Catalytic nucleic acids: from lab to applications.

Since the discovery of self-cleavage and ligation activity of the group I intron, the expansion of research interest in catalytic nucleic acids has provided a valuable nonprotein resource for manipulating biomolecules. Although a multitude of reactions can be enhanced by this class of catalyst, including trans-splicing activity of the group I intron (which could be applied to gene correction), RNA-cleaving RNA enzymes or "ribozymes" hold center stage because of their tremendous potential for mediating gene inactivation. This application has been driven predominantly by the "hammerhead" and "hairpin" ribozymes as they induce specific RNA cleavage from a very small catalytic domain, allowing delivery either as a transgene expression product or directly as a synthetic oligonucleotide. Although advances in the development of RNA modifications have improved the biological half-life of synthetic ribozymes, their use is restricted by the mechanistic dependence on conserved 2'OH-moieties. Recently a new class of catalytic nucleic acid made entirely of DNA has emerged through in vitro selection. DNA enzymes or deoxyribozyme with extraordinary RNA cleavage activity has already demonstrated their capacity for gene suppression both in vitro and in vivo. These new molecules, although rivaling the activity and stability of synthetic ribozymes, are limited equally by inefficient delivery to the intracellular target RNA. The challenge of in vivo delivery is being addressed with the assessment of a variety of approaches in animal models with the aim of bringing these compounds closer to the clinic.

The use of ribozyme gene therapy for the inhibition of HIV replication and its pathogenic sequelae.

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is a lentivirus, a separate genus of the Retroviridae which are RNA viruses that integrate as DNA copies into the genomes of host cells and replicate intracellularly through various RNA intermediates. Several of these RNA molecules can be targeted by ribozymes and a number of investigators, including our group, have demonstrated the ability of ribozymes to suppress HIV replication in cultured cells. It is argued that the use of this ribozyme gene therapy approach for the treatment of HIV infection may act as an adjunct to chemotherapeutic drugs and may affect not just viral suppression, but also immune restoration. This approach can be tested in Clinical Trials, several of which are currently under way.

Suppression of smooth muscle cell proliferation by a c-myc RNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme.

A small catalytic DNA molecule targeting c-myc RNA was found to be a potent inhibitor of smooth muscle cell (SMC) proliferation. The catalytic domain of this molecule was based on that previously derived by in vitro selection (Santoro, S. W., and Joyce, G. F. (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 94, 4262-4266) and is known as the "10-23" general purpose RNA-cleaving deoxyribozyme. In addition to inhibiting SMC proliferation at low concentration, this molecule (targeting the translation initiation region of c-myc RNA) was found to efficiently cleave its full-length substrate in vitro and down-regulate c-myc gene expression in smooth muscle cells. The serum nuclease stability of this molecule was enhanced without substantial loss of kinetic efficiency by inclusion of a 3'-3'-internucleotide inversion at the 3'-terminal. The extent of SMC suppression was found to be influenced by the length of the substrate binding arms. This correlated to some extent with catalytic activity in both the short substrate under multiple turnover conditions and the full-length substrate under single turnover conditions, with the 9 + 9 base arm molecule producing the greatest activity.

Preclinical characterization of an anti-tat ribozyme for therapeutic application.

A hammerhead ribozyme retroviral construct, denoted RRz2, targeting the coding region of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) tat gene, has shown itself to be effective in a range of test systems. Inhibition of the replication of HIV-1 IIIB and primary drug-resistant strains in pooled transduced CEMT4 cells was consistently found to be more than 80% compared with the control-vector transduced cells, whereas a mutant RRz2 gave approximately 45% inhibition. A multiple HIV-1 passage assay showed the absence of emergence of mutations within the specific viral RNA ribozyme target sequences. This lack of generation of ribozyme "escape mutants" occurred despite the almost complete disappearance of a HIV-1 quasi-species in the testing virus. When RRz2 was tested in peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) from HIV-1-infected patients, paired analysis showed that cell viability in the ribozyme-transduced HIV-1-infected PBLs was significantly higher than that in the vector-transduced cells. This difference in viability (vector versus RRz2) was not observed in PBLs from non-HIV-1-infected donors. Taken together, these results indicate that the transfer of an anti-HIV-1 ribozyme gene into human T lymphocytes could have major impact on viral replication and T cell viability in the HIV-1-infected individual.

Target sequence-specific inhibition of HIV-1 replication by ribozymes directed to tat RNA.

The structural motif formed between a hammerhead ribozyme and its substrate consists of three RNA double helices in which the sequence 5' to the XUY is termed helix I and the sequence 3' to the XUY helix III. Two hammerhead ribozymes targeted to the tat gene of HIV-1SF2 were designed to study target specificity and the potential effect of helix I mismatch on ribozyme efficacy both in vitro and in vivo. The first ribozyme (Rz1) targeted to the 5' splicing region of the tat gene was designed to cleave GUC*A. In HIV-1IIIB the A is changed to a G. The second ribozyme (Rz2) was targeted to the translational initiation region of the tat gene which is highly conserved among a variety of HIV-1 isolates, including both HIV-1SF2 and HIV-1IIIB. In vitro cleavage studies demonstrated that Rz1 efficiency cleaved HIV-1SF2 substrate RNA, but not HIV-1IIIB, presumably due to the base change from A to G. In contrast, Rz2 cleaved HIV-1SF2 or HIV-1IIIB substrate with equal efficiency. Both ribozymes were cloned into the 3' untranslated region of the neomycin gene (neo) within the pSV2neo vector and transfected into the SupT1 human CD4+ T cell line. Following selection, stable transfectants were challenged with either HIV-1SF2 or HIV-1IIIB virus. While Rz1-expressing cells were significantly protected from HIV-1SF2 infection, they exhibited no protection when infected with HIV-1IIIB virus. In contrast, Rz2 was effective in inhibiting the replication of both HIV-1SF2 and HIV-1IIIB in SupT1 cells. Expression of both ribozymes in these cells was demonstrated by Northern analysis. RT-PCR sequencing analysis confirmed the respective HIV-1 target sequence integrity. These data demonstrate the importance of the first base pair distal to the XUY within helix I of the hammerhead structure for both in vitro and in vivo ribozyme activities and imply that the effectiveness of the anti-HIV-1 ribozymes against appropriate target sequences is due to their catalytic activities rather than any antisense effect.

The expression of antisense and ribozyme genes targeting citrus exocortis viroid in transgenic plants.

Four ribozyme and antisense genes targeting citrus exocortis viroid (CEVd) positive- and negative-strand RNA molecules were constructed and used to transform the tomato Lycopersicon lycopersicum cv. UC82B. The tomato is a readily transformable plant and will support replication of CEVd following mechanical inoculation. The ribozyme genes contained three hammerhead catalytic motifs with long hybridizing arms and synthetic RNA transcripts were shown to cleave the target CEVd RNA molecule in vitro. Homozygous transgenic plants were produced from independent transformants expressing either ribozymes or antisense constructs. Inoculation of transgenic seedlings expressing antisense constructs targeting the negative-strand CEVd RNA molecule with CEVd resulted in a moderate reduction in the accumulation of CEVd RNA. In contrast, similarly inoculated transgenic plants expressing constructs targeting the positive-strand CEVd RNA molecule resulted in an increase in the rate of CEVd RNA accumulation. Addition of the ribozyme motifs to the antisense genes did not enhance their efficiency in the suppression of viroid replication and a moderation or elimination of the observed antisense effects was seen in plants expressing the corresponding catalytic RNA-encoding genes.

Characterisation of the subgenomic RNAs of an Australian isolate of barley yellow dwarf luteovirus.

We have characterised the subgenomic RNAs of an Australian isolate of BYDV-PAV. Northern blot analyses of infected plants and protoplasts have shown that this isolate synthesizes three subgenomic RNAs. Precise mapping of the transcription start sites of all three subgenomic RNAs and translational analyses of subgenomic RNA 2 and 3 have revealed a number of features. First, the transcription start site of subgenomic RNA 1 in this isolate differs markedly from the start site determined for an Illinois isolate of BYDV-PAV. Second, the start sites of subgenomic RNA 1 and 2 occur at a sequence that closely resembles the 5' end sequence of the genomic RNA (5'AGUGAAGA). Third, subgenomic RNA 2 appears to express ORF 6 of BYDV-PAV but the gene product is truncated due to the appearance of a new stop codon in the sequence. Last, subgenomic RNA 3, which is abundantly transcribed and encapsidated by the virus particle, appears to have no coding ability. We postulate that this novel subgenomic RNA has a regulatory function.

Artificial ribozyme and antisense gene expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

A sensitive, quantitative reporter gene-based experimental system for the in vivo analysis of hammerhead ribozyme and antisense gene function in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is described. The system was constructed to test the activity of ribozyme and antisense genes targeting the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene (CAT) in both a cis and trans configuration relative to the target. When both target and ribozyme or antisense genes were transcribed in the same mRNA from an expression vector, CAT expression was reduced by up to 90%. Although the cis-positioned ribozyme molecule cleaved the target RNA in vitro, the steady state RNA levels of these chimeric transcripts were increased several fold relative to control mRNAs. This observation indicates a mechanism of suppression of CAT gene expression other than duplex-dependent degradation of mRNA. When the ribozyme or antisense genes were transcribed in trans from a plasmid-based expression vector, expression of a CAT gene integrated into a chromosome was unaffected. The effect of the cis-located RNA molecules may be dependent on an interaction requiring co-localization of ribozyme or antisense and target mRNAs during or immediately after target gene transcription. The failure of such a co-localization of these RNAs when synthesized in trans may contribute to the lack of efficacy seen in the trans-acting ribozymes or antisense RNAs. These observations are consistent with other studies reporting inefficient trans-acting ribozyme and antisense activity in S. cerevisiae.

Evolution and replication of tobacco ringspot virus satellite RNA mutants.

The replication properties of linker insertion-deletion mutants of tobacco ringspot virus satellite RNA have been studied by amplification in plants infected with the helper virus. Sequence analysis of the cDNAs corresponding to the replicated forms shows that only one of the original mutated molecules replicates unaltered, and in general new variants accumulate. Depending on the location of the original mutation three types of sequence modifications were observed: (i) deletion of the mutated region followed by sequence duplication, (ii) sequence duplication and deletion outside of the mutated region and (iii) limited rearrangements at the site of mutation. The mutant that replicates without sequence changes accumulates linear multimeric forms suggesting that self-cleavage is affected although the sequence alteration does not involve the hammerhead catalytic domain. Alternative RNA conformations are likely to play a role in the origin of this phenotype and in the formation of sequence duplications. These results demonstrate the great structural flexibility of this satellite RNA.

Putative full-length clones of the genomic DNA segments of subterranean clover stunt virus and identification of the segment coding for the viral coat protein.

Subterranean clover stunt disease is an economically important aphid-borne virus disease affecting certain pasture and grain legumes in Australia. The virus associated with the disease, subterranean clover stunt virus (SCSV), was previously found to be representative of a new type of single-stranded DNA virus. Analysis of the virion DNA and restriction mapping of double-stranded cDNA synthesized from virion DNA suggested that SCSV has a segmented genome composed of 3 or 4 different species of circular ssDNA each of about 850-880 nucleotides. To further investigate the complexity of the SCSV genome, we have isolated the replicative form DNA from infected pea and from it prepared putative full-length clones representing the SCSV genome segments. Analysis of these clones by restriction mapping indicated that clones representing at least 4 distinct genomic segments were obtained. This method is thus suitable for generating an extensive genomic library of novel ssDNA viruses containing multiple genome segments such as SCSV and banana bunchy top virus. The N-terminal amino acid sequence and amino acid composition of the coat protein of SCSV were determined. Comparison of the amino acid sequence with partial DNA sequence data, and the distinctly different restriction maps obtained for the full-length clones suggested that only one of these clones contained the coat protein gene. The results confirmed that SCSV has a functionally divided genome composed of several distinct ssDNA circles each of about 1 kb.

A ribozyme that enhances gene suppression in tobacco protoplasts.

Site-directed mutagenesis has been used to produce two hammerhead ribozyme molecules targeting the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene (CAT). One ribozyme has a single catalytic domain between two 12-nucleotide arms that can hybridize 5' and 3' of the GUC target site of the CAT RNA transcript. The second ribozyme is a full-length antisense RNA with four catalytic domains inserted along the length, each targeting a specific GUC site within the CAT mRNA. Our results show that both ribozymes can produce almost equivalent rates of cleavage of the CAT mRNA in vitro (T1/2 of 18 or 15 min, respectively). In tobacco protoplasts we show consistently greater gene suppression in the presence of the long ribozyme molecule, compared with the equivalent antisense (22% gene reduction for antisense compared with 44% with the long ribozyme). These results suggest that hammerhead ribozymes may be developed for the inactivation of gene activity in plant cells.

Extended target-site specificity for a hammerhead ribozyme.

In vitro mutagenesis has been used to systematically mutate the GUC target site cleaved by a synthetic ribozyme based on the catalytic domain of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus. Amongst the spectrum of changes, it is found that GUC, UUC, CUC, GUA and GUU targets show equivalent rates of cleavage. An AUC target does not cleave, in contrast to observations from other studies. For a GUG target site, the normal ribozyme cannot induce cleavage, but an alteration of the stem-loop in the catalytic domain leads to the formation of a weakly active ribozyme. Certain double mutations, not previously studied, showed slow but discernable cleavage. This mutational approach shows that general rules for cleavage at NUY triplets for the target site of hammerhead ribozymes should be modified. Not all NUY targets cleave under all circumstances, and there are some targets with nucleotides other than U in the centre position which show significant, discernable cleavage.

A satellite RNA of barley yellow dwarf virus contains a novel hammerhead structure in the self-cleavage domain.

An RNA molecule with properties of a satellite RNA was found in an isolate of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV), RPV serotype. It is 322 nucleotide long, single-stranded, and does not hybridize to the viral genome. Dimers of the RNA, which presumably represent replicative intermediates, were able to self-cleave into monomers. In vitro transcripts from cDNA clones were capable of self-cleavage in both the plus (encapsidated) and minus orientations. The sequence flanking the minus strand cleavage site contained a consensus "hammerhead" structure, similar to those found in other self-cleaving satellite RNAs. Although related to the hammerhead structure, sequences flanking the plus strand termini showed differences from the consensus and may be folded into a different structure containing a pseudo-knot.

Infectious in vitro transcripts from a cloned cDNA of barley yellow dwarf virus.

A full-length cDNA clone of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV-PAV serotype) has been constructed and fused to the bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase promoter. RNA transcripts produced in vitro, either capped or uncapped, were infectious in Triticum monococcum protoplasts. Protoplasts inoculated with in vitro-transcribed BYDV RNA accumulated coat protein, synthesized new viral RNAs, and produced virus particles. Aphid feeding on extracts from protoplasts inoculated with in vitro RNA transcripts can be used to transfer the virus progeny to whole plants. Introduction of mutations which interrupt specific BYDV-PAV open reading frames (ORFs) V and VI eliminated infectivity while an ORF I-mutant remained infectious. Infectious RNA transcripts derived from BYDV cDNA clones will facilitate analysis of the molecular aspects of BYDV infection and further enhance our understanding of this economically important virus.

Nucleotide sequences of an Australian and a Canadian isolate of potato leafroll luteovirus and their relationships with two European isolates.

The genomes of an Australian and a Canadian isolate of potato leafroll virus have been cloned and sequenced. The sequences of both isolates are similar (about 93%), but the Canadian isolate (PLRV-C) is more closely related (about 98% identity) to a Scottish (PLRV-S) and a Dutch isolate (PLRV-N) than to the Australian isolate (PLRV-A). The 5'-terminal 18 nucleotide residues of PLRV-C, PLRV-A, PLRV-N and beet western yellows virus have 17 residues in common. In contrast, PLRV-S shows no obvious similarity in this region. PLRV-A and PLRV-C genomic sequences have localized regions of marked diversity, in particular a 600 nucleotide residue sequence in the polymerase gene. These data provide a world-wide perspective on the molecular biology of PLRV strains and their comparison with other luteoviruses and related RNA plant viruses suggests that there are two major subgroups in the plant luteoviruses.

Sequences required for self-catalysed cleavage of the satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus.

The satellite RNA of tobacco ringspot virus (sTobRV) undergoes self-catalysed cleavage during replication. A plasmid for in vitro expression of sTobRV has been constructed and used to obtain a library of mutagenized sTobRV sequences. Screening of these mutants has allowed precise definition of the sequences required for (+) and (-) strand cleavage. The sequences and RNA structures associated with cleavage of each strand differ markedly. Cleavage of the (+) strand requires those sequences flanking the site for cleavage to form a 'hammerhead' domain, similar to those found in other satellite and viroid RNA. In contrast, cleavage of the (-) strand requires only a small region of 12 nucleotides (nt) at the site of cleavage, and a sequence of 55 nt positioned elsewhere in the molecule. Comparison with a closely related satellite suggests that a novel RNA structure may be involved in (-) strand cleavage.

Anaerobically regulated aldolase gene of maize. A chimaeric origin?

The sequence of the anaerobically induced fructose 1,6-bisphosphate aldolase gene of maize is presented. Analysis of the upstream sequences of the aldolase gene reveals a six base-pair sequence (TGGTTT) with perfect homology to one of the sub-regions of the anaerobic regulatory element (ARE) which is responsible for the anaerobic induction of the maize alcohol dehydrogenase 1 gene (Adh1). In the aldolase gene this sequence is located at position -70 relative to the start of transcription, in a small segment proven by functional analysis to be important for expression of the aldolase gene. Since this six base-pair sequence has been shown to be critical for anaerobic induction of the Adh1 mRNA, is in the functional promoter region of aldolase and is also present in a homologous position in Adh2 (another anaerobically-induced gene), we suggest this hexanucleotide is essential for anaerobic regulation of each of these genes. The maize aldolase gene is about 50% homologous at the amino acid level to the animal aldolase gene but has a completely different intron/exon structure. While the rat aldolase gene has nine introns the maize gene has a single large intron near the N terminus of the coding region. Because there is 55% homology downstream from the intron and very little homology upstream, we suggest that the maize gene has acquired a 5' region containing signals for anaerobic regulation and fortuitously adding a new N-terminal region to the protein. We must suppose that the plant gene has lost the remaining introns.