Transforming Health Care from Volume to Value: Moving the Needle Through Population Health.

United States health systems face unique challenges in transitioning from volume-based to value-based care, particularly for academic institutions. Providing complex specialty and tertiary care dependent on servicing large geographic areas, and concomitantly meeting education and research academic missions may limit the time and resources available for focusing on the care coordination needs of complex local populations. Despite these challenges, academic medicine is well situated to capitalize on the promise of value-based care and to lead broad improvements in both teaching and nonteaching hospitals. If properly executed, value-based care and complex specialty care can be complementary and synergistic. We postulate that the transition from volume to value in population health requires all health care organizations to advance and formalize infrastructure in 3 core areas: organizational capabilities; provider engagement; and engagement of the patient, family, and community. Although these apply to all organizations, for academic health systems, this transition must also be interwoven with the other domains of the tripartite mission.

Impactability Modeling for Reducing Medicare Accountable Care Organization Payments and Hospital Events in High-Need High-Cost Patients: Longitudinal Cohort Study.

BACKGROUND: Impactability modeling promises to help solve the nationwide crisis in caring for high-need high-cost patients by matching specific case management programs with patients using a "benefit" or "impactability" score, but there are limitations in tailoring each model to a specific program and population. OBJECTIVE: We evaluated the impact on Medicare accountable care organization savings from developing a benefit score for patients enrolled in a historic case management program, prospectively implementing the score, and evaluating the results in a new case management program. METHODS: We conducted a longitudinal cohort study of 76,140 patients in a Medicare accountable care organization with multiple before-and-after measures of the outcome, using linked electronic health records and Medicare claims data from 2012 to 2019. There were 489 patients in the historic case management program, with 1550 matched comparison patients, and 830 patients in the new program, with 2368 matched comparison patients. The historic program targeted high-risk patients and assigned a centrally located registered nurse and social worker to each patient. The new program targeted high- and moderate-risk patients and assigned a nurse physically located in a primary care clinic. Our primary outcomes were any unplanned hospital events (admissions, observation stays, and emergency department visits), count of event-days, and Medicare payments. RESULTS: In the historic program, as expected, high-benefit patients enrolled in case management had fewer events, fewer event-days, and an average US $1.15 million reduction in Medicare payments per 100 patients over the subsequent year when compared with the findings in matched comparison patients. For the new program, high-benefit high-risk patients enrolled in case management had fewer events, while high-benefit moderate-risk patients enrolled in case management did not differ from matched comparison patients. CONCLUSIONS: Although there was evidence that a benefit score could be extended to a new case management program for similar (ie, high-risk) patients, there was no evidence that it could be extended to a moderate-risk population. Extending a score to a new program and population should include evaluation of program outcomes within key subgroups. With increased attention on value-based care, policy makers and measure developers should consider ways to incorporate impactability modeling into program design and evaluation.

Risk from delayed or missed care and non-COVID-19 outcomes for older patients with chronic conditions during the pandemic.

BACKGROUND: During the COVID-19 pandemic, patients with chronic illnesses avoided regular medical care, raising concerns about long-term complications. Our objective was to identify a population of older patients with chronic conditions who may be at risk from delayed or missed care (DMC) and follow their non-COVID outcomes during the pandemic. METHODS: We used a retrospective matched cohort design using Medicare claims and electronic health records at a large health system with community and academic clinics. Participants included 14,406 patients over 65 years old with two or more chronic conditions who had 1 year of baseline data and up to 9 months of postpandemic follow-up from March 1, 2019 to December 31, 2020; and 14,406 matched comparison patients from 1 year prior. Risk from DMC was defined by 13 indicators, including chronic conditions, frailty, disability affecting the use of telehealth, recent unplanned acute care, prior missed outpatient care, and social determinants of health. Outcomes included mortality, inpatient events, Medicare payments, and primary care and specialty care visits (in-person and telehealth). RESULTS: A total of 25% of patients had four or more indicators for risk from DMC. Per 1000 patients annually, those with four or more indicators had increased mortality of 19 patients (95% confidence interval, 4 to 32) and decreased utilization, including unplanned events (-496 events, -611 to -381) and primary care visits (-1578 visits, -1793 to -1401). CONCLUSIONS: Older patients who had four or more indicators for risk from DMC had higher mortality and steep declines in inpatient and outpatient utilization during the pandemic.

A practical model for research with learning health systems: Building and implementing effective complex case management.

For researchers to contribute meaningfully to the creation of learning health systems, practical tools are required to operationalize existing conceptual frameworks. We describe a model currently in use by the University of Wisconsin Health Innovation Program (HIP). The HIP model consolidates and enhances existing learning health system frameworks by defining specific steps needed to create sustainable change based on research conducted within the health system. As an example of the model's application, we describe its use to improve patient identification for the University of Wisconsin health system's case management program. Our case study shows the importance of culture, infrastructure, and strong leadership support in realizing a learning health systems research project and creating sustainable change within the health system. By articulating the foundational elements and steps to conduct research with learning health systems, our model supports researchers in achieving the challenge of moving learning health systems from concept to action.

Medicare Shared Savings Programs: Higher Cost Accountable Care Organizations are More Likely to Achieve Savings.

In the United States, Medicare's flagship Accountable Care Organization (ACO) program, the Medicare Shared Savings Program (MSSP), is under close scrutiny to improve health care quality and decrease costs. First year measures, released in November 2014, reveal a wide range of financial and quality performance across MSSP participants. In this observational study we used 2013 results for 220 participating ACOs to assess key characteristics associated with generating savings. ACOs with higher baseline expenditures were significantly more likely to generate savings than lower cost ACOs. Average quality scores for ACOs that successfully reported on quality were not different between organizations that did and did not generate savings. These findings suggest ACOs that had lower utilization prior to program enrollment are less likely to be rewarded in the current program. This has important policy implications for the MSSP's ability to attract and retain efficient ACOs and incent efforts to reduce waste and improve quality.

The importance of health insurance claims data in creating learning health systems: evaluating care for high-need high-cost patients using the National Patient-Centered Clinical Research Network (PCORNet).

OBJECTIVE: Case management programs for high-need high-cost patients are spreading rapidly among health systems. PCORNet has substantial potential to support learning health systems in rapidly evaluating these programs, but access to complete patient data on health care utilization is limited as PCORNet is based on electronic health records not health insurance claims data. Because matching cases to comparison patients on baseline utilization is often a critical component of high-quality observational comparative effectiveness research for high-need high-cost patients, limited access to claims may negatively affect the quality of the matching process. We sought to determine whether the evaluation of programs for high-need high-cost patients required claims data to match cases to comparison patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective cohort study design with multiple measures of before-and-after health care utilization for 1935 case management patients and 3833 matched comparison patients aged 18 years and older from 2011 to 2015. EHR and claims data were extracted from 3 health systems participating in PCORNet. RESULTS: Without matching on claims-based health care utilization, the case management programs at 2 of 3 health systems were associated with fewer hospital admissions and emergency visits over the subsequent 12 months. With matching on claims-based health care utilization, case management was no longer associated with admissions and emergency visits at those 2 programs. DISCUSSION: The results of a PCORNet-facilitated evaluation of 3 programs for high-need high-cost patients differed substantially depending on whether claims data were available for matching cases to comparison patients. CONCLUSIONS: Partnering with learning health systems to rapidly evaluate programs for high-need high-cost patients will require that PCORNet facilitates comprehensive and timely access to both electronic health records and health insurance claims data.

WITHDRAWN: Endothelium in the allograft.

The paper entitled "Endothelium in the allograft" by Bryan N Becker et al, which was published online on 9 September 2009, has been withdrawn at the authors' request. Kidney International advance online publication, 9 September 2009; doi:10.1038/ki.2009.333.

Calciphylaxis responsive to lanthanum carbonate (FOSRENOL) therapy.

Calciphylaxis is a rare and debilitating vasculopathy predominantly seen in patients with renal failure. The proposed mechanism of injury is active vascular calcification with associated elevated parathyroid hormone, hypercalcemia, or hyperphosphatemia. With improved pharmacologic agents including non-calcium containing phosphate binders, vitamin D analogues, calcimimetics, and bisphosphonates, targeted therapy on the mineralization process has been tried with varied success. We report a case of biopsy-proven calciphylaxis in a patient with acute kidney injury requiring dialysis that had persistently elevated calcium-phosphorus product refractory to treatment. The patient, however, responded rapidly to the initiation of lanthanum carbonate therapy and modified dialysis. This is the first known case reported in the literature utilizing this new non-calcium-based phosphate binder in the setting of calciphylaxis.

Knowledge of phosphorus compared with other nutrients in maintenance dialysis patients.

OBJECTIVE: This study's objective was to assess knowledge of phosphorus compared with other nutrients in patients undergoing maintenance dialysis (MD). DESIGN: We compared knowledge of phosphorus vs. other nutrients important to the MD diet (potassium, sodium, and protein) in patients undergoing hemodialysis (HD) and peritoneal dialysis (PD). We further measured gender, age, education level, and functional health literacy to assess correlations in patient nutrient knowledge. Nutrient knowledge was measured using a 25-item Chronic Kidney Disease Knowledge Assessment Tool for Nutrition (CKDKAT-N), and functional health literacy was measured using the short form of the Test of Functional Health Literacy in Adults (S-TOFHLA). SETTING AND PATIENTS: Patients received maintenance outpatient PD or HD at Wisconsin Dialysis, Inc. (Madison, WI). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The main outcome measure was knowledge of phosphorus vs. knowledge of potassium, sodium, and protein. RESULTS: Forty-seven MD patients participated in the study (29 undergoing HD, 18 undergoing PD, 30 males, 17 females, average age of 58.6 (SD, 13.8) years, and average grade level of 1.4 (SD, 2.6) years of post-secondary education). Thirty-five participants had adequate health literacy, 4 had marginal health literacy, and 8 had inadequate health literacy. The CKDKAT-N scores ranged from 6-21 for 25 items, with a mean score of 13 (SD, 2.91). Knowledge of phosphorus compared with knowledge of other nutrients was poor (0.38 vs. 0.72, P = .003). In a comparison of HD vs. PD patient knowledge, both phosphorus (0.37 vs. 0.42, P = .231) and other nutrients (0.69 vs. 0.80, P = .115) were the same. CONCLUSION: Despite regular dietary instruction, patients undergoing MD have a poor knowledge of dietary phosphorus content, compared with knowledge of other nutrients important in chronic kidney disease. Interestingly, there was no difference in nutrition knowledge when comparing PD and HD patients, despite differences in education level and health literacy between groups.

Local television news reporting of kidney disease.

BACKGROUND: Local television is the primary news source for the majority of Americans. This study aims to describe how local news reports on kidney disease. METHODS: Using our searchable database of health-related late local news segments from 2002, we identified stories with the key words kidney, hypertension, blood pressure, or diabetes. This database is a representative sample of the late local news on 122 stations in the 50 largest US media markets, comprising 60% of the population. The content of each identified story was reviewed to determine whether it mentioned: (1) chronic kidney disease (CKD), (2) screening for kidney disease, or (3) kidney disease as a potential complication (for blood pressure- or diabetes-related stories). RESULTS: Only 2 of 1,799 database news stories (0.11%) included "kidney" as a summary key word; neither referred to CKD, screening, or complications of other diseases. Of 19 stories about hypertension or blood pressure (1.06% of all stories) and the 14 stories about diabetes (0.78% of all stories), none mentioned these criteria. CONCLUSION: Despite efforts to increase public awareness of and screening for CKD, local television news (the most important news source for a majority of Americans) did little to help achieve these goals. Further work will be needed to confirm whether this paucity of coverage varies over time and determine why so little attention is given to CKD. Educating physicians and public relations personnel who advocate for kidney disease about journalists' needs may be an important step to help advance public awareness of CKD.

Conflicting dietary advice for adhering to low-sodium and low-phosphorus diets.

OBJECTIVE: To elucidate conflicts that patients face when advised to limit multiple nutrients in their diet. DESIGN: We analyzed the phosphorus content of low-sodium foods compared with their regular-sodium content counterparts, and the sodium content of low-phosphorus foods compared with foods containing higher levels of phosphorus. Low-sodium and low-phosphorus foods were identified with the use of recommendations from National Kidney Foundation patient information Web sites. Content of sodium and phosphorus was quantified with use of the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) Nutrient Database. SETTING: Review and analysis of publicly available patient information Web sites and nutrient databases. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Phosphorus content of low- versus regular-sodium-containing foods, and sodium content of low- versus high-phosphorus-containing foods. RESULTS: Of 47 low-sodium foods, 32 had identical phosphorus content--8 higher and 7 lower--compared with regular-sodium alternatives. Of 9 foods recommended as low-phosphorus alternatives to high-phosphorus choices, 4 had higher sodium content and 5 had lower, with considerable variability. However, choosing servings of 4 low-sodium alternatives could increase ingestion of phosphorus by up to 16% of recommended intake, and choosing servings of 4 low-phosphorus alternatives could increase ingestion of sodium by more than 20% of recommended intake. CONCLUSION: Adhering to a complex renal diet is extremely difficult for patients with chronic kidney disease. Balancing sodium and phosphorus restrictions is particularly challenging, especially as food choices low in one nutrient may not be low in the other. To help patients follow these diets, alternative methods of achieving dietary restrictions of multiple, often conflicting, components may be needed.

Karyomegalic tubulointerstitial nephritis--a case report.

Karyomegalic tubulointerstitial nephritis is a rare disease of uncertain etiology, which leads to progressive renal failure. Here, we report on a 39-year-old patient who presented with asymptomatic progressive decline of renal function. Two sequential renal biopsies demonstrated chronic tubulointerstitial nephritis with bizarre and dramatic enlargement of proximal tubule epithelial cell nuclei - the hallmark of karyomegalic nephritis. Clinical and pathologic findings of this case are discussed in light of the available literature. The morphologic changes in this disease are highly characteristic if the pathologist is aware of this entity.

Low serum magnesium is associated with decreased graft survival in patients with chronic cyclosporin nephrotoxicity.

BACKGROUND: Hypomagnesaemia is a common side effect of cyclosporin A (CsA) therapy. Animal studies suggest that magnesium (Mg) supplementation inhibits chronic CsA nephropathy. METHODS: To determine if low Mg levels correlate with true CsA-induced nephrotoxicity in humans, we examined kidney transplant biopsy records at our centre for all transplant biopsies performed between 1990 and 2002. We simultaneously reviewed the medical records to determine whether serum Mg levels were checked at the time of biopsy. Those individuals with histologically proven CsA nephrotoxicity were studied. RESULTS: Serum total Mg levels were available for 320 patients, 60 of whom were diagnosed with chronic CsA-mediated nephropathy. Patients were divided in two groups, a low Mg [n = 29, 1.8 (1.67-1.9) mg/dl or 0.74 (0.68-0.78) mmol/l] and a normal Mg group [n = 31, 2.2 (2.0-2.4) mg/dl or 0.9 (0.82-0.98) mmol/l, P<0.05] based on the median Mg level in the entire cohort (2 mg/dl or 0.82 mmol/l). Both groups were analysed for disease progression and graft loss using the slope of creatinine clearance (CCR) and multivariate analyses. Although the CCR at the time of biopsy was greater in the low Mg group [44.3 (36.3-64.3) ml/min vs 37.8 (25.2-47.3) ml/min, P<0.05), the decline in graft function was faster in this group (-8.9+/-3.5 vs 1+/-2.7 ml/min/year; P = 0.02) compared with the normal Mg cohort. Using Cox proportional hazards analyses, the adjusted graft survival was significantly reduced in the low Mg group 5 years after biopsy. CONCLUSIONS: Our study demonstrates that low serum Mg levels were associated with a faster rate of decline in kidney allograft function and increased rates of graft loss in renal transplant recipients with chronic CsA nephropathy. This suggests that hypomagnesaemia could potentiate CsA-mediated nephropathy.

Evaluation of eHealth web sites for patients with chronic kidney disease.

BACKGROUND: Chronic kidney disease (CKD) affects up to 19.2 million Americans, and untreated kidney disease can progress to kidney failure. Patient education is an important part of slowing disease progression, but the ability of health professionals to provide this education is limited by time constraints. To date, there have been no systematic evaluations of CKD eHealth Web sites. METHODS: Seven nonproprietary and 4 proprietary Web sites geared toward educating patients with CKD were identified by using the Internet to search for the terms "chronic kidney disease," "kidney disease," and "chronic renal failure." Web sites were evaluated according to (1) compliance with the principles of the Health on the Net (HON) Foundation Code of Conduct and (2) reading grade level. RESULTS: Nonproprietary sites were in compliance with an average of 5.2 principles, with a range of 3 to 8. Average compliance of proprietary Web sites with the HON Code of Conduct principles was 3.12, with a range of 2 to 4 (P = 0.021). Of nonproprietary Web sites, average reading grade level assessed by the Fry Readability Scale was greater than grade 14, with a range from grade 11 through graduate school. Of proprietary sites, average readability was grade 11, with a range from grades 7 through 16 (P = 0.575). CONCLUSION: The Internet has the potential to be a very powerful educational tool for patients with CKD. However, many easily accessed CKD public health Web sites do not comply with accepted standards for health Web sites and are written using language beyond the general public's reading comprehension.