Evaluating effects of different control strategies for Infectious Salmon Anaemia (ISA) in marine salmonid farming by scenario simulation using a disease transmission model.

Infectious salmon anaemia (ISA) is an important viral disease causing economic losses and reduced welfare in farmed Atlantic salmon. Here, we present a spatio-temporal stochastic model for the spread of ISA between and within marine aquaculture farms. The model is estimated on historical production data for all marine salmonid farms in Norway from 2004 to February 2019. In this time 142 outbreaks of ISA occurred. We find that transmission from infected neighbouring farms accounts for around 50% of the infections, whereas transmission from "non-specified sources" accounts for around 40%. We hypothesise that the most important of the latter are viruses mutating from the non-virulent ISAV HPR0 to the virulent ISAV HPRdel. The model is used for scenario simulation, or what-if analysis, to investigate the effects of potential strategies to combat ISA, including screening, vaccination and culling. Changing from the current strategy of culling farms with detected ISA-outbreaks to mandatory screening and culling when virus is detected will reduce the fraction of cohorts with a clinical ISA outbreak from 3.8 to 0.36%. Introducing mandatory vaccination would have approximately the same effect as the current stamping-out strategy. The scenario simulation is a useful tool for deciding on appropriate mitigation measures.

The epidemiological and economic effects from systematic depopulation of Norwegian marine salmon farms infected with pancreas disease virus.

Pancreas disease (PD) is a viral disease associated with significant economic losses in Scottish, Irish, and Norwegian marine salmon aquaculture. In this paper, we investigate how disease-triggered harvest strategies (systematic depopulation of infected marine salmon farms) towards PD can affect disease dynamics and salmon producer profits in an endemic area in the southwestern part of Norway. Four different types of disease-triggered harvest strategies were evaluated over a four-year period (2011-2014), each scenario with different disease-screening procedures, timing for initiating the harvest interventions on infected cohorts, and levels of farmer compliance to the strategy. Our approach applies a spatio-temporal stochastic model for simulating the spread of PD in the separate scenarios. Results from these simulations were then used in cost-benefit analyses to estimate the net benefits of different harvest strategies over time. We find that the most aggressive strategy, in which infected farms are harvested without delay, was most efficient in terms of reducing infection pressure in the area and providing economic benefits for the studied group of salmon producers. On the other hand, lower farm compliance leads to higher infection pressure and less economic benefits. Model results further highlight trade-offs in strategies between those that primarily benefit individual producers and those that have collective benefits, suggesting a need for institutional mechanisms that address these potential tensions.

Space-time modelling of the spread of pancreas disease (PD) within and between Norwegian marine salmonid farms.

Infectious diseases are a constant threat to industrialised farming, which is characterised by high densities of farms and farm animals. Several mathematical and statistical models on spatio-temporal dynamics of infectious diseases in various farmed host populations have been developed during the last decades. Here we present a spatio-temporal stochastic model for the spread of a disease between and within aquaculture farms. The spread between farms is divided into several transmission pathways, including (i) distance related spread and (ii) other types of contagious contacts. The within-farm infection dynamics is modelled by a susceptible-infected-recovered (SIR) model. We apply this framework to model the spread of pancreas disease (PD) in salmon farming, using data covering all farms producing salmonids over 9 years in Norway. The motivation for the study was partly to unravel the spatio-temporal dynamics of PD in salmon farming and partly to use the model for scenario simulation of PD control strategies. We find, for example, that within-farm infection dynamics vary with season and we provide estimates of the timing from unobserved infection events to disease outbreaks on farms are detected. The simulations suggest that if a strategy involving culling of infectious cohorts is implemented, the number of detected disease outbreaks per year may be reduced by 57% after the full effect has been reached. We argue that the high detail and coverage of data on salmonid production and disease occurrence should encourage the use of simulation modelling as a means of testing effects of extensive control measures before they are implemented in the salmon farming industry.