Infection prevention and control factors associated with post-cataract surgery endophthalmitis - a review of the literature from 2010 - 2023.

Patients undergoing cataract surgery are at risk of post-cataract surgery endophthalmitis (PCSE), a sight-threatening complication. Cataract surgery is a relatively straightforward and quick procedure often performed under local anaesthetic. It is therefore simple to scale up to reduce the currently long waiting times, but it is important to maintain patient safety when considering high throughput surgery. This literature review aimed to identify appropriate infection prevention and control (IPC) measures to support increased throughput of cataract surgery in Scotland. Database searches were conducted using Medline and Embase from 2010 to 2023. Further hand-searching was also performed. The organisms associated with PCSE and IPC factors relevant to PCSE were analyzed. A range of microorganisms was associated with PCSE, where outbreak reports were most associated with Gram-negative bacteria and fungi, whereas retrospective chart reviews were most associated with Gram-positive bacteria. IPC risk factors identified were related to the built environment and issues with sterilization. Specifically, the sources of outbreaks included failures in the ventilation system, as well as contaminated ophthalmic solutions, surgical instruments, and medications. The factors identified in this review should be considered when implementing high throughput cataract surgery to ensure that patient safety is maintained.

Implementation and barriers to waterless care: a questionnaire study of infection prevention and control practitioners, clinicians, and engineers.

BACKGROUND: Water and wastewater in healthcare settings are recognized to represent a risk to patients. However, waterless care has not been widely implemented in UK healthcare settings. AIM: To identify barriers to implementation of waterless care. METHODS: A questionnaire study of infection prevention and control (IPC) practitioners, non-IPC clinicians, and estates managers and engineers was undertaken. FINDINGS: Alternatives to water present challenges in perceived acceptability to patients, particularly cleansing wipes for bathing and dry shampoo. There are concerns about cleansing wipes in terms of storage, disposal, sustainability and contamination during manufacture. Estates and engineering concerns include relative water tank size for water turnover and clinical disruption due to works. CONCLUSION: Further work is required on acceptability of reduced water scenarios and patient views but the results of this questionnaire provide a grounding for sentiment from healthcare workers on waterless care.

Water-free patient care: a narrative review of the literature and discussion of the pressing need for a way forward.

BACKGROUND: Florence Nightingale was the first person to recognize the link between the built environment and patient ill-health. More than 160 years later, the threat of the end of the antibiotic era looms large. The antimicrobial resistance action plan focuses on antimicrobial stewardship and developing new therapeutic agents. The risk from the built environment has been ignored, with wastewater systems identified as major sources of antimicrobial resistance within healthcare facilities. England is undertaking the largest healthcare construction programme globally. These facilities will be operating when antimicrobial resistance is predicted to be at its fiercest. Water-free patient care is a strategy for limiting dispersal of antimicrobial resistance, and preventing patient infections that need further evaluation in new hospitals. METHODS: A narrative review was undertaken using the terms: waterless/water-free units; waterless/water-free care; sink reduction; sink removal; and washing without water. PubMed, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, and Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effects were searched from January 2000 to February 2024 for reviews and original articles. Unit type, geographical location, reasons for a waterless/water-free approach, and outcomes were recorded. FINDINGS: Seven papers were identified. Four involved adult intensive care units (ICUs), one involved a care of the elderly setting, and two involved neonatal ICUs. In five papers, the aim of intervention was to reduce Gram-negative infections/colonizations. One paper was a systematic review of 'washing without water' which reviewed cost-effectiveness and patient experience. All of the five papers focusing on Gram-negative bacilli reported a reduction in infections or colonizations post intervention. CONCLUSION: More studies are highlighting the risks from water and wastewater to patient safety, and the value of water-free strategies in reducing infection rates.

A narrative review and update on drain-related outbreaks.

BACKGROUND: Outbreaks linked to hospital drainage systems are well reported, and continue to present challenges to incident management teams. Such outbreaks can be protracted and complex, with multi-modal strategies being required for remediation. AIM: To summarize recent drain-related outbreaks, investigate whether multi-modal control measures are being implemented, and determine any antecedent factors. METHODS: Databases were searched for drain-related outbreaks over a 5-year period. Search terms employed included 'healthcare drainage outbreaks', 'drain outbreaks', 'drainage system outbreaks', 'sink outbreaks' and 'shower outbreaks'. Information was collected on country of origin, pathogens involved, unit affected, drain types, patient numbers, drainage system interventions, type of drain disinfectant, infection control interventions, typing method, outcomes and any antecedent factors. FINDINGS: Nineteen drain-related outbreak studies were reviewed. The majority of incidents were due to carbapenemase-producing Enterobacterales, and were from critical care settings. Most (16/19) studies recognized the need for a multi-modal approach. Information on the success of interventions was not documented for all incidents, but 13/19 studies reported no further cases after control measures. Variation in the choice of agent and frequency of application exists with regards to drain disinfection. Seven studies discussed antecedent factors. CONCLUSION: Despite drain-related outbreaks being reported for the last 24 years and review articles on the subject, outbreaks continue to pose significant challenges. There is currently no UK guidance on the management of drain-related outbreaks or the design of new buildings to mitigate the risk. Addressing the challenges from hospital drainage systems should be considered a priority by agencies and guidance developers.

Development and evaluation of test methods for the detection and enumeration of opportunistic waterborne pathogens from the hospital environment.

BACKGROUND: Many Gram-negative bacteria other than Pseudomonas aeruginosa have been implicated in waterborne outbreaks, but standardized laboratory detection methods for these organisms have not been established. AIM: This study aimed to establish laboratory testing methodologies for six waterborne pathogens: Acinetobacter spp., Burkholderia spp., Cupriavidus spp., Delftia acidovorans, Elizabethkingia spp. and Stenotrophomonas maltophilia. METHODS: Water samples were spiked by UK Health Security Agency laboratories and sent to the Glasgow Royal Infirmary laboratory for analysis. Water samples were spiked with either a pure culture of target organism or the target organism in water containing normal background flora, to ensure that the methodology could identify organisms from a mixed culture. Volumes of 100 mL were filtered under negative pressure on to culture media and incubated at 30 °C and 37 °C. The incubation time was 7 days, with plates read on days 2, 5 and 7. Further identification of colonies was undertaken using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS). FINDINGS: Optimal recovery of organisms was obtained by culturing water samples on tryptic soy agar, chocolate bacitracin agar and pseudomonas selective agar. The optimal temperature for isolation was 30 °C. The optimal incubation time was 5 days, and MALDI-TOF MS identified all test species reliably. CONCLUSION: The methodology described was able to detect the six tested waterborne pathogens reliably, and can be utilized by laboratories involved in testing water samples during outbreak investigations.

Advancing outbreak simulation training: a collaborative pilot study for dual-specialty medical trainees and infection prevention and control professionals.

BACKGROUND: In response to identified gaps in infection prevention and control (IPC) training within Scotland, a Short Life Working Group initiated an innovative outbreak simulation training programme. AIM: To enhance the knowledge and confidence of medical microbiology and infectious diseases trainees and IPC professionals in managing healthcare-associated infection (HAI) outbreaks, employing the National Infection Prevention and Control Manual guidelines. METHODS: Participants completed prerequisite online training in epidemiology and surveillance before engaging in a meticulously crafted vancomycin-resistant enterococci outbreak simulation, which mirrored a real-life incident and adhered to the standards set by the Association for Simulated Practice in Healthcare. The programme incorporated Kolb's experiential learning cycle, fostering an authentic and engaging learning environment. A total of 41 individuals participated in the synchronous online training phase, with eight individuals involved in the pilot outbreak simulation. Evaluation of the training's efficacy followed Kirkpatrick's model, combining quantitative (five-point Likert scales) and qualitative (open-ended questions and participant reflections) data collection methods. FINDINGS: Results demonstrated significant improvements in participants' knowledge, skills, and confidence in outbreak management. Feedback highlighted the realism and educational value of the simulation, with 100% agreement on its efficacy in enhancing outbreak management capabilities. CONCLUSION: The success of this pilot study underscores the potential of simulation training in IPC and paves the way for broader implementation. It emphasizes the effectiveness of structured, experiential learning in equipping healthcare professionals with practical skills and confidence for managing complex HAI outbreaks, contributing to a more competent and prepared workforce.

Development of an infection prevention and control pathway to facilitate high-throughput cataract surgery in Scotland.

INTRODUCTION: Cataract surgery offers significant improvement to quality of life for patients with cataracts. However, there are growing waiting lists and challenges in providing this type of surgery in a timely manner. Feedback from stakeholders had previously indicated infection prevention and control (IPC) as a potential barrier to high-throughput surgery. Antimicrobial Resistance and Healthcare Associated Infection Scotland was asked to support the implementation of high-throughput cataract surgery aimed at addressing these challenges. AIM: To develop an IPC pathway to facilitate high-throughput surgery. This would be based on best practice, and would address any barriers identified by stakeholders. METHODS: A short life working group with input from key stakeholders, including clinical teams, was established. A rapid literature review was also undertaken. RESULTS: An agreed patient pathway was developed, with the aim of helping to facilitate high-throughput surgery. Pre-, intra- and postoperative phases were considered. Where literature was unavailable, expert/consensus opinion was utilized. Facilities for high-throughput surgery were also considered, including the Jack and Jill theatre arrangement which lends itself well to this concept. CONCLUSION: Through collaboration with stakeholders, an IPC pathway was developed to facilitate high-throughput cataract surgery and address any potential IPC barriers to implementation. The process and the output described could be utilized to develop similar pathways for other surgeries that lend themselves well to high throughput, improving quality of life for patients and reducing waiting times. This study highlights the importance of establishing surveillance for postoperative endophthalmitis following implementation.

Waterborne infections in haemato-oncology units - a narrative review.

Bone marrow transplant and haemato-oncology patients are at risk of healthcare-associated infections due to waterborne pathogens. We undertook a narrative review of waterborne outbreaks in haemato-oncology patients from 2000 to 2022. Databases searched included PubMed, DARE and CDSR, and were undertaken by two authors. We analysed the organisms implicated, sources identified and infection prevention and control strategies implemented. The most commonly implicated pathogens were Pseudomonas aeruginosa, non-tuberculous mycobacteria and Legionella pneumophila. Bloodstream infection was the most common clinical presentation. The majority of incidents employed multi-modal strategies to achieve control, addressing both the water source and routes of transmission. This review highlights the risk to haemato-oncology patients from waterborne pathogens and discusses future preventative strategies and the requirement for new UK guidance for haemato-oncology units.

Safe design and maintenance of bone marrow transplant units: a narrative review.

BACKGROUND: Patients undergoing bone marrow transplantation or chemotherapy for cancer are profoundly immunosuppressed. They are at risk for both endogenous and exogenous infections and require enhanced protection from infection while in hospital. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this narrative review was to determine the optimal design features of bone marrow transplant (BMT) units for reducing infection risk in these vulnerable patients. SOURCES: A literature search was performed on PubMed and other databases for documents published between January 2000 and October 2021. Keywords were: bone marrow transplant unit OR hematopoietic stem cell transplant unit OR haematology unit OR haemato-oncology unit AND design OR design guidelines OR design criteria OR ventilation specification OR HEPA filtration OR water outbreaks OR water system design. CONTENT: Guidelines and other papers pertaining to BMT unit design are discussed. Key design features identified from the literature to reduce infection risks include high efficiency particulate air filtration, positive-pressure ventilation, sufficient air changes and sealed rooms. The evidence for each of these parameters and other findings are discussed. We found no guidelines specific to water quality and control in BMT units. IMPLICATIONS: Guidelines on the various components of design were found, but no comprehensive guidance documents addressing all relevant aspects, such as ventilation, water, and other design features, were found. Literary publications and policy documents were combined and summarised to highlight key design features aimed at reducing infection risk in this vulnerable patient group. We propose the development of international guidance for the design of BMT units encompassing all components.

Cupriavidus spp. and other waterborne organisms in healthcare water systems across the UK.

BACKGROUND: Cupriavidus pauculus is a rare clinical pathogen, cases of which have been linked to contaminated hospital water systems. An outbreak of three cases of C. pauculus and other waterborne organisms was reported in a Glasgow hospital in 2018. AIMS: To determine whether Cupriavidus spp. are present in hospital water systems elsewhere in Scotland and the UK, and to ascertain the optimal laboratory methodology for detection. This study also sought to establish where in the water system these organisms are detected, and whether a selective media could be developed for isolation. In addition, water samples were tested for the presence of other Gram-negative waterborne organisms. METHODS: Water samples were received from 10 UK National Health Service hospitals and from various parts of the water system. Isolates were plated on to tryptone soya agar (TSA) and Pseudomonas isolation agar, and were further identified using matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-time of flight mass spectrometry and 16S polymerase chain reaction. FINDINGS: Cupriavidus spp. were detected in four of 10 hospitals tested, and all five isolates were from the periphery of the water system. All hospitals had evidence of other opportunistic premise plumbing pathogens. Cupriavidus spp. were identified using TSA, with some isolates growing on Pseudomonas isolation agar; as such, they may be detected inadvertently when testing water specifically for Pseudomonas aeruginosa. CONCLUSION: Isolation of Cupriavidus spp. was not unique to the Glasgow incident, and these bacteria are present in hospital water systems elsewhere in the UK. Water testing in response to clinical cases is recommended. Consideration should also be given to water testing following bacteraemias due to other rare and unusual water-borne pathogens.

Investigation of two cases of Mycobacterium chelonae infection in haemato-oncology patients using whole-genome sequencing and a potential link to the hospital water supply.

BACKGROUND: Haemato-oncology patients are at increased risk of infection from atypical mycobacteria such as Mycobacterium chelonae which are commonly found in both domestic and hospital water systems. AIMS: To describe the investigation and control measures following two patient cases of M. chelonae and positive water samples in the study hospital. METHODS: Water testing was undertaken from outlets, storage tanks and mains supply. Whole-genome sequencing (WGS) was used to compare patient and positive water samples. The subsequent infection control measures implemented are described. FINDINGS: The WGS results showed two main populations of M. chelonae within the group of sampled isolates. The results showed that the patient strains were unrelated to each other, but that the isolate from one patient was closely related to environmental samples from water outlets, supporting nosocomial acquisition. CONCLUSIONS: WGS was used to investigate two patient cases of M. chelonae and positive water samples from a hospital water supply. Relevant control measures and the potential for chemical dosing of water systems to enhance proliferation of atypical mycobacteria are discussed.

Investigation and control of an outbreak due to a contaminated hospital water system, identified following a rare case of Cupriavidus pauculus bacteraemia.

BACKGROUND: Cupriavidus pauculus is rare cause of clinical infection. We describe an outbreak of C. pauculus and other Gram-negative bacteraemias in a paediatric haemato-oncology unit secondary to a contaminated water supply and drainage system. AIM: To describe the investigation and control measures implemented for a waterborne infection outbreak in a new build hospital. METHODS: Extensive water testing from various points within the water system was undertaken. Taps, showerheads and components including flow straighteners underwent microbiological analysis. Drains were also swabbed. Surveillance for Gram-negative infections was established on the unit. FINDINGS: Water testing revealed widespread contamination of the water and drainage system. Outlets were also heavily contaminated, including flow straighteners. Drains were found to have underlying structural abnormalities. Water testing enabled us to detect high-risk components within the water system such as the expansion vessels and outlets and the results assisted with hypotheses generation. Review of commissioning data and risk assessments revealed extensive risks present within the water system prior to and after hospital opening. CONCLUSION: Careful design, adequate control measures and maintenance are essential for hospital water systems in order to prevent infections due to waterborne organisms. We discuss what can be learned from this incident with a view to future prevention.

Water springing to life the fungal desert.

Immunosuppressed patients are at increased risk of developing hospital-acquired fungal infections. The risk of fungal infection from construction is well established, but water ingress also presents a risk if it is not dealt with promptly. This article describes four such scenarios and the learning points from each. Water ingress may go under-reported and, as such, may be an underestimated source of fungal healthcare-associated infections.

Drains and the periphery of the water system - what do you do when the guidance is outdated?

The periphery of the water system (defined as the last 2 m of pipework from an outlet and ensuing devices including drainage), is the juncture of multiple inherent risks: the necessity to use materials with higher risk of biofilm formation, difficulty in maintaining safe water temperatures, a human interface with drainage systems, poor design, poor layout and use by staff. Add to this risk a large new healthcare facility capital build programme in England, outdated guidance and bacteria emanating from drainage systems containing highly mobile genetic elements (threatening the end of the antibiotic era), and the scene is set for the perfect storm. There is an urgent need for the re-evaluation of the periphery of the water system and drainage systems. Consequently, in this article we examine the requirement and placement of hand wash stations (HWSs), design of showers, kitchens and the dirty utility with respect to water services. Lastly, we discuss the provision of safe water to high-risk patient groups. The purpose of this article is to stimulate debate and provide infection control and design teams with support in deviating from the outdated existing guidance and to challenge conventional thinking until new advice is forthcoming.

Potential infection control risks associated with chilled beam technology: experience from a UK hospital.

Energy efficiency technologies are now a feature in hospital design, with active chilled beams an example of one in use worldwide. Such innovations have clear benefits but there is a paucity of information with respect to any infection control risks. We describe our experience of chilled beam technology from one of our hospitals where we faced challenges with cleaning and episodes of water ingress including condensation. We highlight the importance of infection control risk assessment in relation to new technologies and the implementation of appropriate risk mitigation.