RESUMO
Stereochemically defined organofluorine compounds are central to drug discovery and development. Here, we present a catalytic cross-metathesis method for the synthesis of Z-trisubstituted olefins that contain a Cl- and a CF3-bound carbon terminus. Notably, the process is stereoselective, which is in contrast to the existing stereoretentive strategies that also involve a trisubstituted olefin as starting material. Reactions are catalyzed by a Mo monoaryloxide pyrrolide alkylidene, involve a trisubstituted alkene and gem-Cl,CF3-substituted alkene, and are fully Z-selective. Catalytic cross-coupling can be used to convert the C-Cl bond of the trisubstituted olefin to C-B, C-D, and different C-C bonds. We elucidate the role of Cl,CF3-disubstituted Mo alkylidenes. Experimental and computational (DFT) data show that in some instances a disubstituted alkylidene is formed and then transformed to a more active complex. In other cases, the Cl,CF3-disubstituted alkylidene is a direct participant in a catalytic cycle. The studies described shed new light on the chemistry of high oxidation-state disubstituted alkylidenes-scarcely investigated entities likely to be pivotal to approaches for stereocontrolled synthesis of tetrasubstituted alkenes through olefin metathesis.
RESUMO
A compound's overall contour impacts its ability to elicit biological response, rendering access to distinctly shaped molecules desirable. A natural product's framework can be modified, but only if it is abundant and contains suitably modifiable functional groups. Here we introduce a programmable strategy for concise synthesis of precisely altered scaffolds of scarce bridged polycyclic alkaloids. Central to our approach is a scalable catalytic multi-component process that delivers diastereo- and enantiomerically enriched tertiary homoallylic alcohols bearing differentiable alkenyl moieties. We used one product to launch progressively divergent syntheses of a naturally occurring alkaloid and its precisely expanded, contracted and/or distorted framework analogues (average number of steps/scaffold of seven). In vitro testing showed that a skeleton expanded by one methylene in two regions is cytotoxic against four types of cancer cell line. Mechanistic and computational studies offer an account for several unanticipated selectivity trends.
Assuntos
Alcaloides Indólicos , Catálise , Alcaloides Indólicos/química , Alcaloides Indólicos/síntese química , Humanos , Linhagem Celular Tumoral , Estereoisomerismo , Antineoplásicos/química , Antineoplásicos/síntese química , Antineoplásicos/farmacologia , Estrutura Molecular , Ensaios de Seleção de Medicamentos AntitumoraisRESUMO
The appeal of catalytic click chemistry is largely due to the copper-catalysed azide-alkyne cycloaddition (CuAAC) process, which is orthogonal to the more recently introduced sulfur-fluoride exchange (SuFEx). However, the triazole rings generated by CuAAC are not readily modifiable, and SuFEx connectors cannot be selectively functionalized, attributes that would be attractive in a click process. Here we introduce bisphosphine-copper-catalysed phenoxydiazaborinine formation (CuPDF), a link-and-in situ modify strategy for merging a nitrile, an allene, a diborane and a hydrazine. We also present copper- and palladium-catalysed quinoline formation (Cu/PdQNF), which is applicable in aqueous media, involving an aniline as the modifier. CuPDF and Cu/PdQNF are easy to perform and deliver robust, alterable and tunable fluorescent hubs. CuPDF and Cu/PdQNF are orthogonal to SuFEx and CuAAC, despite the latter and CuPDF also being catalysed by an organocopper species. These advantages were applied to protecting group-free syntheses of sequence-defined branched oligomers, a chemoselectively amendable polymer, three drug conjugates and a two-drug conjugate.
RESUMO
ConspectusIn this Account, we share the story of the development of catalytic olefin metathesis processes that efficiently deliver a wide range of acyclic and macrocyclic E- or Z-trisubstituted alkenes. The tale starts with us unveiling, in collaboration with Richard Schrock and his team, the blueprint in 2009 for the design of kinetically controlled Z-selective olefin metathesis reactions. This paved the way for the development of Mo-, W-, and Ru-based catalysts and strategies for synthesizing countless linear and macrocyclic Z-olefins. Six years later, in 2015, we found that abundant Z-alkene feedstocks, such as oleic acid, can be directly transformed to high-value and more difficult-to-access alkenes through a cross-metathesis reaction promoted by a Ru-catechothiolate complex that we had developed; the approach, later coined stereoretentive olefin metathesis, was extended to the synthesis of E-alkenes.It was all about disubstituted alkenes until when in 2017 we addressed the challenge of accessing stereodefined Z- and E-trisubstituted alkenes, key to medicine and materials research. These transformations can be most effectively catalyzed by Mo monoaryloxides pyrrolide (MAP) and chloride (MAC) complexes. A central aspect of the advance is the merging of olefin metathesis, which delivered trisubstituted alkenyl fluorides, chlorides, and bromides with cross-coupling. These catalytic and stereoretentive transformations can be used in various combinations, thereby enabling access to assorted Z- or E-trisubstituted alkene. Ensuing work led to the emergence of other transformations involving substrates that can be purchased with high stereoisomeric purity, notably E- and Z-trihalo alkenes. Trisubstituted olefins, Z or E, bearing a chemoselectively and stereoretentively alterable F,Cl-terminus or B(pin),Cl-terminus may, thus, be easily and reliably synthesized. Methods for stereoretentive preparation of other alkenyl bromide regioisomers and α,ß-unsaturated carboxylic and thiol esters, nitriles, and acid fluorides followed, along with stereoretentive ring-closing metathesis reactions that afford macrocyclic trisubstituted olefins. Z- and E-Macrocyclic trisubstituted olefins, including those that contain little or no entropic support for cyclization (minimally functionalized) and/or are disfavored under substrate-controlled conditions, can now be synthesized. The utility of this latest chapter in the history of olefin metathesis has been highlighted by applications to the synthesis of several biologically active compounds, as well as their analogues, such as those marked by one or more site-specifically incorporated fluorine atoms or more active but higher energy and otherwise unobtainable conformers.The investigations discussed here, which represent every stereoretentive method that has been reported thus far for preparing a trisubstituted olefin, underscore the inimitable power of Mo-based catalysts. This Account also showcases a variety of mechanistic attributesâsome for the first time, and each instrumental in solving a problem. Extensive knowledge of mechanistic nuances will be needed if we are to address successfully the next challenging problem, namely, the development of catalysts and strategies that may be used to synthesize a wide range of tetrasubstituted alkenes, especially those that are readily modifiable, with high stereoisomeric purity.
RESUMO
Stereochemically defined trisubstituted alkenes with a bromide and a methyl group at a terminus can be readily and stereoretentively derivatized through catalytic cross-coupling, affording unsaturated fragments found in many bioactive natural products. A direct method for generating such entities would be by stereocontrolled catalytic cross-metathesis (CM). Such methods are scarce however. Here, we present a stereoretentive strategy for CM between tri-, Z- or E-di, or monosubstituted olefins and Z- or E-2-bromo-2-butene, affording an assortment of E- or Z-trisubstituted alkenyl bromides. The majority of the transformations were catalyzed by two Mo monoaryloxide pyrrolide (MAP) complexes, one purchasable and the other accessible by well-established protocols. Substrates, such as feedstock trisubstituted olefins, can be purchased; the alkenyl bromide reagents are commercially available or can be prepared in two steps in a multigram scale. The catalytic process can be used to generate products that contain polar moieties, such as an amine or an alcohol, or sterically hindered alkenes that are α- or ß-branched. The utility of the approach is highlighted by a brief and stereocontrolled synthesis of an unsaturated fragment of phomactin A and a concise total synthesis of ambrein. An unexpected outcome of these investigations was the discovery of a new role for the presence of a small-molecule alkene in an olefin metathesis reaction. DFT studies indicate that this additive swiftly reacts with a short-lived Mo alkylidene and probably helps circumvent the formation of catalytically inactive square pyramidal metallacyclobutanes, enhancing the efficiency of a transformation.
Assuntos
Alcenos , Brometos , Estereoisomerismo , Alcenos/química , Indicadores e Reagentes , CatáliseRESUMO
Catalytic cross-metathesis (CM) reactions that can generate trisubstituted alkenes in high stereoisomeric purity are important but remain limited in scope. Here, CM reactions are introduced that generate Z-trisubstituted α-methyl, α,ß-unsaturated, alkyl and aryl esters, thiol esters, and acid fluorides. Transformations are promoted by a Mo bis-aryloxide, a monoaryloxide pyrrolide, or a monoaryloxide chloride complex; air-stable and commercially available paraffin tablets containing a Mo complex may also be used. Alkyl, aryl, and silyl carboxylic esters as well as thiol esters and acid fluoride reagents are either purchasable or can be prepared in one step. Products were obtained in 55-95% yield and in 88:12->98:2 Z/E ratio (typically >95:5). The applicability of the approach is highlighted by a two-step conversion of citronellol to an isomintlactone precursor (1.7 g, 73% yield, and 97:3 Z/E) and a single-step transformation of lanosterol acetate to 3-epi-anwuweizic acid (72% yield and 94:6 Z/E). Included are the outcomes of DFT studies, regarding several initially puzzling catalyst activity trends, providing the following information: (1) it is key that a disubstituted Mo alkylidene, generated by a competing homo-metathesis (HM) pathway, can re-enter the productive CM cycle. (2) Whereas in a CM cycle the formation of a molybdacyclobutane is likely turnover-limiting, the collapse of related metallacycles in a HM cycle is probably rate-determining. It is therefore the relative energy barrier required for these steps that determines whether CM or HM is dominant with a particular complex.
RESUMO
Molecules that contain one or more fluorine atoms are crucial to drug discovery. There are protocols available for the selective synthesis of different organofluorine compounds, including those with a fluoro-substituted or a trifluoromethyl-substituted stereogenic carbon centre. However, approaches for synthesizing compounds with a trifluoromethyl- and fluoro-substituent stereogenic carbon centre are far less common. This potentially impactful set of molecules thus remains severely underdeveloped. Here we introduce a catalytic regio-, diastereo- and enantioselective strategy for the preparation of homoallylic alcohols bearing a stereogenic carbon centre bound to a trifluoromethyl group and a fluorine atom. The process, which involves a polyfluoroallyl boronate and is catalysed by an in situ-formed organozinc complex, can be used for diastereodivergent preparation of tetrafluoro-monosaccharides, including ribose core analogues of the antiviral drug sofosbuvir (Sovaldi). Unexpected reactivity/selectivity profiles, probably originating from the trifluoromethyl- and fluoro-substituted carbon site, are discovered, foreshadowing other unique chemistries that remain unknown.
Assuntos
Carbono , Flúor , Estereoisomerismo , Estrutura Molecular , CatáliseRESUMO
Stereochemically defined organofluorine compounds are vital to drug discovery and many applicable catalytic strategies have been introduced for accessing these entities stereoselectively. One approach entails incorporation of a fluorine atom (C-F bond formation) or an organofluorine moiety (e.g., CF3 or CF2 H), and another exploits commercially available compounds with one or more fluorine atoms. Here, we present the state-of-the-art regarding the use of alkenyl and allylic fluorides in preparation of stereochemically defined fluoro-organic molecules. Allylic and alkenyl fluorides may be purchased or generated from a commercially available acid, carboxylate salt, ester, aldehyde hydrate, or ketone bearing several fluorine atoms next to a carbonyl group. We underscore the untapped potential of purchasable organofluorine compounds, many allylic and alkenyl fluorides, as launching points for development of stereoselective processes that are of value to therapeutic science.
Assuntos
Fluoretos , Flúor , Fluoretos/química , Estereoisomerismo , Catálise , Cetonas/químicaRESUMO
Many therapeutic agents are macrocyclic trisubstituted alkenes but preparation of these structures is typically inefficient and non-selective. A possible solution would entail catalytic macrocyclic ring-closing metathesis, but these transformations require high catalyst loading, conformationally rigid precursors and are often low yielding and/or non-stereoselective. Here we introduce a ring-closing metathesis strategy for synthesis of trisubstituted macrocyclic olefins in either stereoisomeric form, regardless of the level of entropic assistance. The goal was achieved by addressing several unexpected difficulties, including complications arising from pre-ring-closing metathesis alkene isomerization. The power of the method is highlighted by two examples. The first is the near-complete reversal of substrate-controlled selectivity in the formation of a macrolactam related to an antifungal natural product. The other is a late-stage stereoselective generation of an E-trisubstituted alkene in a 24-membered ring, en route to the cytotoxic natural product dolabelide C.
Assuntos
Alcenos , Produtos Biológicos , Alcenos/química , Produtos Biológicos/química , Catálise , Ciclização , EstereoisomerismoRESUMO
Trisubstituted alkenyl fluorides are important compounds for drug discovery, agrochemical development and materials science. Despite notable progress, however, many stereochemically defined trisubstituted fluoroalkenes either cannot be prepared efficiently or can only be accessed in one isomeric form. Here we outline a general solution to this problem by first unveiling a practical, widely applicable and catalytic strategy for stereodivergent synthesis of olefins bearing a fluoro-chloro terminus. This has been accomplished by cross-metathesis between two trisubstituted olefins, one of which is a purchasable but scarcely utilized trihaloalkene. Subsequent cross-coupling can then be used to generate an assortment of trisubstituted alkenyl fluorides. The importance of the advance is highlighted by syntheses of, among others, a fluoronematic liquid-crystal component, peptide analogues bearing an E- or a Z-amide bond mimic, and all four stereoisomers of difluororumenic ester (an anti-cancer compound).
Assuntos
Alcenos , Alcenos/química , Catálise , Estrutura Molecular , EstereoisomerismoRESUMO
The first examples of cross-metathesis between two different allenes is disclosed. First- and second-generation Ru complexes were found to be ineffective, at most affording only oligomeric products. The exception was a first-generation complex bearing a bidentate phenyl isopropoxy ligand (i.e., PCy3 is not released upon initiation), reactions with which afforded a 1,3-disubstituted allenyl boronate in 22% yield. On the basis of mechanistic studies designed to gain deeper understanding of the reasons for the ineffectiveness of different Ru catalysts, it was discovered that phosphine-free Ru-CAAC complexes have the steric and electronic attributes to be highly effective. The results of these investigations pave the way for development of additional olefin metathesis reactions that generate allenes.
RESUMO
The catalytic performances of molecular and silica-supported molybdenum oxo alkylidene species bearing anionic O ligands [ORF9, OTPP, OHMT - where ORF9 = OC(CF3)3, OTPP = 2,3,5,6-tetraphenylphenoxy, OHMT = hexamethylterphenoxy] with different σ-donation abilities and sizes are evaluated in the metathesis of both internal and terminal olefins. Here, we show that the presence of the anionic nonafluoro-tert-butoxy X ligand in Mo(O){âCH-4-(MeO)C6H4}(THF)2{X}2 (1; X = ORF9) significantly increases the catalytic performances in the metathesis of both terminal and internal olefins. Its silica-supported equivalent displays slightly lower activity, albeit with improved stability. In sharp contrast, the molecular complexes with large aryloxy anionic X ligands show little activity, whereas the activity of the corresponding silica-supported systems is greatly improved, illustrating that surface siloxy groups are significantly smaller anionic ligands. Of all of the systems, compound 1 stands out because of its unique high activity for both terminal and internal olefins. Density functional theory modeling indicates that the ORF9 ligand is ideal in this series because of its weak σ-donating ability, avoiding overstabilization of the metallacyclobutane intermediates while keeping low barriers for [2 + 2] cycloaddition and turnstile isomerization.
RESUMO
A widely applicable, practical, and scalable strategy for efficient and enantioselective synthesis of ß,γ-unsaturated ketones that contain an α-stereogenic center is disclosed. Accordingly, aryl, heteroaryl, alkynyl, alkenyl, allyl, or alkyl ketones that contain an α-stereogenic carbon with an alkyl, an aryl, a benzyloxy, or a siloxy moiety can be generated from readily available starting materials and by the use of commercially available chiral ligands in 52-96% yield and 93:7 to >99:1 enantiomeric ratio. To develop the new method, conditions were identified so that high enantioselectivity would be attained and the resulting α-substituted NH-ketimines, wherein there is strong CâN â B(pin) coordination, would not epimerize before conversion to the derived ketone by hydrolysis. It is demonstrated that the ketone products can be converted to an assortment of homoallylic tertiary alcohols in 70-96% yield and 92:8 to >98:2 dr-in either diastereomeric form-by reactions with alkyl-, aryl-, heteroaryl-, allyl-, vinyl-, alkynyl-, or propargyl-metal reagents. The utility of the approach is highlighted through transformations that furnish other desirable derivatives and a concise synthesis route affording more than a gram of a major fragment of anti-HIV agents rubriflordilactones A and B and a specific stereoisomeric analogue.
Assuntos
Cetonas/síntese química , Compostos Organometálicos/química , Propanóis/síntese química , Catálise , Cristalografia por Raios X , Cetonas/química , Ligantes , Modelos Moleculares , Estrutura Molecular , Propanóis/química , EstereoisomerismoRESUMO
Ethylene is the byproduct of olefin metathesis reactions that involve one or more terminal alkenes. Its volatility is one reason why many cross-metathesis or ring-closing metathesis processes, which are reversible transformations, are efficient. However, because ethylene can be converted to a methylidene complex, which is a highly reactive but relatively unstable species, its concentration can impact olefin metathesis in other ways. In some cases, introducing excess ethylene can increase reaction rate owing to faster catalyst initiation. Ethylene and a derived methylidene complex can also advantageously inhibit substrate or product homocoupling, and/or divert a less selective pathway. In other instances, a methylidene's low stability and high activity may lead to erosion of efficiency and/or kinetic selectivity, making it preferable that ethylene is removed while being generated. If methylidene decomposition is so fast that there is little or no product formation, it is best that ethylene and methylidene complex formation is avoided altogether. This is accomplished by the use of di- or trisubstituted alkenes in stereoretentive processes, which includes adopting methylene capping strategy. Here, we analyze the different scenarios through which ethylene and the involvement of methylidene complexes can be manipulated and managed so that an olefin metathesis reaction may occur more efficiently and/or more stereoselectively.
Assuntos
Alcenos/química , Estrutura Molecular , EstereoisomerismoRESUMO
A copper-based complex that contains a sulfonate N-heterocyclic carbene ligand was first reported 15 years ago. Since then, these organometallic entities have proven to be uniquely effective in catalyzing an assortment of enantioselective transformations, including allylic substitutions, conjugate additions, proto-boryl additions to alkenes, boryl and silyl substitutions, hydride-allyl additions to alkenyl boronates, and additions of boron-containing allyl moieties to N-H ketimines. In this review article, we detail the shortcomings in the state-of-the-art that fueled the development of this air stable ligand class, members of which can be prepared on multigram scale. For each reaction type, when relevant, the prior art at the time of the advance involving sulfonate NHC-Cu catalysts and/or subsequent key developments are briefly analyzed, and the relevance of the advance to efficient and enantioselective total or formal synthesis of biologically active molecules is underscored. Mechanistic analysis of the structural attributes of sulfonate NHC-Cu catalysts that are responsible for their ability to facilitate transformations with high efficiency as well as regio- and enantioselectivity are detailed. This review contains several formerly undisclosed methodological advances and mechanistic analyses, the latter of which constitute a revision of previously reported proposals.
Assuntos
Complexos de Coordenação/química , Cobre/química , Compostos Heterocíclicos/química , Metano/análogos & derivados , Ácidos Sulfônicos/química , Alcenos/química , Compostos Alílicos/química , Compostos de Boro/química , Catálise , Iminas/química , Metano/química , Estrutura Molecular , Nitrilas/química , EstereoisomerismoRESUMO
A method for catalytic regio- and enantioselective synthesis of trifluoromethyl-substituted and aryl-, heteroaryl-, alkenyl-, and alkynyl-substituted homoallylic α-tertiary NH2 -amines is introduced. Easy-to-synthesize and robust N-silyl ketimines are converted to NH-ketimines in situ, which then react with a Z-allyl boronate. Transformations are promoted by a readily accessible l-threonine-derived aminophenol-based boryl catalyst, affording the desired products in up to 91 % yield, >98:2 α:γ selectivity, >98:2 Z:E selectivity, and >99:1 enantiomeric ratio. A commercially available aminophenol may be used, and allyl boronates, which may contain an alkyl-, a chloro-, or a bromo-substituted Z-alkene, can either be purchased or prepared by catalytic stereoretentive cross-metathesis. What is more, Z-trisubstituted allyl boronates may be used. Various chemo-, regio-, and diastereoselective transformations of the α-tertiary homoallylic NH2 -amine products highlight the utility of the approach; this includes diastereo- and regioselective epoxide formation/trichloroacetic acid cleavage to generate differentiated diol derivatives.
Assuntos
Aminas/química , Compostos de Boro/química , Treonina/química , Catálise , Iminas/química , Espectroscopia de Ressonância Magnética/métodos , Nitrilas/química , EstereoisomerismoRESUMO
A protecting group-free strategy is presented for diastereo- and enantioselective routes that can be used to prepare a wide variety of Z-homoallylic alcohols with significantly higher efficiency than is otherwise feasible. The approach entails the merger of several catalytic processes and is expected to facilitate the preparation of bioactive organic molecules. More specifically, Z-chloro-substituted allylic pinacolatoboronate is first obtained through stereoretentive cross-metathesis between Z-crotyl-B(pin) (pin = pinacolato) and Z-dichloroethene, both of which are commercially available. The organoboron compound may be used in the central transformation of the entire approach, an α- and enantioselective addition to an aldehyde, catalyzed by a proton-activated, chiral aminophenol-boryl catalyst. Catalytic cross-coupling can then furnish the desired Z-homoallylic alcohol in high enantiomeric purity. The olefin metathesis step can be carried out with substrates and a Mo-based complex that can be purchased. The aminophenol compound that is needed for the second catalytic step can be prepared in multigram quantities from inexpensive starting materials. A significant assortment of homoallylic alcohols bearing a Z-F3C-substituted alkene can also be prepared with similar high efficiency and regio-, diastereo-, and enantioselectivity. What is more, trisubstituted Z-alkenyl chloride moiety can be accessed with similar efficiency albeit with somewhat lower α-selectivity and enantioselectivity. The general utility of the approach is underscored by a succinct, protecting group-free, and enantioselective total synthesis of mycothiazole, a naturally occurring anticancer agent through a sequence that contains a longest linear sequence of nine steps (12 steps total), seven of which are catalytic, generating mycothiazole in 14.5% overall yield.
Assuntos
Antineoplásicos/síntese química , Cloretos/química , Clorofluorcarbonetos de Metano/química , Propanóis/síntese química , Tiazóis/síntese química , Catálise , Cromatografia Líquida de Alta Pressão , Propanóis/química , Espectroscopia de Prótons por Ressonância Magnética , EstereoisomerismoRESUMO
Catalytic enantioselective methods are introduced that allow access to a variety of allyl boronates and silanes that contain a difluoroalkene unit; the resulting products may be used for the preparation of organofluorine compounds in high enantiomeric purity. Furthermore, a number of key mechanistic aspects of the transformations have been investigated and analyzed. Thus, first, an NHC-Cu-catalyzed method for boryl substitution with F3C-substituted alkenes is introduced. These processes, unlike the previously reported strategies, are applicable to alkyl as well as aryl substituted substrates, afford allyl boronates bearing a difluoroalkene moiety (up to 98% yield and 95:5 er). Second, the corresponding silyl substitutions, the first reported cases of their kind, are presented (up to 94% yield and 97:3 er). Third, experimental and computational (DFT) investigations are described that shed light on key mechanistic aspects of the catalytic processes. Evidence (X-ray structures of Cu-alkyl intermediates and kinetic studies) is put forth illustrating that the initial Cu-boryl and Cu-silyl addition is significantly faster than the ensuing Cu-F elimination, and that the latter step can be facilitated by either a mild Lewis acid (e.g., a Li or Na cation) or a nucleophilic promoter (e.g., an alkoxide). These findings together with DFT studies demonstrate that Cu-F ß-elimination probably proceeds with anti-stereochemistry. Representative cases of ways through which the new mechanistic understanding may be used to rationalize previously disclosed findings, significantly improve a transformation, or develop new diastereo- and enantioselective catalytic methods are provided. For example, an explanation is provided regarding why bisphosphine-Cu complexes do not efficiently promote boryl substitutions with aryl-substituted substrates, but the corresponding silyl substitutions are facile, and how the size of a ligand can impact regioselectivity and efficiency.
RESUMO
An emerging area of research in chemistry requires that we learn how to manage the characteristics of a pair of co-catalysts so that a transformation proceeds as we wish it to. These are processes during which one catalyst first generates a non-isolable intermediate, which then in situ undergoes a reaction that is promoted by a different catalyst. This scenario raises several design issues. Since co-catalysts often have overlapping functions, what if there is an exchange of ligands between two organometallic catalysts? How can we be certain that a co-catalyst reacts specifically with a particular intermediate? What if the less reactive co-catalyst must engage first, and the one that is more active needs to wait its turn? How might we orchestrate the proper sequence of events? While many dual-catalytic processes have been introduced and reviews are available, there are subtle yet crucial distinguishing attributes that remain unappreciated. While the terms "dual-catalysis" and "cooperative catalysis" are often used interchangeably, on many occasions the catalysts are not entirely cooperative. Here, we will discuss how chemists have been able to harmonize the opposing functions of catalysts to achieve high efficiency and/or stereoselectivity. We will show that the progress achieved thus far is likely the preamble to the future development of non-orthogonal multi-catalytic processes (i.e., transformations involving several catalysts that are not inherently cooperative) where the order with which each catalyst enters the fray will demand additional innovative strategies.