamps and full-scale UV treated wastewater samples. Results from the study demonstrated that the UV LED system provides a robust treatment that outperformed LP systems at the bench-scale. A comparison of relative energy consumptions of the UV LED system at 20 mJ cm-2 and LP system at 30 and 40 mJ cm-2 was completed. Based on current projections for wall plug efficiencies (WPE) of UV LED it is expected that the energy consumption of LED reactors will be on par or lower compared to the LP systems by 2025. This study determined that, at a WPE of 20%, the equivalent UV LED system would lead to a 24.6% and 43.4% reduction in power consumption for the 30 and 40 mJ cm-2 scenarios, respectively.
RESUMO
Reduced atmospheric acid deposition has given rise to recovery from acidification - defined as increasing pH, acid neutralization capacity (ANC), or alkalinity in surface waters. Strong evidence of recovery has been reported across North America and Europe, driving chemical responses. The primary chemical responses identified in this review were increasing concentration and changing character of natural organic matter (NOM) towards predominantly hydrophobic nature. The concentration of NOM also influenced trace metal cycling as many browning surface waters also reported increases in Fe and Al. Further, climate change and other factors (e.g., changing land use) act in concert with reductions in atmospheric deposition to contribute to widespread browning and will have a more pronounced effect as deposition stabilizes. The observed water quality trends have presented challenges for drinking water treatment (e.g., increased chemical dosing, poor filter operations, formation of disinfection by-products) and many facilities may be under designed as a result. This comprehensive review has identified key research areas to be addressed, including 1) a need for comprehensive monitoring programs (e.g., larger timescales; consistency in measurements) to assess climate change impacts on recovery responses and NOM dynamics, and 2) a better understanding of drinking water treatment vulnerabilities and the transition towards robust treatment technologies and solutions that can adapt to climate change and other drivers of changing water quality.
Assuntos
Água Potável , Poluentes Químicos da Água , Purificação da Água , Qualidade da Água , Desinfecção , Mudança Climática , Poluentes Químicos da Água/análiseRESUMO
Orthophosphate-polyphosphate blends are commonly used to control lead release into drinking water, but little is known about how they interact with lead corrosion scale. Conventional corrosion control practice assumes that orthophosphate controls lead release by forming insoluble Pb-phosphate minerals, but this does not always occur, and under certain conditions, phosphate blends may increase lead release. Here, we used continuously-stirred tank reactors to compare orthophosphate-polyphosphate blends with orthophosphate on the basis of lead (II) carbonate dissolution and transformation at environmentally relevant phosphate concentrations. Three model polyphosphates-tripoly-, trimeta- and hexametaphosphate-were used. Hexametaphosphate was the strongest complexing agent (1.60-2.10 molPb/molPolyphosphate), followed by tripolyphosphate and trimetaphosphate (1.00 and 0.07 molPb/molPolyphosphate, respectively. At equivalent orthophosphate and polyphosphate concentrations (as P), orthophosphate-trimetaphosphate had minimal impact on lead release, while orthophosphate-tripolyphosphate increased dissolved lead. Orthophosphate-hexametaphosphate also increased dissolved lead, but only over a 24-h stagnation. Both orthophosphate-tripolyphosphate and orthophosphate-hexametaphosphate increased colloidal lead after 24-h. Increasing the concentrations of hexameta- and tripoly-phosphate increased dissolved lead release, while all three polyphosphates inhibited the formation of hydroxypyromorphite and reduced the phosphorus content of the resulting lead solids. We attributed the impacts of orthophosphate-polyphosphates to a combination of complexation, adsorption, colloidal dispersion, polyphosphate hydrolysis, and lead mineral precipitation.
Assuntos
Água Potável , Solubilidade , Chumbo , Fosfatos , Polifosfatos , Carbonatos , FósforoRESUMO
Orthophosphate is widely used to control lead (Pb) release in drinking water distribution systems, but phosphorus addition is not sustainable. Alternative corrosion control treatments are needed, and sodium silicate is one possibility. Here, pre-corroded Pb coupons-with and without free chlorine-were used to examine early-phase corrosion scale development after silicate addition, with orthophosphate as a reference corrosion inhibitor. Scale development was evaluated in terms of total Pb release, phase transformation, electrochemical impedance, morphological changes, Pb dissolution kinetics, and short-term Pb-Cu galvanic corrosion. Elevated Pb release occurred for approximately one month after silicate addition, and total Pb release peaked at 1968.1 µg/L and 1176.9 µg/L from systems with and without free chlorine, respectively. In contrast, orthophosphate-treated coupons exhibited fewer, less pronounced spikes in Pb release. By day 354, the median total Pb release from orthophosphate-treated coupons with and without free chlorine had decreased to 3.7 and 5.0 µg/L, respectively, while the median total Pb release from corresponding silicate-treated coupons was much higher, at 44.9 µg/L and 34.3 µg/L. Calcium lead apatite (Ca0.56Pb3.77(PO4)3OH0.67) was identified in orthophosphate-treated scales, with hydroxylpyromorphite (Pb5(PO4)3OH) present in the absence of free chlorine. Plattnerite occurred on coupons in all chlorinated systems. Pb silicate compounds were not detected, but Ca2SiO4 and Na2Ca2(SiO3)3 were identified by X-ray powder diffraction. The charge transfer: film resistance ratio characterizing the orthophosphate-treated coupons decreased slowly while that of the silicate-treated coupons increased after silicate was added. These variations suggest orthophosphate provided better corrosion control than silicate did. Silicate treatment generally caused degradation of the top Pb scale layer, resulting in elevated Pb release, while orthophosphate encouraged the growth of more structured, generally thicker, corrosion scales that were effective in limiting Pb release.
Assuntos
Fosfatos , Poluentes Químicos da Água , Cloro/química , Corrosão , Chumbo , Fosfatos/química , Silicatos , Poluentes Químicos da Água/química , Abastecimento de ÁguaRESUMO
This study aimed to develop a repeatable, reliable, high-throughput protocol to monitor bacterial growth in 96-well plates and analyze the maximum growth rate. The growth curves and maximum growth rates of two bacterial species were determined. Issues including (i) lid condensation, (ii) pathlength correction, (iii) inoculation size, (iv) sampling time interval, and (v) spatial bias were investigated. The repeatability of the protocol was assessed with three independent technical replications, with a standard deviation of 0.03 between the runs. The maximum growth rates of Bacillus mycoides and Paenibacillus tundrae were determined to be (mean ± SD) 0.99 h-1 ± 0.03 h-1 and 0.85 h-1 ± 0.025 h-1, respectively. These bacteria are more challenging to monitor optically due to their affinity to clump together. This study demonstrates the critical importance of inoculation size, path length correction, lid warming, sampling time intervals, and well-plate spatial bias to obtain reliable, accurate, and reproducible data on microplate readers. The developed protocol and its verification steps can be expanded to other methods using microplate readers and high-throughput protocols, reducing the researchers' innate errors and material costs.
Assuntos
Bactérias , Reprodutibilidade dos TestesRESUMO
Immersive ultraviolet disinfection provides a chemical-free technology for safer textiles, surfaces, and public spaces by inactivating communicable pathogens. This study examined immersive UV disinfection, using a disinfection cabinet, of E. coli and MS2 that was inoculated on white cotton T-shirts. The impact that porous materials have on UV disinfection is poorly understood with the majority of previous surface disinfection research focusing on hard, smooth surfaces. Several approaches were used in this study to characterize the light dynamics within the disinfection cabinet including colorimetric dosimetry coupons, biodosimetry, and spectroradiometry. Micro and macro geometry of porous surfaces are important factors to consider when using immersive UV technologies. The geometry of the cabinet impacted the distribution of emitted UV light within the disinfection cabinet and the physical properties of a porous material, such as the woven pattern of cotton, both contribute to UV disinfection efficiency. This work identified that light distribution is crucial for immersive UV technologies as the delivered fluence was highly variable within the disinfection cabinet and resulted in a difference of several logs of reduction for adjacent areas of T-shirt samples. Other inoculated areas achieved upwards of 1-log reductions values for MS2 and upwards of 2-log reductions for E. coli.
Assuntos
Desinfecção , Levivirus , Desinfecção/métodos , Escherichia coli , Têxteis , Raios UltravioletaRESUMO
Based on recent studies, passive sampling is a promising method for detecting SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater surveillance (WWS) applications. Passive sampling has many advantages over conventional sampling approaches. However, the potential benefits of passive sampling are also coupled with apparent limitations. We established a passive sampling technique for detecting severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) in wastewater using electronegative filters. Though, it was evident that the adsorption capacity of the filters constrained their use. This work intends to demonstrate an optimized passive sampling technique for SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater using granular activated carbon (GAC). Through bench-scale batch-adsorption studies and sewershed deployments, we established the adsorption characteristics of SARS-CoV-2 and two human feacal viruses (PMMoV and CrAssphage) onto GAC. A pseudo-second-order model best-described adsorption kinetics for SARS-CoV-2 in either deionized (DI) water and SARS-CoV-2, CrAssphage, and PMMoV in wastewater. In both laboratory batch-adsorption experiments and in-situ sewershed deployments, the maximum amount of SARS-CoV-2 adsorbed by GAC occurred at ~60 h in wastewater. In wastewater, the maximum adsorption of PMMoV and CrAssphage by GAC occurred at ~60 h. In contrast, the adsorption capacity was reached in DI water seeded with SARS-CoV-2 after ~35 h. The equilibrium assay modeled the maximum adsorption quantity (qmax) in wastewater with spiked SARS-CoV-2 concentrations using a Hybrid Langmuir-Freundlich equation, a qmax of 2.5 × 109 GU/g was calculated. In paired sewershed deployments, it was found that GAC adsorbs SARS-CoV-2 in wastewater more effectively than electronegative filters. Based on the anticipated viral loading in wastewater, bi-weekly sampling intervals with deployments up to ~96 h are highly feasible without reaching adsorption capacity with GAC. GAC offers improved sensitivity and reproducibility to capture SARS-CoV-2 RNA in wastewater, promoting a scalable and convenient alternative for capturing viral pathogens in wastewater.
Assuntos
COVID-19 , Águas Residuárias , Adsorção , Carvão Vegetal , Humanos , RNA Viral , Reprodutibilidade dos Testes , SARS-CoV-2 , Vigilância Epidemiológica Baseada em Águas Residuárias , ÁguaRESUMO
Monitoring lead in drinking water is important for public health, but seasonality in lead concentrations can bias monitoring programs if it is not understood and accounted for. Here, we describe an apparent seasonal pattern in lead release into orthophosphate-treated drinking water, identified through point-of-use sampling at sites in Halifax, Canada, with various sources of lead. Using a generalized additive model, we extracted the seasonally varying components of time series representing a suite of water quality parameters and we identified aluminum as a correlate of lead. To investigate aluminum's role in lead release, we modeled the effect of variscite (AlPO4·2H2O) precipitation on lead solubility, and we evaluated the effects of aluminum, temperature, and orthophosphate concentration on lead release from new lead coupons. At environmentally relevant aluminum and orthophosphate concentrations, variscite precipitation increased predicted lead solubility by decreasing available orthophosphate. Increasing the aluminum concentration from 20 to 500 µg L-1 increased lead release from coupons by 41% and modified the effect of orthophosphate, rendering it less effective. We attributed this to a decrease in the concentration of soluble (<0.45 µm) phosphorus with increasing aluminum and an accompanying increase in particulate lead and phosphorus (>0.45 µm).
RESUMO
Implementation of water safety planning methods globally has focused primarily on developing an evidence base to demonstrate the benefits of the WSP methodology for risk management in water systems. However, little work has been completed to understand the appropriateness of the risk matrix method currently used to capture levels of risk for system-specific hazardous events. This study examines two quantitative risk calculations (probability density functions and event trees) compared to the risk matrix method employed in water safety planning. This analysis was undertaken to understand if the risk matrix provides an accurate estimation of risk in a water system. Two data sets were collected from nine water supply systems, both continuous inline monitoring and grab samples collected in water distribution systems (discrete events) for chlorine residual data. Using quantitative risk calculations, our study found the risk matrix does not accurately estimate risk compared to water quality data from a water system. In thirty-four (77%) of the forty-four possible scenarios investigated, the risk matrix method provided an underestimation or overestimation compared to the probability calculated using water quality data. The probabilities calculated using continuous data and the event tree method provided the closest estimations to the risk matrix, indicating larger data sets with simpler methods may be more likely to match WSP results. The lack of accuracy obtained reveals the need for a re-evaluation of the risk matrix within a water safety plan (WSP), particularly for systems with data available to perform advanced risk analysis. The risk matrix method has been used historically for systems with little data; however, for water systems with advanced water quality monitoring, adding quantitative probability calculations to a water safety plan has the potential to increase accuracy of risk assessment in water safety planning.
Assuntos
Cloro , Abastecimento de Água , Medição de Risco , Gestão de Riscos , Qualidade da ÁguaRESUMO
Despite several years of targeted interventions, First Nations drinking water systems in Canada remain under-resourced and require substantial improvements in both infrastructure and management to provide communities with safe drinking water. The purpose of this study was to co-develop a risk assessment process integral to the water safety planning methodology to determine if proactive risk assessment provides a beneficial management tool for First Nations water systems. We co-developed a risk assessment web-application with First Nations stakeholders to identify hazards and assess risk in six Atlantic region First Nations communities. Using this application, we were able to successfully identify high-risk hazards in each community, both risks specific to individual systems, and risks common at a regional level. Through semi-structured interviews we identified the following benefits of a risk assessment web application: increased communication, data ownership and centralized data management. However, challenges remain, including current fragmented governance realities, and liability concerns associated with adopting a new risk management strategy. Successful adoption of proactive risk management strategies in First Nations communities will depend on strong co-development of risk assessment tools, transparent communication between stakeholders and clearly defined data ownership and management practices.