Proton Mobility in b2 Ion Formation and Fragmentation Reactions of Histidine-Containing Peptides.

A detailed energy-resolved study of the fragmentation reactions of protonated histidine-containing peptides and their b2 ions has been undertaken. Density functional theory calculations were utilized to predict how the fragmentation reactions occur so that we might discern why the mass spectra demonstrated particular energy dependencies. We compare our results to the current literature and to synthetic b2 ion standards. We show that the position of the His residue does affect the identity of the subsequent b2 ion (diketopiperazine versus oxazolone versus lactam) and that energy-resolved CID can distinguish these isomeric products based on their fragmentation energetics. The histidine side chain facilitates every major transformation except trans-cis isomerization of the first amide bond, a necessary prerequisite to diketopiperazine b2 ion formation. Despite this lack of catalyzation, trans-cis isomerization is predicted to be facile. Concomitantly, the subsequent amide bond cleavage reaction is rate-limiting.

Formation of a(1) ions directly from oxazolone b(2) ions: an energy-resolved and computational study.

It is well-known that oxazolone b2 ions fragment extensively by elimination of CO to form a2 ions, which often fragment further to form a1 ions. Less well-known is that some oxazolone b2 ions may fragment directly to form a1 ions. The present study uses energy-resolved collision-induced dissociation experiments to explore the occurrence of the direct b2→a1 fragmentation reaction. The experimental results show that the direct b2→a1 reaction is generally observed when Gly is the C-terminal residue of the oxazolone. When the C-terminal residue is more complex, it is able to provide increased stability of the a2 product in the b2→a2 fragmentation pathway. Our computational studies of the relative critical reaction energies for the b2→a2 reaction compared with those for the b2→a1 reaction provide support that the critical reaction energies are similar for the two pathways when the C-terminal residue of the oxazolone is Gly. By contrast, when the nitrogen of the oxazolone ring in the b2 ion does not bear a hydrogen, as in the Ala-Sar and Tyr-Sar (Sar = N-methylglycine) oxazolone b2 ions, a1 ions are not formed but rather neutral imine elimination from the N-terminus of the b2 ion becomes a dominant fragmentation reaction. The M06-2X/6-31+G(d,p) density functional theory calculations are in general agreement with the experimental data for both types of reaction. In contrast, the B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p) model systematically underestimates the barriers of these SN2-like b2→a1 reaction. The difference between the two methods of barrier calculation are highly significant (P < 0.001) for the b2→a1 reaction, but only marginally significant (P = 0.05) for the b2→a2 reaction. The computations provide further evidence of the limitations of the B3LYP functional when describing SN2-like reactions.

Effect of the sarcosine residue on sequence scrambling in peptide b(5) ions.

The effect of N-methylation on sequence scrambling in the fragmentation of b5 ions has been investigated by studying a variety of peptides containing sarcosine (N-methylglycine). The product ion mass spectra for the b5 ions derived from Sar-A-A-A-Y-A and Sar-A-A-Y-A-A show only minor signals for non-direct sequence ions the major fragmentation reactions occurring from the unrearranged structures. This is in contrast to the b5 ions where the Sar residue is replaced by Ala and sequence scrambling occurs. The b5 ion derived from Y-Sar-A-A-A-A shows a product ion mass spectrum essentially identical to the spectrum of the b5 ion derived from Sar-A-A-A-Y-A, indicating that in the former case macrocyclization has occurred but the macrocyclic form shows a strong preference to reopen to put the Sar residue in the N-terminal position. Similar results were obtained in the comparison of b5 ions derived from A-Sar-A-A-Y-A and Sar-A-A-Y-A-A. The product ion mass spectra of the MH(+) ions of Y-Sar-A-A-A-A and A-Sar-A-A-Y-A show substantial signals for non-direct sequence ions indicating that fragmentation of the MH(+) ions channels extensively through the respective b5 ions and further fragmentation of these species.

Fragmentation reactions of methionine-containing protonated octapeptides and fragment ions therefrom: an energy-resolved study.

The fragmentation reactions of the MH(+) ions as well as the b7, a7, and a7* ions derived therefrom have been studied in detail for the octapeptides MAAAAAAA, AAMAAAAA, AAAAMAAA, and AAAAAAMA. Ionization was by electrospray using a QqToF mass spectrometer, which allowed a study of the evolution of the fragmentation channels as a function of the collision energy. Not surprisingly, the product ion mass spectra for the b7 ions are independent of the original precursor sequence, indicating macrocyclization and reopening to the same mixture of protonated oxazolones prior to fragmentation. The results show that this sequence scrambling results in a distinct preference to place the Met residue in the C-terminal position of the protonated oxazolones. The a7 and a7* ions also produce product ion mass spectra independent of the original peptide sequence. The results for the a7 ions indicate that fragmentation occurs primarily from an amide structure analogous to that observed for a4 ions (Bythell et al. in J Am Chem Soc 132:14766-14779, 2010). Clearly, the rearrangement reaction they have proposed applies equally well to an ions as large as a7. The major fragmentation modes of the MH(+) ions at low collision energies produce b7, b6, and b5 ions. As the collision energy is increased further fragmentation of these primary products produces, in part, non-direct sequence ions, which become prominent at lower m/z values, particularly for the peptides with the Met residue near the N-terminus.

Non-direct sequence ions in the tandem mass spectrometry of protonated peptide amides--an energy-resolved study.

The fragmentation reactions of the MH(+) ions of Leu-enkephalin amide and a variety of heptapeptide amides have been studied in detail as a function of collision energy using a QqToF beam type mass spectrometer. The initial fragmentation of the protonated amides involves primarily formation of bn ions, including significant loss of NH3 from the MH(+) ions. Further fragmentation of these bn ions occurs following macrocyclization/ring opening leading in many cases to bn ions with permuted sequences and, thus, to formation of non-direct sequence ions. The importance of these non-direct sequence ions increases markedly with increasing collision energy, making peptide sequence determination difficult, if not impossible, at higher collision energies.

Using gas-phase guest-host chemistry to probe the structures of b ions of peptides.

Middle-sized b(n) (n ≥ 5) fragments of protonated peptides undergo selective complex formation with ammonia under experimental conditions typically used to probe hydrogen-deuterium exchange in Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR-MS). Other usual peptide fragments like y, a, a*, etc., and small b(n) (n ≤ 4) fragments do not form stable ammonia adducts. We propose that complex formation of b(n) ions with ammonia is characteristic to macrocyclic isomers of these fragments. Experiments on a protonated cyclic peptide and N-terminal acetylated peptides fully support this hypothesis; the protonated cyclic peptide does form ammonia adducts while linear b(n) ions of acetylated peptides do not undergo complexation. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations on the proton-bound dimers of all-Ala b(4), b(5), and b(7) ions and ammonia indicate that the ionizing proton initially located on the peptide fragment transfers to ammonia upon adduct formation. The ammonium ion is then solvated by N(+)-H…O H-bonds; this stabilization is much stronger for macrocyclic b(n) isomers due to the stable cage-like structure formed and entropy effects. The present study demonstrates that gas-phase guest-host chemistry can be used to selectively probe structural features (i.e., macrocyclic or linear) of fragments of protonated peptides. Stable ammonia adducts of b(9), b(9)-A, and b(9)-2A of A(8)YA, and b(13) of A(20)YVFL are observed indicating that even these large b-type ions form macrocyclic structures.

Pathways for water loss from doubly protonated peptides containing serine or threonine.

The doubly-protonated peptides Ala-Ala-Xaa-Ala-Ala-Ala-Arg show extensive loss of H(2)O when Xaa = Ser or Thr. Using quasi-MS(3) techniques the fragmentation reactions of the [M + 2H - H(2)O](+2) ions have been studied in detail. For both Ser and Thr, the [M + 2H - H(2)O](+2) ions show three primary fragmentation reactions, elimination of CH(3)CH=NH, elimination of one Ala residue, and elimination of two Ala residues, in all cases forming doubly-charged products. From a study of the further fragmentation of these products, it is concluded that elimination of two Ala residues results in formation of a three-membered aziridine ring by interaction with the adjacent amide function as H(2)O is lost. The elimination of one Ala residue results in formation of a five-membered oxazoline ring through interaction with the N-terminal adjacent carbonyl function as H(2)O is lost. The elimination of CH(3)CH=NH appears to involve formation of an eight-membered ring by interaction with the remote N-terminal carbonyl function as H(2)O is lost. However, this initial structure undergoes rearrangement through interaction with the adjacent C-terminal carbonyl function prior to further fragmentation. The [MH - H(2)O](+) ion of Ala-Ala-Ser-Ala-Ala-Ala also shows elimination of CH(3)CH=NH, one Ala residue and two Ala residues.

Fragmentation reactions of b(5) and a (5) ions containing proline--the structures of a(5) ions.

A detailed study has been made of the b(5) and a(5) ions derived from the amides H-Ala-Ala-Ala-Ala-Pro-NH(2), H-Ala-Ala-Ala-Pro-Ala-NH(2), and H-Ala-Ala-Pro-Ala-Ala-NH(2). From quasi-MS(3) experiments it is shown that the product ion mass spectra of the three b(5) ions are essentially identical, indicating macrocyclization/reopening to produce a common mixture of intermediates prior to fragmentation. This is in agreement with numerous recent studies of sequence scrambling in b ions. By contrast, the product ion mass spectra for the a(5) ions show substantial differences, indicating significant differences in the mixture of structures undergoing fragmentation for these three species. The results are interpreted in terms of a mixture of classical substituted iminium ions as well as protonated C-terminal amides formed by cyclization/rearrangement as reported recently for a(4) ions (Bythell, Maître , Paizs, J . Am. Chem. Soc. 2010, 132, 14761-14779). Novel fragment ions observed upon fragmentation of the a(5) ions are protonated H-Pro-NH(2) and H-Pro-Ala-NH(2) which arise by fragmentation of the amides. The observation of these products provides strong experimental evidence for the cyclization/rearrangement reaction to form amides and shows that it also applies to a(5) ions.

Towards understanding the tandem mass spectra of protonated oligopeptides. 2: The proline effect in collision-induced dissociation of protonated Ala-Ala-Xxx-Pro-Ala (Xxx = Ala, Ser, Leu, Val, Phe, and Trp).

The product ion spectra of proline-containing peptides are commonly dominated by y(n) ions generated by cleavage at the N-terminal side of proline residues. This proline effect is investigated in the current work by collision-induced dissociation (CID) of protonated Ala-Ala-Xxx-Pro-Ala (Xxx includes Ala, Ser, Leu, Val, Phe, and Trp) in an electrospray/quadrupole/time-of-flight (QqTOF) mass spectrometer and by quantum chemical calculations on protonated Ala-Ala-Ala-Pro-Ala. The CID spectra of all investigated peptides show a dominant y(2) ion (Pro-Ala sequence). Our computational results show that the proline effect mainly arises from the particularly low threshold energy for the amide bond cleavage N-terminal to the proline residue, and from the high proton affinity of the proline-containing C-terminal fragment produced by this cleavage. These theoretical results are qualitatively supported by the experimentally observed y(2)/b(3) abundance ratios for protonated Ala-Ala-Xxx-Pro-Ala (Xxx = Ala, Ser, Leu, Val, Phe, and Trp). In the post-cleavage phase of fragmentation the N-terminal oxazolone fragment with the Ala-Ala-Xxx sequence and Pro-Ala compete for the ionizing proton for these peptides. As the proton affinity of the oxazolone fragment increases, the y(2)/b(3) abundance ratio decreases.

Effect of the identity of Xaa on the fragmentation modes of doubly-protonated Ala-Ala-Xaa-Ala-Ala-Ala-Arg.

The product ion mass spectra resulting from collisional activation of doubly-protonated tryptic-type peptides Ala-Ala-Xaa-Ala-Ala-Ala-Arg have been determined for Xaa = Ala(A), Ser(S), Val(V), Thr(T), Ile(I), Phe(F), Tyr(Y), Sar, Met(M), Trp(W), Pro(P), and Gln(Q). The major fragmentation reaction involves cleavage of the second amide bond (counting from the N-terminus) except for Xaa = Ser and Thr where elimination of H(2)O from the [M + 2H](+2) ion forms the base peak. In general, the extent of cleavage of the second amide bond shows little dependence on the identity of Xaa and little dependence on whether the bond cleavage involves symmetrical bond cleavage to form a y(5)/b(2) ion pair or asymmetrically to form y (5) (+2) and a neutral b(2) species. Notable exceptions to this generalization occur for Xaa equal to Pro or Sar. For Xaa = Pro only cleavage of the second amide bond is observed, consistent with a pronounced proline effect, i.e., cleavage N-terminal to Pro. When Xaa = Sar considerably enhanced cleavage of the second amide bond also is observed, suggesting that at least part of the proline effect relates to the tertiary nature of the amide nitrogen. In the competition between symmetric and asymmetric bond cleavage an attempt to establish a linear free energy correlation in relating ln(y(5)(+2)/y(5)) to PA(H-Xaa-OH) did not lead to a reasonable correlation although the trend of increasing y(5)(+2)/y(5) ratio with increasing proton affinity of H-Xaa-OH was clear. Proline showed a unique behavior in giving a much higher y(5)(+2)/y(5) ratio than any of the other residues studied.

Effect of the His residue on the cyclization of b ions.

The MS(n) spectra of the [M + H](+) and b(5) peaks derived from the peptides HAAAAA, AHAAAA, AAHAAA, AAAHAA, and AAAAHA have been measured, as have the spectra of the b(4) ions derived from the first four peptides. The MS(2) spectra of the [M + H](+) ions show a substantial series of b(n) ions with enhanced cleavage at the amide bond C-terminal to His and substantial cleavage at the amide bond N-terminal to His (when there are at least two residues N-terminal to the His residue). There is compelling experimental and theoretical evidence for formation of nondirect sequence ions via cyclization/reopening chemistry in the CID spectra of the b ions when the His residue is near the C-terminus. The experimental evidence is less clear for ions when the His residue is near the N-terminus, although this may be due to the use of multiple alanine residues in the peptide making identifying scrambled peaks more difficult. The product ion mass spectra of the b(4) and b(5) ions from these isomeric peptides with cyclically permuted amino acid sequences are similar, but also show clear differences. This indicates less active cyclization/reopening followed by fragmentation of common structures for b(n) ions containing His than for sequences of solely aliphatic residues. Despite more energetically favorable cyclization barriers for the b(5) structures, the b(4) ions experimental data show more clear evidence of cyclization and sequence scrambling before fragmentation. For both b(4) and b(5) the energetically most favored structure is a macrocyclic isomer protonated at the His side chain.

Cyclization of peptide b9 ions.

The product ion mass spectra obtained by CID of the b(9) ions derived by loss of neutral alanine from the MH+ ion of the peptides Tyr(Ala)9, (Ala)4Tyr(Ala)5, and (Ala)8TyrAla are essentially identical, indicative of full cyclization reaction to a common intermediate before fragmentation. This leads to abundant nondirect sequence ions in the product ion mass spectra of the b9 ions. The product ion mass spectra of the b8 ions from the first two peptides also are essentially identical. The fragmentation of the MH+ ions also leads to low intensity nondirect sequence ions in the product ion mass spectra. N-terminal acetylation blocks the cyclization and eliminates nondirect sequence fragment ions in the product ion mass spectra.

Fragmentation of doubly-protonated Pro-His-Xaa tripeptides: formation of b(2)(2+) ions.

When ionized by electrospray from acidic solutions, the tripeptides Pro-His-Xaa (Xaa = Gly, Ala, Leu) form abundant doubly-protonated ions, [M + 2H]2+. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) of these doubly-protonated species results, in part, in formation of b(2)(2+) ions, which fragment further by loss of CO to form a(2)(2+) ions; the latter fragment by loss of CO to form the Pro and His iminium [immonium is commonly used in peptide MS work] ions. Although larger doubly-charged b ions are known, this represents the first detailed study of b(2)(2+) ions in CID of small doubly protonated peptides. The most abundant CID products of the studied doubly-protonated peptides arise mainly in charge separation involving two primary fragmentation channels, formation of the b2/y1 pair and formation of the a1/y2 pair. Combined molecular dynamics and density functional theory calculations are used to gain insight into the structures and fragmentation pathways of doubly-protonated Pro-His-Gly including the energetics of potential protonation sites, backbone cleavages, post-cleavage charge-separation reactions and the isomeric structures of b(2)(2+) ions. Three possible structures are considered for the b(2)(2+) ions: the oxazolone, diketopiperazine, and fused ring isomers. The last is formed by cleavage of the His-Gly amide bond on a pathway that is initiated by nucleophilic attack of one of the His side-chain imidazole nitrogens. Our calculations indicate the b(2)(2+) ion population is dominated by the oxazolone and/or fused ring isomers.

Charge-separation reactions of doubly-protonated peptides: effect of peptide chain length.

The collision induced dissociation of doubly-protonated (Ala)(x)His (x = 5, 6, 7, 8, 10) peptides have been studied. The major fragmentation reactions observed are symmetrical amide bond cleavages to give the complementary b(m) and y(N-m) ions, where N is the total number of residues in the peptide. Minor asymmetric cleavage to give doubly-protonated y ions also is observed, involving cleavage near the N-terminus. The shorter peptides (x = 5, 6, 7) show major cleavage of the second amide bond to yield b2 and y(N-2) ions, while (Ala)10His shows major symmetrical cleavage at the fourth and fifth amide bonds. (Ala)8His appears to be a transitional peptide in showing substantial symmetrical cleavage at the second, fourth, and fifth amide bonds. The results are in general agreement with the bifurcating nature of charge separation noted by Zubarev (J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom.2008, 19, 1755-1763) from a statistical analysis of a large body of doubly-protonated tryptic peptide CID mass spectra. It is shown that the b2 ion derived from doubly-protonated (Ala)5His has a protonated oxazolone structure.

To b or not to b: the ongoing saga of peptide b ions.

Modern soft ionization techniques readily produce protonated or multiply protonated peptides. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) of these protonated species is often used as a method to obtain sequence information. In many cases fragmentation occurs at amide bonds. When the charge resides on the C-terminal fragment so-called y ions are produced which are known to be protonated amino acids or truncated peptides. When the charge resides on the N-terminal fragment so-called b ions are produced. Often the sequence of y and b ions are essential for peptide sequencing. The b ions have many possible structures, a knowledge of which is useful in this sequencing. The structures of b ions are reviewed in the following with particular emphasis on the variation of structure with the number of amino acid residues in the b ion and the effect of peptide side chain on b ion structure. The recent discovery of full cyclization of larger b ions results in challenges in peptide sequencing. This aspect is discussed in detail.

Fragmentation reactions of some peptide b3 ions: an energy-resolved study.

The fragmentation reactions of b3 ions of nominal structure AAAoxa, YAAoxa, AYAoxa and AAYoxa have been studied as a function of collision energy, allowing the construction of breakdown graphs expressing in a qualitative way the energy dependence of the fragmentation reactions. The primary fragmentation reactions of the AAAoxa b3 ion involve formation of the a3* (a3-NH3) ion and the b2 ion, with the latter becoming the dominant product at higher internal energies. For both YAAoxa and AYAoxa b3 ions the pathway to a3* is relatively minor with formation of b2 the dominant primary fragmentation reaction. For the AAYoxa b3 ion, in addition to a3*, abundant formation of the tyrosine (Y) iminium ion is observed with only minor formation of the b2 ion. The results support and expand upon the detailed mechanism of fragmentation of b3 ions proposed by Cooper et al. (J. Am. Soc. Mass Spectrom. 2006; 17: 1654).

Sequence-scrambling fragmentation pathways of protonated peptides.

The gas-phase structures and fragmentation pathways of the N-terminal b and a fragments of YAGFL-NH(2), AGLFY-NH(2), GFLYA-NH(2), FLYAG-NH(2), and LYAGF-NH(2) were investigated using collision-induced dissociation (CID) and detailed molecular mechanics and density functional theory (DFT) calculations. Our combined experimental and theoretical approach allows probing of the scrambling and rearrangement reactions that take place in CID of b and a ions. It is shown that low-energy CID of the b(5) fragments of the above peptides produces nearly the same dissociation patterns. Furthermore, CID of protonated cyclo-(YAGFL) generates the same fragments with nearly identical ion abundances when similar experimental conditions are applied. This suggests that rapid cyclization of the primarily linear b(5) ions takes place and that the CID spectrum is indeed determined by the fragmentation behavior of the cyclic isomer. This can open up at various amide bonds, and its fragmentation behavior can be understood only by assuming a multitude of fragmenting linear structures. Our computational results fully support this cyclization-reopening mechanism by showing that protonated cyclo-(YAGFL) is energetically favored over the linear b(5) isomers. Furthermore, the cyclization-reopening transition structures are energetically less demanding than those of conventional bond-breaking reactions, allowing fast interconversion among the cyclic and linear isomers. This chemistry can lead in principle to complete loss of sequence information upon CID, as documented for the b(5) ion of FLYAG-NH(2). CID of the a(5) ions of the above peptides produces fragment ion distributions that can be explained by assuming b-type scrambling of their parent population and a --> a*-type rearrangement pathways ( Vachet , R. W. , Bishop , B. M. , Erickson , B. W. , and Glish , G. L. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1997, 119, 5481 ). While a ions easily undergo cyclization, the resulting macrocycle predominantly reopens to regenerate the original linear structure. Computational data indicate that the a --> a*-type rearrangement pathways of the linear a isomers involve post-cleavage proton-bound dimer intermediates in which the fragments reassociate and the originally C-terminal fragment is transferred to the N-terminus.

Peptide sequence scrambling through cyclization of b(5) ions.

The CID mass spectra of the MH(+) ions and the b(5) ions derived therefrom have been determined for the hexapeptides YAAAAA, AYAAAA, AAYAAA, AAAYAA, and AAAAYA. The CID mass spectra for the b(5) ions derived from the five isomers are essentially identical and show abundant ion signals for nonsequence b ions. This result is consistent with cyclization of the b(5) ions to a cyclic pentapeptide before fragmentation; this cyclic peptide can open at various positions, leading to losses of amino acid residues that are not characteristic of the original amino acid sequence. These nonsequence b ions are also observed in the fragmentation of the MH(+) ions and increase substantially in importance with increasing collision energy. A comparison of the fragmentation of AAAYAA and Ac-AAAYAA indicates that N-acetylation eliminates the cyclization of b(5) ions and, thus, eliminates the nonsequence ions in the CID mass spectra of both b(5) and MH(+) ions.

Fragmentation of protonated dipeptides containing arginine. Effect of activation method.

The fragmentation reactions of the protonated dipeptides Gly-Arg and Arg-Gly have been studied using collision-induced dissociation (CID) in a quadrupole ion trap, by in-source CID in a single-quadrupole mass spectrometer and by CID in the quadrupole cell of a QqTOF mass spectrometer. In agreement with earlier quadrupole ion trap studies (Farrugia, J. M.; O'Hair, R. A. J., Int. J. Mass Spectrom., 2003, 222, 229), the CID mass spectra obtained with the ion trap for the MH(+) ions and major fragment ions are very similar for the two isomers indicating rearrangement to a common structure before fragmentation. In contrast, in-source CID of the MH(+) ions and QqTOF CID of the MH(+), [MH - NH(3)](+) and [MH <23 HN = C(NH(2))(2)](+) ions provide distinctly different spectra for the isomeric dipeptides, indicating that rearrangement to a common structure has not occurred to a significant extent under these conditions even near the threshold for fragmentation in the QqTOF instrument. Clearly, under normal operating conditions significantly different fragmentation behavior is observed in the ion trap and beam-type experiments. This different behavior probably can be attributed to the shorter observation times and concomitant higher excitation energies in the in-source and QqTOF experiments compared to the long observation times and lower excitation energies relevant to the ion trap experiments. Based largely on elemental compositions derived from accurate mass measurements in QqTOF studies fragmentation schemes are proposed for the MH(+), [MH - NH(3)](+), and [MH - (HN = C(NH(2))(2))](+) ions.

Scrambling of sequence information in collision-induced dissociation of peptides.

Collision-induced dissociation (CID) of protonated YAGFL-NH2 leads to nondirect sequence fragment ions that cannot directly be derived from the primary peptide structure. Experimental and theoretical evidence indicate that primary fragmentation of the intact peptide leads to the linear YAGFLoxa b5 ion with a C-terminal oxazolone ring that is attacked by the N-terminal amino group to induce formation of a cyclic peptide b5 isomer. The latter can undergo various proton transfer reactions and opens up to form something other than the YAGFLoxa linear b5 isomer, leading to scrambling of sequence information in the CID of protonated YAGFL-NH2.