Application of a new approach method to assess the hazard of complex legacy contaminated groundwater mixtures on fathead minnows in outdoor mesocosms.

Assessing the environmental risks of contaminated groundwater presents significant challenges due to its often-complex chemical composition and to dynamic processes affecting exposure of organisms in receiving surface waters. The objective of this study was to characterize the effects of groundwater collected from a legacy contaminated industrial site, in fish under environmentally relevant conditions. A 21-day fish short-term reproduction assay was conducted in outdoor wetland mesocosms by exposing adult fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas) to graded concentrations of groundwater (1 %, 3 %, and 6 %). Offspring were held in mesocosms up to four days post-hatch to apply a new approach method (NAM), the EcoToxChip™, to explore whether traditional apical endpoints could be predicted using an alternative mechanistic approach. None of the groundwater concentrations used in this study were lethal to fish. There was greater cumulative number of eggs produced at the highest concentration of exposure. However, no abnormal histological appearance was observed in the liver and gonads of fish and no significant effect was observed in the relative expression of genes, tubercle counts, and erythrocyte micronuclei counts compared to the negative control. Food availability in the mesocosms was also assessed and the abundance of zooplankton increased in all groundwater-treated mesocosms. Fathead minnow findings are in contrast to those obtained from previous controlled laboratory studies that revealed significant genotoxicity, hepatotoxicity, and reprotoxicity of the same mixtures. Several factors could explain these observations, including the aging of groundwater in mesocosms before fish addition resulting in photo- and biodegradation and binding to sediments of toxic components. Our static exposure scenario likely underestimated realistic exposure scenarios where groundwater inflow to surface water is generally semi-continuous. Nevertheless, focused transcriptome analysis using EcoToxChips also observed greater toxicity during previous laboratory tests compared to mesocosm scenarios, and thus, our results support the use of this NAM in the ecological risk assessment of contaminated groundwater.

Characterization of Adverse Outcomes from Legacy-Contaminated Groundwater Exposure to Early Life Stages of Fathead Minnow.

Complex mixtures of chemicals present in groundwater at legacy-contaminated industrial sites can pose significant risks to adjacent surface waters. The combination of short-term molecular and chronic apical effect assessments is a promising approach to characterize the potential hazard of such complex mixtures. The objectives of this study were to: (1) assess the apical effects (survival, growth, development, and liver histopathology) after chronic exposure of early life stages (ELSs) of fathead minnows (FHM; Pimephales promelas) to contaminated groundwater from a legacy-contaminated pesticide manufacturing and packaging plant, and (2) identify possible molecular mechanisms responsible for these effects by comparing results to mechanistic outcomes previously determined by a short-term reduced transcriptome assay (EcoToxChips). This study revealed a significant increase in mortality and prevalence of spinal curvatures, as well as a significant reduction in the length of FHMs exposed to the groundwater mixtures in a concentration-dependent manner. There was an increasing trend in the prevalence of edema in FHMs, though not significantly different from controls. Additionally, no histopathological effects were observed in the liver of FHMs exposed to the groundwater mixtures. Short-term molecular outcomes determined in a parallel study were found to be informative of chronic apical outcomes, including cardiotoxicity, spinal deformities, and liver toxicity. Overall, the results observed in this study demonstrated that short-term transcriptomics analyses could support the hazard assessment of complex contaminated sites.

Hazard assessment of complex legacy-contaminated groundwater mixtures using a novel approach method in adult fathead minnows.

Traditional risk assessment methods face challenges in the determination of drivers of toxicity for complex mixtures such as those present at legacy-contaminated sites. Bioassay-driven analysis across several levels of biological organization represents an approach to address these obstacles. This study aimed to apply a novel transcriptomics tool, the EcoToxChip, to characterize the effects of complex mixtures of contaminants in adult fathead minnows (FHMs) and to compare molecular response patterns to higher-level biological responses. Adult FHMs were exposed for 4 and 21 days to groundwater mixtures collected from a legacy-contaminated site. Adult FHM showed significant induction of micronuclei in erythrocytes, decrease in reproductive capacities, and some abnormal appearance of liver histology. Parallel EcoToxChip analyses showed a high proportion of upregulated genes and a few downregulated genes characteristic of compensatory responses. The three most enriched pathways included thyroid endocrine processes, transcription and translation cellular processes, and xenobiotics and reactive oxygen species metabolism. Several of the most differentially regulated genes involved in these biological pathways could be linked to the apical outcomes observed in FHMs. We concluded that molecular responses as determined by EcoToxChip analysis show promise for informing of apical outcomes and could support risk assessments of complex contaminated sites.

Characterization of molecular and apical effects of legacy-contaminated groundwater on early life stages of fathead minnows.

Mechanistic toxicology approaches represent a promising alternative to traditional live animal testing; however, the often-noted uncertainties concerning the linkages between effects observed at molecular and apical levels curtails the adoption of such approaches. The objective of this study was to apply a novel transcriptomics tool, EcoToxChips, to characterize the effects of complex mixtures of contaminants in fish and to compare molecular response patterns to higher-level biological responses including swimming behavior, deformities, and mortality. Fathead minnow (FHM) embryos were exposed for seven days to increasing concentrations of groundwater collected from moderate (MIAZ) and high (HIAZ) industrial activity zones of a legacy contaminated site. There was a concentration-dependent disruption of photo-dependent swimming responses associated with avoidance behavior patterns and spinal deformities (HIAZ and MIAZ), and an induction of pericardial edema and mortality (HIAZ-10%). Parallel EcoToxChip analyses showed a shift from a majority of upregulated genes at lower concentrations to a majority of downregulated genes at higher concentrations for both treatment conditions. Many of the significantly differentially regulated genes were involved in biological pathways including induction of oxidative stress, activating of several metabolic processes and growth, cell death, and inhibition of signal transduction signaling processes. Several contaminants present in the groundwater mixtures could have contributed to an exceedance of antioxidant system capacities that possibly led to the deformities, altered swimming behaviours, and mortality observed in FHMs. Therefore, molecular response patterns could be linked to apical outcomes observed in this study. Overall, the results observed in this study demonstrate that transcriptomics approaches such as the EcoToxChip system could be supportive of risk assessment of complex contaminated sites.