The rapid identification of elution conditions for therapeutic antibodies from cation-exchange chromatography resins using high-throughput screening.

Cation-exchange chromatography is widely used in the purification of therapeutic antibodies, wherein parameters such as elution pH and counterion concentration require optimization for individual antibodies across different chromatography resins. With a growing number of antibodies in clinical trials and the pressure to expedite process development, we developed and automated a high-throughput batch-binding screen to more efficiently optimize elution conditions for cation-exchange chromatography resins. The screen maps the binding behavior of antibodies and impurities as a function of pH and counterion concentration in terms of a partition coefficient (Kp). Using this approach, the binding behavior of a library of antibodies was assessed on Poros 50HS and SP Sepharose Fast Flow resins. The diversity in binding behavior between antibodies and across resins translated to the requirement of a variable counterion concentration to elute each antibody. This requirement can be met through the use of a gradient elution. However, a gradient of increasing counterion concentration spans the transition from binding to non-binding for impurities as well as the antibody, resulting in the elution of impurities within the antibody elution peak. Step elution conditions that selectively elute the antibody while retaining impurities on the resin can now be rapidly identified using our high-throughput approach. We demonstrate that by correlating antibody Kp to elution pool volume and yield on packed-bed columns and through the calculation of a separation factor, we can efficiently optimize step elution conditions that maximize impurity clearance and yield for each antibody.

Exploration of overloaded cation exchange chromatography for monoclonal antibody purification.

Cation exchange chromatography using conventional resins, having either diffusive or perfusive flow paths, operated in bind-elute mode has been commonly employed in monoclonal antibody (MAb) purification processes. In this study, the performance of diffusive and perfusive cation exchange resins (SP-Sepharose FF (SPSFF) and Poros 50HS) and a convective cation exchange membrane (Mustang S) and monolith (SO(3) Monolith) were compared. All matrices were utilized in an isocratic state under typical binding conditions with an antibody load of up to 1000 g/L of chromatographic matrix. The dynamic binding capacity of the cation exchange resins is typically below 100 g/L resin, so they were loaded beyond the point of anticipated MAb break through. All of the matrices performed similarly in that they effectively retained host cell protein and DNA during the loading and wash steps, while antibody flowed through each matrix after its dynamic binding capacity was reached. The matrices differed, though, in that conventional diffusive and perfusive chromatographic resins (SPSFF and Poros 50HS) demonstrated a higher binding capacity for high molecular weight species (HMW) than convective flow matrices (membrane and monolith); Poros 50HS displayed the highest HMW binding capacity. Further exploration of the conventional chromatographic resins in an isocratic overloaded mode demonstrated that the impurity binding capacity was well maintained on Poros 50HS, but not on SPSFF, when the operating flow rate was as high as 36 column volumes per hour. Host cell protein and HMW removal by Poros 50HS was affected by altering the loading conductivity. A higher percentage of host cell protein removal was achieved at a low conductivity of 3 mS/cm. HMW binding capacity was optimized at 5 mS/cm. Our data from runs on Poros 50HS resin also showed that leached protein A and cell culture additive such as gentamicin were able to be removed under the isocratic overloaded condition. Lastly, a MAb purification process employing protein A affinity chromatography, isocratic overloaded cation exchange chromatography using Poros 50HS and anion exchange chromatography using QSFF in flow through mode was compared with the MAb's commercial manufacturing process, which consisted of protein A affinity chromatography, cation exchange chromatography using SPSFF in bind-elute mode and anion exchange chromatography using QSFF in flow through mode. Comparable step yield and impurity clearance were obtained by the two processes.

Effect of protein and solution properties on the Donnan effect during the ultrafiltration of proteins.

Formulation of protein biopharmaceuticals as highly concentrated liquids can improve the drug substance storage and supply chain, improve the target product profile, and allow greater flexibility in dosing methods. The Donnan effect can cause a large offset in pH from the target value established with the diafiltration buffer during the concentration and diafiltration of charged proteins with ultrafiltration membranes. For neutral formulations, the pH will typically increase above the diafiltration buffer pH for basic monoclonal antibodies and decline below the diafiltration buffer pH for acidic Fc-fusion proteins. In this study, new equations for the Donnan effect during the diafiltration and concentration of proteins in solutions containing monovalent and divalent ions were derived. The new Donnan models obey mass conservation laws, account for the buffering capacity of proteins, and account for protein-ion binding. Data for the pH offsets of an Fc-fusion protein and a monoclonal antibody were predicted in both monovalent and divalent buffers using these equations. To compensate for the pH offset caused by the Donnan effect, diafiltration buffers with pH and excipient values offset from the ultrafiltrate pool specifications can be used. The Donnan offset observed during the concentration of an acidic Fc-fusion protein was mitigated by operating at low temperature. It is important to account for the Donnan effect during preformulation studies. The excipients levels in an ultrafiltration pool may differ from the levels in a protein solution obtained by adding buffers into concentrated protein solutions due to the Donnan effect.

Weak partitioning chromatography for anion exchange purification of monoclonal antibodies.

Weak partitioning chromatography (WPC) is an isocratic chromatographic protein separation method performed under mobile phase conditions where a significant amount of the product protein binds to the resin, well in excess of typical flowthrough operations. The more stringent load and wash conditions lead to improved removal of more tightly binding impurities, although at the cost of a reduction in step yield. The step yield can be restored by extending the column load and incorporating a short wash at the end of the load stage. The use of WPC with anion exchange resins enables a two-column cGMP purification platform to be used for many different mAbs. The operating window for WPC can be easily established using high throughput batch-binding screens. Under conditions that favor very strong product binding, competitive effects from product binding can give rise to a reduction in column loading capacity. Robust performance of WPC anion exchange chromatography has been demonstrated in multiple cGMP mAb purification processes. Excellent clearance of host cell proteins, leached Protein A, DNA, high molecular weight species, and model virus has been achieved.

High-throughput screening of chromatographic separations: III. Monoclonal antibodies on ceramic hydroxyapatite.

High-throughput screening (HTS) of chromatography resins for identifying optimal protein purification conditions is becoming an integral part of industrial process development. In this work, ceramic hydroxyapatite (cHA) chromatography of 15 humanized monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) was examined by HTS. MAb binding, as quantified by partition coefficient (K(p)), was measured under 92 combinations of sodium chloride, phosphate, and pH. Binding varied inversely with these variables for all mAbs tested. However, the magnitudes of binding among mAbs under identical conditions varied significantly, showing a >1.5 log range in K(p). Analysis of variance (ANOVA) techniques were used to describe the binding of each mAb as a function of the three screen variables. Linear models relating log K(p) to the pH, log[sodium chloride], and log[phosphate] fit the data for each antibody with 93-96% accuracy. From these models, characteristic charge values for the cation exchange and metal coordination components of the multi-modal mAb/cHA interaction varied twofold across the mAbs, reflecting inherent variability in the number of contacts between a particular mAb and the cHA surface. Furthermore, we reduced the number of test conditions required from 92 to 8 while maintaining an accurate representation of the full binding response surface. This eight-point modeling method accurately predicted the binding behavior of mAbs as well as mAb aggregates, a common impurity in crude mAb preparations. Using this eight-point modeling method, binding and selectivity information for mAb and aggregate can be obtained from less than two milligrams of protein, making the method attractive for early manufacturability assessments.

High-throughput screening of chromatographic separations: IV. Ion-exchange.

Ion-exchange (IEX) chromatography steps are widely applied in protein purification processes because of their high capacity, selectivity, robust operation, and well-understood principles. Optimization of IEX steps typically involves resin screening and selection of the pH and counterion concentrations of the load, wash, and elution steps. Time and material constraints associated with operating laboratory columns often preclude evaluating more than 20-50 conditions during early stages of process development. To overcome this limitation, a high-throughput screening (HTS) system employing a robotic liquid handling system and 96-well filterplates was used to evaluate various operating conditions for IEX steps for monoclonal antibody (mAb) purification. A screening study for an adsorptive cation-exchange step evaluated eight different resins. Sodium chloride concentrations defining the operating boundaries of product binding and elution were established at four different pH levels for each resin. Adsorption isotherms were measured for 24 different pH and salt combinations for a single resin. An anion-exchange flowthrough step was then examined, generating data on mAb adsorption for 48 different combinations of pH and counterion concentration for three different resins. The mAb partition coefficients were calculated and used to estimate the characteristic charge of the resin-protein interaction. Host cell protein and residual Protein A impurity levels were also measured, providing information on selectivity within this operating window. The HTS system shows promise for accelerating process development of IEX steps, enabling rapid acquisition of large datasets addressing the performance of the chromatography step under many different operating conditions.

High-throughput screening of chromatographic separations: I. Method development and column modeling.

The development of purification processes for protein biopharmaceuticals is challenging due to compressed development timelines, long experimental times, and the need to survey a large parameter space. Typical methods for development of a chromatography step evaluate several dozen chromatographic column runs to optimize the conditions. An efficient batch-binding method of screening chromatographic purification conditions in a 96-well format with a robotic liquid-handling system is described and evaluated. The system dispenses slurries of chromatographic resins into filter plates, which are then equilibrated, loaded with protein, washed and eluted. This paper evaluates factors influencing the performance of this high-throughput screening technique, including the reproducibility of the aliquotted resin volume, the contact time of the solution and resin during mixing, and the volume of liquid carried over in the resin bed after centrifugal evacuation. These factors led to the optimization of a batch-binding technique utilizing either 50 or 100 microL of resin in each well, the selection of an industrially relevant incubation time of 20 min, and the quantitation of the hold-up volume, which was as much as one quarter of the total volume added to each well. The results from the batch-binding method compared favorably to chromatographic column separation steps for a cGMP protein purification process utilizing both hydrophobic interaction and anion-exchange steps. These high-throughput screening tools can be combined with additional studies on the kinetics and thermodynamics of protein-resin interactions to provide fundamental information which is useful for defining and optimizing chromatographic separations steps.

High-throughput screening of chromatographic separations: II. Hydrophobic interaction.

A high-throughput screen (HTS) was developed to evaluate the selectivity of various hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) resins for separating a mAb from aggregate species. Prior to the resin screen, the solubility of the protein was assessed to determine the allowable HIC operating region by examining 384 combinations of pH, salt, and protein concentration. The resin screen then incorporated 480 batch-binding and elution conditions with eight HIC resins in combination with six salts. The results from the screen were reproducible, and demonstrated quantitative recovery of the mAb and aggregate. The translation of the HTS batch-binding data to lab-scale chromatography columns was tested for four conditions spanning the range of product binding and selectivity. After accounting for the higher number of theoretical plates in the columns, the purity and recovery of the lab-scale column runs agreed with the HTS results demonstrating the predictive power of the filterplate system. The HTS data were further analyzed by the calculation of pertinent thermodynamic parameters such as the partition coefficient, K(P), and the separation factor, alpha. The separation factor was used to rank the purification capabilities of the resin and salt conditions explored.

Viral clearance studies on new and used chromatography resins: critical review of a large dataset.

Viral clearance studies for naïve and maximally cycled chromatographic resins used for cGMP recombinant protein production are reviewed for three products, comprising 10 different chromatographic steps, including affinity, ion exchange, immobilized metal ion affinity, and hydrophobic interaction modes. Thirty-two separate studies were conducted (over 90 runs in total). No consistent reductions in model virus clearance were observed with used resins. The results address the reproducibility of virus clearance studies conducted by different scientists over several years at multiple contract labs. The log reduction values (LRVs) are typically within 0.5 LRVs for new and used resin, but varied as much as 2 LRVs for resins showing no functional deterioration. This relatively large difference is not believed to reflect resin changes, but highlights the challenges encountered in modeling column clearance. Production column performance and cleaning efficacy are demonstrated for these steps by trending mock runs, impurity removal and product recovery. No deterioration in cGMP column performance is seen over the established resin lifetimes, confirming that the resin regeneration and sanitization procedures restore the resins to a suitable initial state without damage. It is proposed that for some chromatography steps, the combination of lab-scale cycling studies confirming consistent performance throughout the resin lifetime and monitoring of cGMP manufacturing preclude the need for virus clearance studies on maximally cycled resin.

Development and validation of an affinity chromatography step using a peptide ligand for cGMP production of factor VIII.

An affinity chromatography step was developed for purification of recombinant B-Domain Deleted Factor VIII (BDDrFVIII) using a peptide ligand selected from a phage display library. The peptide library had variegated residues, contained both within a disulfide bond-constrained ring and flanking the ring. The peptide ligand binds to BDDrFVIII with a dissociation constant of approximately 1 microM both in free solution and when immobilized on a chromatographic resin. The peptide is chemically synthesized and the affinity resin is produced by coupling the peptide to an agarose matrix preactivated with N-hydroxysuccinimide. Coupling conditions were optimized to give consistent and complete ligand incorporation and validated with a robustness study that tested various combinations of processing limits. The peptide affinity chromatographic operation employs conditions very similar to an immunoaffinity chromatography step currently in use for BDDrFVIII manufacture. The process step provides excellent recovery of BDDrFVIII from a complex feed stream and reduces host cell protein and DNA by 3-4 logs. Process validation studies established resin reuse over 26 cycles without changes in product recovery or purity. A robustness study using a factorial design was performed and showed that the step was insensitive to small changes in process conditions that represent normal variation in commercial manufacturing. A scaled-down model of the process step was qualified and used for virus removal studies. A validation package addressing the safety of the leached peptide included leaching rate measurements under process conditions, testing of peptide levels in product pools, demonstration of robust removal downstream by spiking studies, end product testing, and toxicological profiling of the ligand. The peptide ligand affinity step was scaled up for cGMP production of BDDrFVIII for clinical trials.

Isolation of a peptide ligand for affinity purification of factor VIII using phage display.

Polypeptides for use in affinity chromatography of factor VIII were identified using phage display technology. Phage libraries were designed to express polypeptide fusions containing five to seven residues flanked by two cysteines that form a disulfide bond. Individual bacteriophage were selected for the ability of these polypeptides to bind factor VIII, and then release the protein under mild elution conditions. Strong consensus sequences were observed that appear to be necessary for this reversible interaction. Chemically synthesized ligands identified by this screening were immobilized onto a chromatographic support and used for affinity purification of factor VIII from a complex feedstream. A chromatographic step was developed that provided a 10000-fold reduction in host cell proteins and DNA, while providing exceptional product recovery.