Comment on "Elucidation of charge-transfer SERS selection rules by considering the excited state properties and the role of electrode potential" by M. Mohammadpour, M. H. Khodabandeh, L. Visscher and Z. Jamshidi, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 2017, 19, 7833.

The differences between alternative approaches for quantifying the complex effect of the electronic structure of charged metal-molecule hybrids in SERS (the so-called chemical enhancement mechanism) are highlighted. The discussion is focussed on the predictions obtained by using different methodological tools for modelling the role of the electrode potential in the SERS relative intensities. Finite electric fields are used in the commented paper for this purpose, but we have found some inconsistences in the results and the method for calculating the Raman intensities is not made sufficiently clear, which prevents the assessment of the results.

Adsorption of carbendazim pesticide on plasmonic nanoparticles studied by surface-enhanced Raman scattering.

Surface-Enhanced Raman Spectra (SERS) of methyl N-(1H-benzimidazol-2-yl)carbamate (MBC), usually named carbendazim, have been recorded on silver colloids at different pH values. In order to identify the neutral, protonated or deprotonated species of MBC that originate the SERS, the vibrational wavenumbers of these three isolated forms and linked to a silver atom have been predicted by carrying out DFT calculations. The results indicate that the active SERS species in the studied pH range correspond to the neutral MBC and its deprotonated ion in the amidate form. According to theoretical calculations, neutral MBC is linked to the metal through the imidazolic nitrogen atom, while the deprotonated MBC could be linked through the imidazolic nitrogen together with the amidic nitrogen atom or the carbonyl oxygen atom. Both adsorbed species, neutral and deprotonated, have the benzimidazolic ring orientated almost perpendicular to the silver surface and no molecular reorientation has been detected. pH of the bulk controls the relative abundance of the neutral MBC and its amidate anion which can be monitored through the intensities of the SERS bands recorded at about 1230 and 1270cm(-1). These two key bands correspond to the in-plane NH deformation of amidic and imidazolic groups, respectively.

The electronic structure of metal-molecule hybrids in charged interfaces: surface-enhanced Raman selection rules derived from plasmon-like resonances.

DFT calculations predict that plasmon-like excitations in small metal clusters are able to selectively modify the relative intensities of specific SERS bands of adsorbed molecules. These electronic resonances provide new kinds of SERS selection rules which can explain the huge enhancement of mode 9a of pyridine in the spectra recorded at negative electrode potentials.

On the dual character of charged metal-molecule hybrids and the opposite behaviour of the forward and reverse CT processes.

DFT calculations predict two different electronic structures of metal-molecule hybrids which are selected depending on the surface charge. While the metal-to-molecule CT states are very sensitive to the charge, the energies of the reverse molecule-to-metal CT processes are surprisingly not modified at all by the charge of the metal.

Multicomponent direct detection of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons by surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy using silver nanoparticles functionalized with the viologen host lucigenin.

Silver nanoparticles (NPs) functionalized with the molecular assembler bis-acridinium dication lucigenin (LG) have been used as a chemical sensor system to detect a group of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) pollutants in a multicomponent mixture by means of surface-enhanced raman scattering (SERS). The effectiveness of this system was checked for a group of PAHs with different numbers of fused benzene rings, namely anthracene, pyrene, triphenylene, benzo[c]phenanthrene, chrysene, and coronene. In order to determine the host capacity of this sensor system, the self-assembly of the LG viologen on a metallic surface has been checked by analyzing SERS intensities of PAH bands at different LG concentrations. The NP-LG-analyte affinity is derived from the analysis of PAH band intensities at different concentrations of pollutants, the adsorption isotherm of each PAH on NP-LG cavities has been studied, and the corresponding adsorption constants have been evaluated. The limit of detection at trace-level concentration is confirmed by the presence of their characteristic fingerprint vibrational bands. The SERS spectra of PAH mixtures confirm that LG viologen dication shows a higher analytical selectivity to PAHs constituted by four fused benzene rings, mainly pyrene and benzo[c]phenanthrene, in agreement with their higher affinity which is also related to their better fit into the intermolecular LG cavities. As a conclusion, SERS spectra recorded on modified NP-LG surfaces are a powerful chemical tool to detect organic pollutants.

Vibrational study of the metal-adsorbate interaction of phenylacetic acid and alpha-phenylglycine on silver surfaces.

Raman and SERS spectra of phenylacetic acid and alpha-phenylglycine on silver sols have been recorded at several concentrations and pH values. The alpha-phenylglycine has been also studied in D(2)O. The respective vibrational assignments have been proposed and the analysis of the SERS spectra has made it possible to conclude that phenylacetic acid links to the metal through its carboxylate group only, while alpha-phenylglycine links also through its amino group. In both cases the aromatic ring seems to be almost perpendicular to the metal surface. On the other hand, the contribution of the charge transfer (CT) mechanism to the enhancement of the SERS spectra has been calculated as well and it is found to be very important in both molecules. The band most enhanced by this mechanism is that of vibration 8a, mainly in alpha-phenylglycine.