Radiation Dose-Volume-Response Relationships for Adverse Events in Childhood Cancer Survivors: Introduction to the Scientific Issues in PENTEC.

At its very core, radiation oncology involves a trade-off between the benefits and risks of exposing tumors and normal tissue to relatively high doses of ionizing radiation. This trade-off is particularly critical in childhood cancer survivors (CCS), in whom both benefits and risks can be hugely consequential due to the long life expectancy if the primary cancer is controlled. Estimating the normal tissue-related risks of a specific radiation therapy plan in an individual patient relies on predictive mathematical modeling of empirical data on adverse events. The Pediatric Normal-Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC) collaborative network was formed to summarize and, when possible, to synthesize dose-volume-response relationships for a range of adverse events incident in CCS based on the literature. Normal-tissue clinical radiation biology in children is particularly challenging for many reasons: (1) Childhood malignancies are relatively uncommon-constituting approximately 1% of new incident cancers in the United States-and biologically heterogeneous, leading to many small series in the literature and large variability within and between series. This creates challenges in synthesizing data across series. (2) CCS are at an elevated risk for a range of adverse health events that are not specific to radiation therapy. Thus, excess relative or absolute risk compared with a reference population becomes the appropriate metric. (3) Various study designs and quantities to express risk are found in the literature, and these are summarized. (4) Adverse effects in CCS often occur 30, 50, or more years after therapy. This limits the information content of series with even very extended follow-up, and lifetime risk estimates are typically extrapolations that become dependent on the mathematical model used. (5) The long latent period means that retrospective dosimetry is required, as individual computed tomography-based radiation therapy plans gradually became available after 1980. (6) Many individual patient-level factors affect outcomes, including age at exposure, attained age, lifestyle exposures, health behaviors, other treatment modalities, dose, fractionation, and dose distribution. (7) Prospective databases with individual patient-level data and radiation dosimetry are being built and will facilitate advances in dose-volume-response modeling. We discuss these challenges and attempts to overcome them in the setting of PENTEC.

Reporting Standards for Complication Studies of Radiation Therapy for Pediatric Cancer: Lessons From PENTEC.

The major aim of Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC) was to synthesize quantitative published dose/-volume/toxicity data in pediatric radiation therapy. Such systematic reviews are often challenging because of the lack of standardization and difficulty of reporting outcomes, clinical factors, and treatment details in journal articles. This has clinical consequences: optimization of treatment plans must balance between the risks of toxicity and local failure; counseling patients and their parents requires knowledge of the excess risks encountered after a specific treatment. Studies addressing outcomes after pediatric radiation therapy are particularly challenging because: (a) survivors may live for decades after treatment, and the latency time to toxicity can be very long; (b) children's maturation can be affected by radiation, depending on the developmental status of the organs involved at time of treatment; and (c) treatment regimens frequently involve chemotherapies, possibly modifying and adding to the toxicity of radiation. Here we discuss: basic reporting strategies to account for the actuarial nature of the complications; the reporting of modeling of abnormal development; and the need for standardized, comprehensively reported data sets and multivariate models (ie, accounting for the simultaneous effects of radiation dose, age, developmental status at time of treatment, and chemotherapy dose). We encourage the use of tools that facilitate comprehensive reporting, for example, electronic supplements for journal articles. Finally, we stress the need for clinicians to be able to trust artificial intelligence models of outcome of radiation therapy, which requires transparency, rigor, reproducibility, and comprehensive reporting. Adopting the reporting methods discussed here and in the individual PENTEC articles will increase the clinical and scientific usefulness of individual reports and associated pooled analyses.

Imaging Assessment of Radiation Therapy-Related Normal Tissue Injury in Children: A PENTEC Visionary Statement.

The Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC) consortium has made significant contributions to understanding and mitigating the adverse effects of childhood cancer therapy. This review addresses the role of diagnostic imaging in detecting, screening, and comprehending radiation therapy-related late effects in children, drawing insights from individual organ-specific PENTEC reports. We further explore how the development of imaging biomarkers for key organ systems, alongside technical advancements and translational imaging approaches, may enhance the systematic application of imaging evaluations in childhood cancer survivors. Moreover, the review critically examines knowledge gaps and identifies technical and practical limitations of existing imaging modalities in the pediatric population. Addressing these challenges may expand access to, minimize the risk of, and optimize the real-world application of, new imaging techniques. The PENTEC team envisions this document as a roadmap for the future development of imaging strategies in childhood cancer survivors, with the overarching goal of improving long-term health outcomes and quality of life for this vulnerable population.

Evaluating the Impact of Bowel Gas Variations for Wilms' Tumor in Pediatric Proton Therapy.

(1) Background: Proton therapy, a precise form of radiation treatment, can be significantly affected by variations in bowel content. The purpose was to identify the most beneficial gantry angles that minimize deviations from the treatment plan quality, thus enhancing the safety and efficacy of proton therapy for Wilms' tumor patients. (2) Methods: Thirteen patients with Wilms' tumor, enrolled in the SJWT21 clinical trial, underwent proton therapy. The variations in bowel gas were systematically monitored using daily Cone Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT) imaging. Air cavities identified in daily CBCT images were analyzed to construct daily verification plans and measure water equivalent path length (WEPL) changes. A worst-case scenario simulation was conducted to identify the safest beam angles. (3) Results: The study revealed a maximum decrease in target dose (ΔD100%) of 8.0%, which corresponded to a WEPL variation (ΔWEPL) of 11.3 mm. The average reduction in target dose, denoted as mean ΔD100%, was found to be 2.8%, with a standard deviation (SD) of 3.2%. The mean ΔWEPL was observed as 3.3 mm, with an SD of 2.7 mm. The worst-case scenario analysis suggested that gantry beam angles oriented toward the patient's right and posterior aspects from 110° to 310° were associated with minimized WEPL discrepancies. (4) Conclusions: This study comprehensively evaluated the influence of bowel gas variability on treatment plan accuracy and proton range uncertainties in pediatric proton therapy for Wilms' tumor.

Performance analysis and knowledge-based quality assurance of critical organ auto-segmentation for pediatric craniospinal irradiation.

Craniospinal irradiation (CSI) is a vital therapeutic approach utilized for young patients suffering from central nervous system disorders such as medulloblastoma. The task of accurately outlining the treatment area is particularly time-consuming due to the presence of several sensitive organs at risk (OAR) that can be affected by radiation. This study aimed to assess two different methods for automating the segmentation process: an atlas technique and a deep learning neural network approach. Additionally, a novel method was devised to prospectively evaluate the accuracy of automated segmentation as a knowledge-based quality assurance (QA) tool. Involving a patient cohort of 100, ranging in ages from 2 to 25 years with a median age of 8, this study employed quantitative metrics centered around overlap and distance calculations to determine the most effective approach for practical clinical application. The contours generated by two distinct methods of atlas and neural network were compared to ground truth contours approved by a radiation oncologist, utilizing 13 distinct metrics. Furthermore, an innovative QA tool was conceptualized, designed for forthcoming cases based on the baseline dataset of 100 patient cases. The calculated metrics indicated that, in the majority of cases (60.58%), the neural network method demonstrated a notably higher alignment with the ground truth. Instances where no difference was observed accounted for 31.25%, while utilization of the atlas method represented 8.17%. The QA tool results showed that the two approaches achieved 100% agreement in 39.4% of instances for the atlas method and in 50.6% of instances for the neural network auto-segmentation. The results indicate that the neural network approach showcases superior performance, and its significantly closer physical alignment to ground truth contours in the majority of cases. The metrics derived from overlap and distance measurements have enabled clinicians to discern the optimal choice for practical clinical application.

Improving Pediatric Normal Tissue Radiation Dose-Response Modeling in Children With Cancer: A PENTEC Initiative.

The development of normal tissue radiation dose-response models for children with cancer has been challenged by many factors, including small sample sizes; the long length of follow-up needed to observe some toxicities; the continuing occurrence of events beyond the time of assessment; the often complex relationship between age at treatment, normal tissue developmental dynamics, and age at assessment; and the need to use retrospective dosimetry. Meta-analyses of published pediatric outcome studies face additional obstacles of incomplete reporting of critical dosimetric, clinical, and statistical information. This report describes general methods used to address some of the pediatric modeling issues. It highlights previous single- and multi-institutional pediatric dose-response studies and summarizes how each PENTEC taskforce addressed the challenges and limitations of the reviewed publications in constructing, when possible, organ-specific dose-effect models.

Novel Monthly Quality Assurance Regimen and 5-Year Analysis Using a Proton Metrology System.

Purpose: To develop a novel, monthly quality assurance (QA) regimen for a proton therapy system that uses 2 custom phantoms, each housing a commercial scintillator detector and a charge-coupled device camera. The novel metrology system assessed QA trends at a pediatric proton therapy center from 2018 to 2022. Materials and Methods: The measurement system was designed to accommodate horizontal and vertical positioning of the commercial device and to enable gantry and couch isocentricity measurements (using a star shot procedure), proton spot profile verification, and imaging and radiation congruence tests to be performed simultaneously in the dual-phantom setup. Gantry angles and proton beam energies were varied and alternated each month, using gantry angles of 0°, 30°, 60°, 90°, 120°, 150°, and 180° and discrete beam energies of 69.4, 84.5, 100, 139.1, 180.4, 200.4, and 221.3 MeV after radiographic verification. A total of 1176 individual monthly QA measurements of gantry and couch isocentricity, spot size, and congruence were analyzed. Results: Gantry and couch star shot measurements showed beam isocentricities of 0.3 ± 0.2 mm and 0.2 ± 0.2 mm, respectively, which were within the threshold of 1.0 mm. Spot sizes for each discrete energy were within the threshold of ± 10% of the baseline values for all 3 proton rooms. The imaging and radiation coincidence test results for the 1176 individual monthly QA measurements were 0.5 mm for the 50th percentile and 1.2 mm (the clinical threshold) for the 97.6th percentile. Conclusions: Integrating a commercial device with custom phantoms improved the quality of proton system checks compared with previous methods using radiochromic films, loose ball bearings, and foam. The scheme of alternating beam angles with discrete energies in the monthly QA-enabled, clinically meaningful verification of beam energy and gantry angle combinations while the machine performance and accuracy were being checked.

Risks of Spinal Abnormalities and Growth Impairment After Radiation to the Spine in Childhood Cancer Survivors: A PENTEC Comprehensive Review.

PURPOSE: A PENTEC (Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic) review was performed to estimate the dose-volume effects of radiation therapy on spine deformities and growth impairment for patients who underwent radiation therapy as children. METHODS AND MATERIALS: A systematic literature search was performed to identify published data for spine deformities and growth stunting. Data were extracted from 12 reports of children irradiated to the spine (N = 603 patients). The extracted data were analyzed to find associations between complication risks and the radiation dose (conventional fractionation throughout) as impacted by exposed volumes and age using the mixed-effects logistic regression model. When appropriate, corrections were made for radiation modality, namely orthovoltage beams. RESULTS: In the regression analysis, the association between vertebral dose and scoliosis rate was highly significant (P < .001). Additionally, young age at time of radiation was highly predictive of adverse outcomes. Clinically significant scoliosis can occur with doses ≥15 Gy to vertebrae during infancy (<2 years of age). For children irradiated at 2 to 6 years of age, overall scoliosis rates of any grade were >30% with doses >20 Gy; grade 2 or higher scoliosis was correlated with doses ≥30 Gy. Children >6 years of age remain at risk for scoliosis with doses >30 Gy; however, most cases will be mild. There are limited data regarding the effect of dose gradients across the spine on degree of scoliosis. The risk of clinically meaningful height loss was minimal when irradiating small volumes of the spine up to 20 Gy (eg, flank irradiation), except in infants who are more vulnerable to lower doses. Growth stunting was more frequent when larger segments of the spine (eg, the entire spine or craniospinal irradiation) were irradiated before puberty to doses >20 Gy. The effect was modest when patients were irradiated after puberty to doses >20 Gy. CONCLUSIONS: To reduce the risk of kyphoscoliosis and growth impairment, the dose to the spine should be kept to <20 Gy for children <6 years of age and to <10 to 15 Gy in infants. The number of vertebral bodies irradiated and dose gradients across the spine should also be limited when possible.

Interplay Effect of Splenic Motion for Total Lymphoid Irradiation in Pediatric Proton Therapy.

(1) Background: The most significant cause of an unacceptable deviation from the planned dose during respiratory motion is the interplay effect. We examined the correlation between the magnitude of splenic motion and its impact on plan quality for total lymphoid irradiation (TLI); (2) Methods: Static and 4D CT images from ten patients were used for interplay effect simulations. Patients' original plans were optimized based on the average CT extracted from the 4D CT and planned with two posterior beams using scenario-based optimization (±3 mm of setup and ±3% of range uncertainty) and gradient matching at the level of mid-spleen. Dynamically accumulated 4D doses (interplay effect dose) were calculated based on the time-dependent delivery sequence of radiation fluence across all phases of the 4D CT. Dose volume parameters for each simulated treatment delivery were evaluated for plan quality; (3) Results: Peak-to-peak splenic motion (≤12 mm) was measured from the 4D CT of ten patients. Interplay effect simulations revealed that the ITV coverage of the spleen remained within the protocol tolerance for splenic motion, ≤8 mm. The D100% coverage for ITV spleen decreased from 95.0% (nominal plan) to 89.3% with 10 mm and 87.2% with 12 mm of splenic motion; (4) Conclusions: 4D plan evaluation and robust optimization may overcome problems associated with respiratory motion in proton TLI treatments. Patient-specific respiratory motion evaluations are essential to confirming adequate dosimetric coverage when proton therapy is utilized.

A User's Guide and Summary of Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC): Radiation Dose-Volume Response for Adverse Effects After Childhood Cancer Therapy and Future Directions.

Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC) is an international multidisciplinary effort that aims to summarize normal-tissue toxicity risks based on published dose-volume data from studies of children and adolescents treated with radiation therapy (RT) for cancer. With recognition that children are uniquely vulnerable to treatment-related toxic effects, our mission and challenge was to assemble our group of physicians (radiation and pediatric oncologists, subspecialists), physicists with clinical and modeling expertise, epidemiologists, and other scientists to develop evidence-based radiation dosimetric guidelines, as affected by developmental status and other factors (eg, other cancer therapies and host factors). These quantitative toxicity risk estimates could serve to inform RT planning and thereby improve outcomes. Tandem goals included the description of relevant medical physics issues specific to pediatric RT and the proposal of dose-volume outcome reporting standards to inform future studies. We created 19 organ-specific task forces and methodology to unravel the wealth of data from heterogeneous published studies. This report provides a high-level summary of PENTEC's genesis, methods, key findings, and associated concepts that affected our work and an explanation of how our findings may be interpreted and applied in the clinic. We acknowledge our predecessors in these efforts, and we pay homage to the children whose lives informed us and to future generations who we hope will benefit from this additional step in our path forward.

Setup Uncertainty of Pediatric Brain Tumor Patients Receiving Proton Therapy: A Prospective Study.

This study quantifies setup uncertainty in brain tumor patients who received image-guided proton therapy. Patients analyzed include 165 children, adolescents, and young adults (median age at radiotherapy: 9 years (range: 10 months to 24 years); 80 anesthetized and 85 awake) enrolled in a single-institution prospective study from 2020 to 2023. Cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) was performed daily to calculate and correct manual setup errors, once per course after setup correction to measure residual errors, and weekly after treatments to assess intrafractional motion. Orthogonal radiographs were acquired consecutively with CBCT for paired comparisons of 40 patients. Translational and rotational errors were converted from 6 degrees of freedom to a scalar by a statistical approach that considers the distance from the target to the isocenter. The 95th percentile of setup uncertainty was reduced by daily CBCT from 10 mm (manual positioning) to 1-1.5 mm (after correction) and increased to 2 mm by the end of fractional treatment. A larger variation existed between the roll corrections reported by radiographs vs. CBCT than for pitch and yaw, while there was no statistically significant difference in translational variation. A quantile mixed regression model showed that the 95th percentile of intrafractional motion was 0.40 mm lower for anesthetized patients (p=0.0016). Considering additional uncertainty in radiation-imaging isocentricity, the commonly used total plan robustness of 3 mm against positional uncertainty would be appropriate for our study cohort.

Effects of Radiation Therapy on the Female Reproductive Tract in Childhood Cancer Survivors: A PENTEC Comprehensive Review.

PURPOSE: The PENTEC (Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic) task force aimed to quantify effects of radiation therapy (RT) dose to the female reproductive organs after treatment for childhood cancer. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Relevant studies published 1970 to 2017 were identified systematically through PubMed, Medline, and Cochrane databases with additional articles before 2021 identified by the group. Two large studies reported sufficient data to allow modeling of acute ovarian failure (AOF; loss of function ≤5 year from diagnosis) and premature ovarian insufficiency (POI; loss of function at attained age <40 years) based on maximum dose to least affected ovary. Although normal tissue complication probability modeling was not feasible for the uterus due to limited data, the relationship between ultrasound-measured uterine volume and estimated amount of RT was plotted. Limited data regarding vaginal toxicity were available. RESULTS: The risk of AOF increases with RT dose to least affected ovary, alkylating agent cumulative dose (cyclophosphamide equivalent dose [CED] in g/m2), age at RT, and stem cell transplantation: Two Gy to the least affected ovary resulted in AOF risk of 1% to 5% (CED = 0, risk increasing with age), 4% to 7% (CED = 10 g/m2, risk increasing with age), and 6% to 13% (CED = 30 g/m2, risk increasing with age). For patients aged 1 and 20 years at time of RT, AOF risk was ≥50% at doses of 24 Gy and 20 Gy with no alkylating chemotherapy, 22.5 Gy and 17 Gy with intermediate alkylator dose (10 g/m2), and 17 Gy and 13 Gy with high alkylator dose (30 g/m2). Risk of POI increases with survivor (attained) age (rather than age at time of RT), radiation dose to least affected ovary, and alkylator dose. Data review suggested that higher radiation doses to the uterus are associated with uterine toxicity, with uterine size considerably restricted after 12 Gy. Vaginal radiation in children is associated with high toxicity risk, although dose-volume data are not available for quantification. CONCLUSIONS: Risk of AOF increases with age at RT, CED exposure, and RT dose; risk of POI likewise increases with RT dose, CED exposure, and survivor age. Both AOF and POI are expected to affect fertility and estrogen production. Data suggest that RT uterine dose >12 Gy may be associated with uterine size restriction. Adult literature suggests that maintaining vaginal dose <5 Gy may limit toxicity. Treatment of life-threatening malignancy remains a priority over reproductive preservation; however, when possible, radiation and surgical techniques should be considered to minimize dose to least affected ovary, uterus, and vagina. Survivors should receive endocrine and gynecologic support; those desiring pregnancy should be counseled early to maximize reproductive options.

Monitoring of Interfractional Proton Range Verification and Dosimetric Impact Based on Daily CBCT for Pediatric Patients with Pelvic Tumors.

(1) Background: Synthetic CT images of the pelvis were generated from daily CBCT images to monitor changes in water equivalent path length (WEPL) and determine the dosimetric impact of anatomy changes along the proton beam's path; (2) Methods: Ten pediatric patients with pelvic tumors treated using proton therapy with daily CBCT were included. The original planning CT was deformed to the same-day CBCT to generate synthetic CT images for WEPL comparison and dosimetric evaluation; (3) Results: WEPL changes of 20 proton fields at the distal edge of the CTV ranged from 0.1 to 12 mm with a median of 2.5 mm, and 75th percentile of 5.1 mm for (the original CT-rescanned CT) and ranged from 0.3 to 10.1 mm with a median of 2.45 mm and 75th percentile of 4.8 mm for (the original CT-synthetic CT). The dosimetric impact was due to proton range pullback or overshoot, which led to reduced coverage in CTV Dmin averaging 12.1% and 11.3% in the rescanned and synthetic CT verification plans, respectively; (4) Conclusions: The study demonstrated that synthetic CT generated by deforming the original planning CT to daily CBCT can be used to quantify proton range changes and predict adverse dosimetric scenarios without the need for excessive rescanned CT scans during large interfractional variations in adaptive proton therapy of pediatric pelvic tumors.

Children's Oncology Group's 2023 blueprint for research: Radiation oncology.

Radiation oncology is an integral part of the multidisciplinary team caring for children with cancer. The primary goal of our committee is to enable the delivery of the safest dose of radiation therapy (RT) with the maximal potential for cure, and to minimize toxicity in children by delivering lower doses to normal tissues using advanced technologies like intensity-modulated RT (IMRT) and proton therapy. We provide mentorship for y ators and are actively involved in educating the global radiation oncology community. We are leaders in the effort to discover novel radiosensitizers, radioprotectors, and advanced RT technologies that could help improve outcomes of children with cancer.

A hybrid method of correcting CBCT for proton range estimation with deep learning and deformable image registration.

Objective. This study aimed to develop a novel method for generating synthetic CT (sCT) from cone-beam CT (CBCT) of the abdomen/pelvis with bowel gas pockets to facilitate estimation of proton ranges.Approach. CBCT, the same-day repeat CT, and the planning CT (pCT) of 81 pediatric patients were used for training (n= 60), validation (n= 6), and testing (n= 15) of the method. The proposed method hybridizes unsupervised deep learning (CycleGAN) and deformable image registration (DIR) of the pCT to CBCT. The CycleGAN and DIR are respectively applied to generate the geometry-weighted (high spatial-frequency) and intensity-weighted (low spatial-frequency) components of the sCT, thereby each process deals with only the component weighted toward its strength. The resultant sCT is further improved in bowel gas regions and other tissues by iteratively feeding back the sCT to adjust incorrect DIR and by increasing the contribution of the deformed pCT in regions of accurate DIR.Main results. The hybrid sCT was more accurate than deformed pCT and CycleGAN-only sCT as indicated by the smaller mean absolute error in CT numbers (28.7 ± 7.1 HU versus 38.8 ± 19.9 HU/53.2 ± 5.5 HU;P≤ 0.012) and higher Dice similarity of the internal gas regions (0.722 ± 0.088 versus 0.180 ± 0.098/0.659 ± 0.129;P≤ 0.002). Accordingly, the hybrid method resulted in more accurate proton range for the beams intersecting gas pockets (11 fields in 6 patients) than the individual methods (the 90th percentile error in 80% distal fall-off, 1.8 ± 0.6 mm versus 6.5 ± 7.8 mm/3.7 ± 1.5 mm;P≤ 0.013). The gamma passing rates also showed a significant dosimetric advantage by the hybrid method (99.7 ± 0.8% versus 98.4 ± 3.1%/98.3 ± 1.8%;P≤ 0.007).Significance. The hybrid method significantly improved the accuracy of sCT and showed promises in CBCT-based proton range verification and adaptive replanning of abdominal/pelvic proton therapy even when gas pockets are present in the beam path.

Toward Systematic Assessment and Improvement of Radiation Therapy Plan Quality of Cooperative Group Trial Submissions: A Report From the Children's Oncology Group.

PURPOSE: This study evaluates the quality of plans used for the treatment of patients in the Children's Oncology Group study ACNS1123. Plan quality is quantified based on a scoring system specific to the protocol. In this way, the distribution of plan quality scores is determined that can be used to identify plan quality issues for this study and for future plan quality improvement. METHODS AND MATERIALS: ACNS1123 stratum 1 patients (70) were evaluated. This included 50 photon and 20 proton plans. Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine (DICOM) structure and dose data were obtained from the Children's Oncology Group. A commercially available plan quality scoring algorithm was used to create a scoring system we designed using the protocol dosimetric requirements. The whole ventricle and boost planning target volumes (PTVs) could earn a maximum of 70 points, whereas the organs at risk could earn 30 points (total maximum score of 100 points). The scoring algorithm adjusted scores based on the difficulty in achieving the structure dose requirements, which depended on the proximity of the PTVs and the dose gradients achieved relative to the organs at risk. The distribution of plan scores was used to determine the mean, median, and range of scores. RESULTS: The median adjusted plan quality scores for the 20 proton and 50 photon plans were 83.3 and 86.9, respectively. The range of adjusted scores (maximum to minimum) was 50 points. The average score adjustment was 7.4 points. Photon and proton plans performed almost equally. Average plan quality by individual structure revealed that the brain stem, PTV boost, and cochlea lost the most points. CONCLUSIONS: This report is the first to systematically analyze overall radiation therapy plan quality scores for an entire cohort of patients treated in a cooperative group clinical trial. The methodology demonstrated a large variation in plan quality in this trial. Future clinical trials could potentially use this method to reduce plan quality variability, which may improve outcomes.

Physics Considerations for Evaluation of Dose for Dose-Response Models of Pediatric Late Effects From Radiation Therapy.

PURPOSE: We describe the methods used to estimate the accuracy of dosimetric data found in literature sources used to construct the Pediatric Normal Tissue Effects in the Clinic (PENTEC) dose-response models, summarize these findings of each organ-specific task force, describe some of the dosimetric challenges and the extent to which these efforts affected the final modeling results, and provide guidance on the interpretation of the dose-response results given the various dosimetric uncertainties. METHODS AND MATERIALS: Each of the PENTEC task force medical physicists reviewed all the journal articles used for dose-response modeling to identify, categorize, and quantify dosimetric uncertainties. These uncertainties fell into 6 broad categories. A uniform nomenclature was developed for describing the "dosimetric quality" of the articles used in the PENTEC reviews. Among the multidisciplinary experts in the PENTEC effort, the medical physicists were charged with the dosimetric evaluation, as they are most expert in this subject. RESULTS: The percentage dosimetric uncertainty was estimated for each late effect endpoint for all PENTEC organ reports. Twelve specific sources of dose uncertainty were identified related to the 6 broad categories. The most common reason for organ dose uncertainty was that prescribed dose rather than organ dose was reported. Percentage dose uncertainties ranged from 5% to 200%. Systematic uncertainties were used to correct the dose component of the models. Random uncertainties were also described in each report and in some cases used to modify dose axis error bars. In addition, the potential effects of dose binning were described. CONCLUSIONS: PENTEC reports are designed to provide guidance to radiation oncologists and treatment planners for organ dose constraints. It is critical that these dose constraint recommendations are as accurate as possible, acknowledging the large error bars for many. Achieving this accuracy is important as it enables clinicians to better balance target dose coverage with risk of late effects. Evidence-based dose constraints for pediatric patients have been lacking and, in this regard, PENTEC fills an important unmet need. One must be aware of the limitations of our recommendations, and that for some organ systems, large uncertainties exist in the dose-response model because of clinical endpoint uncertainty, dosimetric uncertainty, or both.

Development of a log file analysis tool for proton patient QA, system performance tracking, and delivered dose reconstruction.

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE(S): To describe a log file-based patient-specific quality assurance (QA) method and develop an in-house tool for system performance tracking and dose reconstruction in pencil-beam scanning proton therapy that can be used for pre-treatment plan review. MATERIALS/METHODS: The software extracts beam-specific information from the treatment delivery log file and automatically compares the monitor units (MU), lateral position, and size of each spot against the intended values in the treatment plan to identify any discrepancies in the beam delivery. The software has been used to analyze 992 patients, 2004 plans, 4865 fields, and more than 32 million proton spots from 2016 to 2021. The composite doses of 10 craniospinal irradiation (CSI) plans were reconstructed based on the delivered spots and compared with the original plans as an offline plan review method. RESULTS: Over the course of 6 years, the proton delivery system has proved stable in delivering patient QA fields with proton energies of 69.4-221.3 MeV and an MU range of 0.003-1.473 MU per spot. The planned mean and standard deviation (SD) of the energy and spot MU were 114.4 ± 26.4 MeV and 0.010 ± 0.009 MU, respectively. The mean and SD of the differences in MU and position between the delivered and planned spots were 9.56 × 10-8 ± 2.0 × 10-4 MU and 0.029/-0.007 ± 0.049/0.044 mm on the X/Y-axis for random differences and 0.005/0.125 ± 0.189/0.175 mm on the X/Y-axis for systematic differences. The mean and SD of the difference between the commissioning and delivered spot sizes were 0.086/0.089 ± 0.131/0.166 mm on the X/Y-axis. CONCLUSION: A tool has been developed to extract crucial information about the performance of the proton delivery and monitor system and provide a dose reconstruction based on delivered spots for quality improvement. Each patient's plan was verified before treatment to ensure accurate and safe delivery within the delivery tolerance of the machine.

Treatment-planning approaches to intensity modulated proton therapy and the impact on dose-weighted linear energy transfer.

PURPOSE: We quantified the effect of various forward-based treatment-planning strategies in proton therapy on dose-weighted linear energy transfer (LETd). By maintaining the dosimetric quality at a clinically acceptable level, we aimed to evaluate the differences in LETd among various treatment-planning approaches and their practicality in minimizing biologic uncertainties associated with LETd. METHOD: Eight treatment-planning strategies that are achievable in commercial treatment-planning systems were applied on a cylindrical water phantom and four pediatric brain tumor cases. Each planning strategy was compared to either an opposed lateral plan (phantom study) or original clinical plan (patient study). Deviations in mean and maximum LETd from clinically acceptable dose distributions were compared. RESULTS: In the phantom study, using a range shifter and altering the robust scenarios during optimization had the largest effect on the mean clinical target volume LETd, which was reduced from 4.5 to 3.9 keV/µm in both cases. Variations in the intersection angle between beams had the largest effect on LETd in a ring defined 3 to 5 mm outside the target. When beam intersection angles were reduced from opposed laterals (180°) to 120°, 90°, and 60°, corresponding maximum LETd increased from 7.9 to 8.9, 10.9, and 12.2 keV/µm, respectively. A clear trend in mean and maximum LETd variations in the clinical cases could not be established, though spatial distribution of LETd suggested a strong dependence on patient anatomy and treatment geometry. CONCLUSION: Changes in LETd from treatment-plan setup follow intuitive trends in a controlled phantom experiment. Anatomical and other patient-specific considerations, however, can preclude generalizable strategies in clinical cases. For pediatric cranial radiation therapy, we recommend using opposed lateral treatment fields to treat midline targets.

A predictive model of the effect of therapeutic radiation on the human ovary.

Radiation to the female pelvis as part of treatment for cancer predisposes young women to develop Premature Ovarian Insufficiency (POI). As the human female is born with their full complement of non-growing follicles which decline in an exponential fashion until the menopause, the age at which POI occurs is dependent on the age of the patient at treatment and the dose received by the ovary. A model that predicts the age at which POI occurs for a known dose at a known age will aid counselling patients on their fertility risk. Patients deemed to be at high risk of POI may be considered to be good candidates for established fertility preservation techniques. An updated and externally validated model of the age-related decline in human ovarian reserve was combined with the best available estimate of the median lethal dose LD50 for the human ovary. Using known age at diagnosis and posited radiotherapy treatment plan to estimate the dose to the least-affected ovary, we use an age-related model of the decline in ovarian reserve to generate a personalized age prediction of premature ovarian insufficiency. Our algorithm is available as an online calculator which graphs model outputs to inform discussions around survivor fertility. We report four example cases across different ages and diagnoses, each with two carefully designed photon and proton treatment plans. The treatment options are compared in terms of remaining fertile lifespan for the survivor. International oncology guidelines now mandate the consideration of later fertility when reviewing treatment options for children diagnosed with cancer. Our calculator (https://sites.cs.st-andrews.ac.uk/radiosensitivity), and the underlying algorithm and models, allow detailed predictions of the impact of various radiotherapy plans on fertility. These patient-specific data enhance pre-treatment discussions around post-treatment fertility and fertility preservation.