MR and conventional angiography: work in progress toward assessing utility in radiology.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: The authors assessed health-related quality of life changes associated with peripheral x-ray angiography and magnetic resonance (MR) angiography. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Utility (the desirability or preference that individuals exhibit for a particular health state) was assessed in 30 patients with peripheral vascular disease referred for angiography by using a rating scale, additional categoric scaling questions to separate preference from experience, a willingness-to-pay technique, functional and cognitive status questions, and a time trade-off technique. All patients underwent both MR angiography and x-ray angiography. RESULTS: Patients reported significantly (P < .05) less anxiety after the test, less pain after the test, fewer new physical limitations, and less effect on performance of daily activities with MR angiography. Findings from the overall rating scale and categoric scaling questions also significantly (P < .05) favored MR angiography. Patients were willing to pay a mean of 2.12% of annual income to avoid MR angiography and a mean of 7.41% to avoid x-ray angiography. The median quality-adjusted life gain required by patients to undergo the procedures was 52.5-60 days for x-ray angiography and 10.5 days for MR angiography, without discounting. CONCLUSION: X-ray angiography has more profound short-term adverse effects on life than does MR angiography. Preference-based measures can be adapted to elicit patient values for short-term health states as seen in radiology.

Effective early treatment of hepatic venoocclusive disease with a central splenorenal shunt in an infant.

Venoocclusive disease of the liver (VOD) is a well-described complication following chemotherapy. It is manifested by jaundice and signs of portal hypertension and carries a mortality rate approaching 50%. There is no known treatment for the disease itself, although several recent reports suggest portacaval diversion may be effective in treating its sequelae. A 6.75-kg 8-month-old boy with VOD following bone marrow ablation and bone marrow transplantation (BMT) for juvenile chronic myelogenous leukemia (JCML) is presented. Over a 6-week period following bone marrow ablation he developed ascites refractory to diuretics, jaundice, and hematemasis with normal hepatocellular function. Splenectomy with a central splenorenal shunt was performed, which resulted in a significant reduction in portal pressures and complete resolution of his ascites and hematemasis without resultant encephalopathy. We propose that central end-to-side splenorenal shunting is an acceptable treatment for portal hypertension due to VOD and can be successfully performed in infants.

Immunologic alterations following excisional wounding and immediate repair with syngeneic or allogeneic skin grafts.

Immunosuppression and its associated infectious complications have long been recognized as consequences of major thermal trauma, though the factors that mediate this suppression remain unclear. A murine split-thickness skin graft model was developed to investigate the role of a large surface area wound in the initiation of immunosuppression in the absence of burn injury. Significant T cell-mediated immunosuppression was demonstrated following wounding and immediate repair with either syngeneic or allogeneic split-thickness skin grafts. These results are consistent with previous experiments in a murine burn model treated by escharectomy and resurfacing with syngeneic composite full-thickness skin. Data also supports the concept that mediators of inflammation at the wound site play an important role in postburn immunosuppression. Furthermore, these results suggest that the use of skin allografts during the early postburn period does not adversely affect cell-mediated immunity in any way that could be abrogated by primary autografting.

Immunosuppression following excision of burn eschar and syngeneic grafting in major thermal trauma.

Recent reports have suggested that very early excision (less than 24 hours post-burn) and primary closure of burn wounds might circumvent the immunosuppression which follows severe thermal trauma. The total body surface are (TBSA) involved in burn injuries of human subjects at risk for significant post-burn immunosuppression is large enough to require grafting. In the present study cell-mediated immunity was measured via one-way allogeneic mixed lymphocyte reactions (MLR) in mice subjected to full-thickness scald wounds over 25-30 percent TBSA followed by escharectomy and syngeneic full-thickness skin grafting. A significant decrease in the proliferative capability of T-cells could be demonstrated on days five and seven post-treatment in unburned grafted animals (day five, 30.7 percent; day seven, 24.8 percent) over untreated normals. T-cells from animals burned but not excised also showed significant hyporesponsiveness (day five, 33.2 percent; day seven, 26.1 percent normal MLR). Animals undergoing both burning and excision showed even more profound immunosuppression (day five, 18.3 percent to 23.7 percent; day seven, 7.4 percent to 11.6 percent normal MLR). Surgical incision without excising the skin did not suppress cell-mediated immunity (day five, 90.8 percent; day seven, 90.4 percent normal MLR). When T-cells from treated animals of each group (with the exception of the incision control group) were added to normal MLR cultures, significant (greater than 50 percent) cell-mediated suppression by suppressor T-cells could be demonstrated. This study showed that the trauma of excision and grafting alone results in depression of cell-mediated immunity. These data call into question the ability of very early excision and grafting to alter the immunosuppression which follows severe thermal trauma.